one and done rule discussion

1991greywildcat

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2014
2,337
1,580
0
What is the general public opinion about one and done around rupp rafters? Do you agree with it or do you wish Cal would start taking a more conservative approach and start recruiting more mutli year players?
 

Big John Stud

All-American
Jan 14, 2003
23,281
8,876
0
What is the general public opinion about one and done around rupp rafters? Do you agree with it or do you wish Cal would start taking a more conservative approach and start recruiting more mutli year players?
General opinion depends on who you're talking about. Kentucky and Coach Cal are ruining the game, Duke and Coach K have adapted brilliantly.
 

ORCAT

Heisman
Jan 6, 2003
24,802
12,253
113
I have mixed feelings. I don't blame anyone for wanting to make a great living and wouldn't deny having guys that opportunity. Also, I love having the top players wearing UK uniforms. But, I also admit that I greatly miss guys playing for UK for multiple years and getting to know them and watching them play for us for multiple seasons. So, I guess I have to be OK with it as we have no other choice right now unless we want to be like Wisconsin, Virginia, Gonzaga and schools like that keeping players around for 3-4 years.
 

Cat in ga

All-Conference
Nov 2, 2017
2,898
2,806
0
I say let em go right out of high school. Or must stay two years @ school. They can join the military right out of high school so I see no reason they should not be able to join the NBA. Also if they stay for two years at least they leave with an associates degree. Put the student back in student athlete.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MbergCat

marshalfan

All-Conference
Oct 2, 2005
6,149
1,148
0
I say let em go right out of high school. Or must stay two years @ school. They can join the military right out of high school so I see no reason they should not be able to join the NBA. Also if they stay for two years at least they leave with an associates degree. Put the student back in student athlete.

I can see the NBA's reasoning for the one and done. It igives them the opportunity to see players against better competition before committing big bucks for a player. It is not illegal for kids to go to the NBA, just not in the leagues best interest.
 
May 22, 2002
18,442
15,937
113
Not a fan of any restrictions on draft age. Let them go straight from HS if they're good enough. And let them go at any point in their college career if they feel they're ready. I'd also like to see a rule that if they enter the draft and do not get picked, they can keep their eligibility and return to school.
 

UKErik

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
27,441
3,092
0
One and done has helped and hurt UK basketball, IMO. Fans absolutely love being in the hunt for almost every elite high school player in the country, but the revolving door that is our roster has taken it's toll.

I don't think fans are bothered when guys like Davis, Wall, Boogie, Townes, and Booker leave early.

Seeing 2-3 guys leave early every year is one thing. Having to replace 93% of your scoring is another. It would be nice to see a UK program that could somehow have more of a balance. Unfortunately, the culture at Kentucky seems to be "one and done" no matter your draft status.

I hope the NBA changes the rule. Allow kids to either go the NBA out of high school or spend two years in college/overseas. That would be better for UK anyway. Afterall, Cal is likely gonna thrive in any system.

GBB!!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wally2000_rivals

Bluegrassking

All-Conference
Jul 18, 2006
4,050
1,913
0
The only change that will actually be beneficial for Kentucky and college basketball over all is straight up increasing the waiting period to two years (three probably would be best for the game but would probably erode our advantage a bit just on pure roster opening limitations).

Anything else is a be careful what you wish for because it might come true situation.
 

Neue Regel

All-Conference
Mar 12, 2003
12,346
2,061
0
Name your All Duke NBA team bandwagon Duke fan. Does it have 1 or 2 Plumlee's?

You just asked this the other day. That was after a couple of Kentucky fans said you were a UNC fan posing. Get some new material. (Btw what’s the Plumlee’s record against Chapel Hill College?)
 

Big John Stud

All-American
Jan 14, 2003
23,281
8,876
0
You just asked this the other day. That was after a couple of Kentucky fans said you were a UNC fan posing. Get some new material. (Btw what’s the Plumlee’s record against Chapel Hill College?)
No Kentucky fans think I'm a UNC fan, only moronic bandwagon Duke fans. I have a looong history here and people say a lot of things about me, but the UNC accusation is laughable.

So about that All Duke NBA team, who ya got. Kyrie, X Plumlee, X Plumlee, and who else?
 

Neue Regel

All-Conference
Mar 12, 2003
12,346
2,061
0
No Kentucky fans think I'm a UNC fan, only moronic bandwagon Duke fans. I have a looong history here and people say a lot of things about me, but the UNC accusation is laughable.

So about that All Duke NBA team, who ya got. Kyrie, X Plumlee, X Plumlee, and who else?

No it was Kentucky fans who pointed that out. Maybe they’re wrong, maybe they weren’t. Either way please climb down off your little throne, you haven’t been appointed the Dictator of fan support for anybody. And I already answered this the other day and have no interest in placating an agenda poster again. Thanks.
 

Wildcats1st

Heisman
Sep 16, 2017
18,949
28,911
0
My fear with letting players go straight from high school is that it makes recruiting very tricky. I think you will have 10-20 players every year on top of the studs throwing their hat in the NBA ring. It won’t be college vs nba it will be g league vs college for many. I say mandatory of 2 yrs from graduation for nba draft
 

Big John Stud

All-American
Jan 14, 2003
23,281
8,876
0
No it was Kentucky fans who pointed that out. Maybe they’re wrong, maybe they weren’t. Either way please climb down off your little throne, you haven’t been appointed the Dictator of fan support for anybody. And I already answered this the other day and have no interest in placating an agenda poster again. Thanks.
You actually didn't answer. Duke fans never do. Dictator of fans because I asked you a simple question that you didnt answer? Nice deflection bro.
 

TheAnonymous13

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2011
3,314
3,391
0
While it is allowable, he should continue as he has. Certainly there is sometimes a ceiling related to freshmen talent, but there is no arguing against his annual success. He has consistently had title contending teams, and though he has "only" won one--- his rosters have been in position to have won three.
I personally do not like the rule, nor I find the annual turnover to be satisfying from a personal fan perspective. But he is here to win, and has found a formula that does so in big numbers.
All that said, I hope the rule changes.
 

Primedfor9

Senior
Oct 1, 2015
1,094
601
0
I like it and think the rule should stay as it is. The NBA benefits by being able to evaluate the players at a higher level than high school making it less likely to draft a bust, the NBA even complained about this when players could go directly out of high school so I don't get why they want to change it now. The NCAA benefits by having more star players, which I'd think definitely helps ratings.
 

Whatsup

All-American
Feb 15, 2011
8,987
8,085
0
Doesn't really matter one way or the other to me. I love the one and done and I would be ok with letting the best kids go pro right out of HS. Either way Cal and Kentucky will always get top notch players. Well as long as Cal is at KY.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball IT'S A MILAN MOMCILOVIC PARTY AND YOU'RE INVITED!
  2. 02 KSR Basketball LIVE BLOG: Kentucky vs. Indiana
  3. 03 KSR Women's Basketball WATCH: KSR Rapidly Reacts to Kentucky WBB's 36-point win over Marshall
  4. 04 KSR Football Friday Night SEC Availability Report for Kentucky vs. Missouri
  5. 05 KSR Women's Basketball FINAL: O'Neal, Sivka combine for 38 points as No. 12 Kentucky WBB takes down Marshall