Fact: we can hire no one with greater impact on recruits? I think you confuse facts with your opinion. No one. Seriously think about that. Smoot is the absolute best recruiter possible to hire for MS kids in your mind and has never done it before. Think about that for a second longer.
I agree he would love coaching at MSU. No doubt there.
Also, no one else can coach emotion as good as Smoot. Ok. Sounds logical.
I don't think anyone can do anything but speculate one way or another. Positive and negative.
But look at Mirando, minus his departure. He was way too young and inexperienced to be a position coach, especially in the SEC. He also didn't play wide receiver. Granted, as a quarterback he knew the position and that's not uncommon (Tee Martin). What Mirando brought was youth and excitement to the WR position. The players loved him. His demise was getting drunk at night in the Cotton District, hitting on 19 year old girls, and telling every Tom, Dick, and Harry MSU's business.
Was it an awful hire? Not really. Here are the facts and you can make whatever conclusion you wish:
Smoot has more knowledge of the position he'd coach for us.
Smoot has played the position he'd coach before at a high level.
Smoot is a figure most 18 year olds we recruit now are familiar with, and Mirando wasn't (it was his first college coaching gig, no knock).
Smoot went to MSU, is older, and has a family... So the likeliness of him going out, getting drunk, hitting on 19 year olds, and telling people who don't need to know our business things and could possibly hurt us by doing so are very low vs. Mirando, who had no emotional connection to MSU.
... I really like the upside of Smoot. We do gamble the downside of him not knowing what the hell hes doing but unless we hit a home run like Brewster I see us just going and getting another young guy like Mirando who gives us the same gamble. Smoot is a good guy, and if he didn't work out I think he'd be ok with leaving. See Felker.