Cal needs to be Brutally honest

BigBlueFanGA

Heisman
Jun 14, 2005
26,435
23,456
0
Knox is really hurting his NBA stock in my opinion, plays no defense and just does not play hard at all. At this point I would say we would still be a first rounder but maybe in the 20’s.
As of a couple days ago ESPN (draft express) had Knox at 12. The NBA isn't overly concerned with defense. They are terribly concerned about potential and ceilings, Knox looks good in both those areas - and he is VERY young.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

etowncatfan

All-American
Jan 3, 2003
15,952
5,874
113
I don't think that is OPs point (I could be wrong) but I think he means THESE guys need to hear it, to improve.
And imo if they "can't" hear it or improve. There is the door. The least liked team (for me). Just coming back for another year isn't going to make them hustle more. Jmo

Exactly
 

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,171
0
Again, after 8 years.... you people still dont get it...


Doesnt matter if they are ready, it only matters if a team is dumb enough and willing to give them a guaranteed multi-million dollar contract.

Why do you people think that coming back to college with classes and a 20 hour limit practice week during season and only an 8 hour practice week in the off season will get them their 2nd contract easier than working 24/7 with pro coaches...?

Not to mention they have the multi-million dollars? I'd like to see them all stay but lets be honest and not stupid, we want them here for us to win games.


Now... you are correct for those who do NOT have that guarantee. I read a great article i'll try to locate on the commitment teams put into 1st round picks versus 2nd's and UFA's...

If you are not a 1st Rounder as a freshman you should most definitley stay.

I don't buy the argument that staying in college can't prepare you better than getting NBA coaching for a lot of these guys.

The reason is, when you leave, you are now in a mans game. You also have money now, which totally complicates things. Those coaches are not going to hold your hand, if you can't prioritize you're done. Getting better in college keeps your dream in view, it simplifies what you need to do. You won't be out hanging with stars (young) and instead of picking between practicing and buying a car that day, you'll be working on your dream.

I don't think it's one size fits all and this board has pushed this idea off a cliff.

Some of the best players that have ever played stayed in school.
 

Soupbean

All-American
Jan 19, 2007
5,945
8,109
0
We all know that's never going to happen, Cal just doesn't operate that way, and the consequences for doing so would hurt more than help. These kids will get a reality check in the combine, some will leave regardless, others will transfer or return.
He can't because his whole mantra is he can get them ready for the league earlier than everybody else. Would be admitting failure at the main thing he's hung his hat on. Not the only thing but the main thing. He also does preach that he wants them to get ready for life and be good servants and I do think he's done a good job of that, and not being facetious. But he has sort of backed himself into a corner on the main thing.
 

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,171
0
He can't because his whole mantra is he can get them ready for the league earlier than everybody else. Would be admitting failure at the main thing he's hung his hat on. Not the only thing but the main thing. He also does preach that he wants them to get ready for life and be good servants and I do think he's done a good job of that, and not being facetious. But he has sort of backed himself into a corner on the main thing.

Right. And what happens when those players say nah, I can go anywhere and get to the league?

You end up with the fringe second rounders who want to use this program for the Kentucky effect and Anthony Davis goes to Albany or Duke or Arizona or Oklahoma.

The game has changed since Wall but Cal can't accept it. If he has we will see it, but right now he appears to be doubling down. It could destroy his legacy if he doesn't adjust. Might as well go be a pro coach.

And that's real. I'm not hoping for it or hating. I'm not calling to fire CAL.

It is what it is.
 

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
Just an aside. But I think it would be helpful if everybody who uses the phrase "ready for the NBA" and the word "talent" defines what they mean by the terms. Because they obviously mean different things to different people, which is understandable because they are sort of amorphous terms.
 

JC43

All-Conference
Oct 6, 2006
3,807
2,956
0
Cal needs to have his former players visit this team, one at a time. Before each game if possible. I don't think it's only our players, but a generational thing. You are seeing it throughout all college ball. It started three years ago, when the players felt/play like the deserve too. To much focus on potential vs ability. Not only is it destroying college basketball, but producing a watered down NBA product.
Doesn't help when LaVar creates another option for lazy/non fundamentals based players...like to see overall points scored, amount of charges per year/ vs decades past.
Off topic,think the players kneeling in NFL has anything to do with this... hold on
When one player on a team, can take all the attention of the public in team based sports.
A general I am more important/my feelings are more important than the institutions they are representing?
 

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,171
0
Cal needs to have his former players visit this team, one at a time. Before each game if possible. I don't think it's only our players, but a generational thing. You are seeing it throughout all college ball. It started three years ago, when the players felt/play like the deserve too. To much focus on potential vs ability. Not only is it destroying college basketball, but producing a watered down NBA product.
Doesn't help when LaVar creates another option for lazy/non fundamentals based players...like to see overall points scored, amount of charges per year/ vs decades past.
Off topic,think the players kneeling in NFL has anything to do with this... hold on
When one player on a team, can take all the attention of the public in team based sports.
A general I am more important/my feelings are more important than the institutions they are representing?

What I would like to see is college adopt a two year rule, and even though they can't enforce it by law, they can make it as hard as possibly for guys to leave.

Lifetime scholarship pulled.
Have them sign in the contract that tbeybwill be forced to return all monitary compensation including tuition, room and board.

Some people actually want to pay these kids, ridiculous. It will just continue to destroy the game.

Something has to be done for college basketball. Close the door to the kids using it for instant accessibility to the nba.

I know some of these kids are fun to watch, but it's like having sex with Pamela Anderson in 92. Super fun, a dream. But the next morning you wake up with Hep-C.

It's not worth it because it's damaging the sport.

The sport was fine when they could go straight out of high school. We missed nothing by not having LeBron James in college.
 

JC43

All-Conference
Oct 6, 2006
3,807
2,956
0
As neat as that solution sounds implementing it will night impossible. Other programs will use against us.
Simply, the NBA has to draft kids straight out of HighSchool. If said player tries to be drafted, he may join team but won't be eligible til next year. This will weed out all who are borderline, let's the player practice and develop without playing and makes the penalty be if you try to be drafted and don't, it will be two yrs before you are on the court.
Think that will only have best of best..the aytons Bagley davis' make the league...
 

kevcat

Heisman
Feb 26, 2007
27,686
32,625
0
What I would like to see is college adopt a two year rule, and even though they can't enforce it by law, they can make it as hard as possibly for guys to leave.

Lifetime scholarship pulled.
Have them sign in the contract that tbeybwill be forced to return all monitary compensation including tuition, room and board.

Some people actually want to pay these kids, ridiculous. It will just continue to destroy the game.

Something has to be done for college basketball. Close the door to the kids using it for instant accessibility to the nba.

I know some of these kids are fun to watch, but it's like having sex with Pamela Anderson in 92. Super fun, a dream. But the next morning you wake up with Hep-C.

It's not worth it because it's damaging the sport.

The sport was fine when they could go straight out of high school. We missed nothing by not having LeBron James in college.
100% spot on.
Good post.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crpoore
A

anon_013cn8yrfncx2

Guest
If any of you think Cal isn't brutally honest with these kids, you are 1000% wrong.

Not every kid wants/needs to be a top 10 pick, some just want to go make money playing basketball somewhere. Cal gives them the best opportunity to further their career and goals...did he push Patterson out the door? Did he push Harrisons out? How about Ullis? Poythress? If I recall, he told Teague he should come back, and thought he was going to, which led to scrambling to fill that spot and having Harrow run the point. There are other factors in each decision other than "being ready" for NBA.

Didn't he tell Ulis not to come unless he planned on leaving after 2 years?

If Ulis gets a 2nd contract then I'll say Csl was right. Otherwise no real reason for Tyler not to play 4 years. Well, except to make room for Fox of course.

Tyler would be a senior this year.
 

brianpoe

Heisman
Mar 25, 2009
27,769
21,825
113
I don't buy the argument that staying in college can't prepare you better than getting NBA coaching for a lot of these guys.

The reason is, when you leave, you are now in a mans game. You also have money now, which totally complicates things. Those coaches are not going to hold your hand, if you can't prioritize you're done. Getting better in college keeps your dream in view, it simplifies what you need to do. You won't be out hanging with stars (young) and instead of picking between practicing and buying a car that day, you'll be working on your dream.

I don't think it's one size fits all and this board has pushed this idea off a cliff.

Some of the best players that have ever played stayed in school.



Again, I must correct you.

My point was in regard to 1st Rounders who fans say are not ready and should come back.

An NBA team has invested a 1st Round pick and 3 year guaranteed salary. I suggest you google the amount of commitment teams put into these 1st Rounders, it is obscene.

Secondly, there is a reason why kids explode once they reach the NBA - it is called working with pro coaches 24/7.... no one on this planet could possibly believe that with a 20 hour week practice rule including classes and everything else AND an 8 hour a week practice restraint in the offseason could come remotely close to improving a players game at remotely even the same rate the unlimited time they have as a pro.

I dont think you could be any more wrong with this one.


And I dont want to come across as I want this kids to leave, nor that I dont agree they are not ready... I am simply looking at the facts and with fan heart...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: kyjohn

ManitouDan_anon

Heisman
Dec 7, 2006
20,073
32,434
0
Didn't he tell Ulis not to come unless he planned on leaving after 2 years?

If Ulis gets a 2nd contract then I'll say Csl was right. Otherwise no real reason for Tyler not to play 4 years. Well, except to make room for Fox of course.

Tyler would be a senior this year.

Ahhh the thought of another Tyler . Pure hoops dreams
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe
Feb 5, 2010
952
787
0
To the Media and to the Players. He needs to tell both that none of these players are even close to being ready for the NBA. Potential is a great thing but it does not guarantee you an NBA career. I am guessing these so called NBA players are playing now to just get the season over. I know he won't but he needs to be honest.


Coach K would tell them, and they would come back like some of his do....Let's hope he doesn't persuade his freshman class this year to come back wouldn't be pretty for anybody next year!!
 

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,171
0
Again, I must correct you.

My point was in regard to 1st Rounders who fans say are not ready and should come back.

An NBA team has invested a 1st Round pick and 3 year guaranteed salary. I suggest you google the amount of commitment teams put into these 1st Rounders, it is obscene.

Secondly, there is a reason why kids explode once they reach the NBA - it is called working with pro coaches 24/7.... no one on this planet could possibly believe that with a 20 hour week practice rule including classes and everything else AND an 8 hour a week practice restraint in the offseason could come remotely close to improving a players game at remotely even the same rate the unlimited time they have as a pro.

I dont think you could be any more wrong with this one.


And I dont want to come across as I want this kids to leave, nor that I dont agree they are not ready... I am simply looking at the facts and with fan heart...

The problem is you're saying they blow up once they get to the league. How many? Who? How many guys left that counldnt handle the situation, blew their money and don't progress their games? The simple fact is we only look at the ones it worked for, and if they don't pan out we never attribute leaving college too early as a reason.

I understand they have more time to practice, doesn't mean they will. In the NBA you make your own choices, in college a lot of those choices are made for you as you grow into the type of person that can make the correct choices themselves.

Where I think the real issue comes in is, as you say, the contract. Hard to turn down? Yea, but life is full of hard choices and if you're making money the goal instead of the byproduct, you're doing it wrong. And most of those types, unless naturally gifted, fail.

I'm not saying it's one size fits all, that's my point. Every individual kid needs to determine his correct path, whether or not it's a well worn path is irrelevant in their case. Some need the cash and need to take the risk. They have the luck of the draw and it is what it is. But there are players who mentally need to stay in school, I don't care how much money is waiting.

That's my opinion on it.
 

brianpoe

Heisman
Mar 25, 2009
27,769
21,825
113
The problem is you're saying they blow up once they get to the league. How many? Who? How many guys left that counldnt handle the situation, blew their money and don't progress their games? The simple fact is we only look at the ones it worked for, and if they don't pan out we never attribute leaving college too early as a reason.

I understand they have more time to practice, doesn't mean they will. In the NBA you make your own choices, in college a lot of those choices are made for you as you grow into the type of person that can make the correct choices themselves.

Where I think the real issue comes in is, as you say, the contract. Hard to turn down? Yea, but life is full of hard choices and if you're making money the goal instead of the byproduct, you're doing it wrong. And most of those types, unless naturally gifted, fail.

I'm not saying it's one size fits all, that's my point. Every individual kid needs to determine his correct path, whether or not it's a well worn path is irrelevant in their case. Some need the cash and need to take the risk. They have the luck of the draw and it is what it is. But there are players who mentally need to stay in school, I don't care how much money is waiting.

That's my opinion on it.


Dakari and the twins have all excelled.

No way players dont improve over being in school a year that doesnt make any sense.

If a player isnt going to reach the second contract with 24/7 pro coaching they damn sure wont get it 8 hours a week in college.



If you want to change the subject and move it to maturity and money management that is a totally different conversation.
 

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,171
0
Dakari and the twins have all excelled.

No way players dont improve over being in school a year that doesnt make any sense.

If a player isnt going to reach the second contract with 24/7 pro coaching they damn sure wont get it 8 hours a week in college.



If you want to change the subject and move it to maturity and money management that is a totally different conversation.

I didn't mean to move the conversation, but that's the conversation for me in regards to the topic.

Should every player take the cash when it's available? No.
 

keefsopeng

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2005
5,015
2,068
0
I thought it was funny after we won the title in 2012 and Cal was on his press tour Mike Francessa asked him about players stock and what he says to gm's. He said that if a kid leaves who has no business he lies his *** off to the gm because at that point he has to do everything to help the kid even though said kid would be making a terrible decision. So to think Cal would ever publicly chastise a player or comment negatively on their NBA stock is laughable.
 

Doc4UK!

All-Conference
Aug 14, 2003
2,888
1,955
113
If any of you think Cal isn't brutally honest with these kids, you are 1000% wrong.

Not every kid wants/needs to be a top 10 pick, some just want to go make money playing basketball somewhere. Cal gives them the best opportunity to further their career and goals...did he push Patterson out the door? Did he push Harrisons out? How about Ullis? Poythress? If I recall, he told Teague he should come back, and thought he was going to, which led to scrambling to fill that spot and having Harrow run the point. There are other factors in each decision other than "being ready" for NBA.

The kids who elect to come to Kentucky seem to be among those who expect to stay in college for the minimal amount of time. Not necessarily what Cal says to them during or after the season as much as what he tells them (and their families) during their recruitment ie his goals for them and it is about them rather than the program. He has told us this repeatedly and all is fine until we start losing. Whenever someone asks one of our recruits why they chose UK they respond that it is the quickest way into the NBA.
 

ala_kat2

Heisman
Jan 4, 2003
11,459
11,030
103
The kids who elect to come to Kentucky seem to be among those who expect to stay in college for the minimal amount of time. Not necessarily what Cal says to them during or after the season as much as what he tells them (and their families) during their recruitment ie his goals for them and it is about them rather than the program. He has told us this repeatedly and all is fine until we start losing. Whenever someone asks one of our recruits why they chose UK they respond that it is the quickest way into the NBA.

dic4UK, you nailed it. If Cal would sell the "program" a little better, maybe every 4 or 5 star who comes here will not think they're entitled to go to the NBA after one year, or at least not expect to. There's a few of them out there, but Cal would have to take a little bit different recruiting approach. And if he didn't get alpha-males, could he coach them up?
 

jameslee32

Heisman
Mar 26, 2009
33,666
22,359
83
What I would like to see is college adopt a two year rule, and even though they can't enforce it by law, they can make it as hard as possibly for guys to leave.

Lifetime scholarship pulled.
Have them sign in the contract that tbeybwill be forced to return all monitary compensation including tuition, room and board.

Some people actually want to pay these kids, ridiculous. It will just continue to destroy the game.

Something has to be done for college basketball. Close the door to the kids using it for instant accessibility to the nba.

I know some of these kids are fun to watch, but it's like having sex with Pamela Anderson in 92. Super fun, a dream. But the next morning you wake up with Hep-C.

It's not worth it because it's damaging the sport.

The sport was fine when they could go straight out of high school. We missed nothing by not having LeBron James in college.
The status quo or more stupidity like keeping 5-stars away from money they feel they deserve, is a sure fire way to more FBI perp walks.
 

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,171
0
Well lock them up.

The players don't deserve to be paid in college. None of them are forced to go to school. They have means of advancing into professionalism if that's what they want to do.

If they get paid they get paid. But I don' agree with changing much. Let the ones that want money at 18 go, create a rule for college, and if you want to be in school and play / get educated then stay.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kevcat

W_Heisenberg

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2013
2,435
1,075
0
The kids who elect to come to Kentucky seem to be among those who expect to stay in college for the minimal amount of time. Not necessarily what Cal says to them during or after the season as much as what he tells them (and their families) during their recruitment ie his goals for them and it is about them rather than the program. He has told us this repeatedly and all is fine until we start losing. Whenever someone asks one of our recruits why they chose UK they respond that it is the quickest way into the NBA.

dic4UK, you nailed it. If Cal would sell the "program" a little better, maybe every 4 or 5 star who comes here will not think they're entitled to go to the NBA after one year, or at least not expect to. There's a few of them out there, but Cal would have to take a little bit different recruiting approach. And if he didn't get alpha-males, could he coach them up?

I think you don't fully understand the current landscape of recruiting...in order to get elite players you have to convince them you can get them ready for the NBA the best/quickest. What else are these guys looking for...education, amenities, weather? None of that matters, and frankly college is for that in any fashion. Want to be a lawyer/doctor/teacher/welder? Go to the school that preps you best in the least amount of time so you can go make money, which is what we all want in life.
 

W_Heisenberg

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2013
2,435
1,075
0
Didn't he tell Ulis not to come unless he planned on leaving after 2 years?

If Ulis gets a 2nd contract then I'll say Csl was right. Otherwise no real reason for Tyler not to play 4 years. Well, except to make room for Fox of course.

Tyler would be a senior this year.

Yes he did, and it got Ullis here, but he wasn't pushing him out the door if he wasn't ready.
 

Soupbean

All-American
Jan 19, 2007
5,945
8,109
0
I think you don't fully understand the current landscape of recruiting...in order to get elite players you have to convince them you can get them ready for the NBA the best/quickest. What else are these guys looking for...education, amenities, weather? None of that matters, and frankly college is for that in any fashion. Want to be a lawyer/doctor/teacher/welder? Go to the school that preps you best in the least amount of time so you can go make money, which is what we all want in life.
I think this is where you are missing some of the change . . . I think more and more of the true one and dones are looking for more than "the quickest path to the NBA". You hear it in the comments from guys like Zion and others who already know they can get there just as quickly anywhere they go so they are looking for the best college environment that feels like home as they can find to enjoy their one year in college. I think this is getting missed in the conversation.

I've said before that Big Blue Madness has lost it's effect because sometimes the hype and build up can be over the top to some and some don't want the overwhelming spotlight and pro type environment that this place can be. How many have come out of madness committed in the past 5 years? IMO more and more want a more relaxed college feel for their time in college and that might be some of the appeal Duke is having right now . . . come here and get the league but get the college environment. I know that blasphemous but I think its real.
 

armchairpg

All-Conference
Oct 24, 2012
2,608
1,736
113
A public statement like that would be easy for all rival recruiters to turn around on Cal. he can be honest to the players and to teams that call but making this a public statement has zero upside. Besides scouts have eyes.
 

Pete391

Junior
Feb 10, 2018
277
254
0
I heard a tv commentator talking about the one and done the other day and to me he made alot of sense...He said one big thing making these kids want to go pro after their first year is that they have to worry about being recruited over and if someone comes in a little better then they are, then they will be sitting on the bench and their NBA career hopes are pretty much over...So the players have to be aware of who is coming in next year also..
 

nickhorvathsuxazz

All-American
Jul 21, 2015
5,777
8,938
0
What I would like to see is college adopt a two year rule, and even though they can't enforce it by law, they can make it as hard as possibly for guys to leave.

Lifetime scholarship pulled.
Have them sign in the contract that tbeybwill be forced to return all monitary compensation including tuition, room and board.

Some people actually want to pay these kids, ridiculous. It will just continue to destroy the game.

Something has to be done for college basketball. Close the door to the kids using it for instant accessibility to the nba.

I know some of these kids are fun to watch, but it's like having sex with Pamela Anderson in 92. Super fun, a dream. But the next morning you wake up with Hep-C.

It's not worth it because it's damaging the sport.

The sport was fine when they could go straight out of high school. We missed nothing by not having LeBron James in college.
You're killing it on this issue...I've found myself nodding in agreement w/ about all of your posts on the subject.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football LIVE BLOG: No. 16 Kentucky at Missouri
  2. 02 KSR Football Listen to KSR's Pregame Show before Kentucky vs. Mizzou
  3. 03 KSR A Brief History of Weird Football Between Kentucky and Missouri
  4. 04 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  5. 05 KSR DJ Miller will play homecoming game against Missouri