Interesting topic from 247

randystewart

Junior
Jan 14, 2009
1,208
359
83
There is quite a heated thread over there about the proposed consolidation of Starkville and Oktibbeha county school districts. Somehow it turned into a pissing match between public and private schools, with people chiming in about how great the Starkville school district is. I don't have a dog in this hunt, as I don't have kids in school, but I do have an intimate knowledge of the MSU recruiting process (administrators, coaches, faculty, etc...). Do you know what the number one concern listed as to why a qualified individual (with a family) would not/did not take a job at MSU? The Starkville School district. The first step in fixing a problem is admitting that you have a problem, and there seems to be a whole lot of people in denial in that 247 thread. Is the SSD the worst in the nation? Not even close. Is the SSD up to par for what it should be in a major university town? Not even close.
Like it or not the SSD is a huge problem for the University in attracting/retaining qualified people, period end of story. With that said, Starkville Academy doesn't help either as they don't have near the academic standards that a private school should have.
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
As far as academics go SSD and SA are both terrible. SSD actually seems to be trending down and consilidation will ultimately further that.
 

tommyboy1520

Redshirt
Dec 25, 2007
341
0
0
I would say the SSD USED to be top-notch, but this simply isn't the case anymore. Generally, people seem to have a fondness with their hometown/childhood/formative years, and I think this probably, more than anything else, is what perpetuates the belief that Starkville public schools still provide strong, academic value. There's no reason why it can't be good again. You just need to put good leadership in place.
 
Last edited:

Railin Jemmye

Redshirt
Oct 29, 2012
1,937
0
0
Sounds like it'd be better for SSD and SA to merge. I've always asked that question, and I know the answer, I'm not dumb. I'm from Mississippi too.

But let's face it, the resources in Starkville are at SA. Maybe those resources are just what is needed at SSD.
 

Xenomorph

Heisman
Feb 15, 2007
16,320
11,142
113
Most on this board understand how dysfunctional Jackson, MS city government is..

Well, it's a mirror of SSD leadership. The decisions made in that district, across the board, over the last decade (or more?) are absolutely mind boggling and sad.

Starkville (as a whole) trying to be progressive while dealing with that cluster 17 is like trying to swim the Mississippi River with a '57 Chevy tied around your neck.
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
What impact would one of these new charter schools they are talking about have in Starkville? Could it happen here? I have no knowledge whatsoever on the subject.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,277
5,822
113
Starkville would be a very good candidate for a charter school. It's amazing they've screwed up the SSD with the demographics they have, but the fact that the SSD is underperforming so badly will make it very attractive to start a charter school there. If people that support charter schools want an easy boost for their cause, they'd make sure somebody is working on it in Starkville.

Haven't looked at the legislation, but depending on how it is set up, a charter school could be a death knell for Starkville Academy.
 

randystewart

Junior
Jan 14, 2009
1,208
359
83
and consilidation will ultimately further that.
That is an excellent point. I have actually heard some people say how great consolidation would be..... Consolidation is good for the state, great for Oktibbeha County, but the worst possible thing that could happen to the Starkville School district. Oktibbeha County will be nothing more than a resource leach to the SSD especially when it comes to infrastructure projects.
 

randystewart

Junior
Jan 14, 2009
1,208
359
83
Of current available options, the best thing that could happen to Starkville would be for MSU to open a University School. However, the backlash from the city would be so huge it will never happen.
 

DerHntr

All-Conference
Sep 18, 2007
16,209
3,714
113
"Do you know what the number one concern listed as to why a qualified individual (with a family) would not/did not take a job at MSU? The Starkville School district."

Not surprising. Those of us with kids in school or nearing school age can tell you that one of the firtst things that comes to mind is the quality of the schools in a potentially new area for the family.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,277
5,822
113
Of current available options, the best thing that could happen to Starkville would be for MSU to open a University School. However, the backlash from the city would be so huge it will never happen.

That's pretty damn sad. The city of Starkville collects tax money and doesn't provide good educational opportunities, but there would be backlash if somebody tried to provide the educational opportunities that the city of starkville won't/cant provide?

I don't know what it is, but there is something about public schools that turns some people into heartless mfers. It blows my mind that people in areas with ****** public schools would argue against things like vouchers or charter schools (or a university school)that would expand opportunities for children to be educated and at worst, slightly decrease the money available for non-functioning schools to waste.
 

jeremyrbrown

Junior
Sep 4, 2008
1,549
216
63
Do you know what the number one concern listed as to why a qualified individual (with a family) would not/did not take a job at MSU? The Starkville School district.

Honest question: Does that mean SSD is not on par with other Mississippi schools or that SSD is not on par with school districts in other university towns? I assume the bulk of individuals turning down jobs at MSU are faculty members taking jobs at other universities, not staff.
 

randystewart

Junior
Jan 14, 2009
1,208
359
83
Does that mean SSD is not on par with other Mississippi schools or that SSD is not on par with school districts in other university towns? I assume the bulk of individuals turning down jobs at MSU are faculty members taking jobs at other universities, not staff.
More of the latter, I think SSD is an average Mississippi School district. The problem is that with all of the advantages that MSU provides to Starkville, SSD should be one of the top performing 2 or 3 school districts in the state. Also with the large quantity of educated people associated with a university town, Starkville Academy should have more of a prep school curriculum.
 

Xenomorph

Heisman
Feb 15, 2007
16,320
11,142
113
Well...

"Oktibbeha County will be nothing more than a resource leach to the SSD"

Not if er'body is gonna get bumped to the city school tax rate.

worms, can, opened
 

randystewart

Junior
Jan 14, 2009
1,208
359
83
I see your point, but still think it is a problem. Starkville High will still be far and away the largest school in the county, but you will catch **** every time you try to make an improvement there. Want to put in a new tennis court at SHS? Better be prepared to put in new tennis courts at East & West Oktibbeha. Even a new tax rate doesn't account for that kind of spending.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,396
33,172
113
If you consolidate the school districts, you've got to close the other high schools and move them all to SHS. Otherwise you're right. All consolidation would do would make the city of Starkville subsidize 2 schools that really shouldn't exist in the first place.
 

starkvegasdawg

Redshirt
Dec 1, 2011
1,316
0
0
I have a girl in kindergarten in Sudduth and a three old that will be entering the school system in a couple of years. I have no problem with Sudduth but have some real concerns about the higher grade level schools. For giggles I looked at the SA tuition rates and just tuition is $4,670/year. Then you have all of the other fees that they tack on. And I have from those that transfer their kids from SSD to SA that the education is, at best, no better than SSD. The other alternative in town...Starkville Christian School. Their tuition is $3,100/year but they are not even accredited. I am sorry but I am not paying that kind of money for 12 years of tuition only for my kids to have to take a GED to get into college. There really are no good answers right now and I can't fathom how merging with the county schools is going to make things any better.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,551
3,161
113
Mobile/Mobile County and all the little bergs in the county consolidated years ago, so that would be a good data point to check to see how it works. Of course, they are much, much larger than a S'ville/Oktibbeha district would be but results should be similar.

Personally, I think it should be done everywhere to save money. School admin costs are very high. It's always a "not in my backyard" thing though.
 

mount lefroy

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
2,501
0
36
There is quite a heated thread over there about the proposed consolidation of Starkville and Oktibbeha county school districts. Somehow it turned into a pissing match between public and private schools, with people chiming in about how great the Starkville school district is. I don't have a dog in this hunt, as I don't have kids in school, but I do have an intimate knowledge of the MSU recruiting process (administrators, coaches, faculty, etc...). Do you know what the number one concern listed as to why a qualified individual (with a family) would not/did not take a job at MSU? The Starkville School district. The first step in fixing a problem is admitting that you have a problem, and there seems to be a whole lot of people in denial in that 247 thread. Is the SSD the worst in the nation? Not even close. Is the SSD up to par for what it should be in a major university town? Not even close.
Like it or not the SSD is a huge problem for the University in attracting/retaining qualified people, period end of story. With that said, Starkville Academy doesn't help either as they don't have near the academic standards that a private school should have.

Having 2 kids in Starkville Public schools, it's long since been apparant to me that most who express an opinion of Starkville and it's schools base it upon a few hours they spend in the fall tailgating waiting to go into a game.

The SSD was for my entire school life in Starkville, just fine. That is 1973 to 1985. I have something to compare it to. That is both my kids have spent time in Hernando, MS, Nashville, Tn and Hendersonville TN public schools.

Hendersonville was by far the best experience, then Starkville, then Hernando and FAR below, Nashville. My point is not that I'm right about the entire school system, but that of my experience with the particular teachers and schools placed them in that order. I have the money to send my kids to any private school I wish in the near area, but SSD is doing a great job and there is no need.

I know many more like me who work at MSU and who's kids attend Starkville Public Schools. Our experience is similar. I dont know everyone who has considered MSU and decided against. But the notion that your description is the "end of the story" is a load of ********.

I also dont know if consolidation will be better or not. There are just so many things to consider. I do know this: I experience first hand each week what the school district produces. I talk to the teachers. We'll be fine either way.
 
Last edited:

randystewart

Junior
Jan 14, 2009
1,208
359
83
But the notion that your description is the "end of the story" is a load of ********.
Here we go with the defensiveness..... Again the first step in fixing a problem is admitting that you have one. Starkville did not have a single school that performed higher than a C last year on the statewide rankings. The middle school performed at a D. If you don't see a problem with that in a university town, then I don't know what to say. For reference, Mississippi had 343 schools perform at an A or B level. But if you like for your kids to attend a D middle school......
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
Having 2 kids in Starkville Public schools, it's long since been apparant to me that most who express an opinion of Starkville and it's schools base it upon a few hours they spend in the fall tailgating waiting to go into a game.

The SSD was for my entire school life in Starkville, just fine. That is 1973 to 1985. I have something to compare it to. That is both my kids have spent time in Hernando, MS, Nashville, Tn and Hendersonville TN public schools.

Hendersonville was by far the best experience, then Starkville, then Hernando and FAR below, Nashville. My point is not that I'm right about the entire school system, but that of my experience with the particular teachers and schools placed them in that order. I have the money to send my kids to any private school I wish in the near area, but SSD is doing a great job and there is no need.

I know many more like me who work at MSU and who's kids attend Starkville Public Schools. Our experience is similar. I dont know everyone who has considered MSU and decided against. But the notion that your description is the "end of the story" is a load of ********.

I also dont know if consolidation will be better or not. There are just so many things to consider. I do know this: I experience first hand each week what the school district produces. I talk to the teachers. We'll be fine either way.

There are a limited number of great teachers and advanced level classes at the SSD. For the vast majority of students the education is far from where it could be. Yes, the top 60 in the class can receive some quality but what those 60 get should be closer to the norm for 225 and the advanced curriculum could be improved upon as well. Trust me, I know.

SSD- 1999-2005
 

mount lefroy

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
2,501
0
36
I know how my kids performed and what they accomplished. How they've improved. I do not contend the entire school system is good because of that if you will re read my post.

Describe for us all the stipulations that go into those grades and rankings.

And again, I'm not defensive. You just seemed to have made an absolute judgement about something you have no first hand knowlege of. I'm telling you what I know from what I've experienced as a student there and as a parent. Someone who is married to a person who works for MSU. And someone who has experienced other school systems who have absolutely wonderful rankings. They arent that different.

So what will it be? First hand knowlege or some grading system you were just given by the State of Mississippi? I'm telling you there are great things about the public schools and it's up to the individual parents and kids to extract from it what they will. Our perception of it's quality is based on our experience and not some standardized test score.

But just like recruiting, the 'grades' dont always match the actual experience. Believe what you want to about Starkville.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,277
5,822
113
SA tuition rates and just tuition is $4,670/year. Then you have all of the other fees that they tack on. And I have from those that transfer their kids from SSD to SA that the education is, at best, no better than SSD. The other alternative in town...Starkville Christian School. Their tuition is $3,100/year but they are not even accredited.

If SA is $4670 a year, that's pretty damn cheap. Probably a few thousand less than the per student cost at SHS.
 

Carlton31698

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
100
0
16
Starkville Daily News (along with others) has painted an inaccurate picture of the County Elementary Schools. Here are the facts from last year: EOCES is a SUCCESSFUL school just like Starkville, the paper always list Starkville as successful and EOCES as a C, well successful = C in the accountability rankings. That means Starkville just like EOCES is a C level district. When we look even deeper Armstrong (6th-7th) in Starkville is a D ‐ Academic Watch ranked below both County Elementary Schools, all the other Starkville schools that are tested are C = Successful.
WOCES is B = High Performing School, Which is the highest ranked school in both the city and county school systems.
What this means it the county Elementary schools are ranked one on the same level as Starkville, one higher than Starkville. This needs to be acknowledged. Both EOCES and WOCES worked hard and did a good job last year in spite of the problems that caused the State to take over the district.
The High schools in the county didn't perform last year and are ranked as WOCHS F = Low Performing and EOCHS F = Failing. This is not acceptable and must improve, but it isn't a reflection on the two Elementary Schools. It is a reflection on past administration. That is all I am going to say on that.
If we are going to head down the consolidation path then this idea that the County Schools are going to "bring down" the city schools needs to stop. If both High Schools were moved to Starkville today we are talking about around 300 students 7th - 12th, that is an average of 50 students per grade level or two classes per grade level. In a district the size of Starkville that will not have a huge impact on scores. The Elementary Schools are larger Both schools prek - 6th gave about 500 students or about 63 students per grade level about Three classes per grade. And these students are scoring on par with Starkville. To be honest the scores would more than likely balance out if the schools were consolidated.Starkville Daily News (along with others) has painted an inaccurate picture of the County Elementary Schools. Here are the facts from last year: EOCES is a SUCCESSFUL school just like Starkville, the paper always list Starkville as successful and EOCES as a C, well successful = C in the accountability rankings. That means Starkville just like EOCES is a C level district. When we look even deeper Armstrong (6th-7th) in Starkville is a D ‐ Academic Watch ranked below both County Elementary Schools, all the other Starkville schools that are tested are C = Successful.
WOCES is B = High Performing School, Which is the highest ranked school in both the city and county school systems.
What this means it the county Elementary schools are ranked one on the same level as Starkville, one higher than Starkville. This needs to be acknowledged. Both EOCES and WOCES worked hard and did a good job last year in spite of the problems that caused the State to take over the district.
The High schools in the county didn't perform last year and are ranked as WOCHS F = Low Performing and EOCHS F = Failing. This is not acceptable and must improve, but it isn't a reflection on the two Elementary Schools. It is a reflection on past administration. That is all I am going to say on that.
If we are going to head down the consolidation path then this idea that the County Schools are going to "bring down" the city schools needs to stop. If both High Schools were moved to Starkville today we are talking about around 300 students 7th - 12th, that is an average of 50 students per grade level or two classes per grade level. In a district the size of Starkville that will not have a huge impact on scores. The Elementary Schools are larger Both schools prek - 6th gave about 500 students or about 63 students per grade level about Three classes per grade. And these students are scoring on par with Starkville. To be honest the scores would more than likely balance out if the schools were consolidated.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,551
3,161
113
$4670 is a bargain. At Randolph School, Huntsville's best private college prep school, Kindergarten is $12,775 and grades 9-12 s $17,365. On top of that is a book fee ranging from $565 for lower school to $700 for upper school. If you're a senior, there's a $300 graduation fee. So your senior year is approaching $20K.

Madison Academy, subsidized by the Church of Christ is a pretty good college prep school. Tuition there ranges from $6425 for preschool to $7450 for upper school. It's a bit cheaper per child if you have more than one going.

Other private and church supported schools are similar, but generally a bit lower, respectively.

But there are advantages. My son went K-12 at Randolph, then got a full ride to MSU. Randolph tuition was a little less half the above numbers when he was there, which was 1982-1995. So pay for elementary and high school, don't pay for college. He could have gone to Florida, Vanderbilt, and Florida State on scholarship too but he chose MSU because it was such a friendly place with a very good honors college.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,551
3,161
113
I went to school in Meridian, graduating in 1965. Went to Highland Elementary, Northwest Junior High, and Meridian High. The schools then were top-notch, with many advanced courses available in high school. I don't know what the schools are like there now, but I was well prepared when I got to MSU. Never went to kindergarten ... that wasn't done much back in the dark ages.

A question: Have the academics deteriorated at the universities, such as MSU and Ole Miss, like they apparently have in the public schools? I certainly hope not.
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
A question: Have the academics deteriorated at the universities, such as MSU and Ole Miss, like they apparently have in the public schools? I certainly hope not.

Most every elective in the "requirement" portion aka humanities history are a joke

ETA this is true across most college campuses. It really is big business now just getting as many kids on loans and in school. With free loans, many of which can never be paid back, supply/demand has driven the cost of tuition through the roof everywhere. Sad but true. Also unsustainable. Higher education will see major MAJOR reforms sooner rather than later because A. The loan bubble will burst and B. a degree isn't worth nearly as much anymore education wise. A HS grad with 4 years experience working is more mmarketable in many aspects than a college grad with a liberal arts major IMO.
 
Last edited:

rabiddawg

Redshirt
Aug 19, 2010
2,017
0
0
I have wanted to move the wife and kids to StarkVegas for sometime but can't because they don't have a big enough hospital. If they had a Level 3 or 4 trauma center then I would make the move. Starkville is a very good community to raise your kids in.
 

randystewart

Junior
Jan 14, 2009
1,208
359
83
Starkville is a very good community to raise your kids in.
I completely agree. Starkville is about as good as it gets for Mississippi with good food, college sports, etc... What I don't understand from this school argument though is how some are complacent and defensive of the Starkville School system. Again, there are 343 schools in Mississippi above the SSD's highest performing school, and Starkville's middle school is on the border of failing. Couple that with Starkville Academy not having higher academic standards, and you have a huge problem for a university town.
 

futaba.79

Redshirt
Jun 4, 2007
2,296
0
0
I've got to ask..........

Do you have direct experience with either the Academy or the SPS? Do you live in Starkville? How are you forming your opinion? Why do you think Starkville's citizens are complacent?
 

Vv83

Redshirt
Oct 21, 2012
102
0
0
I attended SSD from K to 12 and I can tell you, while I don't remember the exact details, SSD has decreased greatly over the years. When I arrived at MSU I was NOT prepared when it came to calculus, biology, chemistry even after taking these AP classes at Starkville High. And ever worse the education at SA does not even compare to SSD. It's a complete joke at SA. I remember growing up my SA friends telling me how students slept with teachers, and that they would slip a $100 and get an A for the semester. While SSD is not top a top notch public system, SA does not even compare. It's a complete joke.
 

randystewart

Junior
Jan 14, 2009
1,208
359
83
I work for MSU in a capacity where I see the hardships of attracting people to Starkville. Anytime you float a proposal to improve things at SHS or at SA, it is always met with extreme defensiveness. Even in this thread you can see it, as one guy basically said "school rankings be damned I think my kids are doing fine." I have no doubt that there are plenty of students doing just fine in both schools, but the fact remains that each is a joke compared to what they should be in a major university town. Like it or not, education (the rankings) is the first thing that perspective faculty/coaches/etc.. look at when considering a move to a new town, and Starkville is not up to par. There is no reason at all that SSD shouldn't have schools in the top 10-20 in the State, and currently the highest ranked SSD school is in the 350 neighborhood.
 

Railin Jemmye

Redshirt
Oct 29, 2012
1,937
0
0
What about Baptist Memorial in Columbus? I don't really know what Levels mean in regards to hospitals, but it's pretty big I guess. And honestly, I travel a good bit with work, and have lived in bigger cities, so I see the whole Golden Triangle as basically the same place. And whatever is in Tupelo is definitely not far away.

The way I see it, the schools are the only thing holding Starkville back, period.
 

GTAdawg

Redshirt
Sep 11, 2010
2,162
25
48
IMO I believe there are too many private schools in the Golden Triangle Area. At least 4 I can think of off hand. Instead of combining county and city districts, the region should work to consolidate private schools back into their respective areas.

Now before you get your panties in a wad I'm not saying there shouldn't be private schools. I'm just suggesting maybe consolidate into 1 in the GTA. That way more resources will ultimately get reinvested into the public districts. But I feel we are to far past that in the area anyway.....so I guess its one big moot point now.
 

BulldogBacker

Redshirt
Nov 23, 2001
128
0
0
I went to Highland Park elementary school as well, except it was 1st then 5th grades, as we traveled a lot as a military family. I was born in Meridian, but lived all over the place. I wound up at Biloxi Senior High School for all of high school, and we had an exceptional school, primarily due to the presence of Keesler AFB and the National Marine Biology Lab in Ocean Springs (now run by USM). My Principal graduated from Harvard. One of my teachers got her Master's Degree from the Sorbonne, in Paris. My Chemistry and Physics teacher worked at the National Marine Biology Lab and had a Ph.D. We had 8 National Merit Scholarship Finalists in my graduating class. There were 9 in the state that year. The other went to Murrah. We had a lot of students whose parents had advanced degrees in engineering and such. I felt my preparation for Mississippi State was about as good a a guy could want. Back then they "stratified" each year class with the highest performing and highest aptitude students all in the same classes with advanced mathematics and sciences.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Jeff Lebby fires assistants Phil Loadholt and Cliff Odom after Auburn loss
  2. 02 Maroon and White Mississippi State PFF Grades from 41-9 loss to Auburn
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Lopsided analytics illustrate Mississippi State's collapse against Auburn
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football "Not good enough": Jeff Lebby answers questions of performance and job security following blowout loss to Auburn
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Rapid Recap: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State