There have been multiple threads regarding the dichotomy seen in SEC officiating versus NCAAT officiating. As such, I thought it prudent to outline my take on this issue and open it to further discussion in a consolidated thread.
I have been lamenting the inconsistency of league officiating compared to NCAAT officiating for nearly half a decade. Based upon my observation this has been an issue since the other team in state fouled themselves into a national championship in 2013. The following year, due to the blatant disgust by the basketball community, the NCAA proposed a stricter whistle -- the so-called 'freedom of movement' trend.
I am of the belief that this has been a detriment to us (the cayuts). To be clear I don't believe that freedom of movement or a stricter whistle is in itself a detriment to us, but rather the inconsistency in officiating. The primary reason for my belief is that the SEC, and thereby SEC officials, call a tight game, which by my estimation is fairly close to the letter of the law. However, this tight officiating isn't reflected in other conferences nor is it reflected in the NCAAT. It takes very little observatory skills to notice the difference between the officiating in SEC play versus what we have experienced thus far in the NCAAT.
Due to the SEC's strict adherence, our players are conditioned to avoid content on the defensive end and aren't used to as much contact on the offensive end.
Now, consider the effect once we enter tournament play where the refs "let'em play." The opposing team benefits from us not fouling them when we are on defense. Simply stated, the other team enjoys freedom of movement. However, when we are on offense the opposing team, not conditioned to avoid the tic-tac fouls, contact our guys, but are not called for a foul, which should be the case per the letter of the law. As such, we do not get the benefit of 'freedom of movement', which as argued above is allowed to our opponent.
Consistency is the issue here. I don't care if it is a tight whistle or a loose whistle, but consistency must be the goal. Some of the issue lies in the fact that the NCAA allows each conference to regulate its own officials, which accounts for the conference variation. Perhaps, centralizing the regulation of officiating would help.
I know some will argue that there are some SEC officials calling tournament games and that their officiating style is reflected and should even things out. To that point, I would say, that there is a minority of SEC officials and these officials adopt the calling style of the teams with which they are paired.
I want to conclude by saying that officiating must be a really hard job. Officials are human and thus will err like you and I. The issue, to me, isn't individual officials, but rather the inconsistency that exists in a flawed system.
I am very interested to read the comments of other on this matter.
I have been lamenting the inconsistency of league officiating compared to NCAAT officiating for nearly half a decade. Based upon my observation this has been an issue since the other team in state fouled themselves into a national championship in 2013. The following year, due to the blatant disgust by the basketball community, the NCAA proposed a stricter whistle -- the so-called 'freedom of movement' trend.
I am of the belief that this has been a detriment to us (the cayuts). To be clear I don't believe that freedom of movement or a stricter whistle is in itself a detriment to us, but rather the inconsistency in officiating. The primary reason for my belief is that the SEC, and thereby SEC officials, call a tight game, which by my estimation is fairly close to the letter of the law. However, this tight officiating isn't reflected in other conferences nor is it reflected in the NCAAT. It takes very little observatory skills to notice the difference between the officiating in SEC play versus what we have experienced thus far in the NCAAT.
Due to the SEC's strict adherence, our players are conditioned to avoid content on the defensive end and aren't used to as much contact on the offensive end.
Now, consider the effect once we enter tournament play where the refs "let'em play." The opposing team benefits from us not fouling them when we are on defense. Simply stated, the other team enjoys freedom of movement. However, when we are on offense the opposing team, not conditioned to avoid the tic-tac fouls, contact our guys, but are not called for a foul, which should be the case per the letter of the law. As such, we do not get the benefit of 'freedom of movement', which as argued above is allowed to our opponent.
Consistency is the issue here. I don't care if it is a tight whistle or a loose whistle, but consistency must be the goal. Some of the issue lies in the fact that the NCAA allows each conference to regulate its own officials, which accounts for the conference variation. Perhaps, centralizing the regulation of officiating would help.
I know some will argue that there are some SEC officials calling tournament games and that their officiating style is reflected and should even things out. To that point, I would say, that there is a minority of SEC officials and these officials adopt the calling style of the teams with which they are paired.
I want to conclude by saying that officiating must be a really hard job. Officials are human and thus will err like you and I. The issue, to me, isn't individual officials, but rather the inconsistency that exists in a flawed system.
I am very interested to read the comments of other on this matter.