Who impressed you the least? 2026 NCAA Championship Edition

What impressed you the least at the 2026 NCAA Championships?

  • Rutgers (tied with George Mason for 34th place at 7 pts)

    Votes: 5 3.2%
  • Referees / Challenge Officials

    Votes: 83 52.5%
  • Crowd booing SVN for being drug tested

    Votes: 7 4.4%
  • Locking fingers in neutral

    Votes: 35 22.2%
  • Ohio State

    Votes: 24 15.2%
  • Without naming names, some of the MFFs

    Votes: 3 1.9%
  • Wrestling Twitter

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other (Please Specify Below)

    Votes: 1 0.6%

  • Total voters
    158

Honcho

Senior
Jan 20, 2016
202
644
93
I said it was unnecessary but that's premature because I'm not sure if it's something he always does if so I will revisit
Tired Ariana Grande GIF by NETFLIX
 

paleryder

Junior
Apr 28, 2017
78
243
33
Just trying to understand what happened. Did Mitchell do this when he won his other Title? Is this something he's always done or is it new this year? You can think what you want but I'm actually being serious and trying to understand the situation better. It's not always what you think but you do you
Just let it go son, it's not that big of a deal
 

PSUer89

Senior
Feb 6, 2017
146
411
63
Caliendo shook hands after the match ended. Maybe standing there and watching Mitch get the medal, again, was just really difficult and he didn’t feel the need to shake hands again. I am sure members of the board are giving it way more thought than Messenbrink. I know I have never lost on the biggest stage (or gotten to the biggest stage) so I have no idea how I would react.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cali_Nittany1

Corby2

All-American
Jul 14, 2025
3,454
7,500
113
I think you’re trying to be clever and play a game with the people on here. What’s not cool is that the people you’re playing your game with are typically the most respectful people posting here. That’s my opinion and I’m sticking with it.
I'm actually not .
 

donboy6499

All-Conference
Jun 9, 2025
741
1,402
93
Did Mitchell shake everyone's hand on the podium after Carr beat him? Or is only a gentleman when he wins?
Unless that was going through Caliendo’s mind at that moment, why does that matter?

Right, with no evidence otherwise, you’re both sidesing this one.

Me to my 7 year old: Why didn’t you say thank you to the kind lady who held the door for you at Sheetz?

My son: Do you think she always says thanks to people holding the door.

Me to my 7 year old: Good point, makes sense why you didn’t say thanks.
 

donboy6499

All-Conference
Jun 9, 2025
741
1,402
93
So what's the answer to my questions ? Did he shake everyone's hand when he lost?


I'm a wrestling fan that's been stated by me over and over and I don't have a team . The last "team" I rooted for was Rutgers when I lived in NJ years ago
“So dad, you haven’t answered my question, Does she always say thank you to everyone”
 
  • Like
Reactions: trufan

Nittany1997

Sophomore
Dec 18, 2014
256
198
28
Caliendo shook hands after the match ended. Maybe standing there and watching Mitch get the medal, again, was just really difficult and he didn’t feel the need to shake hands again. I am sure members of the board are giving it way more thought than Messenbrink. I know I have never lost on the biggest stage (or gotten to the biggest stage) so I have no idea how I would react.
You would have some class, I am sure of it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSUer89

El_Jefe

Heisman
Oct 11, 2021
3,310
13,105
113
The ref and review official in Duke match.
Obviously many people including myself have commented the numerous issues about that decision. Some have said worst call ever at Nationals. I would think Jordan Oliver would disagree. His grab of a 2nd ankle against Steiber with no points awarded was in the finals. They ended up changing the rule.
Moving forward I would think that the officials will be told to signal 3 but allow action to continue with no whistle blown . On first break award the 3 even if pin takes place (No pin bonus point). They can review the original call to confirm without stopping the initial move .
Offhand, Perry-Evans and Churella-Hendricks were also worse calls.
 

Corby2

All-American
Jul 14, 2025
3,454
7,500
113
It doesn’t matter if he always does it. He did it this time and Caliendo looked like an ***. Everyone except for Iowa fans and Bo Nickel agree.
Obviously the others would shake they had been done wrestling for hours. Caliendo was done for 15 min. And if it wasn't a look at me thing he does it while they're seated for 5 min before the awards stand.

So shaking hands before and after the match isn't enough now in wrestling we gotta do it while getting awards as well? And if not it's a bad look? I can't believe this is a story and Antrell throwing his bands at Landon isn't guess Antrell doesn't where the right singlet for that to be a story. Regardless of results Iowa still moves the wrestling needle and people won't allow it any other way
 

Conewago

Freshman
Jul 10, 2017
24
92
13
I would tend to give the poor kid the benefit of the doubt. Maybe he just wasn’t in the mood to hug or shake hands or whatever. Sometimes a guy is not in the mood to give an autograph. It’s the same thing. Nobody is obligated to give their time to somebody else. They might not be in the mood.
Yeah I'm going with a solid hell no to this one.

images (75).jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: donboy6499

Conewago

Freshman
Jul 10, 2017
24
92
13
Caliendo shook hands after the match ended. Maybe standing there and watching Mitch get the medal, again, was just really difficult and he didn’t feel the need to shake hands again. I am sure members of the board are giving it way more thought than Messenbrink. I know I have never lost on the biggest stage (or gotten to the biggest stage) so I have no idea how I would react.
It's not like Mitchell banged his GF or something.

I haven't said one word prior to criticize Caliendo. There's no need to criticize him. But there's also certainly no need to defend him. If a man offers you his hand in respect, you'd better have a reason to refuse, not just "I'm in a mood because I lost."
 

donboy6499

All-Conference
Jun 9, 2025
741
1,402
93
Obviously the others would shake they had been done wrestling for hours. Caliendo was done for 15 min. And if it wasn't a look at me thing he does it while they're seated for 5 min before the awards stand.

So shaking hands before and after the match isn't enough now in wrestling we now gotta do it while getting awards as well?
Why is it a problem though?
Yeah I'm going with a solid hell no to this one.

View attachment 1227956

It's not like Mitchell banged his GF or something.

I haven't said one word prior to criticize Caliendo. There's no need to criticize him. But there's also certainly no need to defend him. If a man offers you his hand in respect, you'd better have a reason to refuse, not just "I'm in a mood because I lost."
That’s where I’m at. Mitchell beat me a bunch of times in wrestling. Now I won’t shake his hand.

Looks or not, guy reaches his hand out in almost any situation outside like banging your wife, man up and do it. If you think it’s to show everyone up and look cool, beat him on the mat.
 

Reiterate

Senior
Dec 27, 2016
348
466
63
It's not like Mitchell banged his GF or something.

I haven't said one word prior to criticize Caliendo. There's no need to criticize him. But there's also certainly no need to defend him. If a man offers you his hand in respect, you'd better have a reason to refuse, not just "I'm in a mood because I lost."
You just answered your own question. I dont feel it was out of respect, jmo. Ive never seen anyone walk the podium shaking everyones hand.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Dogwelder

Conewago

Freshman
Jul 10, 2017
24
92
13
You just answered your own question. I dont feel it was out of respect, jmo. Ive never seen anyone walk the podium shaking everyones hand.
Oh, so what, Mitch likes to shake hands out of passive-aggression? Get real.

7 other men on that podium. All 7 had something in common: they are all inferior wrestlers to the champ. Only one had a problem with it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hotshoe

Reiterate

Senior
Dec 27, 2016
348
466
63
Oh, so what, Mitch likes to shake hands out of passive-aggression? Get real.
Caliendo is a cheap shot artist no doubt. Mitchell is calculating. He is either not situationally aware or he was drawing a response imo.

Edit. After further consideration Mikey isnt a cheap shot artist. Total respect for him.
 
Last edited:

AgSurfer

All-Conference
Aug 9, 2013
616
1,899
92
Oh, so what, Mitch likes to shake hands out of passive-aggression? Get real.

7 other men on that podium. All 7 had something in common: they are all inferior wrestlers to the champ. Only one had a problem with it.
I think you’re addressing the wrong point. All seven had something in common with Mitch. They were all AAs for 2026 and I think Mitch was just welcoming everyone to join him on the podium.
 

Headlock

All-Conference
Dec 28, 2023
668
1,393
93
Obviously the others would shake they had been done wrestling for hours. Caliendo was done for 15 min. And if it wasn't a look at me thing he does it while they're seated for 5 min before the awards stand.

So shaking hands before and after the match isn't enough now in wrestling we gotta do it while getting awards as well? And if not it's a bad look? I can't believe this is a story and Antrell throwing his bands at Landon isn't guess Antrell doesn't where the right singlet for that to be a story. Regardless of results Iowa still moves the wrestling needle and people won't allow it any other way
When the horse dies, dismount my friend!
 

Nitlion1986

All-Conference
Apr 13, 2024
1,588
4,723
113
Never posted on Ohio St boards. But I have and would on 34 yes. It seems to be a big deal currently so I'm just trying to understand the situation and get all the information I can
Yep, that's what you are doing.
Yepper, sure.

Information needed. Messenbrink and Caliendo have wrestled 9 times. Caliendo managed to not get his *** beat into the ground once. The last college match of Caliendo's college career he got humiliated on national TV and had zero resistance to offer, so he suffered through physical beatdown and for someone as good as he is (which is pretty darn good) he suffered through an emotional humiliation.

Mitch as the champ at the weight was the last introduced and offered a congratulatory hand shake to all of his fellow 165 pound All-Americans. Caliendo, wasn't in the mood to be joyfully greeted by what has become his competitive tormenter and acted with a bit of perceived unsportsmen snottiness.

There you go, all you need to know.
 
Last edited:

Nitlion1986

All-Conference
Apr 13, 2024
1,588
4,723
113
How Ohio State isn't running away with this poll is mind boggling. It wasn't too long ago I was told they were beating Penn State in a dual
The dual was Ohio State's coming out party. Their NCAA performance probably shouldn't be perceived as surprising, just telling.
 

BWFight

Senior
Feb 6, 2014
164
606
93
The dual was Ohio State's coming out party. Their NCAA performance probably shouldn't be perceived as surprising, just telling.
Or perhaps, not having COTY Tan Tom cornering them at nationals revealed just how masterful he is at coaching.

The entire script could have been flipped, and TOSU could have set a new team scoring record if only their COTY had been offering them his wisdom from the corner.

Tan Tom played a masterful game of quantum chess to prove his value…and everyone thought he was accidentally locked on a bus. Well played sir 🏆
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nitlion1986

Nittany1997

Sophomore
Dec 18, 2014
256
198
28

Obviously the others would shake they had been done wrestling for hours. Caliendo was done for 15 min. And if it wasn't a look at me thing he does it while they're seated for 5 min before the awards stand.

So shaking hands before and after the match isn't enough now in wrestling we gotta do it while getting awards as well? And if not it's a bad look? I can't believe this is a story and Antrell throwing his bands at Landon isn't guess Antrell doesn't where the right singlet for that to be a story. Regardless of results Iowa still moves the wrestling needle and people won't allow it any other way
I will go with the 99.999% chance that he was being a baby, I like those odds.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nitlion1986

BobPSU92

Heisman
Aug 22, 2001
43,367
34,672
113
Caliendo shook hands after the match ended. Maybe standing there and watching Mitch get the medal, again, was just really difficult and he didn’t feel the need to shake hands again. I am sure members of the board are giving it way more thought than Messenbrink. I know I have never lost on the biggest stage (or gotten to the biggest stage) so I have no idea how I would react.

It was a bad look for Caliendo, but I feel bad for him. You devote your life to a sport, establish yourself as one of the best, but keep losing to the same guy. And those losses include national championships and aren’t close. 0-9 versus Mesenbrink has to be hard to take.