Realistic expectations for this years team

How far can this team go in the NCAAT?


  • Total voters
    0

SemperFiCat

Heisman
Mar 2, 2009
14,566
30,005
0
This year seems weird to me. I'm used to a new team every year, but for some reason, I have no idea how this squad will turn out. I went with E8 just based on talent.
 

Dakota25

All-Conference
Nov 24, 2014
2,460
1,027
0
I put sweet 16. I just feel like this team will land in the 3-6 seed range so they'll have to play an elite appointment in the sweet 16 barring any upsets. I think UK finished the regular season with anywhere between 22-25 wins.

Again though 18-19 will be our year. I expect Green, Alexandra, Baker, and two big men back from this season.
 

RalphDaltonFan

Heisman
Apr 3, 2002
60,395
41,937
113
Think by year's end they can play with anyone and will be one of his better teams. I'm basing a lot off the fact it's closer to type of roster Cal does best work with--no more small 3 guard lineup approach--which was entertaining to watch but led to worst defensive teams he's had at UK.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rupp'sRunt

SemperFiCat

Heisman
Mar 2, 2009
14,566
30,005
0
So, 41% of us "realistically expect" a national championship? Seriously??? That's probably the same 41% that freak out and want to fire Cal after any loss. Good grief folks, the best team in the nation only wins that tournament maybe a 1/3 of the time.
 

wildcat1515

All-Conference
Feb 7, 2006
5,450
2,953
113
We beat UNC on a last second shot in Final 4 to advance to the Championship game against Duke. We beat them by 20 while Coach K cries on the sidelines and while Allen keeps tripping Capel and other Duke players while on the bench!
 

Bluegrassking

All-Conference
Jul 18, 2006
4,050
1,913
0
Can = Championship (too much talent compared to the field to say this isn't plausibly the ceiling).

Expect = Elite 8 (play the season a thousand times and my bet is this is the most likely outcome).

Disappointed = Fail to reach the Sweet 16 (too loaded with too seasoned of an elite coach not to expect to get at least here versus a field that isn't overbearing).

The question is CAN. How is it unreasonable to say a high top 10 ten CAN when the championship?

Are we the favorite? No.
Are we an overdog? No, but not far from it in most eyes as per out ranking.
Are we a plausible contender? Absolutely relative to the current field. There aren't 10 teams that reasonable expect to be be better. There may not be even five. By definition a championship is just possible (I'd loosely define this as a top 8 seed) but plausible (a top 4 seed) or even one of a favorite few (a top 10ish team).
 
  • Like
Reactions: KDCats11

Bluegrassking

All-Conference
Jul 18, 2006
4,050
1,913
0
So, 41% of us "realistically expect" a national championship? Seriously??? That's probably the same 41% that freak out and want to fire Cal after any loss. Good grief folks, the best team in the nation only wins that tournament maybe a 1/3 of the time.

The question is CAN not WILL.

I think a championship is not just possible but plausible but plausible doesn't mean most likely just that it is a reasonable probability of that outcome and Vegas and about every coach and talking head will agree as indicated by our preseason rankings and odds to win.

If we win it all no one is going to chalk it as any kind of miracle not even a minor one. It will simply be a typical year where one of the best 10 or so teams won.

I think we need a more precise question or for a number of folks to change their votes to reflect the reality of the field.

I feel you are essentially interpreting the question as an "or bust" ( acceptable floor) thing or maybe "what is your expected result" but I'm reading it as more "what do you think the ceiling is for this team" because of the phrasing and the use of "can" versus "will".

I've only expected a championship once and that was 96 (I was young in 78 and was on the edge of my seat hoping, too little to form expectations) and in retrospect I consider even that expectation to be unreasonable despite hindsight and what I consider to be the best team in college basketball history because of the relative quality of the opposition in the field and the one and done format.

It just was not rational to think in a one off a UMass, Syracuse, Mississippi State, or even a Wake Forest to name a few on a hot day just should be expected to lose 1,000/1,000 times or better.

I'd favor 96 in any game but they did and could lose a game against a certain level of team if they had enough balance on a given day not playing our best.
 

Rupp'sRunt

Heisman
Apr 19, 2008
14,675
20,094
0
The question is CAN not WILL.

I think a championship is not just possible but plausible but plausible doesn't mean most likely just that it is a reasonable probability of that outcome and Vegas and about every coach and talking head will agree as indicated by our preseason rankings and odds to win.

If we win it all no one is going to chalk it as any kind of miracle not even a minor one. It will simply be a typical year where one of the best 10 or so teams won.

I think we need a more precise question or for a number of folks to change their votes to reflect the reality of the field.

I feel you are essentially interpreting the question as an "or bust" ( acceptable floor) thing or maybe "what is your expected result" but I'm reading it as more "what do you think the ceiling is for this team" because of the phrasing and the use of "can" versus "will".

I've only expected a championship once and that was 96 (I was young in 78 and was on the edge of my seat hoping, too little to form expectations) and in retrospect I consider even that expectation to be unreasonable despite hindsight and what I consider to be the best team in college basketball history because of the relative quality of the opposition in the field and the one and done format.

It just was not rational to think in a one off a UMass, Syracuse, Mississippi State, or even a Wake Forest to name a few on a hot day just should be expected to lose 1,000/1,000 times or better.

I'd favor 96 in any game but they did and could lose a game against a certain level of team if they had enough balance on a given day not playing our best.
Realistically*
 

Aike

Heisman
Mar 17, 2002
75,464
46,468
90
Yup that's right too. I like how I've been corrected from both angles, haha. I just think this is a S16 team dang it!!

I think that's about what they look like too.

And as I've argued with a bunch of numbskulls over the years, that doesn't mean they can't make the Final Four.

It just means that on average, I expect them to be in that 4/5 seed range. On average, I expect a tough 2nd round and Sweet Sixteen matchup. Which means that ON AVERAGE they probably drop one of those games or the other.

But they could win more games and earn a better seed. Or they could win a few coin flips, like they did in 2011, 2014, etc.

Just, eyeballin'. Right now. Sweet 16 looks about right.
 

Bluegrassking

All-Conference
Jul 18, 2006
4,050
1,913
0
Realistically*

I guess then I have to ask for your definition of realistically then because it seems tighter than the dictionary. Vegas has us the fourth favorite and there isn't a poll that we aren't high top 10 in.

Again, no one in the country is going to declare even a minor miracle if we win the championship.

Is your realistic mean something like most likely? If so compared to what?
 

Tannerdad

Heisman
Mar 30, 2002
55,573
60,371
48
Too young. No upperclass help. Big questions on shooting and big men. Best wings in America though.

Beat up early, come together in Feb/March. Elite 8.

I predict a ton of fan heartache until they get it together.
 

Rupp'sRunt

Heisman
Apr 19, 2008
14,675
20,094
0
I guess then I have to ask for your definition of realistically then because it seems tighter than the dictionary. Vegas has us the fourth favorite and there isn't a poll that we aren't high top 10 in.

Again, no one in the country is going to declare even a minor miracle if we win the championship.

Is your realistic mean something like most likely? If so compared to what?
Up to you man, its an opinion question. If you think UK will win the NC vote that way. I think we have a F4 ceiling and a second round floor
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cowtown Cat

SemperFiCat

Heisman
Mar 2, 2009
14,566
30,005
0
The question is CAN not WILL.

I think a championship is not just possible but plausible but plausible doesn't mean most likely just that it is a reasonable probability of that outcome and Vegas and about every coach and talking head will agree as indicated by our preseason rankings and odds to win.

If we win it all no one is going to chalk it as any kind of miracle not even a minor one. It will simply be a typical year where one of the best 10 or so teams won.

I think we need a more precise question or for a number of folks to change their votes to reflect the reality of the field.

I feel you are essentially interpreting the question as an "or bust" ( acceptable floor) thing or maybe "what is your expected result" but I'm reading it as more "what do you think the ceiling is for this team" because of the phrasing and the use of "can" versus "will".

I've only expected a championship once and that was 96 (I was young in 78 and was on the edge of my seat hoping, too little to form expectations) and in retrospect I consider even that expectation to be unreasonable despite hindsight and what I consider to be the best team in college basketball history because of the relative quality of the opposition in the field and the one and done format.

It just was not rational to think in a one off a UMass, Syracuse, Mississippi State, or even a Wake Forest to name a few on a hot day just should be expected to lose 1,000/1,000 times or better.

I'd favor 96 in any game but they did and could lose a game against a certain level of team if they had enough balance on a given day not playing our best.

The question was "realistic expectation" not "possible potential".
 
  • Like
Reactions: KyFaninNC

KDCats11

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2008
19,806
3,351
113
Can = Championship (too much talent compared to the field to say this isn't plausibly the ceiling).

Expect = Elite 8 (play the season a thousand times and my bet is this is the most likely outcome).

Disappointed = Fail to reach the Sweet 16 (too loaded with too seasoned of an elite coach not to expect to get at least here versus a field that isn't overbearing).

The question is CAN. How is it unreasonable to say a high top 10 ten CAN when the championship?

Are we the favorite? No.
Are we an overdog? No, but not far from it in most eyes as per out ranking.
Are we a plausible contender? Absolutely relative to the current field. There aren't 10 teams that reasonable expect to be be better. There may not be even five. By definition a championship is just possible (I'd loosely define this as a top 8 seed) but plausible (a top 4 seed) or even one of a favorite few (a top 10ish team).
This is the right answer. All of it.
 

KDCats11

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2008
19,806
3,351
113
The question was "realistic expectation" not "possible potential".
The poll literally says, "How far *can* this team go in the NCAAT?" This team *can* absolutely win the title. If there's confusion regarding the post or the answers posted then that it on the OP.
 

School boy

All-Conference
Oct 29, 2007
5,506
3,865
0
The unknowns of this young team, I think we can win it all. But this could be a team where we could lose 7-8 games and lose in the second round as a 4 seed. Can they grow as a team? Can they play fast at this college level? can they defend without fouling? Can they hit the open shots? Will they be a good rebounding team?

No one knows yet, we'll see by Thanksgiving time and that will be the only way of knowing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bluebornwildcat

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
So, 41% of us "realistically expect" a national championship? Seriously??? That's probably the same 41% that freak out and want to fire Cal after any loss. Good grief folks, the best team in the nation only wins that tournament maybe a 1/3 of the time.


What formula did ya use to come up with "1/3rd" of the time ?
 

kentucky_wildcat_#1

All-Conference
Aug 23, 2003
33,780
1,041
0
I keep hearing about Kentucky going into this upcoming season without the type of star level player that when you need a big score late, you give him the ball and he makes good things happen. I don't know why so many Kentucky fans dont see that with Kevin Knox. When it looked like Knox was headed to Duke, many thought this kid would be a future star. I promise you the kid is at the least still as talented as before after signing with Kentucky. The kid is 6'9, has the frame of a NFL linebacker and quickness to play on the wing at Kentucky and if Cal wants to go small, the kid has the frame to guard any college 4. This kid will be one of the best players in college basketball this upcoming season. When Knox decides to drive the lane, many guards are going to pay the price and feel like a tank just hit them. Knox is that NBA lottery type of talent most of you are worried about. If our two true bigs can look the part of being starting big men, this team can make the final four. Kentucky doesnt lack talent. Talent is the best cure to not playing together for long.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WildMoon

Wall2Boogie

Heisman
Jan 28, 2010
26,239
21,732
0
This thread will be Ann interesting read at years end. That said, after the blue/white game somehow there will be 10k votes for national champs because brad will score 30 skj will have a triple double and baker will not miss a shot.
 

Jakarii

All-Conference
Jan 29, 2016
4,640
3,048
0
I think you're confusing Knox with someone else as far as size. He's only 6'9 210-215. Not sure if you have played but that's not really big and he's not muscular. KD is 240, Derek Willis was 228 last year so saying Knox feeling like a tank is incorrect


I keep hearing about Kentucky going into this upcoming season without the type of star level player that when you need a big score late, you give him the ball and he makes good things happen. I don't know why so many Kentucky fans dont see that with Kevin Knox. When it looked like Knox was headed to Duke, many thought this kid would be a future star. I promise you the kid is at the least still as talented as before after signing with Kentucky. The kid is 6'9, has the frame of a NFL linebacker and quickness to play on the wing at Kentucky and if Cal wants to go small, the kid has the frame to guard any college 4. This kid will be one of the best players in college basketball this upcoming season. When Knox decides to drive the lane, many guards are going to pay the price and feel like a tank just hit them. Knox is that NBA lottery type of talent most of you are worried about. If our two true bigs can look the part of being starting big men, this team can make the final four. Kentucky doesnt lack talent. Talent is the best cure to not playing together for long.
 

Jakarii

All-Conference
Jan 29, 2016
4,640
3,048
0
I'll start with E8 before seeing them play. First year I can really say that because Cal has never had such a question mark team as far as college experience. After about 5 games the picture should be much more clear
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aike

JStaff21

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
12,735
58,188
0
Honestly, with the exception of 1 year (and that being because Noel went down) I would always say we have had a shot at a title since Cal came here.

Even when Skal was here, if he had turned it on the last 1/4 of the season and developed into what Cal knew he was capable of, we have an outside shot of making a run.

Realistically it's almost unfair to not at least say the elite 8. We've reached the elite 8 or better in all but 2 years of Cal's time here.
 

SemperFiCat

Heisman
Mar 2, 2009
14,566
30,005
0
What formula did ya use to come up with "1/3rd" of the time ?

Something that ancient humans bestowed upon me. I'd try to explain it, but don't understand it myself. But I'm sure if someone took the time to chart how many times the consensus #1 regular season team actually cuts down the nets, I've heard it's about 33%, or roughly 1/3. The chances of me being wrong are much higher though.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football LIVE BLOG: No. 16 Kentucky at Missouri
  2. 02 KSR Football Listen to KSR's Pregame Show before Kentucky vs. Mizzou
  3. 03 KSR A Brief History of Weird Football Between Kentucky and Missouri
  4. 04 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  5. 05 KSR Football DJ Miller will play homecoming game against Missouri