People bring that up a lot. They also forget that pre-1992, the conference only had 10 teams. Each team played 7 conference games. You had pretty good dispersion of games, so the #1 team at the end of the year was pretty representative. The SEC now has 16 teams with 9 conference games. A team avoids almost half the conference every year. Conferences initially expanded BECAUSE they wanted to have championship games. Take the championship game away and there's no need for the conferences as they exist.
Crowning a conference champion in a 16-team conference based on 9 games is moronic. In the NFL, every team plays every other team in their division 2x in the season.
Comparing pre-1992 to today is apples/oranges. The conference is 60% larger.
At the least, the 24-team CFP is a great reason for conference contraction.
With the SEC's current 16-team setup and 9 conference games, I'd simply make the entire conference one 16-team standings table.
Each team would continue playing 9 conference games using the current scheduling system:
• 3 permanent opponents
• 6 rotating opponents
• 9 conference games total
At the end of the regular season, the team with the best SEC record would be the SEC champion.
For example:
- Georgia 8-1
- Alabama 8-1
- Texas 7-2
- LSU 7-2
etc.
If two teams finish with the same record, use tiebreakers:
- Head-to-head result
- Record against common opponents
- Record against the highest-finishing common opponent
- Record against the next-highest common opponent
- Combined SEC winning percentage of opponents played
- CFP ranking
- Computer ranking as the final tiebreaker
I don't think the SEC needs a championship game to determine its champion. The 9-game conference schedule is already a significant enough sample size to determine who had the best conference season.
Eliminating the championship game would also have a huge benefit: it opens up an additional weekend on the college football calendar.
That weekend could then be used to start an expanded College Football Playoff earlier, which would be especially important if the CFP eventually expands to 24 teams.
In other words, let the SEC regular season determine the SEC champion, and use the weekend currently occupied by the SEC Championship Game to help accommodate a larger national playoff.