Time to Kill the Bowl Games With a 24-Team Playoff?

Time to Kill the Bowl Games With a 24-Team Playoff?


  • Total voters
    19

Gamecock72

Joined Sep 24, 2019
Sep 24, 2019
681
550
93
I just don't understand the point of the SEC Championship once they eliminated the East / West Divisions?

I guess the schedule is a grab bag each year so it might make sense for #1 and #2 to play but it feels alot different.
The SEC had a Champion before the division split. Pre-1992.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Lurker123

Gamecock72

Joined Sep 24, 2019
Sep 24, 2019
681
550
93
Maybe it will help insure all a teams stars play rather than sit out. I'm tired of paying a couple of thousand bucks for a few days in Fla to watch half a team (lose,).
I doubt I will ever go back to a bowl game unless I know it will be the same team that played in the regular season. With the exception of injuries, of course. But until they fix the sitting-out problem, I am not spending my money on one of those games.
 

Gamecock72

Joined Sep 24, 2019
Sep 24, 2019
681
550
93
I think many younger folks don't remember life before championship games. I love championship games. But here's the deal, I believe that, most often, the team that played best all season long won them - most often.
Yep. Seems people have forgotten we did have conference champions long before the conference championship games. They act like going back to crowning only a regular-season champion is impossible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,794
18,487
113
The SEC had a Champion before the division split. Pre-1992.

People bring that up a lot. They also forget that pre-1992, the conference only had 10 teams. Each team played 7 conference games. You had pretty good dispersion of games, so the #1 team at the end of the year was pretty representative. The SEC now has 16 teams with 9 conference games. A team avoids almost half the conference every year. Conferences initially expanded BECAUSE they wanted to have championship games. Take the championship game away and there's no need for the conferences as they exist.

Crowning a conference champion in a 16-team conference based on 9 games is moronic. In the NFL, every team plays every other team in their division 2x in the season.

Comparing pre-1992 to today is apples/oranges. The conference is 60% larger.

At the least, the 24-team CFP is a great reason for conference contraction.
 
Last edited:

Gamecock72

Joined Sep 24, 2019
Sep 24, 2019
681
550
93
People bring that up a lot. They also forget that pre-1992, the conference only had 10 teams. Each team played 7 conference games. You had pretty good dispersion of games, so the #1 team at the end of the year was pretty representative. The SEC now has 16 teams with 9 conference games. A team avoids almost half the conference every year. Conferences initially expanded BECAUSE they wanted to have championship games. Take the championship game away and there's no need for the conferences as they exist.

Crowning a conference champion in a 16-team conference based on 9 games is moronic. In the NFL, every team plays every other team in their division 2x in the season.

Comparing pre-1992 to today is apples/oranges. The conference is 60% larger.

At the least, the 24-team CFP is a great reason for conference contraction.
With the SEC's current 16-team setup and 9 conference games, I'd simply make the entire conference one 16-team standings table.

Each team would continue playing 9 conference games using the current scheduling system:
• 3 permanent opponents
• 6 rotating opponents
• 9 conference games total

At the end of the regular season, the team with the best SEC record would be the SEC champion.

For example:

  1. Georgia 8-1
  2. Alabama 8-1
  3. Texas 7-2
  4. LSU 7-2
    etc.
If two teams finish with the same record, use tiebreakers:

  1. Head-to-head result
  2. Record against common opponents
  3. Record against the highest-finishing common opponent
  4. Record against the next-highest common opponent
  5. Combined SEC winning percentage of opponents played
  6. CFP ranking
  7. Computer ranking as the final tiebreaker
I don't think the SEC needs a championship game to determine its champion. The 9-game conference schedule is already a significant enough sample size to determine who had the best conference season.

Eliminating the championship game would also have a huge benefit: it opens up an additional weekend on the college football calendar.

That weekend could then be used to start an expanded College Football Playoff earlier, which would be especially important if the CFP eventually expands to 24 teams.

In other words, let the SEC regular season determine the SEC champion, and use the weekend currently occupied by the SEC Championship Game to help accommodate a larger national playoff.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,207
3,774
113
People bring that up a lot. They also forget that pre-1992, the conference only had 10 teams. Each team played 7 conference games. You had pretty good dispersion of games, so the #1 team at the end of the year was pretty representative. The SEC now has 16 teams with 9 conference games. A team avoids almost half the conference every year. Conferences initially expanded BECAUSE they wanted to have championship games. Take the championship game away and there's no need for the conferences as they exist.

Crowning a conference champion in a 16-team conference based on 9 games is moronic. In the NFL, every team plays every other team in their division 2x in the season.

Comparing pre-1992 to today is apples/oranges. The conference is 60% larger.

At the least, the 24-team CFP is a great reason for conference contraction.
There also used to be co-champions in the SEC if teams had the same conference record and no head to head game. The Sugar Bowl used to take the SEC champion and if there were co-champions and one of them had played in the Sugar bowl the previous year, the other would go.
 

Blues man

Joined Jul 1, 2009
Jan 22, 2022
1,981
1,950
113
Now that conference games are going away. What is the board's thoughts on moving the CU game back a few days? Bring back Thursdays? I'm not usually too fond of mid-week games because they seem kinda gimmicky but I think it would do the rivalry well.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,207
3,774
113
Now that conference games are going away. What is the board's thoughts on moving the CU game back a few days? Bring back Thursdays? I'm not usually too fond of mid-week games because they seem kinda gimmicky but I think it would do the rivalry well.
The NFL has taken over Thursday night and Friday is HS football night. I'm not sure a Wednesday night game would work well for people who had to travel to attend, especially if the game was at Clemson. The old "Big Thursday" game was always in Columbia during the state fair. I doubt Clemson would want to give up the home and home aspect of the game.
 

Blues man

Joined Jul 1, 2009
Jan 22, 2022
1,981
1,950
113
The NFL has taken over Thursday night and Friday is HS football night. I'm not sure a Wednesday night game would work well for people who had to travel to attend, especially if the game was at Clemson. The old "Big Thursday" game was always in Columbia during the state fair. I doubt Clemson would want to give up the home and home aspect of the game.
Just thinking out loud. Thursday and Friday games have become pretty common place nowadays. I would not expect anyone to give up their home game. I guess it would also depend on what week the playoffs start. Jumping the gun I reckon.
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,922
9,023
113
People bring that up a lot. They also forget that pre-1992, the conference only had 10 teams. Each team played 7 conference games. You had pretty good dispersion of games, so the #1 team at the end of the year was pretty representative. The SEC now has 16 teams with 9 conference games. A team avoids almost half the conference every year. Conferences initially expanded BECAUSE they wanted to have championship games. Take the championship game away and there's no need for the conferences as they exist.

Crowning a conference champion in a 16-team conference based on 9 games is moronic. In the NFL, every team plays every other team in their division 2x in the season.

Comparing pre-1992 to today is apples/oranges. The conference is 60% larger.

At the least, the 24-team CFP is a great reason for conference contraction.
It's not moronic. Given the right parameters and digital help, it is possible to crown a credible, demonstrable champion. In fact, I'd say that such a process is now a necessity. It just isn't as sexy as with a championship game.

Including the overall record and overall strength of schedule in that computation and even beating UPC could wind up winning us an SEC championship some year. How cool would that be?
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,794
18,487
113
It's not moronic. Given the right parameters and digital help, it is possible to crown a credible, demonstrable champion. In fact, I'd say that such a process is now a necessity. It just isn't as sexy as with a championship game.

Including the overall record and overall strength of schedule in that computation and even beating UPC could wind up winning us an SEC championship some year. How cool would that be?

Crowning a conference champion when you don't play 44% of the teams in your conference just doesn't make any sense. There's way too much variability for scheduling difficulty.

The most sensible thing would be conference contraction.
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,922
9,023
113
Crowning a conference champion when you don't play 44% of the teams in your conference just doesn't make any sense. There's way too much variability for scheduling difficulty.

The most sensible thing would be conference contraction.
That would certainly occasion a different TV money distribution system. Otherwise, you're looking at every school, or smaller cluster conferences, making individual rights deal. How well do you think we would come out in that arrangement?
 

Gamecock Jacque

Joined Dec 20, 2020
Jan 30, 2022
5,949
5,412
113
The NFL has taken over Thursday night and Friday is HS football night. I'm not sure a Wednesday night game would work well for people who had to travel to attend, especially if the game was at Clemson. The old "Big Thursday" game was always in Columbia during the state fair. I doubt Clemson would want to give up the home and home aspect of the game.
There's a college game tonight and Clemson is playing tomorrow on HS night.
 

cocksx5

Redshirt
Aug 16, 2026
112
44
28
then usc wont be able to go to some podunk bowl last week was our future without sellars,
unless sellars come back it's reason I'd fire beamer and make briles HC, or keep beamer elevate briles to cohead coach with big pay raise briles much more likely to get good qb out of portal v beamer
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,922
9,023
113
It wasn't supposed to be, but NIL is pay to play.
Everything was screwed when NIL went from being between players and the people who wanted to engage them for commercial purposes and started being packages that schools bundled to entice players to come. It was never intended to be that way: collectives, direct NIL involvement by schools. etc. Now it's wacked.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,794
18,487
113
Everything was screwed when NIL went from being between players and the people who wanted to engage them for commercial purposes and started being packages that schools bundled to entice players to come. It was never intended to be that way: collectives, direct NIL involvement by schools. etc. Now it's wacked.
Yeah, I think most of us on here saw exactly where it was heading. Conceptually, NIL was fine. Allow players to secure marketing deals for themselves. But it didn't take a genius to see how it would be exploited. Florida started the first collective one month after NIL took effect, so I don't know if there was ever a time when it was as you correctly state it should have been: between players and the people who wanted to engage them for commercial purposes.

It has been pay to play from the start.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,207
3,774
113
Yeah, I think most of us on here saw exactly where it was heading. Conceptually, NIL was fine. Allow players to secure marketing deals for themselves. But it didn't take a genius to see how it would be exploited. Florida started the first collective one month after NIL took effect, so I don't know if there was ever a time when it was as you correctly state it should have been: between players and the people who wanted to engage them for commercial purposes.

It has been pay to play from the start.

It is definitely de facto pay to play but the rules dictate that NIL payments cannot be tied to a player playing or his performance. That is why players can opt out of bowl games, or claim injury and not lose any money. I think as long as the player is on the team, he has to be paid his NIL money.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 18IsTheMan

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,794
18,487
113
It is definitely de facto pay to play but the rules dictate that NIL payments cannot be tied to a player playing or his performance. That is why players can opt out of bowl games, or claim injury and not lose any money. I think as long as the player is on the team, he has to be paid his NIL money.

Every year we hear how the current situation is unsustainable and that it will eventually come crashing down, but every year NIL money goes up. Kamario Taylor has started 8 games in his entire career and got an $8 million NIL deal. He's 4-4 against P4 teams in his career. I genuinely don't know where the money is coming from.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,207
3,774
113
Every year we hear how the current situation is unsustainable and that it will eventually come crashing down, but every year NIL money goes up. Kamario Taylor has started 8 games in his entire career and got an $8 million NIL deal. He's 4-4 against P4 teams in his career. I genuinely don't know where the money is coming from.
I especially wonder about it at places like MSSt, UK, NCSt, Arkansas or even SC for that matter. None of these programs are football powers and never have been. Who is putting up the huge sums of money that funds these NIL deals? Are the people donating really convinced they can give enough to buy enough talent to win big?

You point to Taylor, look no farther than right here with Sellers. He has gotten huge money and he is 4-4 against P4 teams so far this season. I wonder what Harbor is getting, or Stewart?

I know people will point to Indiana, but very few programs have a Mark Cuban willing to put huge money into NIL.
 
GamecockCentral

Latest

  1. 01 GamecockCentral Football Recruiting INTEL: Huge list of top prospects, including flip target, visiting South Carolina for UGA game
  2. 02 GamecockCentral Football Three keys to a South Carolina win over Georgia
  3. 03 GamecockCentral Football Behind Enemy Lines: Georgia radio personality breaks down Bulldogs ahead of South Carolina game
  4. 04 TheBigSpur Football Perry Orth | South Carolina needs LaNorris Sellers' legs to beat No. 1 Georgia
  5. 05 TheBigSpur Basketball South Carolina faces its toughest test yet, and Torvik says the gap is real