Toggle sidebar

OT: 2026 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Nominees

MADHAT1

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
31,648
16,440
113
bac2therac said:
They should start breaking it up into catagories and nominate one from each group and start puttting in country artists which somehow dont fit their diversity aim

Rock
Pop
R&B
Rap
Country
Wildcard
Fan Vote
Click to expand...
Change the name to The Music Hall of Fame, like many artists want, and have the categories you posted part of it
As for adding Country singers , I grew up thinking Carl Perkins , Johnny Cash , Brenda Lee and some other rockabilly singers were rock and roll , not Country artists.
Later as rockabilly songs lost popularity I looked at them as country and not rock and roll
But in the 1950s you could say "a little bit country-a little rock&roll" made the rockabilly movement popular
and some of the artists deserving a place in both the Country and Rock & Roll Hall of Fame
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUGuitarMan1 and bac2therac
R

RUGuitarMan1

All-Conference
Apr 5, 2021
2,528
3,945
73
MADHAT1 said:
Change the name to The Music Hall of Fame, like many artists want, and have the categories you posted part of it
As for adding Country singers , I grew up thinking Carl Perkins , Johnny Cash , Brenda Lee and some other rockabilly singers were rock and roll , not Country artists.
Later as rockabilly songs lost popularity I looked at them as country and not rock and roll
But in the 1950s you could say "a little bit country-a little rock&roll" made the rockabilly movement popular
and some of the artists deserving a place in both the Country and Rock & Roll Hall of Fame
Click to expand...

“Rockabilly” is rock & roll in its purest form. A fusion of mostly rhythm & blues and country western. Elvis Presley, Eddie Cochran, Gene Vincent among others. There is a lot of music today that gets broadly labeled under “country” which is much more blues, rock, funk, etc. The reason is that there are some people who write or talk about music today that are uninformed and not musically literate:

 
  • Like
Reactions: BIGRUBIGDBIGredmachine and MADHAT1
R

RUShea

All-Conference
Jan 31, 2017
1,051
1,867
113
Couple links. If you can watch this and think Pink, New Edition or anyone else on the ballot (except Maiden, they absolutely should be in) is more rock & roll, then I don't know what to say. Crowes need to be in.



 
K

Kbe4

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
637
591
93
I've actually only enjoyed The Black Crowes from 2007-2011, when one of my favorite guitarists...Luther Dickinson...was in the band.
 
R

RUGuitarMan1

All-Conference
Apr 5, 2021
2,528
3,945
73
I had checked out of rock music from the late ‘70’s to the late ‘80’s. There was some good stuff in the ‘80’s but for me - no where near the quality of the rock music of the ‘60s and early 70’s. When the ‘90’s hit, it seemed to be a rebirth (at least for a while) and the Black Crowes were my favorite band from that era. I think this is my favorite tune from them:

 
R

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,234
44,313
113
Here are your inductees. The only ones I really cared about, Joy Division/New Order, got in, so I'm happy about that.

1776141755112.png
 
B

Bueller

Junior
Nov 28, 2025
385
332
63
Vlife said:
I'm surprised Joy Division/New Order were not already in
Click to expand...

I heard a music biz exec say a reason some musicians/bands make it in over others is their current profitability. Robert Smith of The Cure said that without Joy Division there might never have been The Cure. The Cure are still active and making money and Joy Division isn't so The Cure got in HOF and JD had to wait until now
 
R

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,234
44,313
113
Bueller said:
I heard a music biz exec say a reason some musicians/bands make it in over others is their current profitability. Robert Smith of The Cure said that without Joy Division there might never have been The Cure. The Cure are still active and making money and Joy Division isn't so The Cure got in HOF and JD had to wait until now
Click to expand...
Joy Division probably has a more fanatic following, but New Order is/was a far bigger act, financially, especially in the UK, where they had 6 #1 albums (7 if you count Substance, their greatest hits album thru 1987), while they only had a few top 40 albums in the US. But I'm pretty sure their influence on countless bands is the biggest reason they got in. Will be interesting to see if co-founder Peter Hook rejoins the band for the induction (he left the band in 2007).
 
K

Kbe4

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
637
591
93
RU848789 said:
We disagree - I'm good with the "big tent" approach of the R&RHOF.
Click to expand...
I've been a fan of rock and roll for over 60 years. I know what rock and roll is. The three I mentioned are most definitely NOT rock and roll. And thus they do not belong in the Rock and Roll Hall Of Fame.
It's not a friggin tent. It's a hall of fame.....supposedly for rock and roll. Put them in the Popular Music Hall Of Fame and you' ll get no argument from me.
 
K

Kbe4

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
637
591
93
RU848789 said:
Joy Division probably has a more fanatic following, but New Order is/was a far bigger act, financially, especially in the UK, where they had 6 #1 albums (7 if you count Substance, their greatest hits album thru 1987), while they only had a few top 40 albums in the US. But I'm pretty sure their influence on countless bands is the biggest reason they got in. Will be interesting to see if co-founder Peter Hook rejoins the band for the induction (he left the band in 2007).
Click to expand...
I'm definitely one of Joy Division's most fanatic fans. New Order not so much.
 
B

Bueller

Junior
Nov 28, 2025
385
332
63
Kbe4 said:
I'm definitely one of Joy Division's most fanatic fans. New Order not so much.
Click to expand...

Ian Curtis was Joy Division pretty much. New Order formed just weeks after his suicide at 24 yrs old. I like New Order better but still not a lot. Joy Division laid the groundwork for a lot of post-punk alternative so I appreciate the cultural shift but "Love Will Tear Us Apart" is sort of like Van Gogh's Sunset With Crows in that both are permeated with death. Curtis was already gone when song came out
 
K

Kbe4

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
637
591
93
I'm still waiting on a nomination for Ravi Shankar ?
How many albums did he sell ?
 
R

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,234
44,313
113
Kbe4 said:
I've been a fan of rock and roll for over 60 years. I know what rock and roll is. The three I mentioned are most definitely NOT rock and roll. And thus they do not belong in the Rock and Roll Hall Of Fame.
It's not a friggin tent. It's a hall of fame.....supposedly for rock and roll. Put them in the Popular Music Hall Of Fame and you' ll get no argument from me.
Click to expand...
Length of fandom is irrelevant. You have an opinion, which you're entitled to, as do I. We simply disagree - there is no "definitely" associated with a subjective opinion.
 
R

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,234
44,313
113
Kbe4 said:
I'm definitely one of Joy Division's most fanatic fans. New Order not so much.
Click to expand...
I love both with a slight preference for New Order, probably because they have a few more of my favorite songs: Age of Consent, Love Vigilantes and, possibly my all-time favorite song, Temptation.
 
R

RUGuitarMan1

All-Conference
Apr 5, 2021
2,528
3,945
73
I wanted The Black Crowes and INXS to get in. Thought both terrific rock bands with at least several very good albums. I’m for an expanded view of rock music, it is not an easy thing to define. I think many have a very constricted view of what rock music is. However, with a number of the musical acts added into the HOF over the last 15 years or so, I’m now in favor of calling it “The Popular Music Hall of Fame”.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift and Kbe4
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom