I have frequently said that Greg‘s ceiling is 9 wins, regardless of what roster and what I summarize below is yet another reason why
To summarize more succinctly what Greg said after the game was that if you want to be the type of program with a large playbook doing a lot of different things, then you need to go all in on that. He did not elaborate on what that means, but we are supposed to infer that is not the philosophy of our program therefore whatever it is, we are not doing it.
So let’s say you take our current philosophy, and everybody is healthy and you have competent players at all positions, I see the logic that you can be successful as opposed to trying to run a larger playbook and not executing all of the plays perfectly.
Here is the problem though. As soon as any cog in that wheel breaks and you no longer can execute, you are dead in the water with nowhere to go. I think the biggest illustration was the Illinois game last year where coming into the game, their defense was poorly rated, but we had Strong out. Whatever Illinois did, they completely owned us on every play, and we barely could move the ball. Series after series, we didn’t try to do anything different and just kept trying to ‘execute’ even though we could not. With a larger playbook, you would at least be able to lean on running some riskier plays even with a higher level of execution risk. You need to have somewhere to go when the standard approach is not working.
These types of philosophies are why there is a 9 win ceiling, even with an elite roster, because when the going gets tough, you are curling up in the fetal position and don’t have a way of trying to win the game. By no means do I want to compare Bryant basketball to Nebraska football but when the basketball team was struggling the other day, Knight went with a completely different lineup with a completely different philosophy and totally flipped the game.