A former pro is about to play for Alabama’s basketball team. It’s the latest college sports absurdity with a simple solution

Nitt1300

Heisman
Nov 2, 2008
7,036
13,287
113
If Charles Bediako plays for Alabama against Tennessee on Saturday night, it will not be because college sports are broken or Congress refuses to act or the NCAA is feckless.

The G League player, who signed a two-way contract with San Antonio in 2023 but never played in the NBA itself, will play because Alabama head coach Nate Oats will look down his bench and insert him into the game.

That’s it. That is how a 23-year-old former Crimson Tide player who declared for the NBA draft and has since played in developmental leagues for the Spurs, Orlando Magic, Denver Nuggets and Detroit Pistons gets to return to college basketball. The temporary restraining order issued by an Alabama judge, which read in part that the NCAA is “restrained from threatening, imposing, attempting to impose, suggesting or implying any penalties or sanctions,’’ backs the NCAA into a corner.




It doesn’t force Oats to play him any more than Scott Drew had to play G League player James Nnaji at Baylor.

College sports did not break themselves. People broke them, chipping away at their essence one selfish decision at a time. Now everyone is fretting over the latest death to the system, desperately searching for a way to close Pandora’s box. The NCAA is asking for Congress to intercede, and administrators are suggesting that the NCAA should ding offenders by denying them NCAA Tournament eligibility.

Yet the clear path to a solution is a lot less complicated.

Coaches can say no.

Say no to $6 million deals for quarterbacks. Say no to agents’ demands on behalf of high school players. And now say no to ex-college players looking for a bailout and instead say yes to the guys sitting on your bench. Better yet, do your job and develop them.


MORE: A former pro is about to play for Alabama’s basketball team. It’s the latest college sports absurdity with a simple solution
 

Ludd

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
3,990
4,287
113
I have no doubt that somewhere down the road a professional who still has eligibility will be back playing college after he gets cut in the pros.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nitt1300

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
5,508
3,227
113
I get what you're saying and I'm not saying you're wrong but if you're a coach that says no there will be others that say yes and then you'll be looking for a new job very soon.
See where Dabo is because he refuses to embrace the portal and how the system works.
 
  • Like
Reactions: slwlion01

SleepyLion

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2022
2,491
3,730
113
Years left. Guys that leave early and only play a couple years in the NFL and get cut, then they’ll come back to college.
first it was amateur eligibility...
then it was academic...
now it's tenure (or whatever one would call it)...
 

Ludd

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
3,990
4,287
113
first it was amateur eligibility...
then it was academic...
now it's tenure (or whatever one would call it)...
Yes…I can see people getting five years of eligibility no matter what.
 

step.eng69

All-Conference
Nov 7, 2012
3,555
4,843
113

blion72

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2021
1,587
1,202
113
If “college” athletics (😞) are the minor leagues, why even have eligibility?

😞
I think that is correct and the NFL could take over and run CFB as a minor league. The NCAA cannot manage any of this, as the likes of Tom Mars have used some creative lawyering to argue that the NCAA was a "monopoly" - using this logic we could have defeated the NCAA when they sanctioned us. when Saban talked to congress, he pointed that out and no matter who would oversee this they would need immunity from these types of lawsuits.

I think the history of the NCAA was formed by the US President and Congress to address problems in college sports and create some oversite. What they didn't do was give the NCAA anti-trust immunity, because it wasn't thought of like a company and anti-trust law was a new idea. What would happen if the NCAA declared a player ineligible for poor GPA or not attending school? A new organization that would replace the NCAA to manage this would encounter the same lawsuits.

While most of the lawsuits were players in suit v NCAA, some of the schools also challenged the NCAA. This is wild since the schools are members of the NCAA - it is an extension of the schools.

there would be complications in the NFL taking over, it would likely make the players part of the union and under CBA. It would also put them under the same type of contracts as the NFL players. There would be no need to require players to be "students" so the only ones going to school would be those who wanted the benefit. Many complications and unlikely this would ever happen. it would be interesting to see what would happen to 140 FBS teams as well as to current player compensation.
 

MtNittany

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
3,199
4,402
113
Years left. Guys that leave early and only play a couple years in the NFL and get cut, then they’ll come back to college.
They wouldn't have to be guys that were cut. Could be guys that have $50M in the bank and are tired of the nfl grind and want to go back and play for their old school for $7M a season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: slwlion01 and Ludd