IOWA #15 in the 3rd CFP Rankings (Nov 17). "Clearly the decal matters quite a bit to this committee."

DukeSlater

All-American
Jul 2, 2023
2,488
5,491
113
Good lord folks. Let’s take a deep breath and stop panicking like a bunch of ladies. When we beat Illinois, we’ve got another data point advantage on Oregon and I’m not convinced that OSU is winning out. Let’s let the games play out instead of whining like a bunch of Nebraska fans.
Whining? Is it whining when somebody tries to overthrow the government and ends up dictator and we complain? When somebody commits a mugging, is it whining to complain when they get off with a $5 fine? This whole CFP thing is bullshitt, and everybody knows it. The SEC knows it. ESPN knows it. But just like in DC, they also know they can get away with it. In the context of college football, what is happening is absolutely criminal.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Iron Doc

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,212
29,238
113
Committee, driven by ESECPN, is playing chess....

--Everyone knows O$U frosh QB SUX, and they are a shell of the team they were to start the season.

--They know Oregon is playing their backup QB.

--They know they will get flack not including BIG teams with a chance to get into the Playoff

--By putting O$U/Oregon ABOVE Iowa, if any of the (NON-SEC) teams right above the BIG Teams lose(TxTch,WF), the BIG sends the weaker O$U and/or Oregon to the Playoff, setting them up to fail, and the committee can then 'brag' about including 3+ BIG teams, and also 'brag' about the $EC reclaiming they are the better conference.

sadly, you are probably right....
 
  • Like
Reactions: oldxbbc

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,212
29,238
113
He won't be next Year with Iowa returning nearly it's entire roster and at home and mad

This young IOWA team is definitively ahead of schedule. It would have been nice to see them get some experience in the CFP this year that they could have carried over to next year.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,212
29,238
113
I'm not convinced that will really matter. They'll just squeeze more SEC teams in.

If it was a 24 team bracket this year, I would not be surprised at all no matter how much lower Iowa would be.

With a 24 team field, I guess we should expect at least 8 SEC teams and maybe, if we are lucky, 4 B1G teams....
 
  • Like
Reactions: LIV4GOD

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,212
29,238
113
The weird thing is that Iowa wasn't even mentioned on the show after they showed them at 15. They talked about 1-12 and then the 3 and 4 loss teams that were just outside that group. Iowa wasn't mentioned once after that.

eSECpn tried to make little ol' IOWA's snub appear noncontroversial....
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,212
29,238
113
And people keep posting that, BUT that's not the issue. Many of these other teams have bad losses, certainly worse then Iowa losing at Minnesota, regardless of how bad we played. I can guarantee you if we had 4 losses we wouldn't sniff the top 25, maybe even 3 losses.

but IOWA is the only team where a "bad loss" seems to matter....

make it make sense....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Burghawk87

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,212
29,238
113
I live in Columbus and everyone was celebrating the win over Northwestern like they were a top 10 team. They were just happy to win the game. Even everyone Columbus thought they were done for the year, but now they're all excited again. The jump in rankings was like Iowa lost this week. Iowa didn't play bad enough for anyone to jump over them. Unfortunately, I think OSU will win out and make the top 12. Iowa will be on the outside looking in.

The screw job is in.
 

Anon1750875978

Heisman
Dec 26, 2018
10,439
17,984
113
We beat NW worse ON the Road than OSU did in the Shoe, and they jumped OSU over us with one more loss. Wouldn't have mattered if we scored again. They have their own metrics..
Doesn't change the FACT that there was no aggressiveness from the offense in either game in 2nd half.
That's hardly debatable.
As I mentioned in another post, Wake Forest scored 42 in the first half, on the road, against a good SMU team...then jumped two spots into the top 11.
Want to argue that fact as well?
Wake Forest doesn't involve "SEC bias".
 
Last edited:

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,212
29,238
113
Like Scott said its the decal. That and they know their not putting OSU in the playoff, so if they're above us, there's no way were getting in. They've already decided they're only going to put two B1G teams in this year. There was a lot of blow back after the B1G won the third straight title, and ESPN/ voters set the season up propping the SEC up even more than normal;.

Nailed it.

And what can be done about it?
 

83Hawk

All-Conference
Jan 1, 2023
1,930
4,297
113
Don't trip on their dicks against Minn and Iowa is in. Gave the committee a reason to leave them out. Nothing Iowa can do to get in at this point. Is what it is.
I don’t believe that. I think Iowa would still be on the outside looking in, even with only 1 loss.
The Hawks are not a blue blood, big name, or in the SEC. 3 strikes and you’re out.
I am on record stating Oregon would jump us this week. I was wrong about Ohio State, though. I thought they wouldn’t jump us until next week.
 

iahawkeyes17

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2014
963
2,401
83
IOWA playing a ranked Illinois team this week would have mattered

Instead, they ranked FOUR OF THE 7 of the 6-4 SEC teams

At least they showed some restraint and didn't rank 6-4 Auburn, 6-4 LSU and 6-4 Missouri....
Sure if committee showed teams receiving votes just outside top 25 it would be
26- LSU
27- Mizzou
28- Auburn
29- Miss St
30- A & M
31- Vandy
32- Arkansas
 
  • Like
Reactions: Franisdaman

iahawkeyes17

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2014
963
2,401
83
The Big10 doesn't care about Iowa as long as 3 loss OSU and Oregon are above them.
If we got passed by teams like this from other conference sure our commish may pipe in. But it’s radio silence because they probably feel like those 2 have a better shot in the playoffs than us.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,212
29,238
113
They are using OSU as a decoy to slide Oregon by Iowa. Everyone will celebrate saying OSU is out and forget all about the Oregon screw job of Iowa. They also aren’t talking about Tennessee losing to LSU which should eliminate them. I honestly think now Tennessee could lose and they will put them in because it was a “close loss” to a “great” lsu team.

Yep. Moving up Ohio State allowed the head to head to come into play.

The selection committee considers head-to-head results when evaluating teams that are comparable or when teams are being ranked side-by-side within the same evaluation pod.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,212
29,238
113
Sad but true. You flip our resume with Ohio st and Oregon zero chance we get in with 1 more loss than them let alone ever ranked higher. I bet if we had one of their resumes we’d be in the upper teens. Same if another big 10 school not a name brand like mich st or Wisconsin had their 3 loss resume they aren’t sniffing top 15 either.

It really is something. Like you said, NO WAY a 7-3 IOWA passes an 8-2 Ohio State or an 8-2 Oregon....
 

bulletproof90

Sophomore
Oct 9, 2010
43
100
18
The Minnesota loss was by 3 on the road. Minnesota almost beat Indiana in Indiana, were it not for 60 yard FG on the last play. Is it really that bad of a loss?

Conversely, the majority of our wins have been wrapped up in the 2nd quarter. Winning that convincingly should count for something.

I’m curious to see what the committee does next week if we beat Illinois. It’s going to become really difficult for them to justify ranking Oregon ahead of Iowa, with them having one more loss and now having a common opponent that we beat and they lost to, in addition to their loss to an Oklahoma State team that was beaten by our non-conference opponent ISU.
 

BigOHawk1

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2001
671
1,225
93
The Minnesota loss was by 3 on the road. Minnesota almost beat Indiana in Indiana, were it not for 60 yard FG on the last play. Is it really that bad of a loss?

Conversely, the majority of our wins have been wrapped up in the 2nd quarter. Winning that convincingly should count for something.

I’m curious to see what the committee does next week if we beat Illinois. It’s going to become really difficult for them to justify ranking Oregon ahead of Iowa, with them having one more loss and now having a common opponent that we beat and they lost to, in addition to their loss to an Oklahoma State team that was beaten by our non-conference opponent ISU.
1,000 percent THIS and I'm still shocked they moved Oregon this week knowing the opponent for Iowa. They can take their pods and do you know what! OSU moving up that far is so dumb, I can't even go there..
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,212
29,238
113
You were VERY clear that its Iowa's fault because they lost to Minny. Don't backpedal now. Should we have lost? NO. BUT its over the top obvious that every team is NOT being graded the same way. That's all were saying

It really does amaze me how some IOWA fans consider any IOWA loss 100% unacceptable.

The reality, that you and most of us know? Upsets happen all of the time. Should we be 9-1? Yeah. But that's why the games are played....When the IOWA players don't show up and make mistake after mistake, well, you get what you deserve....
 

iahawkeyes17

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2014
963
2,401
83
#21 South Carolina (6-4).

SMGDH....
I mentioned before they play Georgia this week. First I was thinking stayed ranked so with it being prime time game have a # next to each team and I’m sure Somehow they’ll keep them at 25 if they lose because of how much it benefits sec if they do.

South Carolina being ranked helps 2 teams for sec a lot. bama give them a 2nd top 25 win and usc also beat Tenn. and so it doesn’t count as a “bad loss”. Them being ranked benefits 2 of their playoff teams even though they have no business being so. It would be like USC losing to Maryland this week by 4 tds and only dropping 4 spots.
 

10001110101

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2003
1,329
1,775
113
So Wisconsin, Northwestern and Michigan were not "fake rankings"? SEC bias exists, sure. But like it or not, the teams above us all have better resumes. One problem is our schedule (which is largely out of our control). No Indiana, Oregon, USC, UCLA.
Losing at Minnesota knocked us out of the hunt. End of story.
Iowa lost a game they shouldn't have lost this season. A college football first! Such a thing has never happened before... (sarcasm, of course)

Also, oh by they way, the college football power structure is unacceptably biased and corrupt.

We are allowed to talk about the bias and corruption. If all you want to talk about is Iowa's bad loss, have at it. We can talk about about the bigger picture too. The bigger picture that is ruining college football.

So, no, your post was not the "end of story."
 
  • Love
Reactions: Franisdaman

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,666
15,901
113
If we got passed by teams like this from other conference sure our commish may pipe in. But it’s radio silence because they probably feel like those 2 have a better shot in the playoffs than us.
Well he's certainly not going to rail about Oregon and OSU being ranked above Iowa. That's Iowa's job.
 

iahawkeyes17

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2014
963
2,401
83
Well then, let's do this:
OSU loses to Neb
Oregon loses to Sparty and/or Wash
Indiana loses a game

Iowa to BTCG...and beats UCLA to get into the CFP!
If, and a big if. Wash going 2-0 would be huge for us. Beat IU at home this week and Oregon week later helps us a ton. then makes our W over them look a whole lot better.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Franisdaman

BunchofAholes

All-American
Jul 9, 2025
2,645
5,001
113
Iowa lost a game they shouldn't have lost this season. A college football first! Such a thing has never happened before... (sarcasm, of course)

Also, oh by they way, the college football power structure is unacceptably biased and corrupt.

We are allowed to talk about the bias and corruption. If all you want to talk about is Iowa's bad loss, have at it. We can talk about about the bigger picture too. The bigger picture that is ruining college football.

So, no, your post was not the "end of story."
But it was the end of our playoff chances. That's the point.
 

MacMiney

Senior
Jul 3, 2025
377
696
93
If I heard right, the committee chair used a "still figuring out their quarterback situation" excuse for another team. I'm not sure of the exact wording, but that very wording could have been used in Iowa's case too when considering Minnesota. I think that's when I had to stop listening to that bubba man, or my brain was gonna explode.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Franisdaman

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,212
29,238
113
Seriously? His message to his PLAYERS is we need to go win the next game. Control what we can. He knows he has NO control over what this dumb A---- committee does.

A few weeks ago Kirk said that since we were a "FOX team" and no longer an "ESPN team," we probably wouldn't even be ranked. He was being tongue in cheek but he knew the politics and BS involved in this whole process.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MacMiney
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Basketball WATCH: Jan Jensen, Hawkeyes recap Vandy, preview Montana State
  2. 02 Rivals Basketball Recruiting Inside the recruitment of No. 12-ranked Grant Duggins: Where things stand with UNC, NC State, Kansas & more
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Basketball Recruiting Keller Daugherty officially signs with Iowa
  4. 04 On3 Football Kirk Ferentz: Iowa coaches bringing up style points in CFP race 'could be grounds for firing'
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Football PFF Deep Dive: Illinois Fighting Illini