Does Duke's Jon Scheyer deserve any heat ?

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
52,135
73,733
113
Duke has been riding the top of the best wave for a long time. Eventually that wave is going to crash and Scheyer better hope he gets a title before that happens.
We know what it's like to be on top, but as we found out, it's really hard to sustain it, especially now, everyone has big money.
At some point, those duke donors aren’t going to be as willing to put up the cash they have been throwing at the basketball program all these years if the result is some 20 point losses at home and a bunch if choke jobs in the tournament.
But, duke has one thing in their favor, Scheyer isn’t a guy that coaches to win NBA draft night, he’s actually trying to win games.
 

CrimsonCats_rivals

All-Conference
Mar 22, 2022
1,826
3,787
61
I’m definitely not a Duke aplologist, but I generally find these “should have multiple titles by now with all that talent” conversations to be silly because they pretty much assume the best team will win the tournament as long as the coach doesn’t do something to blow it, but that greatly underestimates the randomness of a 64 (or 68 if you prefer) team single elimination event where something like a 30% chance to win makes you the overwhelming favorite. It’s hard to win one, and very few coaches have ever won multiple.

Scheyer is now starting his 5th season and so far already has two conference titles, two Elite Eights, and a Final Four. He’s not on the hot seat, and quite frankly they’d be stupid if he was.
 
Last edited:

meteordealer

All-Conference
Nov 20, 2004
11,833
2,874
113
It would be foolish to move off a coach with a FF and multiple EEs early in his coaching career. I am not saying you personally don't know, but many people fail to realize how hard it actually is to make deep runs in the Big Dance.
It's easier to do at Duke. They always get a higher seed than they deserve, and a cakewalk bracket.
 

CATALCOHOLIC

Senior
Apr 13, 2018
277
480
52
I’m definitely not a Duke aplologist, but I generally find these “should have multiple titles by now with all that talent” conversations to be silly because they pretty much assume the best team will win the tournament as long as the coach doesn’t do something to blow it, but that greatly underestimates the randomness of a 64 (or 68 if you prefer) team single elimination event where something like a 30% chance to win makes you the overwhelming favorite. It’s hard to win one, and very few coaches have ever won multiple.

Scheyer is now starting his 5th season and so far already has two conference titles, two Elite Eights, and a Final Four. He’s not on the hot seat, and quite frankly they’d be stupid if he was.
Kinda like Jon blew it last year. Little Boozer just had to hold the ball and time would have ran out. Jon was telling him to throw the ball forward. BLEW THAT GAME!!
 

Omega_X

Senior
Sep 7, 2026
432
741
93
This would get heat if true. What is stopping kids from leaving one program for another mid season?


Absolutely nothing. It’s why a couple weeks ago I said I wouldn’t put Zoom coming off the bench until the start of the second semester if they were going to do it.
 

Omega_X

Senior
Sep 7, 2026
432
741
93
Scheyer is getting some heat from Duke fans. Which is funny because the few times I went to Duke boards years ago expecting them to be fuming mad they would be fairly calm.

I saw them saying a lot of the same things we said about Cal. Stuff like “sure we might have just got blown out but we have 42 five stars so it’s all cool!” Saw Scheyer being called Hubert Jr. 😂
 

Beatle Bum

Heisman
Sep 1, 2002
44,386
67,267
113
There is a lot of good talent in the country. Gathering high school future pros and putting them against more mature players has always been a process and a bit of a crap shoot. Even more so in the era of NIL and the portal. Getting teams like Duke and Arky to peak at tourney time may not be enough. Duke has had Cooper and Boozer the past two years. Those were dudes who could put the team on their back when it needed to get it. I don’t see that person on this Duke team.

Who are those freshmen this year? Stokes at Kansas? Is he the only one? Is there an Acuff? A Peterson?

I have not seen Branch. Is he that kind of freshmen? Holt seems like a good compliment to Zona. I don’t think Duke has that kind of dominating presence.
 

BOOGIEMAN1914

All-Conference
May 15, 2007
7,954
2,125
113
I’m definitely not a Duke aplologist, but I generally find these “should have multiple titles by now with all that talent” conversations to be silly because they pretty much assume the best team will win the tournament as long as the coach doesn’t do something to blow it, but that greatly underestimates the randomness of a 64 (or 68 if you prefer) team single elimination event where something like a 30% chance to win makes you the overwhelming favorite. It’s hard to win one, and very few coaches have ever won multiple.

Scheyer is now starting his 5th season and so far already has two conference titles, two Elite Eights, and a Final Four. He’s not on the hot seat, and quite frankly they’d be stupid if he was.
Exactly...4 full seasons 124-25 record basically 31-6 record per year...2 acc reg seasons titles, 3 ACCt Championships, 2 Elite 8, and 1 Final Four..with essentially freshman led talent
 

HeismanWinner

All-Conference
Sep 12, 2025
1,526
3,643
113
They have 9 recruits/transfers that were ranked 5 stars. Including the #1 PF in the 2026 class, the #1 PG in the 2026 class, the #1 SG in the transfer portal, and the projected #1 pick in the 2028 NBA draft.

BTW no team has ever lost by 20 at home and gone on to win the NCAA Championship.
Not sure what losing at home vs on the road reflects in terms of winning a title.

2014 UConn got blasted 48-81 vs Louisville and then one month later, won the national championship.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football What happened on every Kentucky red zone possession against Missouri
  2. 02 KSR Football Stein Proud of Kentucky's Fight, but will not have a Loser's Mentality
  3. 03 KSR Football Instant Takeaways: Red zone miscues, porous pass defense help continue Kentucky's November losing streak
  4. 04 KSR Football Stein: Kentucky Must Finish Strong in the "Most Important Game of the Year"
  5. 05 KSR Football Will Stein says he "friggin' hates losing" in his postgame press conference