Rare Penn State Wrestling Cards

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Nov 12, 2025

• #1

Please delete if not allowed

Check out our wrestling cards in eBay

Many more to be listed, lots of Cael cards available

americanvintagewrestlingcards on eBay

 

• 

Reactions: mh-larch

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Nov 13, 2025

• #2

(Lot Of 5) 2009 Press Pass Fusion Cael Sanderson Olympic College Wrestling Card | eBay

 

M

mh-larch

Senior

Nov 20, 2019

264

597

93

• Nov 13, 2025

• #3

Interesting. I didn't even know wrestling cards were a thing.

 

• 

Reactions: Pointingdogsrule, BobPSU92, Fatwoodchuck and 1 other person

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Nov 14, 2025

• #4

mh-larch said:

Interesting. I didn't even know wrestling cards were a thing.

Click to expand...

It is a great hobby, but we have too many.

 

• 

Reactions: mh-larch

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Nov 17, 2025

• #5

Kerry McCoy

2 Kerry McCoy Penn State College Wrestling Cards 1998 Culture House + 2001 Roox | eBay

 

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Nov 29, 2025

• #6

15 Different Penn State College Wrestling Cards, Including John Hughes | eBay

Putting up a bunch of cool, affordable Penn State Cards now

 

Goggles Paisano

All-Conference

Feb 6, 2018

774

2,007

93

• Nov 29, 2025

• #7

Aren't all wrestling cards rare?

 

• 
• 

Reactions: Brian LB-U, Pointingdogsrule, WexfordWarrior and 1 other person

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Nov 29, 2025

• #8

Goggles Paisano said:

Aren't all wrestling cards rare?

Click to expand...

Probably true

 

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Nov 30, 2025

• #9

15 Different Penn State College Wrestling Cards, Including Jeff Prescott + Kolat | eBay

Jeff Prescott Card!

 

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Dec 31, 2025

• #10

Bill Koll - 1985 Big League Legends of Wrestling College Olympic Penn State Card | eBay

Bill Koll card

 

• 

Reactions: mh-larch

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Jan 5, 2026

• #11

2 Kerry McCoy Penn State College Wrestling Cards 1998 Culture House + 2001 Roox | eBay

Kerry Mc Coy is a hot item in card market

 

E

Efejle

All-Conference

Apr 30, 2023

882

2,080

93

• Jan 8, 2026

• #12

Im looking for the following:

Andy Mater
Hoagie Sciabica
Jerry "White Lightning" White
Dan Mayo
Sanshiro Abe
Jimmy Martin
Hughes Brothers
James English rookie card, extremely rare

 

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Jan 15, 2026

• #13

2009 Emerald Press Pass Auto/50 Bruce Baumgartner Olympic College Wrestling Card | eBay

 

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Jan 15, 2026

• #14

Efejle said:

Im looking for the following:

Andy Mater
Hoagie Sciabica
Jerry "White Lightning" WhiteReply
Dan Mayo
Sanshiro Abe
Jimmy Martin
Hughes Brothers
James English rookie card, extremely rare

Click to expand...

Checking the inventory now!

 

jayridescarbon

Senior

Jan 28, 2019

272

769

93

• Jan 15, 2026

• #15

AmericanVintageCards said:

Checking the inventory now!

Click to expand...

Have any paid Iowa hater cards?

 

• 

Reactions: Danoftw

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Jan 16, 2026

• #16

Efejle said:

Im looking for the following:

Andy Mater
Hoagie Sciabica
Jerry "White Lightning" White
Dan Mayo
Sanshiro Abe
Jimmy Martin
Hughes Brothers
James English rookie card, extremely rare

Click to expand...

 

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Jan 16, 2026

• #17

jayridescarbon said:

Have any paid Iowa hater cards?

Click to expand...

Tons of Iowa cards
Hate at your discretion

 

A

AmericanVintageCards

Redshirt

Nov 12, 2025

38

14

8

• Saturday at 6:59 AM

• #18

KYLE DAKE 2nd Edition Real American Freestyle Olympic College Wrestling Card RAF | eBay

RAF Cards are up in the Store

 

P

Potterlion

Senior

Jan 25, 2011

183

712

93

• Saturday at 11:02 AM

• #19

AmericanVintageCards said:

15 Different Penn State College Wrestling Cards, Including Jeff Prescott + Kolat | eBay

Jeff Prescott Card!

Click to expand...

This set has some pretty cool guys. It's not my cup of tea and I'm not really too interested, but I do know Jeff and run into him occasionally. He'd probably be pleased to see that card.

 

• 

Reactions: AmericanVintageCards

P

Piketownman

Junior

Oct 8, 2021

185

390

63

• Saturday at 3:15 PM

• #20

The Iowa cards are great for clipping to the spokes of my grandsons bike wheels