Does Duke's Jon Scheyer deserve any heat ?

Johnnie Africa

All-Conference
Feb 27, 2003
1,198
3,689
113
He hasn’t been coaching that long. If he still doesn’t have a title 6 years from now then ya but so far he’s had a pretty spectacular career for how early it is. I will say however he’s had some pretty generational freshmen the previous two years and those are hard to come by. Kinda like a John Wall or Anthony Davis for Cal.
 

*Fox2Monk*

Heisman
Jun 10, 2009
49,262
91,072
113
He hasn’t been coaching that long. If he still doesn’t have a title 6 years from now then ya but so far he’s had a pretty spectacular career for how early it is. I will say however he’s had some pretty generational freshmen the previous two years and those are hard to come by. Kinda like a John Wall or Anthony Davis for Cal.
He bound to have those Cal classes where he has like one first round pick and the other five stars come back or just don’t pan out:
 

Drogon

All-Conference
Mar 14, 2017
2,161
3,133
113
1000% he does.. and im worried they might actually get rid of him

Ive said for years now, with what he's being given from Duke boosters, ESPN media, and the NCAA protecting them.. he starts on 3rd base, but he never is able to score.

Same. He's Harold Reynolds and X's and O's are Bo Jackson.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LineSkiCat14

BookofMormon

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2026
1,427
1,880
113
They have really good seasons but considering the talent he has had should have won a title by now ?
He basically picks whatever five star talent he wants.
For something to talk about is he going to be this generations Cal, or does he win some national titles ?
He's Calipari Junior. He chases recruiting stars, he doesn't identify traits, intangibles, competitiveness, fit for culture. Quentin Coleman was easily the best player on the floor, but he wasn't recruited by Duke because he was a late riser.

This is why I'd want no part of Lucas.
 

HeismanWinner

All-Conference
Sep 12, 2025
1,510
3,612
113
Because they have an NBA roster, and got teabagged twice already this season.
Yeah but no one really cares about November games. That’s the truth about this sport. March is all that matters. Most people couldn’t tell you about a November loss by the time the tournament rolls around.

You’ll always be judged on how far you can go in the tournament. For the last three years, they have done really well. If not for a bonehead play by Boozer Bro., that’s two Final Fours in back to back years. So, for me, you could lose to Gardner Webb by 20 in November and I couldn’t care less as long as you still got a deep run.
 
Oct 23, 2025
701
960
93
They have 9 recruits/transfers that were ranked 5 stars. Including the #1 PF in the 2026 class, the #1 PG in the 2026 class, the #1 SG in the transfer portal, and the projected #1 pick in the 2028 NBA draft.

BTW no team has ever lost by 20 at home and gone on to win the NCAA Championship.
 

theBlues

All-Conference
Oct 18, 2025
2,168
4,909
113
As long as he keeps assembling enough talent to be a contender every year he should be safe, even if he keeps underachieving.
 

SkyPrince

All-Conference
Jul 7, 2025
723
1,196
93
He has a team full of overrated players.
Williams as the headliner in last yrs class is a big step back from Flagg and Boozer..
Blackwell is in the same boat as Juke Harris, Momcilovic,Diop, Bidunga.
Top portal guys who are having a hard time adjusting to their new program.
 

preacherfan

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2003
29,196
4,940
113
This is a good thread with some valid points on both sides. Also, it is refreshing that the debate is focused on the issues and not the posters.

I don't think Scheyer is on the hotseat but I do think his seat could get warm down the road. At this point, he is Cal 2.0.
 

mhs1964

Senior
Feb 8, 2018
572
666
88
They have 9 recruits/transfers that were ranked 5 stars. Including the #1 PF in the 2026 class, the #1 PG in the 2026 class, the #1 SG in the transfer portal, and the projected #1 pick in the 2028 NBA draft.

BTW no team has ever lost by 20 at home and gone on to win the NCAA Championship.
Now this is a post from a true rival who hates Duke. A lot of the posters on this board hate UNC more than Duke but for me between the two schools I say “Go Heels”
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Heshimu Evans arrested on domestic violence charge in Lexington
  2. 02 KSR KSR Today: Mark Pope previews Indiana, Will Stein previews Missouri
  3. 03 KSR Football Kentucky Drops Out of 12-Team Field in Latest CFP Top 25 Rankings
  4. 04 KSR Football CFP Rankings Reaction: How Does Kentucky Get Back Into 12-Team Field?
  5. 05 KSR Football Recruiting Kentucky Flips Trinity TE Jack Stivers