KC and the Offensive game plan and calls

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
Exactly how it happened. Rumor was Schiano upped the salary 3 separate times to get Kirk to the banks. All while getting denied by multiple other OC candidates in the process.
And yet some want KC fired so the next OC can come in and be told not to put receivers in motion, not to pitch the ball, not to run a play that has any risk of negative yardage, etc.
 

kupuna133

All-American
Jul 13, 2015
7,836
9,074
113
And yet some want KC fired so the next OC can come in and be told not to put receivers in motion, not to pitch the ball, not to run a play that has any risk of negative yardage, etc.
I am one of the biggest critics of Kirk. Mostly due to the fact that he is awful in the red zone. But Kirk has not been the biggest issue the past 3-4 years.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
I am one of the biggest critics of Kirk. Mostly due to the fact that he is awful in the red zone. But Kirk has not been the biggest issue the past 3-4 years.
We can be critics and believe that an OC is just average and nothing special. That’s fair but it doesn’t mean that they are ‘bad’ and solely responsible for the outcome. The outcome is dependent on so many things, S&C coach, recruiting, position coaches, of course the head coach.

A poorly run program with a good OC and good DC probably will have bad outcomes.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,525
61,846
113
He fired KC 1.0 and, paraphrasing, said that we tried to go to an offense we didn’t fully understand and needed to revert back. In other words, he wasn’t comfortable with the spread offense.

He tried AGAIN to deviate with Gleason and could not

Both KC ans SG would go on to have better success elsewhere.

The common theme is Schiano and Rutgers associated with the failures, not the OCs.

There is no scenario on earth where Schiano hasn’t influenced this. None.
completely agree.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU on Manns Planet

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,872
3,363
66
The lack of actual historical knowledge is astounding in this thread.

We have posters here who believe that GS is telling the coordinator not to put people in motion and that that is his philosophy. Did these people not watch when McNulty was the coordinator or other years when we had multiple people in motion? Or other years when we tried multiple trick plays? But yet, they want to take the KC years, the lack of motion, the lack of creativity, and tie that to a general philosophy. If it was correct, it would be correct. It’s just not factually correct. There’s nothing to demonstrate that he has not had a free hand in calling the offense.

there is plenty to complain about, most notably the linebacker usage. But making up facts or bootstrapping things that just aren’t true doesn’t really help the discussion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rutgers25

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
The lack of actual historical knowledge is astounding in this thread.

We have posters here who believe that GS is telling the coordinator not to put people in motion and that that is his philosophy. Did these people not watch when McNulty was the coordinator or other years when we had multiple people in motion? Or other years when we tried multiple trick plays? But yet, they want to take the KC years, the lack of motion, the lack of creativity, and tie that to a general philosophy. If it was correct, it would be correct. It’s just not factually correct. There’s nothing to demonstrate that he has not had a free hand in calling the offense.

there is plenty to complain about, most notably the linebacker usage. But making up facts or bootstrapping things that just aren’t true doesn’t really help the discussion.
I’m open to further debate, but using stuff from 1.0 isn’t convincing. Schiano used to block kicks in the past but doesn’t anymore, for example. Coaches change, based on their experiences.

I believe:
1. He feels snake bitten by trying more varied offenses, especially seeing the Wisky, OSU and Michigan games get taken away with pick 6s and/or scoop and scores.
2. Has a ‘woh is Rutgers’ mindset that we can’t match up, which justifies the philosophy that we must make less mistakes than our opponents.

I don’t believe there is an OC on earth who designs an offense with a tiny playbook that focuses on eliminating every potential execution risk and which isn’t focused on some level of deception. Were WRs never in motion when KC was at Minny?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wagram97

B6510

Freshman
Jun 29, 2026
91
85
3
You have this backward I think. People don’t want to work for Schiano. Schiano had to court KC for a long time to get him to agree to come and had to over pay him to get him….the ‘Schiano tax’. Rutgers needed him more than he needed Rutgers.

KC is an older guy and I’m sure told Greg that he’ll do what Greg wants him to do at this salary level and is beyond the point in his career where he feels like battling. Remember that Schiano already scape goated KC after the 2010 season…..gee, and I wonder why we had to over pay him the second time!
I agreee that most of what you’re saying was all true when he was hired. They were a 3 win team that was in the process of rebuilding the program and had limited talent. But now two straight years the team is regressing and you have two new quarterbacks who are not mobile and an Online that can’t pass protect. As the team struggles each week all that other stuff you mentioned should no longer matter. He’s still the OC trying to win and if Schiano is gone, so is he. So if he values his job he should be willing to do what it takes to win.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
I agreee that most of what you’re saying was all true when he was hired. They were a 3 win team that was in the process of rebuilding the program and had limited talent. But now two straight years the team is regressing and you have two new quarterbacks who are not mobile and an Online that can’t pass protect. As the team struggles each week all that other stuff you mentioned should no longer matter. He’s still the OC trying to win and if Schiano is gone, so is he. So if he values his job he should be willing to do what it takes to win.
I still think it’s more nuanced. The OC reports to the HC so if the HC doesn’t like what the OC is doing, then they work on alternate tactics and strategies. The HC doesn’t just sit there all season not providing input and direction.

Remember that KC didn’t want to come here and only took the job with a contract that set him up for life. At his age, he is not terrified about keeping this job. I’m sure in his mind he is doing the best that he can within the bounds of the players that are there and what Greg is asking for which is minimize turnovers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Caliknight

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,872
3,363
66
There is no proof that KC has been fettered in any way in his play calling, or his use of personnel.
Again, there’s plenty of blame on a lot of issues, but the idea that the offensive coordinator has been limited in his ability to call plays and is not being himself is just flat out wrong.

The relevance is next year. If we are not expected to have superior talent, you can’t go into next year, have him calling the exact same type of plays
 

ddsmugs

All-Conference
Jun 5, 2009
7,021
3,941
113
How hard is it to script a few plays with 2 backs in the backfield......would give something for a defense to figure out.
 

sct1111

All-American
Nov 30, 2014
6,170
8,516
113
Kirk Ciarocca is not the problem with this team. Last 2 years were our best offenses in a long time. The players stink.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
How hard is it to script a few plays with 2 backs in the backfield......would give something for a defense to figure out.
Schiano at the post game press conference literally told us what the philosophy of the program is, which is to limit the playbook and focus on execution. That is why Gleason was fired and he hired a guy that is aligned his philosophy or at least willing to go along with it. There were reports from 1.0 that a play could not be run in a game until he cleared it in practice.

He did say with so many injuries they are trying to add some things, presumably such as the end around we saw, but made it clear that he is concerned with execution if you try to do too many things.

I don’t know how to do this but I’d like to compare the playbook when KC was at PSU and Minny compared to now.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
I have frequently said that Greg‘s ceiling is 9 wins, regardless of what roster and what I summarize below is yet another reason why

To summarize more succinctly what Greg said after the game was that if you want to be the type of program with a large playbook doing a lot of different things, then you need to go all in on that. He did not elaborate on what that means, but we are supposed to infer that is not the philosophy of our program therefore whatever it is, we are not doing it.

So let’s say you take our current philosophy, and everybody is healthy and you have competent players at all positions, I see the logic that you can be successful as opposed to trying to run a larger playbook and not executing all of the plays perfectly.

Here is the problem though. As soon as any cog in that wheel breaks and you no longer can execute, you are dead in the water with nowhere to go. I think the biggest illustration was the Illinois game last year where coming into the game, their defense was poorly rated, but we had Strong out. Whatever Illinois did, they completely owned us on every play, and we barely could move the ball. Series after series, we didn’t try to do anything different and just kept trying to ‘execute’ even though we could not. With a larger playbook, you would at least be able to lean on running some riskier plays even with a higher level of execution risk. You need to have somewhere to go when the standard approach is not working.

These types of philosophies are why there is a 9 win ceiling, even with an elite roster, because when the going gets tough, you are curling up in the fetal position and don’t have a way of trying to win the game. By no means do I want to compare Bryant basketball to Nebraska football but when the basketball team was struggling the other day, Knight went with a completely different lineup with a completely different philosophy and totally flipped the game.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Wagram97

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,707
151,546
113
How hard is it to script a few plays with 2 backs in the backfield......would give something for a defense to figure out.
Takes imagination. Schiano is a meathead who has watched Rocky 1.0 too many times. He said himself in the press conference “we put a high value on execution”. He hasn’t realized you can execute trickery. But as he said, “he’s not in the business of tricking people”.
 

CaptBob

Junior
Jun 3, 2001
283
216
43
And just think, Schiano's here for at least another year!!
Bill Murray Well Its Groundhog Day Again GIF
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUnotentertained

Wagram97

Senior
Mar 27, 2023
600
793
93
I have frequently said that Greg‘s ceiling is 9 wins, regardless of what roster and what I summarize below is yet another reason why

To summarize more succinctly what Greg said after the game was that if you want to be the type of program with a large playbook doing a lot of different things, then you need to go all in on that. He did not elaborate on what that means, but we are supposed to infer that is not the philosophy of our program therefore whatever it is, we are not doing it.

So let’s say you take our current philosophy, and everybody is healthy and you have competent players at all positions, I see the logic that you can be successful as opposed to trying to run a larger playbook and not executing all of the place perfectly.

Here is the problem though. As soon as any cog in that wheel breaks and you no longer can execute, you are dead in the water with nowhere to go. I think the biggest illustration was the Illinois game last year where coming into the game, their defense was poorly rated, but we had Strong out. Whatever Illinois did, they completely owned us on every play, and we barely could move the ball. Series after series, we didn’t try to do anything different and just kept trying to ‘execute’ even though we could not. With a larger playbook, you would at least be able to lean on running some riskier plays even with a higher level of execution risk. You need to have somewhere to go when The Standard approach is not working.

These types of philosophies are why there is a 9 win ceiling, even with an elite roster, because when the going gets tough, you are curling up in the fetal position and don’t have a way of trying to win the game. By no means do I want to compare Bryant basketball to Nebraska football but when the basketball team was struggling the other day, Knight went with a completely different lineup with a completely different philosophy and totally flipped the game.
This is also why we never seem to be able to get that "surprising win." Other teams can do that because they try different plays that catch the other team by surprise. How you get Gleason calling a completely new game plan against Purdue back in 2020 with Langan.

But after 2022, especially that Nebraska loss, that mindset went out the door. After that season, Schiano went back to believing it was all about being in control and minimizing mistakes.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
Takes imagination. Schiano is a meathead who has watched Rocky 1.0 too many times. He said himself in the press conference “we put a high value on execution”. He hasn’t realized you can execute trickery. But as he said, “he’s not in the business of tricking people”.
And ‘deception is over rated’.

Rutgers put a WR in motion last year in the red zone and scored an easy TD.

Can you imagine trying to play basketball without using picks and screens because of fear of getting called for a moving pick?
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
This is also why we never seem to be able to get that "surprising win." Other teams can do that because they try different plays that catch the other team by surprise. How you get Gleason calling a completely new game plan against Purdue back in 2020 with Langan.

But after 2022, especially that Nebraska loss, that mindset went out the door. After that season, Schiano went back to believing it was all about being in control and minimizing mistakes.
I think at the beginning of 2.0, he tried to come in with a new philosophy, and he also was in the honeymoon phase and had some rope to play with. He made a big show of saying that the offense will be multiple and make the other team defend sideline into sideline. As the pressure mounted, and he saw turnovers and what he considers riskiness causing problems, I think he slowly but surely dialed things back to the way that he prefers them.

To pull off an upset in football or even to win a good share of 50/50 games, there are two primary ways to do it.

-Just get lucky where the other team makes a lot of mistakes. Think of Michigan missing field goals, and all of the mistakes that Washington made against us a couple of years ago. By the end of the season, though, we would realize that was barely an upset as they had a pretty mediocre season. I would call this the passive approach as you are basically just sitting back and hoping the other team makes errors, which is primarily actually not going to work to pull an upset because good teams are typically good teams because they don’t do this.

-Making your own luck means introducing wrinkles that the other team has not seen and taking risks and hoping they work in your favor. For example, UCLA did an onside kick against Penn State last season in the first quarter and it was a significant contributor to why they pulled the upset. I have seen elite teams like Oregon and Indiana called trick place at critical points in tight games to pull off wins. People get confused about when Greg goes for it on fourth and short and saying he is taking big risks and being aggressive, but he is doing this formulaically as the statistics show that he actually isn’t taking big risks when he makes these type of calls.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wagram97
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report The Knight Report - Ask The Experts Chat: November 18th Edition
  2. 02 The Knight Report Wrestling Rutgers Wrestlers in the latest InterMat Rankings - Week Three
  3. 03 The Knight Report Basketball How to watch Rutgers / Notre Dame; Pregame Info, More: Gameday Central
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's Houston Postgame Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 8 Houston in Players Era 8 opener