3 guard lineup not working for this team

yoshukai

Heisman
Dec 21, 2002
30,930
44,369
102
If Gabriel is not starting and used as a defensive freak, then he has no position in the floor. He has no offensive game. Willis is a role player, shoot the ball and do not hurt us on defense.
Again though, Bam and Hump cannot play together. In an era of small ball, they would get destroyed guarding the perimeter.
Well Gabriel is TERRIBLE on defense so .........
 

Ky_Bred_Cat

All-Conference
Dec 28, 2014
2,201
4,090
113
The placement of Briscoe is problematic. as stated before, he HAS to paly (hopefully to keep him from being a big blemish on the Cal 5* pipeline). He's a great college gaurd. But he's not better than Fox or Monk at the 1 and 2 position so...he man's the 3 a lot. In the grande scheme of things this may be hurting us more than helping us.
 

Longtrip

Junior
May 12, 2003
372
240
0
1) Mulder deserves minutes, but is not a starter.
2) Willis is too inconsistent and can vaporize in big games.
3) If defense is important, Hawkins has to play.
4) I think Gabriel is developing, but slowly.
5) I would like to see more of SKJ
6) Humphries has been a disappointment, thus far.
7) The jury is still out on Bam being effective in zone situations, which are coming.
8) Briscoe is solid, should play, but has been struggling to the rim lately.
9) Fox and Monk simply HAVE to play much better defense.

I think we might lose as many as six (6) games and will end up a#2 seed.
I will be disappointed if we do not beat Kansas here at home.

Briscoe is anything but "solid".
If this continues to be his team our odds of making the Final Four decrease
I would like to see more of SKJ and a little less of Humphries and Gabriel
We definitely need to improve on defense and right now no one seems to play it
Bam is coming around.
We need better passing and better shot selection.
 

MNantz

Heisman
Dec 20, 2001
9,086
11,921
98
I guess I will just let Cal figure this out lol since no one is paying me anything to figure it out !
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
Its a REAL GOOD THING you are not the coach , starting DW and Gabriel together ? Dang dude. One lineup that cant defend and one that cant score . No balance at all.

Well, we can put SKJ in at the 4 instead, but then you have only one guy that could hit the 3 starting. Poor offensive balance. So, we are back to being bigger, but having no outside game at all.

Put Mulder in at the 3, and we are back to being small, but at least we have two shooters. But Mulder plays better with Briscoe with him on the floor, so I put him on the second unit.

We really don't have great options at the 3, but I think if Gabriel can get better defensively, his length at the 3 can help us.

If not, just stick with Briscoe as a small 3. At least he can rebound for a 6'3 guy.

Yes, it's a good thing I am not the coach. I bet the same could be said for you.
 

CincyUKFan

All-American
Dec 1, 2009
4,590
7,587
66
It's as simple as this:

If an elite coach, college or pro, spent a few weeks with this team and was asked what lineup would stand the best chance of winning, he would not in a million years come to the conclusion that it's the lineup that Cal has been running out there.

As many have said, this is a loyalty issue. Briscoe's defensive abilities are negated by the fact that he is guarding 3's and offensively, he is a liability in the half court.

As a lifelong Bengals fan who has seen the stubbornness of Marvin Lewis year in and year out - I have read this book before. Cal will continue giving Briscoe over 30 minutes per game and we will not be a threat in March because of it.

We will continue to see this team struggle against quality competition (good thing the SEC blows) and we will have this same conversation every time we lose. And the homers will continue to tell everyone that Cal is the one who gets paid millions, etc. etc.
 

plumdog69

Senior
Jan 12, 2006
742
812
57
Mulder is still a guard... :-/ You actually went form 3 guard line up to 3 guard line up. SO if you want to propose traditional line up...please do first.

second point is that Mulder doesn't have any proof that he can contribute against top level team. Most of his stats and F/G% is based off scrub teams after getting huge lead. Yesterday, he DID make 2 threes. However, NO ONE mentions the fact that he got 0 reb, 0 assist, 0 STL, 0 BLK in 9 minutes.

I'm okay to maybe test him 5-8 minutes to see what he can do...however that's just it. Yesterday, he proved he wasn't qualified to play.
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
It's just really hard to find a perfect lineup for this team.

Gabriel is not playing well, yet. He has potential and could be a defensive menace by the end of the year or next year.

Briscoe is a good defender, but is defending bigger guys and is an offensive liability.

Willis can't guard a fence post, but his shooting stretches the floor.

SKJ is just not ready yet to help. Hump isn't ready either. Bam is the only big we really have and he is just learning to post up.

Fox can't shoot, but other than that, he is a stud.

Monk is easily the best player on the team, but he isn't a good defender.

I guess we just have to let Cal sort it out. Remember, we are starting four Freshmen, they are bound to get better. It's just December.

I just love to talk about possibilities. I definitely am glad the coaching staff gets to decide what to do, because if this board made the call, we would probably be 2-10 instead of 10-2.
 

dave5164

All-Conference
Apr 6, 2009
4,119
2,599
0
I would agree that we don't see the players at practice and who deserves the minutes and how many for each game. This has to be the problem with Mulder and SKJ right now because a perfect example is last night Mulder hits 2-3 from 3 and gets 8 minutes of playing time. SKJ for third straight game is not even playing like he was in the first 8-9 games. Mulder has done this before coming in and draining the three but only plays 8 or 9 minutes a game. I still feel that Mulder should play 15-20 mpg but it won't happen at Kentucky and Coach Cal this year. It seems that when we have these 5* players like a Fox, Monk, Bam, and Gabriel that come in they get the 35 minutes a game which doesn't leave too many minutes for a Mulder, SKJ, Hump, etc. This year and even in the UNC game it felt like we are seeing Fox, Monk, Briscoe, and sometimes Bam getting the 35 minutes and then you have Gabriel and Willis splitting the 4 minutes. Then we see Mulder, Hawkins, and SKJ getting 5-10 minutes a game. Last night you have Mulder scoring 2 threes and you would think he would get 15-20 minutes but still gets his 8 minutes. That is what I don't understand with this Rotation yet is that if one player is not hitting the shot or playing the 'D' we have decent players like Mulder and SKJ that can come in and help this team. Mulder just seems to be such a better player this year and has more confidence in his outside shot and 3 point shot. Mulder even seems to be playing better on the defensive side of the ball.
 

Cawood86_rivals

Heisman
Feb 20, 2005
36,711
64,715
0
I do not think either Bam or Hump could guard anyone on the perimeter. It showed last night when Bam switched onto Snider, one of the slower guards we will face.
The issue s more about the offense will completely go stagnant. No coach would guard either more than 10 feet from the basket. It would simply clog the lane.
I guess my point is, what is Gabriel giving UK right now that Hump or SKJ couldn't. Love Gabriel but maybe at least something a little different to see what happens.
 
Feb 21, 2006
8,403
9,162
0
3 guards can work if 2 of the three can shoot efficiently enough from the field and free throw stripe, but that simply isn't the case for our 3 lead guards, we have one that can do that..

Right now Cal is clearly going with a rim running line up to showcase his lottery picks and potential picks in the open court, and that is fine until we run up against teams that have comparable talent on the court as well as comparable coaching talent.

If it wasn't for Monk we'd be 0-3 vs tourney caliber teams with good coaches and equal talent.

In addition to two of our lead guards being inconsistent and inefficient our 4 is a thin project that is unreliable. Gabriel is a very nice prospect with a high ceiling, but you can say that about a lot of guys, some pan out and make the pros, some transfer to U of Cal after not panning out.

Bam needs help in the front court, but Hump isn't getting the minutes. It's also hard for him to perform at the 15-20 ppg level when the guards are running out and laying bricks before he can get back get and easy lay up/put back or have the offense run through him in the half court.
 

Elliott Tim

All-American
Dec 10, 2005
10,122
6,290
0
I think you guys are being a little too tough. NO ONE but the best team in America could have beaten UNC last week, and we did. The season is young and this team has not yet found its footing, but it will. Willis, Briscoe, and Hawkins are stabilizing influences. They may not be the best players on the team, but they keep the other guys settled down. Try to be optimistic. Or, think like a coach. Teams evolve during the season, and this one will get MUCH better.
Thank you for this!
 

Aike

Heisman
Mar 17, 2002
75,464
46,468
90
The three guard lineup works fine. There's just a give and take to it.

We put more pressure on the defense but we also can be left exposed in the halfcourt.

Being able to score in 3-4 seconds after a made basket is a function of the three guard lineup.

This is a different kind of team this year. We are that fast team that everyone has wanted for 20 years.

Probably will never be a team that absolutely chokes out the other team. But we have to be better at getting a stop and securing a rebound when necessary. That's the difference right now between 10-2 and 12-0.

For my money, 10-2 and scoring 90 PPG = working. But we still have work to do.
 

oldsports_

Heisman
Dec 18, 2010
22,834
38,983
113
A friend of mine in the horse industry is friends with Cal. He wanted me to tell all of you that Cal reads Rupp Rafters daily,and said thanks for the line up adjustments advise. ....
 

UKGrad93

Heisman
Jun 20, 2007
17,437
22,789
0
Part of the problem is that Briscoe is one of the 5 best players on the team. I woud rate them something like:

1. Monk
2. Bam
3. Fox
4. Briscoe

Then we get into roll players.

Willis/Gabriel/Hump/Mulder/Hawkins

As mentioned, the pf position is a problem with Willis & Gabriel. Bam seems more like a pf than a center, but a lineup of Hump, Bam, Briscoe, Fox & Monk clogs the middle & leaves no one to come in for the front court.

IMO, our recruiting has to get better balance. We need a true SF.
 

BourbonBalz

All-American
Mar 5, 2005
11,430
9,235
0
The biggest problem with this team is the same problem we've had for several years now. No true SF on the entire roster. Mulder is the closest thing we have to one and he's still a bit small.
 

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
I've been saying the same as far as the lineup goes. You cant throw 3 guards out there when two of them can't shoot. WAY too easy for any top 10 team with a halfway decent coach to defend.

But what if those two guards can score - and do so very well - and create more opportunities for others to score? Does it only count if it's a 3 point shot? And what if those two guards net more points than they allow? Is that useful? Is that how you win? Or is the game much simpler than that, and all we really need to focus on is what a players 3 point percentage is? I'm just asking.
 

UK90

Heisman
Dec 30, 2007
31,460
27,816
0
The biggest problem with this team is the same problem we've had for several years now. No true SF on the entire roster. Mulder is the closest thing we have to one and he's still a bit small.

No, the "biggest problem with this team" is the four spot, not the three. Briscoe is obviously a flawed and undersized 3, but he is still covering our starting needs at that position better than either Gabriel or Willis is doing at the 4.

Amazed how some don't see that--appears obvious to me. Sure, it would be nice if we had some prototypical SF superstud there--but you can't have everything you want--and that spot is NOT "the biggest problem" position with this team, instead the 4 is.
 
Last edited:
Nov 27, 2009
21,246
21,450
0
It's just really hard to find a perfect lineup for this team.

Gabriel is not playing well, yet. He has potential and could be a defensive menace by the end of the year or next year.

Briscoe is a good defender, but is defending bigger guys and is an offensive liability.

Willis can't guard a fence post, but his shooting stretches the floor.

SKJ is just not ready yet to help. Hump isn't ready either. Bam is the only big we really have and he is just learning to post up.

Fox can't shoot, but other than that, he is a stud.

Monk is easily the best player on the team, but he isn't a good defender.

I guess we just have to let Cal sort it out. Remember, we are starting four Freshmen, they are bound to get better. It's just December.

I just love to talk about possibilities. I definitely am glad the coaching staff gets to decide what to do, because if this board made the call, we would probably be 2-10 instead of 10-2.

And Johnny David is a cowboy that rides an ostrich. Just glad it is not March and they still have some time to improve their basketball skill defects and Cal still has time to tweek.
 

CatsnRoses

All-Conference
May 13, 2007
6,803
2,717
0
Briscoe calmed the Freshman down against UL. Plus, he was hitting free throws. Silly to have him sit, the problem is at 4 and no back up for Bam. Hump has regressed.

I saw zero evidence of him calming the freshman.

He's a liability right now. Has to play much better.
 

wkycatfan7

All-Conference
Oct 16, 2002
9,091
3,305
113
The biggest problem with this team is the same problem we've had for several years now. No true SF on the entire roster. Mulder is the closest thing we have to one and he's still a bit small.

We had one in Charles Matthews. Wish he would have stayed, I think he would be getting some minutes each game.
 

BlueRunner11

Heisman
Mar 26, 2011
11,563
35,627
0
But what if those two guards can score - and do so very well - and create more opportunities for others to score? Does it only count if it's a 3 point shot? And what if those two guards net more points than they allow? Is that useful? Is that how you win? Or is the game much simpler than that, and all we really need to focus on is what a players 3 point percentage is? I'm just asking.

Good teams will force our guards to take outside jumpers come tourney time. The teams that can make shots will advance and the ones who can't, won't. That's why I'm advocate of getting Mulder more minutes and experience to have another outside threat. I'd like to see fox Monk and Mulder starting at the 1 2 and 3 but that will never happen.
 

LeonThe Camel

Senior
May 3, 2016
1,896
717
0
I guess my point is, what is Gabriel giving UK right now that Hump or SKJ couldn't. Love Gabriel but maybe at least something a little different to see what happens.
Nothing really. But he appears to be one of Cal's players, meaning one who will get playing time so he may as well be part of the solution.
 

Calsarmy

All-Conference
Jul 24, 2013
1,009
1,232
0
All this works in concert. Briscoe is overweight and a 6-2 guard weighing 225 pounds that cant shoot. The weight makes him more than a step slow and he is trying but not being successful at guarding a 3 that is 6-6 or 6-7 with quickness. Briscoe should be weighing 200-205 tops. Now the second half of this problem is what it is doing to Bam. Bam is getting doubled down inside and when the ball swings to Briscoe outside, his defender drops inside to in effect be triple teamed. There is simply a cause and effect to all this and it unfortunately begins with Cal and Briscoe. There is really only one correction but Im pretty sure it wont happen. In the mean time enjoy a lot of high flying and unbelievable plays.
 

qwesley

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
17,606
23,461
0
Good teams will force our guards to take outside jumpers come tourney time. The teams that can make shots will advance and the ones who can't, won't. That's why I'm advocate of getting Mulder more minutes and experience to have another outside threat. I'd like to see fox Monk and Mulder starting at the 1 2 and 3 but that will never happen.
Yes longer better teams will exploit this. It will also stunt Bam,who could be a dominant player by the end of the year, by clogging the lane. I'm so disappointed in both Willis and WG I would roll SKJ for 25 mpg and see if he takes the leap. It should be about building to beat the elite teams in the end.
 

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
It's as simple as this:

If an elite coach, college or pro, spent a few weeks with this team and was asked what lineup would stand the best chance of winning, he would not in a million years come to the conclusion that it's the lineup that Cal has been running out there.

As many have said, this is a loyalty issue. Briscoe's defensive abilities are negated by the fact that he is guarding 3's and offensively, he is a liability in the half court.

As a lifelong Bengals fan who has seen the stubbornness of Marvin Lewis year in and year out - I have read this book before. Cal will continue giving Briscoe over 30 minutes per game and we will not be a threat in March because of it.

We will continue to see this team struggle against quality competition (good thing the SEC blows) and we will have this same conversation every time we lose. And the homers will continue to tell everyone that Cal is the one who gets paid millions, etc. etc.

The problem with your claim, however, is that you have no idea what an elite coach, college or pro, would think. You’re just not on that level.

A lot of people who have played or watched a game for some time – whether it’s basketball, chess or poker, etc. – are convinced that they understand the correct way to play. But they just don’t. They have a superficial understanding of the game. Their lack of in depth understanding is obvious to others, but never themselves.

Calipari is a professional coach, and one of very best in the business. You and I are not. We on this message board are fans. We question. We complain. That’s what we fans do – and that’s all well and good. But any fan on a message board who thinks he has a better understanding about anything regarding a UK player’s basketball ability or what is best for the success of the UK basketball team is delusional.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aike

Aike

Heisman
Mar 17, 2002
75,464
46,468
90
The problem with your claim, however, is that you have no idea what an elite coach, college or pro, would think. You’re just not on that level.

A lot of people who have played or watched a game for some time – whether it’s basketball, chess or poker, etc. – are convinced that they understand the correct way to play. But they just don’t. They have a superficial understanding of the game. Their lack of in depth understanding is obvious to others, but never themselves.

Calipari is a professional coach, and one of very best in the business. You and I are not. We on this message board are fans. We question. We complain. That’s what we fans do – and that’s all well and good. But any fan on a message board who thinks he has a better understanding about anything regarding a UK player’s basketball ability or what is best for the success of the UK basketball team is delusional.

Had to click on unignore to see who you were talking to.

You are trying to speak rationally to an irrational poster.

Kudos to you for the attempt, but you'd accomplish just as much by banging your head with a hammer for the next 6 weeks.
 

CincyUKFan

All-American
Dec 1, 2009
4,590
7,587
66
The problem with your claim, however, is that you have no idea what an elite coach, college or pro, would think. You’re just not on that level.

A lot of people who have played or watched a game for some time – whether it’s basketball, chess or poker, etc. – are convinced that they understand the correct way to play. But they just don’t. They have a superficial understanding of the game. Their lack of in depth understanding is obvious to others, but never themselves.

Calipari is a professional coach, and one of very best in the business. You and I are not. We on this message board are fans. We question. We complain. That’s what we fans do – and that’s all well and good. But any fan on a message board who thinks he has a better understanding about anything regarding a UK player’s basketball ability or what is best for the success of the UK basketball team is delusional.
Good job. You did exactly what I said you would.
 

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
Had to click on unignore to see who you were talking to.

You are trying to speak rationally to an irrational poster.

Kudos to you for the attempt, but you'd accomplish just as much by banging your head with a hammer for the next 6 weeks.

Thanks for the heads up. I know that I’m often dumb as a box of rocks about a lot of things. But the level of undeserved arrogance on this board by some in regard to their perceived superiority of basketball knowledge vis-a’-vis Cal blows my mind.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball KSR's top takeaways from Kentucky's double-digit loss at Indiana
  2. 02 KSR Kentucky players not going to let outside noise infect locker room
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Should we look at Kentucky's updated KenPom numbers? Why not? It can't hurt any worse.
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Zoom Diallo: Kentucky Can’t Keep Trading Baskets
  5. 05 KSR Basketball Hear from Mark Pope, Milan Momcilovic, and Zoom Diallo after Kentucky's 90-76 loss