Forde & Thamel: Is Zion Williamson the new Cam Newton? Why Duke's star could face eligibility issues

CatOfDaVille

All-American
Mar 30, 2007
6,173
8,106
0
What's to investigate really, seems pretty simple. There is a taped conversation which says this guy's "representative/handler/whatever" is asking for illegal benefits. Per Cecil Newton rule, that makes ZW ineligible. Period.

I think the problem here is that there's no proof that Zion's stepfather asked for anything... at least that's what the NCAA would say.

That's why there needs to be an investigation...to try to find that proof. Will the be an investigation is the question.

I think that's the best we can hope for...an investigation that forces Duke to sit Zion or risk vacating games a la Billy Preston. Duke won't get punished, but it may be that they are without their best player for some games.

Probably wishful thinking on my part.
 

Bluesnky

All-American
Jan 24, 2013
6,363
9,715
0
I doubt anything happens with Zion.

Kansas is going down.

This is probably why Zion went to Duke: no one will push too hard to prove what happened.
 

wildcat1515

All-Conference
Feb 7, 2006
5,446
2,937
113
Hell no they wont do anything to Duke or Coach ***-K! They will probably make up a new rule with this new G-league thing and Kansas and Duke will escape because the NCAA will grandfather them in, with some new thing. Heck why do you think they came out with this G-League thing today, right after the trail??? Yeah I know I could be stretching a bit, but who knows with them. Duke Sucks!!!
 

wildcat1515

All-Conference
Feb 7, 2006
5,446
2,937
113
Loophole of “the athlete didn’t know” was closed. No way he should suit up for them but we know he will. The NCAA has no balls to stand up to dUKe

Well if he went to Duke then there was no problems at all! Once again if he went to Duke then there are no problems, once again repeat after me..............
 

K_TIME

Heisman
Jan 2, 2003
18,481
25,947
113
I think the problem here is that there's no proof that Zion's stepfather asked for anything... at least that's what the NCAA would say.

That's why there needs to be an investigation...to try to find that proof. Will the be an investigation is the question..
But it doesn't take much to investigate where his family current lives and where they used to live before he got to Duke. If they are indeed living in a swank neighborhood along with testimony he was "up for sale"....then that is more than enough to punish. But like most...not holding my breath.
 

Ben101er

Heisman
Apr 21, 2004
25,916
61,015
103
Like Mike White said, “every athlete every summer has been thoroughly vetted,” ie the NCAA let us get away with this same **** last year with Bagley and his family now there’s just a silly wiretap recording.

Yep. If you were the NCAA who would you believe? Some silly FBI wiretapped conversations and sworn testimony, or Mike White's word that Puke's internal vetting showed everyone was eligible? Of course Duke is more trustworthy than evidence, everyone knows that.
 

KYCAT78

All-American
May 24, 2006
7,858
6,073
0
I think the problem here is that there's no proof that Zion's stepfather asked for anything... at least that's what the NCAA would say.

That's why there needs to be an investigation...to try to find that proof. Will the be an investigation is the question.

I think that's the best we can hope for...an investigation that forces Duke to sit Zion or risk vacating games a la Billy Preston. Duke won't get punished, but it may be that they are without their best player for some games.

Probably wishful thinking on my part.
Who cares if Zion plays we are going to beat Duke like a rented mule. Duke will be screaming NO MAS, NO MAS.
 

kevcat

Heisman
Feb 26, 2007
27,686
32,625
0
Penis Thameltoe, Patty Ford, and the NCAA are all pathetic losers with zero credibility.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crpoore

flacat22

Heisman
Mar 12, 2011
8,566
12,561
113
Yep. If you were the NCAA who would you believe? Some silly FBI wiretapped conversations and sworn testimony, or Mike White's word that Puke's internal vetting showed everyone was eligible? Of course Duke is more trustworthy than evidence, everyone knows that.

But, but, White’s son is the AD at 2017 NCAA undefeated football National Champ UCF. That family can claim ANYTHING they want!!
 

Wildcats1st

Heisman
Sep 16, 2017
18,949
28,911
0
Tired of hearing “duke isn’t touchable”. If rules were broken and the media stays on it and digs digs digs and puts pressure on ncaa the ncaa will cave

OR it will have such a negative impact that it will screw dukes season. Ratface ends up with a back injury
 
Last edited:
Jan 29, 2003
18,120
12,185
0
zeit·geist
/ˈtsītˌɡīst,ˈzītˌɡīst/
noun
the defining spirit or mood of a particular period of history as shown by the ideas and beliefs of the time.

Word of the day. All of you that are cock-sure Duke and Kansas are gong to get off scot free...that’s fear, and disgust, and honestly a deserved lack of faith in the NCAA. But I’m telling you, we are in the middle of a cultural moment. Politics, sports, all of it. The idea that elites should somehow get away with something others would not, doesn’t match the zeitgeist of this era. Plus the NCAA genuinely fears extinction, coming out of this my bet is it will correctly understand it’s under a microscope and that it has something to prove. Letting either Duke or KU “get away” with something just won’t do. I think KU is in real danger, and Duke is in some trouble too.....
 

GonzoCat90

Heisman
Mar 30, 2009
32,377
34,559
0
If a shady shoe guy talking to someone at Kansas constitutes proof then we're in trouble too because they named us in a text with Self.

Let's wait and see what else comes out.
 

westerncat

Heisman
Feb 19, 2012
15,923
20,891
0
zeit·geist
/ˈtsītˌɡīst,ˈzītˌɡīst/
noun
the defining spirit or mood of a particular period of history as shown by the ideas and beliefs of the time.

Word of the day. All of you that are cock-sure Duke and Kansas are gong to get off scot free...that’s fear, and disgust, and honestly a deserved lack of faith in the NCAA. But I’m telling you, we are in the middle of a cultural moment. Politics, sports, all of it. The idea that elites should somehow get away with something others would not, doesn’t match the zeitgeist of this era. Plus the NCAA genuinely fears extinction, coming out of this my bet is it will correctly understand it’s under a microscope and that it has something to prove. Letting either Duke or KU “get away” with something just won’t do. I think KU is in real danger, and Duke is in some trouble too.....

I will believe that when pigs fly !
 

GonzoCat90

Heisman
Mar 30, 2009
32,377
34,559
0
You don't see the difference? He named us with no actual contact with anybody from UK. Self actually texted with these people.

This is a conversation with an assistant. The bag man himself named us in a text to Self.

If we're believing the texts of crooks and cheaters let's go see what Rick Pitino thinks while we're at it.

I'm not saying Zion is clean. I'm saying I'm going to need more than a text from a scumbag before I start crying about how the NCAA never punishes Duke and saying it's cut and dry that Zion should be ineligible or that it's exactly like the Cam Newton situation.

But nobody reads anymore. Just take the headline and get real mad in whatever direction it takes you. Everyone make sure you vote in two weeks.
 

Spanish Radio

All-Conference
Moderator
Nov 18, 2004
3,677
2,362
113
This is a conversation with an assistant. The bag man himself named us in a text to Self.

If we're believing the texts of crooks and cheaters let's go see what Rick Pitino thinks while we're at it.

I'm not saying Zion is clean. I'm saying I'm going to need more than a text from a scumbag before I start crying about how the NCAA never punishes Duke and saying it's cut and dry that Zion should be ineligible or that it's exactly like the Cam Newton situation.

But nobody reads anymore. Just take the headline and get real mad in whatever direction it takes you. Everyone make sure you vote in two weeks.
Is it enough to launch an investigation into Duke?
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football SEC Availability Report: Kentucky is in good shape after bye week
  2. 02 KSR Football Kentucky isn't Paying Attention to CFP Rankings, Only Rocky Top
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Sources Say talks Cherif Millogo & Manhattan, makes Kentucky season picks!
  4. 04 KSR Podcasts 11 Personnel: How Kentucky Attacks Tennessee in a CFP Eliminator
  5. 05 KSR Basketball Mason Williams can knock down 3s with either shooting hand