Why doesn't the NCAA by pass the NBA rules

420grover

All-American
Mar 26, 2006
7,703
7,860
0
I say that the NBA makes whatever rules they want and if you want to work there, you follow their rules. They are an employer, all employers make their own rules how they see fit for their business.

The NCAA can't do anything to make a kid stay in school. They can change their rules to entice them to stay in school and that's where their focus should be.
 
Mar 23, 2012
23,493
6,068
0
This may have been discussed before and I missed the thread. But why doesn't the NCAA just negate the NBA one year rule by making its own rules? Couldn't the NCAA make a rule that all scholarships must be honored for two years other than transfers to another school or some other hardships that may occur? If a player breaks the rule and leaves after one year, have it written into by-laws that he has to pay a percentage of his first contract to the NCAA as a penalty. 30% of a lotto pick is some serious cash. Seems they could do something like this rather than let the NBA dictate to them. Players could choose other options if they don't want to play in the NCAA for two years. Some think its unfair to tell these guys you HAVE to commit to a school for two years when they have the talents to go to the NBA right outta HS but the NBA is dictating to them already with the one and done rule.
So you want rules in place that denies some kids the opportunity to get a scholarship? That's idiotic.
 

Nubb16

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
128,718
10,043
67
lol, im not sure i was advocating prison or death.. The penalty would be a percentage of the first year NBA contract. I just assume that if the NCAA made the rule and the player signs off on it, its enforceable in any court, Could be wrong though.
What if they don’t get drafted and play overseas? What if someone signs it and doesn’t get drafted and ends up never playing professionally?
 
Oct 1, 2005
3,908
548
0
There is absolutely no way they could enforce that. Not to mention it is simply unethical. A player by leaving after one year is not harming the school. At worst he is disappointing fans.

Also, you do realize I hope, that probably 80-90% of American NBA players grew up below the poverty line. Shame on anyone for wanting to put a mandatory delay in them getting themselves (and family) out of poverty by legal means. Not to mention the added (injury) risk (even if it is only 1-5%) by delaying their ability to earn an income.

What the NCAA should do, is allow undrafted players to return. If they accepted any cash, just pay it back and you can return. Pay for players travel expenses for NBA workouts. The NCAA-T is a Billion-$ cash cow for the NCAA. Say the top 100 players explore their options and workout for some teams, and on average spend $10K (which is a high estimate), that would be $1M, or just 1% of the NCAA-T revenue.

On top of that, I think the NCAA should also allow drafted players to return if they want to. Why protect the NBA's draft? You thought you would go in the 1st, but you went in the 2nd, come on back to school. You went #25 but you think you could be a lottery pick next year with a bigger contract, come on back to school. You don't want to move to OK City and play there, come on back to school. BUT, the NCAA could also use this threat as a tool for encouraging the NBA to change their draft rules and at least let the NCAA provide some input into the direction they change. The NBA teams do not want that added risk of losing their draft picks (even if it doesn't happen often). Think back to the 80's when John Elway said he would rather go play baseball than for the Colts. And I think 20 years later Eli Manning did something similar.
The CBA has the “drafted players returning to school “ covered, unlike the NFL, you can only go through the draft once. The team that drafts you owns your rights until one year after your projected college graduation date. So if you go in the draft after your freshman year and go back to school (if it were allowed) the team would own your rights for the next four years and draft position wouldn’t change.
The NBA has ivy league educated lawyers protecting their interest, I think message board posters are underestimating their intelligence.

“Early Entry players are bound by their drafting teams until one year after the first NBA Draft they could have entered as non-Early Entry players. For example, Ben Simmons declared for the 2016 NBA Draft after his freshman season, making him an Early Entry player. Whichever team drafts Simmons will hold his Draft Rights until the 2020 NBA Draft, one year after the first draft Simmons could have entered as a non-Early Entry ”
https://moorebasketball.com/2016/05/30/how-it-works-draft-rights-and-signing-draft-picks/amp/
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 420grover

KentuckyFlyer

All-Conference
Jan 25, 2007
3,631
1,529
113
What if they don’t get drafted and play overseas? What if someone signs it and doesn’t get drafted and ends up never playing professionally?
Then the proverb "you cant get blood out of a turnip" would apply. This is not going to be the case for one and done's that are most likely going to be the ones that brake my NCAA hypothetical scenario
 

ukgrad83

All-Conference
Sep 26, 2009
931
1,403
0
But aren't all students training for a future profession?

There's the rub in my opinion. They aren't really students. They are in college because of the imposed NBA age rule. Sure they attend class but they aren't looking for a degree to make them marketable. Their value comes from what they do on the hardwood/gridiron. I'm not begrudging them anything - they are merely a product of the system. Personally I believe the NBA rule breaks anti-trust laws. I'm not into conspiracy theories but there may even be collusion between the NBA and NCAA. The NCAA makes outrageous amounts of money on the backs of these kids. The NBA gets another year (at least) to evaluate the talent without having to risk anything. Win/win for them.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: awf

UKWildcatT

All-American
Apr 9, 2009
75,546
8,113
0
I’m not a fan of the one and done stuff at all, but holy crap, we have some utterly ridiculous ideas here. Pay back scholarships; pay back percent of it.

Just ridiculous. (Note: I’d rather just see the nba opt for straight to the nba/two year rule.)
 

ukgrad83

All-Conference
Sep 26, 2009
931
1,403
0
I’m not a fan of the one and done stuff at all, but holy crap, we have some utterly ridiculous ideas here. Pay back scholarships; pay back percent of it.

Just ridiculous. (Note: I’d rather just see the nba opt for straight to the nba/two year rule.)

Why is it ridiculous? A scholarship is an award of financial aid for a student to further their education. Most of those kids aren't there for an education, it's just their best option before they can try to enter the league. If they have no intention of completing their education, why shouldn't they have to pay it back if they leave early?
 

UKWildcatT

All-American
Apr 9, 2009
75,546
8,113
0
Why is it ridiculous? A scholarship is an award of financial aid for a student to further their education. Most of those kids aren't there for an education, it's just their best option before they can try to enter the league. If they have no intention of completing their education, why shouldn't they have to pay it back if they leave early?

Is this serious? Honestly, is it April 1?
 

awf

Heisman
May 31, 2006
10,411
20,774
0
It would seem like the colleges could have the players sign a "no compete" contract........they seem pretty hard to break. They evidently have held up to the rigors of the court system. IF you accept our scholarship then you sign a no compete contract for two years.....I am not a lawyer so there might be a reason that it wouldn't work?
 
Oct 1, 2005
3,908
548
0
Why is it ridiculous? A scholarship is an award of financial aid for a student to further their education. Most of those kids aren't there for an education, it's just their best option before they can try to enter the league. If they have no intention of completing their education, why shouldn't they have to pay it back if they leave early?
You think these high profile players are awarded schollies to further their education? Cal offers KK a scholly to further his education?
 

Nubb16

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
128,718
10,043
67
Then the proverb "you cant get blood out of a turnip" would apply. This is not going to be the case for one and done's that are most likely going to be the ones that brake my NCAA hypothetical scenario
So, only projected one and done guys have to sign? What if a lower tier ranked guy blows up and decides he’s one and done also?
 

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
But slippery slope if trying to mimick a military contract...
If that’s the case then should all college students sign/ be required to sign a 4 year contract? Law students ? Sociology majors? Those who play golf? Lacrosse ? Or just basketball...?

I see your point and agree to an extent but this only would apply to scholarship recipients. I think the key complaint in this case is the payment, and not necessarily the binding contract. If the payment was not to the NCAA or university, but to a charity or scholarship fund for the underprivileged, then . . .

But we all know the greedy bastards at the NCAA would NEVER stand for that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood
Oct 1, 2005
3,908
548
0
Or what if they decide to get financial aid( student loan) and pay their own way? And technically be considered a walk on?
 

KentuckyFlyer

All-Conference
Jan 25, 2007
3,631
1,529
113
So, only projected one and done guys have to sign? What if a lower tier ranked guy blows up and decides he’s one and done also?
Everyone signs. im just saying only one and dones will break the contract.
 

bthaunert

Heisman
Apr 4, 2007
29,518
21,619
0
Why is it ridiculous? A scholarship is an award of financial aid for a student to further their education. Most of those kids aren't there for an education, it's just their best option before they can try to enter the league. If they have no intention of completing their education, why shouldn't they have to pay it back if they leave early?
I don't agree with your premise at all, but what I really don't agree with is holding 4,500 college basketball players to a 2 year contract because 20 of them want to leave after 1 year,
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood
Mar 23, 2012
23,493
6,068
0
Why is it ridiculous? A scholarship is an award of financial aid for a student to further their education. Most of those kids aren't there for an education, it's just their best option before they can try to enter the league. If they have no intention of completing their education, why shouldn't they have to pay it back if they leave early?
The school doesn't have to pay for the years of scholarship a player doesn't use. If a player leaves early, their scholarship just goes to another player. And going to a year of college is furthering one's education as it is one year further than high school.
 
Mar 23, 2012
23,493
6,068
0
It would seem like the colleges could have the players sign a "no compete" contract........they seem pretty hard to break. They evidently have held up to the rigors of the court system. IF you accept our scholarship then you sign a no compete contract for two years.....I am not a lawyer so there might be a reason that it wouldn't work?
lol at making a kid sign a no-compete clause when they aren't a salaried employee.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UKWildcatT

ukgrad83

All-Conference
Sep 26, 2009
931
1,403
0
The school doesn't have to pay for the years of scholarship a player doesn't use. If a player leaves early, their scholarship just goes to another player. And going to a year of college is furthering one's education as it is one year further than high school.

Its just a way to dissuade them from leaving early. The OP was trying to make the point that the NCAA could make their own rules, which is perfectly legal. You wouldn't be keeping athletes from doing other things, but IF they choose to go to college (on a scholarship), they must commit to 2 years. If they leave early, there's a penalty. If they don't want to go to college, they can go overseas. Their choice. The NCAA does NOT have to cater to the NBA.
 
Jul 11, 2007
27,222
34,299
0
I suppose they COULD do this, if the idea was to drive away all potential NBA-caliber players from attending a year of college.....
 

ukgrad83

All-Conference
Sep 26, 2009
931
1,403
0
I suppose they COULD do this, if the idea was to drive away all potential NBA-caliber players from attending a year of college.....

Yep, that's the downside. Which is why it'll never happen. The NCAA cares too much about money. It's not about "student athletes" any more.
 

KA4Prez_rivals78700

All-American
Dec 8, 2003
140,541
5,314
0
You can't enforce it unless you force every student who receives some sort of scholarship or grant or financial assistance meet the same standards.
 
Mar 23, 2012
23,493
6,068
0
Its just a way to dissuade them from leaving early. The OP was trying to make the point that the NCAA could make their own rules, which is perfectly legal. You wouldn't be keeping athletes from doing other things, but IF they choose to go to college (on a scholarship), they must commit to 2 years. If they leave early, there's a penalty. If they don't want to go to college, they can go overseas. Their choice. The NCAA does NOT have to cater to the NBA.
Sure it doesn't. But I don't think it's an intelligent business model to put in rules that encourages the best talent not to participate within your organization.
 

UKnCincy_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2008
3,504
4,024
0
It would seem like the colleges could have the players sign a "no compete" contract........they seem pretty hard to break. They evidently have held up to the rigors of the court system. IF you accept our scholarship then you sign a no compete contract for two years.....I am not a lawyer so there might be a reason that it wouldn't work?

Just because two parties agree to a contract and sign it, that does not mean it is enforceable in court. Courts routinely find employee non-compete clauses to be unenforceable because they are overly broad or otherwise unreasonable.

And in California, non-competes are prohibited by law.

Beyond that specifically, the general concept of putting restrictions on students simply because you want to enjoy a better entertainment product is a terrible idea.
 

Lob2Davis

Sophomore
Mar 31, 2014
792
170
0
This may have been discussed before and I missed the thread. But why doesn't the NCAA just negate the NBA one year rule by making its own rules? Couldn't the NCAA make a rule that all scholarships must be honored for two years other than transfers to another school or some other hardships that may occur? If a player breaks the rule and leaves after one year, have it written into by-laws that he has to pay a percentage of his first contract to the NCAA as a penalty. 30% of a lotto pick is some serious cash. Seems they could do something like this rather than let the NBA dictate to them. Players could choose other options if they don't want to play in the NCAA for two years. Some think its unfair to tell these guys you HAVE to commit to a school for two years when they have the talents to go to the NBA right outta HS but the NBA is dictating to them already with the one and done rule.


A) They dont want to. B) Easy get-around, sign a one day contract for nothing, there's your first contract, then sign the real one.
 

wldctky_rivals70430

All-Conference
Jan 20, 2002
7,844
1,082
0
This may have been discussed before and I missed the thread. But why doesn't the NCAA just negate the NBA one year rule by making its own rules? Couldn't the NCAA make a rule that all scholarships must be honored for two years other than transfers to another school or some other hardships that may occur? If a player breaks the rule and leaves after one year, have it written into by-laws that he has to pay a percentage of his first contract to the NCAA as a penalty. 30% of a lotto pick is some serious cash. Seems they could do something like this rather than let the NBA dictate to them. Players could choose other options if they don't want to play in the NCAA for two years. Some think its unfair to tell these guys you HAVE to commit to a school for two years when they have the talents to go to the NBA right outta HS but the NBA is dictating to them already with the one and done rule.
I am beyond certain they can't stop a kid from quitting school and getting a job
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Women's Basketball KSR's top takeaways from another blowout Kentucky WBB win
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Ticket prices for Kentucky's game against Grambling State are a bad sign
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Kentucky opens as an overwhelming favorite (again) in bounce-back opportunity
  4. 04 KSR Football Kentucky opens as underdog at Missouri in SEC finale
  5. 05 KSR Volleyball Kentucky VB closes regular season strong, locks up No. 2 seed in SEC Tournament