The worst crooks got away

Nubb16

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
128,718
10,043
67
After listening to Matt today I 100% disagree. UNC thing was academics which involved students and athletes. No presedence for NCAA to rule on basically because non student athletes was involved. U6 was 100% athelletic involvement. Big big big difference
Very dumb argument
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blue wood

55wildcat

Heisman
Jan 4, 2006
33,976
99,413
113
If UNC issue was athletic only related the **** would have hit the fan on them as well. Their loophole involved non athletic students. Yeah they scooted and we all know they should have gotten the hammer. They just cheated smarter than U6. It is what it is
 

Blue wood

All-Conference
Oct 17, 2016
1,139
1,749
0
If UNC issue was athletic only related the **** would have hit the fan on them as well. Their loophole involved non athletic students. Yeah they scooted and we all know they should have gotten the hammer. They just cheated smarter than U6. It is what it is
So what you are saying is if louisville had some regular students at those ***** parties they would be in the clear?
 

55wildcat

Heisman
Jan 4, 2006
33,976
99,413
113
So what you are saying is if louisville had some regular students at those ***** parties they would be in the clear?
Not cleared but had a better argument. That would have stated it was not just an athletic thing. Whats the surprise here. Thats what UNC had going for them. Dont get me wrong here. Not on board at all with what UNC got away with. In our eyes it was wrong but give the NCAA credit. U6 is the very first school ever to vacate a championship. If non athletic students lived in Minardi ( yes i know minardis sons lived there thats a no brainer) U6 penalties would have been less severe. All Im saying. Not in no way siding with the UNC outcome but see the loophole why
 
Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
So what you are saying is if louisville had some regular students at those ***** parties they would be in the clear?

Yes.

Want hookers at your parties with recruits, just invite an equal number of "regular" students.
Want a shoe company to funnel some cash to a recruit, just get them to funnel 1/2 of it to a random (non-sports playing) high school senior.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blue wood

55wildcat

Heisman
Jan 4, 2006
33,976
99,413
113
Yes.

Want hookers at your parties with recruits, just invite an equal number of "regular" students.
Want a shoe company to funnel some cash to a recruit, just get them to funnel 1/2 of it to a random (non-sports playing) high school senior.

Jonathan. Basically your right. That was UNC argument. Athletes recieved no more preferential treatmant than regular students. Major loophole they used to their advantage
 

FiveStarCat

All-American
Oct 3, 2009
10,758
5,580
0
It’s funny that UofL got whacked, but my glee is muted since the criminals at UNCheat got away with the worst violations in NCAA history.
Agreed. Sickens me to think about. And they waltzed their way to the title thanks to some questionable officiating in multiple games last tournament. Disgusting is putting it lightly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: law1127

Spanish Radio

All-Conference
Moderator
Nov 18, 2004
3,678
2,362
113
Jonathan. Basically your right. That was UNC argument. Athletes recieved no more preferential treatmant than regular students. Major loophole they used to their advantage
The loophole is that they investigated themselves. Every criminal should get to investigate themselves so that the jails would be empty and the court system would be nonexistent.
 
  • Like
Reactions: preacherfan

preacherfan

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2003
29,208
4,970
113
After listening to Matt today I 100% disagree. UNC thing was academics which involved students and athletes. No presedence for NCAA to rule on basically because non student athletes was involved. U6 was 100% athelletic involvement. Big big big difference

Absolutely false. If Matt said that he needs to do some reading on past cases in which the SAME darn argument was made and rejected. UNC purposefully put regular students in the classes to try and make it appear legit. Anyone who buys the UNC argument is not well-informed.
 

preacherfan

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2003
29,208
4,970
113
The loophole is that they investigated themselves. Every criminal should get to investigate themselves so that the jails would be empty and the court system would be nonexistent.

Not only that, but the FIRST NCAA investigator who showed up on campus when the scandal broke was a UNC grad! That is a clear violation of NCAA rules and procedures. Then, they did, as you said, allow UNC to investigate themselves and do a number of phoney reports with one of the major players in wrongdoing influencing the report.
 

Shlomo

All-Conference
Sep 11, 2005
2,776
3,719
113
Bottom line North Carolina and Duke are untouchable. Academic fraud is fraud. How is it acceptable to let UNC skate and punish Memphis for Derrick Rose issue, or Kentucky with the Eric Manual situation? I am sure whatever made Bagley eligible will also apply to a common student there at Duke too.
 

55wildcat

Heisman
Jan 4, 2006
33,976
99,413
113
Think back about wildcat lodge. At one time they thought that might an advantage in recruiting, hence that is why there are non athletic students living in wildcat lodge. Its all a effin game,
Absolutely false. If Matt said that he needs to do some reading on past cases in which the SAME darn argument was made and rejected. UNC purposefully put regular students in the classes to try and make it appear legit. Anyone who buys the UNC argument is not well-informed.

Count me in as well informed. Thats what was said and its what it is. Worked for thrm and would have wotked for U6 had that been the case. Guess my hate is more U6 than most here. Thats why I see the loophole
 

preacherfan

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2003
29,208
4,970
113
Think back about wildcat lodge. At one time they thought that might an advantage in recruiting, hence that is why there are non athletic students living in wildcat lodge. Its all a effin game,


Count me in as well informed. Thats what was said and its what it is. Worked for thrm and would have wotked for U6 had that been the case. Guess my hate is more U6 than most here. Thats why I see the loophole

It honestly would not have worked for U6 had they invited some regular students in to join the party. That is akin to a federal crime called "structuring" in which the individual uses a technicality to avoid breaking the law.

Marshall had a far better case than UNC and still got nailed:

"For schools like Marshall University and its subsequent sanctions it would appear that there are some inconsistencies with its punishment compared with allegations at schools like North Carolina, Michigan, and Auburn and calls into question the ethical and situational decision making of the COI. The specifics in the Marshall

case concerned only one class and one professor, where it was not proven if he acted alone or in concert with the athletic department. Considering all of these issues, it is not a difficult conclusion to question the NCAA’s consistency when it comes to enforcing academic fraud cases or if they will actually take strong or any action in the UNC case.

It remains to be seen as to what the NCAA will do. One thing in the Marshall case has always stood out to me and that was how the COI took special note of how special treatment for the athletes devalued the educational experience for all. This exact language could be used against UNC, albeit for dozens of more classes, professors and involvement of athletics staff. This strong language gives one pause to examine why the same standards are not applied to all institutions accused of academic fraud and if the NCAA will actually punish North Carolina at all."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lumpy 2

Blue wood

All-Conference
Oct 17, 2016
1,139
1,749
0
It honestly would not have worked for U6 had they invited some regular students in to join the party. That is akin to a federal crime called "structuring" in which the individual uses a technicality to avoid breaking the law.

Marshall had a far better case than UNC and still got nailed:

"For schools like Marshall University and its subsequent sanctions it would appear that there are some inconsistencies with its punishment compared with allegations at schools like North Carolina, Michigan, and Auburn and calls into question the ethical and situational decision making of the COI. The specifics in the Marshall

case concerned only one class and one professor, where it was not proven if he acted alone or in concert with the athletic department. Considering all of these issues, it is not a difficult conclusion to question the NCAA’s consistency when it comes to enforcing academic fraud cases or if they will actually take strong or any action in the UNC case.

It remains to be seen as to what the NCAA will do. One thing in the Marshall case has always stood out to me and that was how the COI took special note of how special treatment for the athletes devalued the educational experience for all. This exact language could be used against UNC, albeit for dozens of more classes, professors and involvement of athletics staff. This strong language gives one pause to examine why the same standards are not applied to all institutions accused of academic fraud and if the NCAA will actually punish North Carolina at all."
That dude bragging on his-self that he was well informed should tell you he dont know ****
 

John Henry

Hall of Famer
Aug 18, 2007
35,574
172,795
113
All I know is U6 got hammered and the banner comes down. That is the bottom line for me not how UNC beat the system and is laughing. They were never going to nail UNC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood

Bkocats

Heisman
Jan 2, 2011
80,908
70,033
67
Okay I get the unc thing being open to non athletes. But here is where it gets sticky for me: athlete or not, a fraudulent class means a fraudulent grade. Athletes have to maintain a certain gpa to remain eligible. Fraudulent grades mean that gpa drops below the required mark...which should mean that athlete is ineligible.
???
 
  • Like
Reactions: preacherfan

preacherfan

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2003
29,208
4,970
113
Okay I get the unc thing being open to non athletes. But here is where it gets sticky for me: athlete or not, a fraudulent class means a fraudulent grade. Athletes have to maintain a certain gpa to remain eligible. Fraudulent grades mean that gpa drops below the required mark...which should mean that athlete is ineligible.
???

Trying to add some common sense into the discussion? I don't think some people can handle that!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bkocats

JBHolmesfan

All-Conference
Jul 23, 2009
8,181
4,747
0
After listening to Matt today I 100% disagree. UNC thing was academics which involved students and athletes. No presedence for NCAA to rule on basically because non student athletes was involved. U6 was 100% athelletic involvement. Big big big difference
This argument holds no merit for anyone who understands the makeup of college classes, and basic understanding of statistics. I could be wrong on the exact number, but I think it was something like 45% of the students in these classes were athletes. I forget the exact number, but even if it was 30%, it shows clear intent on having athletes benefit from this.

I've been in academia for 6 years now (4 at UK as a student and 2 as a graduate student at a power 5 conference. I've been a TA for 2 years now). During that time, there has not been more than 5-6 athletes in any of my classes at one time (as a student or TA). This includes sports like gymnastics and women's soccer, and I'm not sure they're included in the 45% number UNC has given, but could be wrong.

To me, having that large of a percentage of athletes in those classes compared to the typical average for classes shows clear corruption here. 45% of these students in fake classes were athletes for a decade or so when the normal average for athletes in a class is single digits? That doesn't happen by chance and it isn't a statistical outlier. It shows a clear setup by UNC to do what they did.
 
  • Like
Reactions: preacherfan

serdi

All-Conference
Mar 22, 2009
2,672
3,934
0
I am writing this as a 64 year-old alum who has been a fan since I was 10 years old (54 years). Anybody on this board that that says that North Carolina at Chapel Hill should not have been hammered, had at least 20 years of victories taken down and at least the 1993, 2005, and 2009 championship banners taken down (and probation should have not let them play for the 2017 banner) has to be less than 50 years of age. Any UK fan that lived and observed during Coach Rupp's and Coach Hall's era and dealing with the fraud that was Dean E. Smith and his condesending, holier than thou, arrogant, above it all, manner spinning the image of Mr. Perfect as he looked down his nose at UK and other schools dedicated to excellence, and was not outraged beyond outraged when the Cheatin' Dean Smiths walked are lying about their age or really don't bleed blue...don't really care about our program.

Those only old enough to remember the Laetner game and since talk about the hate for Duke. There again, if you could remember before that, you would not even begin to see Duke in the same box as North Carolina at Chapel Hill nor would you have as much disdain for them. You would seem them as a great competitor and rival that you wanted to beat but respected.

There is no respect for NCCH any longer. They and their Carolina Way are the biggest fraud travesty in the history of college sport. Every school should refuse to schedule them. Even their biggest rival, Duke, does not see that they are a rival any more. It is all an imagination of ESPN. If you don't believe me, go look at the comments made by Duke's fan base about their rivalry that is no longer with the Cheatin' Dean Smith's.

I am very disappointed in UofL for taking their banner down. I would tell the NCAA to stick it. I hope if UK ever gets any violations from the NCAA in the future they would do the same.

The NCAA died folks on October 13th 2017 when the biggest fraud cheaters of all time walked PERIOD. Nothing matters anymore.
 

ProfessorOwl

Redshirt
Oct 31, 2017
6
7
0
Okay I get the unc thing being open to non athletes. But here is where it gets sticky for me: athlete or not, a fraudulent class means a fraudulent grade. Athletes have to maintain a certain gpa to remain eligible. Fraudulent grades mean that gpa drops below the required mark...which should mean that athlete is ineligible.
???

SACS never said that the classes were fraudulent retroactively. So past athletes were never ineligible.

UNC never said the classes were fraudulent. Why would they? It would mean thousands of students were now 3 hours short of a degree.

NCAA couldn't deem the classes fraudulent, as that isn't their jurisdiction. They have to accept what the Universities and Accreditation boards say.
 

Spanish Radio

All-Conference
Moderator
Nov 18, 2004
3,678
2,362
113
SACS never said that the classes were fraudulent retroactively. So past athletes were never ineligible.

UNC never said the classes were fraudulent. Why would they? It would mean thousands of students we're now 3 hours short of a degree.

NCAA couldn't deem the classes fraudulent, as that isn't their jurisdiction. They have to accept what the Universities and Accreditation boards say.
Yep, diploma mill and UNC fans defending it. Tells you where they are
 

preacherfan

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2003
29,208
4,970
113
“Within the academic review of the classes outside the NCAA infractions process, UNC told its accrediting body that the 18 years of academic conduct was ‘long-standing and egregious academic wrongdoing.’ It also originally adopted its accreditor’s characterization of the wrongdoing as ‘academic fraud,’” the committee’s report said.

“Despite these early admissions, UNC pivoted dramatically from its position roughly three years later within the infractions process,” the report added. “UNC disavowed its earlier support of the findings and conclusions of an independent report, distanced itself from earlier statements to its accreditor and ultimately defended its courses as a matter of academic autonomy.”


Read more here: http://www.newsobserver.com/news/local/education/article179169576.html#storylink=cpy
 

preacherfan

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2003
29,208
4,970
113
SACS never said that the classes were fraudulent retroactively. So past athletes were never ineligible.

UNC never said the classes were fraudulent. Why would they? It would mean thousands of students were now 3 hours short of a degree.

NCAA couldn't deem the classes fraudulent, as that isn't their jurisdiction. They have to accept what the Universities and Accreditation boards say.

You guys are either complete idiots or complete liars. No other way to put it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rush2112 UK
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football CFB Cheat Sheet: Week 12
  2. 02 KSR Football Bio Blast: Missouri Tigers
  3. 03 KSR KSR GAMEDAY: Kentucky Plays for History at Missouri
  4. 04 KSR Podcasts 11 Personnel: Luckett's Play Sheet at Missouri
  5. 05 KSR Basketball KSR's top takeaways from Kentucky's double-digit loss at Indiana