Can the NCAA fix the One and Done

Owen68_rivals

Sophomore
Nov 1, 2012
584
144
0
The NBA is going to fix the OAD by allowing them to go right out of High School. They’re going to expand the G League. Many are expecting the end to college basketball as we know it. It won’t be that bad but it will impact us. The NBA does not care about us only $$$$$ for them. We can fight back. If we allow the undrafted to come back I think many would. The NCAA needs to take a longer look those that did get drafted and at those that hired agents. Make it easier for players that made a mistake to come back. Even to the point of allowing players who were drafted by a team they didn’t want to be on to come back. The NCAA needs to get their head out of the sand and fight back.
 

BigBlueFanGA

Heisman
Jun 14, 2005
26,435
23,456
0
The NBA is going to fix the OAD by allowing them to go right out of High School. They’re going to expand the G League. Many are expecting the end to college basketball as we know it. It won’t be that bad but it will impact us. The NBA does not care about us only $$$$$ for them. We can fight back. If we allow the undrafted to come back I think many would. The NCAA needs to take a longer look those that did get drafted and at those that hired agents. Make it easier for players that made a mistake to come back. Even to the point of allowing players who were drafted by a team they didn’t want to be on to come back. The NCAA needs to get their head out of the sand and fight back.
They should let undrafted kids come back. Who drafts you is who drafts you, that shouldn't and won't change. College basketball will improve.
 
  • Like
Reactions: THS1979

ThreeHogNight

All-Conference
May 17, 2002
3,214
1,599
0
I think the current draft rules for High School and College Baseball Players is perfect. Players are eligible to be drafted out of High School, but if they decide to go to college, they must stay at least three years.

It would require some tweaking since the High School Players can be drafted and then decline, and I doubt that the NBA would absorb that risk, but some resemblance of this would type of system could easily work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: logiUK

Xception

Heisman
Apr 17, 2007
26,407
22,344
0
It won’t end college bb but it will hurt its popularity, the ncaa has had many years to address the issue and did absolutely nothing. I can’t fathom a scenario to which the NCAA makes a good choice here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: docholiday51

logiUK

Sophomore
Jan 6, 2016
65
126
0
The only way I see this hurting some programs is that some coaches just struggle to develop talent.

If this is done (kids can go to the NBA or G-League out of high school and players in college have to stay 2 or 3 years) then the expectation would be that freshmen players that come into the college game won't necessarily be all that good. But coaches and programs that can develop talent will be able to turn those raw freshmen into better ball players by their junior year.

Coaches and programs that can't develop talent will have issues with this system because they can no longer depend on vastly superior talent coming in as freshmen.
 
Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
The NBA is going to fix the OAD by allowing them to go right out of High School. They’re going to expand the G League. Many are expecting the end to college basketball as we know it. It won’t be that bad but it will impact us. The NBA does not care about us only $$$$$ for them. We can fight back. If we allow the undrafted to come back I think many would. The NCAA needs to take a longer look those that did get drafted and at those that hired agents. Make it easier for players that made a mistake to come back. Even to the point of allowing players who were drafted by a team they didn’t want to be on to come back. The NCAA needs to get their head out of the sand and fight back.

The OAD is an NBA rule, not an NCAA rule. So in regards to that, the NCAA can't do anything.

I've been an advocate for quite a while for the NCAA to allow undrafted players to return to school. Why not! On top of that, I think the NCAA should use as leverage with the NBA, to encourage them to make a change to OAD, that the NCAA would also allow drafted players to return. The NBA doesn't want that added risk that a player unhappy with where he is taken or what city he is going to might come back to school. Sure no lottery picks would likely return, but possibly some taken 20-30, and almost surely some 2nd round (non-guaranteed contract) picks would.
Also if the NCAA paid for, or allowed schools to pay for, player travel to NBA teams they are invited to prior to the draft, then you would probably have fewer marginal players sign with agents.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fatguy87
Feb 21, 2006
8,403
9,162
0
The NCAA has always been a farm league that the NBA doesn't have to pay for and operate.

People hollering about the NCAA and individual institutions having enough money to players, maybe true, but so does the NBA and it's billionaires. The league can afford a better minor league and developmental system, they just haven't had any reason or sense of urgency until recently.

The league and even major apparel companies need to consume the elite level AAU circuits/tournaments, some of the elite prep factories turn them into a low level minor league, and set up a direct pipelines to G-league and franchises. There could be an Adidas league or teams, a Nike league, an under armor league, etc.
 
Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
I think the current draft rules for High School and College Baseball Players is perfect. Players are eligible to be drafted out of High School, but if they decide to go to college, they must stay at least three years.

It would require some tweaking since the High School Players can be drafted and then decline, and I doubt that the NBA would absorb that risk, but some resemblance of this would type of system could easily work.

I've thought that too for awhile.

But, the NBA and MLB are both very different. MLB has an advanced multi-level minor league system that nearly every player goes through (some faster than others). The NBA has created a minor-league system, but it's only for the marginal players. Also baseball is much more a sport reliant on SKILL than is basketball (baseball is 90-95% skill 5-10% athleticism, basketball is 30-50% skill & 50-70% athleticism), and so it takes baseball players much longer to become "major league ready". Thus either way, you are almost never MLB ready coming out of HS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThreeHogNight

ThreeHogNight

All-Conference
May 17, 2002
3,214
1,599
0
I've thought that too for awhile.

But, the NBA and MLB are both very different. MLB has an advanced multi-level minor league system that nearly every player goes through (some faster than others). The NBA has created a minor-league system, but it's only for the marginal players. Also baseball is much more a sport reliant on SKILL than is basketball (baseball is 90-95% skill 5-10% athleticism, basketball is 30-50% skill & 50-70% athleticism), and so it takes baseball players much longer to become "major league ready". Thus either way, you are almost never MLB ready coming out of HS.
I agree. The NBA doesn't have the "player pool" that MLB has, so it would definitely take some adjustments to the baseball system. I do believe that somehow, the decision to go to the NBA or G-League directly out of High School should be left entirely up to the player and their families.
 

Elliott Tim

All-American
Dec 10, 2005
10,122
6,290
0
The NBA is going to fix the OAD by allowing them to go right out of High School. They’re going to expand the G League. Many are expecting the end to college basketball as we know it. It won’t be that bad but it will impact us. The NBA does not care about us only $$$$$ for them. We can fight back. If we allow the undrafted to come back I think many would. The NCAA needs to take a longer look those that did get drafted and at those that hired agents. Make it easier for players that made a mistake to come back. Even to the point of allowing players who were drafted by a team they didn’t want to be on to come back. The NCAA needs to get their head out of the sand and fight back.
Having rainbow stew for dinner? Don't forget the free bubble up to wash it down.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Women's Basketball The Memorial Memo (EP. 76): Previewing Marshall + Clara Strack's WNBA Draft stock
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Braydon Hawthorne's offensive game is only beginning to reveal itself
  3. 03 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  4. 04 KSR Football Kentucky vs. Missouri is Officially the "Who Wants It More?" Bowl
  5. 05 KSR Basketball It's not all bad: Five things Kentucky has done well this season