Basketball needs to borrow two rules from soccer.

pascat

Senior
Aug 19, 2003
14,380
652
0
I'm a traditionalist and don't like it when people tinker too much with things. Only when the game could really be improved do I think about how it might get better. Two things from soccer that could help:

(1) Giving yellow cards and possibly red cards for flopping, feigning contact, or otherwise acting like a person with full-scale epilepsy or a wicked case of Tourette's Syndrome when the slightest bit of contact is made. Watching Duke vs. Michigan State tonight reminded me of how much I hate watching the junk basketball at Cameron Indoor Stadium. The Spartans played almost entirely straight up and Duke engaged in their typical theatrics all evening. It is almost unwatchable in its grotesqueness. Duke is plenty good enough to play basketball without that BS.

Football has already gone this route by giving a warning for certain kinds of unsportsmanlike conduct penalties. The problem is that only one player on a huge roster is getting punished. Those calls rarely hurt the team in the long run. But imagine how quickly Grayson Allen's game would clean up if he got carded.

Another option is to simply charge a technical foul for it. I would take this as a start, but a technical and a personal seem to be too light a punishment for this garbage. It simply has to stop. It is ruining the game.

(2) Playing an advantage. Like when a player is fouled on a fast break--just let the player finish the play. If he doesn't score two points, charge a foul to the defender and the offense gets the ball back at the spot. Or let the player score and assess a foul after the play. An advantage could also be useful on those stupid plays when a defender pushes a player out of bounds, but the ref deems that the contact was too light to warrant a foul call. Just give it back to the offense, who is not at fault at all for getting pushed out of bounds. This is not the same as a "force out" which is perfectly legit.
 

hotelblue

Heisman
Jul 6, 2006
41,683
13,121
0
i'm all for a warning for flopping. one that wouldn't encourage again in the same game or near future. that would have an effect yes.
 

Goingfor9

All-Conference
Jan 27, 2003
16,577
3,696
113
I'm a traditionalist and don't like it when people tinker too much with things. Only when the game could really be improved do I think about how it might get better. Two things from soccer that could help:

(1) Giving yellow cards and possibly red cards for flopping, feigning contact, or otherwise acting like a person with full-scale epilepsy or a wicked case of Tourette's Syndrome when the slightest bit of contact is made. Watching Duke vs. Michigan State tonight reminded me of how much I hate watching the junk basketball at Cameron Indoor Stadium. The Spartans played almost entirely straight up and Duke engaged in their typical theatrics all evening. It is almost unwatchable in its grotesqueness. Duke is plenty good enough to play basketball without that BS.

Football has already gone this route by giving a warning for certain kinds of unsportsmanlike conduct penalties. The problem is that only one player on a huge roster is getting punished. Those calls rarely hurt the team in the long run. But imagine how quickly Grayson Allen's game would clean up if he got carded.

Another option is to simply charge a technical foul for it. I would take this as a start, but a technical and a personal seem to be too light a punishment for this garbage. It simply has to stop. It is ruining the game.

(2) Playing an advantage. Like when a player is fouled on a fast break--just let the player finish the play. If he doesn't score two points, charge a foul to the defender and the offense gets the ball back at the spot. Or let the player score and assess a foul after the play. An advantage could also be useful on those stupid plays when a defender pushes a player out of bounds, but the ref deems that the contact was too light to warrant a foul call. Just give it back to the offense, who is not at fault at all for getting pushed out of bounds. This is not the same as a "force out" which is perfectly legit.

There are ethical issues with flopping and if a player isn't even touched and flops he should be given a technical I agree about that. Anything to protect the integrity of the game is something we should all get behind.

As for playing the advantage the foul is part of the game from a tactical standpoint. Soccer is different bc there is no potential to award points based on allowing an advantage expect when the last defender or keeper are involved. In basketball when the foul occurs it must be whistled. Unlike soccer basketball requires clock management bc it can be stopped and started so many times. A foul in soccer does not stop the clock. If you allow for advantage in basketball then you will see a completely different game.
 

NCukcat62

All-Conference
Jul 22, 2007
8,893
3,671
0
No sport needs to borrow anything from the awfulness of soccer. Basketball is fine if the refs just called it correctly and consistently, but they don't. Duke gets a huge bias over anyone, and there is no debating that.
Why is soccer awful? I respect your opinion but college basketball as a whole and baseball is awful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WildMoon

Drcatfan

All-Conference
Apr 14, 2015
1,453
1,714
61
Just institute a warning, then next offense is a technical for flopping (or otherwise faking contact). Like the Louisville player that faked getting hit by an elbow.
 
Jul 11, 2007
2,406
777
0
Why is soccer awful? I respect your opinion but college basketball as a whole and baseball is awful.

So your telling me that soccer is better to watch when a full grown adult falls on the grown like he was shot with a gun after bumping hips with another player? I like soccer but that is the biggest acting show on the planet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: awf

ORCAT

Heisman
Jan 6, 2003
24,801
12,250
113
Why is soccer awful? I respect your opinion but college basketball as a whole and baseball is awful.

I agree with the other poster. I have tried watching soccer, from the urging of friends, and just find it extremely boring. You can go way long periods of time with no scoring at all and little movement by some of the players. I know others have told me that's just great defense and the wonderful strategy of soccer but I am the type who needs more action and results during a game. On the other hand, I don't, as a whole, find college basketball boring at all. People just have different opinions about different games and that's the way I feel. I could care less if I ever see another minute of soccer played in my life, to be honest. But, can't do without my college basketball and get really anxious about the approaching start of each new season. That's just me, can't answer for the other guy you were questioning.
 

Jmeeks54thebest

All-American
Apr 18, 2009
6,867
9,733
0
How dare you suggest we borrow rules from the most popular sport in the world! How dare you sir!

I'm not a soccer fan at all- the game is too slow for me. But given its popularity and log history it is one of the most rule-refined sports today.

I never would have thought that suggesting rules that prevent flopping would be negatively responded to, but people have to maintain their hatred for soccer so it makes sense now.

As far as advantage goes, purposely fouling players is to ingrained into strategy to change that without making a very serious change to the game. If you implemented advantage players would be getting fouled very hard to make sure the ball doesn't go in. Players start getting hurt, liberals cry, then basketball gets further softened than it already is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WildMoon

Nubb16

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
128,718
10,043
67
When I was in like fourth grade one of our friends brought a soccer ball and tried to play it. There was a friend in our group who was very quiet, very rarely said anything negative and was very passive. But that day he wisely spoke up while we tried at some soccer. "Soccer is for foreigners!" He said. And we made our way back to basketball.
 

NCukcat62

All-Conference
Jul 22, 2007
8,893
3,671
0
I agree with the other poster. I have tried watching soccer, from the urging of friends, and just find it extremely boring. You can go way long periods of time with no scoring at all and little movement by some of the players. I know others have told me that's just great defense and the wonderful strategy of soccer but I am the type who needs more action and results during a game. On the other hand, I don't, as a whole, find college basketball boring at all. People just have different opinions about different games and that's the way I feel. I could care less if I ever see another minute of soccer played in my life, to be honest. But, can't do without my college basketball and get really anxious about the approaching start of each new season. That's just me, can't answer for the other guy you were questioning.
That's fair. Just think college basketball is bad as a whole. NBA on the other hand is good stuff. Football on all levels beats everything. College basketball can only dream to be as great as college football. And for soccer it is the most popular sport in the world.
 

Pope John Wall II

All-Conference
May 22, 2010
4,821
2,561
0
That's fair. Just think college basketball is bad as a whole. NBA on the other hand is good stuff. Football on all levels beats everything. College basketball can only dream to be as great as college football. And for soccer it is the most popular sport in the world.
I think football is the worst and most boring of the big four, and I think OP has at least something with his second point.

Although, the NBA sort of has that with continuation, it is an idea that deserves some discussion.
 

OldRed

All-Conference
Jun 7, 2001
18,119
4,730
113
I like the idea of calling a technical for flopping. I don't think they need a warning. With replay, the flop can be identified and should result in a technical. Play basketball. The flop was adopted from soccer by the players and coaches like coach K. A player that writhes in agony but then realizes he isn't going to get the call and jumps up and gets back in the action sickens me.
 

docholiday51

Heisman
Oct 19, 2001
22,011
26,718
0
I like the idea of calling a technical for flopping. I don't think they need a warning. With replay, the flop can be identified and should result in a technical. Play basketball. The flop was adopted from soccer by the players and coaches like coach K. A player that writhes in agony but then realizes he isn't going to get the call and jumps up and gets back in the action sickens me.
Agree in principle,but but when you put that into practice you have Tony Greene,Doug Shows and Doug Sirmons making yet another judgement call and we know enough about their judgement as it currently stands
 
  • Like
Reactions: JoeBeeHall

mustnotsleepnow

All-Conference
May 18, 2011
1,923
1,328
57
Once again, just do away with the charge unless the driver extends his arm and shoves the defender down.

Simple as that.
 

d2atTech

All-Conference
Apr 15, 2009
3,477
2,578
0
i'm all for a warning for flopping. one that wouldn't encourage again in the same game or near future. that would have an effect yes.

i'm okay with a technical foul for flopping. it's absurd that duke does that kinda crap all the time.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,934
63,121
113
I'll tell you what I DON'T want from Soccer.. ads on jerseys. I know, it's inevitable.. but Soccer jerseys are about the ugliest thing I've seen.
 

GonzoCat90

Heisman
Mar 30, 2009
32,377
34,559
0
Agree completely on the flopping.

I like the idea of advantage in theory, but in practice there are too many logistical issues. It would fundamentally change the way the game is played, and I think that's too far. I think the NBA has it right with the clear path foul and the continuation. That's playing the advantage enough for basketball, although it does work perfectly in soccer.

Good thread though. Interesting discussion.

I also think they should steal soccer's penalty shot rule. One guy in the middle of the lane, not allowed to cross a certain line, and then after the miss it's all fair game until the defense gains possession and you play from there.
 

BlueRunner11

Heisman
Mar 26, 2011
11,563
35,627
0
I'm not in favor of anything that's going to complicate the game for these college officials or add more video reviews to the game and both of these actions would.

What I would suggest is if a player is determined to have flopped after the game is reviewed by the league of officials, suspend the player for the next game or a portion of the next game depending on the severity. Yes it's harsh, but it's the only way to clean this ish up.
 

CalsKittens

Senior
Nov 27, 2012
1,012
763
0
I'm not in favor of anything that's going to complicate the game for these college officials or add more video reviews to the game and both of these actions would.

What I would suggest is if a player is determined to have flopped after the game is reviewed by the league of officials, suspend the player for the next game or a portion of the next game depending on the severity. Yes it's harsh, but it's the only way to clean this ish up.
Well why don't we just take the offending flopper back behind the gym and shoot them. I gurantee no one would flop again. JK
 

pascat

Senior
Aug 19, 2003
14,380
652
0
Yes, the more I think about it, the less and less I'd like college basketball officials to be making judgment calls. Still, they are doing this already in so many areas I thought "why not give them the option of calling at least a technical foul on a flop?"

I also agree on the advantage call on a fast break being too much of a strategic change. Still, I'd like to reserve the option for refs to call an advantage on a "push out of bounds."
 
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,610
113
The penalty for red card would have to be less severe. I mean we can't have one dude flop, get a red card and the team be forced to play 5 on 4 the rest of the game like soccer lol
 

UKhoopCat

All-Conference
Feb 19, 2003
3,180
3,937
0
If the game is interrupted with the officials looking at the screen for 5 minutes, checking to see if someone (Duke) caught an elbow in the face (Louisville) and the video showed there wasn't contact..only theatrics. It SHOULD be a technical foul. No warning! That would stop the ********.
 

WildMoon

Heisman
Apr 7, 2009
78,693
11,120
0
idea that you bash an idea because it's from soccer is borderline ignorant.

anyways...i think this should happen. I do believe for fast breaks in NBA, if player is in front and other team fouls them...its a technical.

I never understood why fouling sometimes reward the fouler. Foul should never reward the fouler.

just my thought...
 
  • Like
Reactions: hotelblue

KyCatFan1

Heisman
May 6, 2002
30,867
31,594
113
How about hockey subbing while we're at it? Screw a dead ball to sub in. Just sub in the backcourt anytime you have the ball.
 

pikespeak1

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2008
1,460
1,144
113
How dare you suggest we borrow rules from the most popular sport in the world! How dare you sir!

I'm not a soccer fan at all- the game is too slow for me. But given its popularity and log history it is one of the most rule-refined sports today.

I never would have thought that suggesting rules that prevent flopping would be negatively responded to, but people have to maintain their hatred for soccer so it makes sense now.

As far as advantage goes, purposely fouling players is to ingrained into strategy to change that without making a very serious change to the game. If you implemented advantage players would be getting fouled very hard to make sure the ball doesn't go in. Players start getting hurt, liberals cry, then basketball gets further softened than it already is.
Popularity doesn't equal quality. Don't believe me? Try to make it through a Creed song, I dare ya.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nubb16

Cats_2010

Heisman
Jan 8, 2010
12,176
21,127
103
I'm a traditionalist and don't like it when people tinker too much with things. Only when the game could really be improved do I think about how it might get better. Two things from soccer that could help:

(1) Giving yellow cards and possibly red cards for flopping, feigning contact, or otherwise acting like a person with full-scale epilepsy or a wicked case of Tourette's Syndrome when the slightest bit of contact is made. Watching Duke vs. Michigan State tonight reminded me of how much I hate watching the junk basketball at Cameron Indoor Stadium. The Spartans played almost entirely straight up and Duke engaged in their typical theatrics all evening. It is almost unwatchable in its grotesqueness. Duke is plenty good enough to play basketball without that BS.

Football has already gone this route by giving a warning for certain kinds of unsportsmanlike conduct penalties. The problem is that only one player on a huge roster is getting punished. Those calls rarely hurt the team in the long run. But imagine how quickly Grayson Allen's game would clean up if he got carded.

Another option is to simply charge a technical foul for it. I would take this as a start, but a technical and a personal seem to be too light a punishment for this garbage. It simply has to stop. It is ruining the game.

(2) Playing an advantage. Like when a player is fouled on a fast break--just let the player finish the play. If he doesn't score two points, charge a foul to the defender and the offense gets the ball back at the spot. Or let the player score and assess a foul after the play. An advantage could also be useful on those stupid plays when a defender pushes a player out of bounds, but the ref deems that the contact was too light to warrant a foul call. Just give it back to the offense, who is not at fault at all for getting pushed out of bounds. This is not the same as a "force out" which is perfectly legit.

No need to hand out colored cards but a flagrant 1 would do the trick. 2nd offense in the same game becomes a flagrant 2. The problem now is there is no consequences for flopping. If any type of consequence was mixed into the equation then you would most certainly see it come to a complete halt.

There is a big difference in selling a charge vs a flop so officials should not have that much difficulty correctly enforcing this and could even make it reviewable in iffy situations.
 

RACdad

Heisman
Mar 8, 2005
10,355
10,466
113
I'd rather watch paint dry than anything associated with soccer
 

JohnBlue

Heisman
Jul 22, 2003
188,376
14,335
0
Not sure how it's going to work if you're expecting the same people that are allowing a player a flop and awarding him a foul to suddenly do a 180 and start handing out warnings. I'd prefer they just make the right call in the first place.
 

CalsKittens

Senior
Nov 27, 2012
1,012
763
0
Not sure how it's going to work if you're expecting the same people that are allowing a player a flop and awarding him a foul to suddenly do a 180 and start handing out warnings. I'd prefer they just make the right call in the first place.
Yeah this leads into referee accountability and the lack thereof. The NCAA has allowed bias into the game and I don't think they know how or even care to fix it.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Podcasts 11 Personnel: Kentucky's Late Season Push Before the Roster Build
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Defensive discipline will be a key to success for Kentucky vs. physical Indiana
  3. 03 KSR Basketball WATCH: Mark Pope previews Kentucky vs. Indiana
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Kentucky prepares for first unique road test against Indiana at Lucas Oil Stadium
  5. 05 KSR Football Kentucky cranks up energy, leans into competition at practice after consecutive losses