One thing is becoming increasing clear about Cohen......

Goat Holder

Redshirt
Mar 18, 2013
286
0
0
He is loyal, to a fault, to the practice warriors.

It's easy to play the talented practice warriors.....the Bradfords, Fraziers, even the Pollorenas. But it proves increasingly tough when you've got guys like Frost and Ammo (Ammo decided to come back and win the starting spot, when we all knew he had no shot - I think Cohen loves that attitude). The guys that Cohen consistently kisses their ***.....for example Devin Jones and Evan Mitchell.....obviously gave it all they had in practice but just couldn't put it together for the games. But he keeps trotting them out there, just like Frost.

I understand that we want a mentally tough team, and you need to reward hard work. But there must be another option in some of these cases.
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
23,122
29,119
113
He is loyal, to a fault, to the practice warriors.

It's easy to play the talented practice warriors.....the Bradfords, Fraziers, even the Pollorenas. But it proves increasingly tough when you've got guys like Frost and Ammo (Ammo decided to come back and win the starting spot, when we all knew he had no shot - I think Cohen loves that attitude). The guys that Cohen consistently kisses their ***.....for example Devin Jones and Evan Mitchell.....obviously gave it all they had in practice but just couldn't put it together for the games. But he keeps trotting them out there, just like Frost.

I understand that we want a mentally tough team, and you need to reward hard work. But there must be another option in some of these cases.

I want the guys working the hardest in practice to be playing. Over the long haul of the season, those will be the ones you can count on most. Pure talent doesn't always translate to the field in baseball like it does in other sports. It's Cohen's livelihood to put the best team on the field in his mind, and I'd tend to let him do his job. He has a track record that suggests he knows what he's doing.
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
I don't care if Renfroe decided to bring a pillow to the OF and napped all practice, he better play.

Of course you reward hard work, and as a coach your players better practice hard or you aren't a good coach, but you can't hurt your team just because some no talent busts his ***. Rewarding comes early in the season. Now it's win first time. Fullerton DH is not win first.
 

Goat Holder

Redshirt
Mar 18, 2013
286
0
0
I want the guys working the hardest in practice to be playing.

Well ideally ALL players would be busting their *** 100% of the time. But we live in reality.

Over the long haul of the season, those will be the ones you can count on most.

Not exactly. There's a mix between talent and hard work. I sure as hell hope I'm not depending on Sam Frost with 2 down in the 9th in a Super Regional.

Pure talent doesn't always translate to the field in baseball like it does in other sports.

Yes it does, no different in baseball. Head cases and lazy guys will be that regardless of the sport. I'm not advocating that the lazy ****-balls (Renardo Sidney/Forrest Moore types) play all the time. But you have to play the guys who will produce the most on the field, no matter the talent, work ethic, etc. within limits.

It's Cohen's livelihood to put the best team on the field in his mind, and I'd tend to let him do his job. He has a track record that suggests he knows what he's doing.

I'll agree here, and hopefully I'm dead wrong on these observations. I would love to be.
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
23,122
29,119
113
well no, we don't want Frost batting with 2 outs in the ninth in a super regional. Everyone has strengths that have to be leveraged situationally. But generally speaking, you would want the hard workers out there.

And no, talent doesn't translate as easily in baseball. There is more parity there. Wes Rea could hit the absolute **** out of a ball with the bases loaded and line out to third, and Frost could come up with the bases loaded, get overmatched, and hit something off the hands over the 2B's head for a 2-RBI single. It doesn't mean I'd rather have Frost up; just that there's a fine line between success and failure in this game. So I'd rather have my workers and grinders in there.
 

bulldogcountry1

Redshirt
Jun 4, 2007
2,311
1
38
I've experienced first hand how some coaches like to play the guys who practice the best, make the honor roll, hustle, show up early, etc., and other coaches just play the guys who have the most potential and know how to turn on the switch in a game when the chips are down.

When you are young, the practice heros will almost always win because there just isn't enough talent. As you progress each level (little league, JV, HS, College, Pro), pure talent becomes more and more important. I think Cohen is too emotionally attached to some of these scrappers when he needs to be sending out some of these guys who actually have a chance to do something special when it's on the line and not be completely overwhelmed by the pressure.
 

Steakonastick

Redshirt
Jan 1, 2009
365
12
18
I beg to differ I think talent translates better in baseball then any other sport.

You can improve somewhat but bat speed and velocity are something you can't teach. You can improve it some. But it's a gift.

Frost could spend 10 years getting pushed and he will never be a sec caliber player.

Frazier could live in the gym and never will be a homerun hitter.

Mitchell could do long toss program for years and never hit 90.

Work ethic is great but when the chips fall talent prevels in d1 baseball. Id much rather have woodruff batting in the bottom of 9th in a super regional then frost.

You can be lazy and a bad college player but if you have talent you will get drafted.
 

Goat Holder

Redshirt
Mar 18, 2013
286
0
0
Yep there's a a reason MLB scouts are looking for strong arms and speed first and foremost, especially in high schoolers. They can teach everything else.
 

Goat Holder

Redshirt
Mar 18, 2013
286
0
0
I agree with your take on the players who play, but I think you have this backwards:

When you are young, the practice heros will almost always win because there just isn't enough talent. As you progress each level (little league, JV, HS, College, Pro), pure talent becomes more and more important.

I think talent is more important when you're young. As you get older, coaching and work ethic becomes increasingly important because the talent disparity is decreasing with each step up: Little League, High School, College, Minor Leagues, Major Leagues. That's in every sport.
 

Goat Holder

Redshirt
Mar 18, 2013
286
0
0
Over the long haul (or a season), talent will win every single time. Wes Rea is going to succeed in that position more than Sam Frost. Give this argument up.
 

bulldogcountry1

Redshirt
Jun 4, 2007
2,311
1
38
I agree with your take on the players who play, but I think you have this backwards:



I think talent is more important when you're young. As you get older, coaching and work ethic becomes increasingly important because the talent disparity is decreasing with each step up: Little League, High School, College, Minor Leagues, Major Leagues. That's in every sport.


The talent disparity does decrease with each step, but so does the amount of work required (in baseball at least). Everyone has to put in a certain amount of effort to make it to the next level. Some get it before others and some have higher ceilings. The question is do you play the guy who gets it but has already hit his ceiling or the guy who hasn't quite got it, but has a very high ceiling?

If you opt for the latter, you could end up with a 2013 Hunter Renfroe.
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
The talent disparity does decrease with each step, but so does the amount of work required (in baseball at least). Everyone has to put in a certain amount of effort to make it to the next level. Some get it before others and some have higher ceilings. The question is do you play the guy who gets it but has already hit his ceiling or the guy who hasn't quite got it, but has a very high ceiling?

If you opt for the latter, you could end up with a 2013 Hunter Renfroe.

This thread has allowed me to combine a couple of my favorite sound bites.

To Drebin. "Practice? We talkin about practice? Not a game... Practice"

To Bulldog Country asking who to play.. "You play to win the game!"

And finally to Cohen talking Omaha preseason. "Playoffs?! You kidding me? Playoffs!? Don't talk about playoffs. I just hope we can win a game."
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
I agree that Cohen is loyal to certain players

But I think your examples were bad. Ammirati has a higher batting average right now than Slauter and was drafted by the Marlins out of high school. Every team needs at least two catchers. We were very lucky that Slauter didn't get hurt last year- it's an extremely physical position and if someone catches too much it can affect their hitting and performance.

There is one reason why Evan Mitchell started- and that's because Woodruff isn't right. Let's be honest- Will Cox wasn't any better Tuesday against Austin Peay. And if your argument is we aren't playing our talented players- Evan doesn't fit that category because he is one of our top 3-4 pitchers from a talent standpoint and is a goofball. We want to keep Pollorena in the bullpen if at all possible- and we just can't do it.
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
But I think your examples were bad. Ammirati has a higher batting average right now than Slauter and was drafted by the Marlins out of high school. Every team needs at least two catchers. We were very lucky that Slauter didn't get hurt last year- it's an extremely physical position and if someone catches too much it can affect their hitting and performance.

There is one reason why Evan Mitchell started- and that's because Woodruff isn't right. Let's be honest- Will Cox wasn't any better Tuesday against Austin Peay. And if your argument is we aren't playing our talented players- Evan doesn't fit that category because he is one of our top 3-4 pitchers from a talent standpoint and is a goofball. We want to keep Pollorena in the bullpen if at all possible- and we just can't do it.

exactly Todd. The only talented player that hasnt been playing enough is Porter. If Woodruff was living up to his billing- Mitchell would never start. Norris start playing more and his average dropped 100 points. Robson is batting .200.

At some point the talent has to start producing if it wants to get on the field
 

coach66

Junior
Mar 5, 2009
12,720
347
83
So do we need to hire a shrink for Woodruff? We need to get his *** going

and fast. It appears to be mostly mental*
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
I still say

Pair him up with Slauter and see what happens. Slauter may be the shrink that he needs.

Everything is up in the air with the weather and all of that- but with Slauter out, but expected to be back by the South Alabama game- that might not be a bad game to start Woodruff in to see what happens.
 

msstate7

Redshirt
Nov 27, 2008
10,388
10
38
Pair him up with Slauter and see what happens. Slauter may be the shrink that he needs.

Everything is up in the air with the weather and all of that- but with Slauter out, but expected to be back by the South Alabama game- that might not be a bad game to start Woodruff in to see what happens.

When did woodruff get cleared after injury?
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
In the pre-season

But he missed most of his pre-season pitching scrimmages. I think that is part of the problem- he is trying to do too much too soon and it has caused him to overthrow his fastball. His velocity is there, but the location isn't.

He needs to understand that it's OK to throw strikes at 89-91 MPH and that he will have plenty of time to increase his draft stock. See Chris Stratton and Hunter Renfroe.
 

msstate7

Redshirt
Nov 27, 2008
10,388
10
38
I'm hoping that's it. I hope we have an opportunity to let him pitch an inning sometime soon. Perhaps a good outing is all he needs.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Jeff Lebby fires assistants Phil Loadholt and Cliff Odom after Auburn loss
  2. 02 Maroon and White Mississippi State PFF Grades from 41-9 loss to Auburn
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Lopsided analytics illustrate Mississippi State's collapse against Auburn
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football "Not good enough": Jeff Lebby answers questions of performance and job security following blowout loss to Auburn
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Rapid Recap: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State