Malik Newman to Kansas

Son_Of_Saul

Hall of Famer
Dec 7, 2007
46,007
102,440
113
Why did Cal covet him so much then the first time around?

Because at closing time, all the women look good, even the whores.

Continuing the analogy, Self is basically taking the midnight ***** knowing that she's carrying various STDs.

I stand guilty, having wanted Newman at that point. I'm not sure what to expect from him now in terms of his actual ability. What is a known variable, however, is the fact that he expects to dominate the ball. I'm not sure you Jayhawk fans are understanding fully what back-to-back years of Jackson's mom and Newman's dad is potentially going to do to your program.
 
Last edited:

Son_Of_Saul

Hall of Famer
Dec 7, 2007
46,007
102,440
113
In his one year at Kentucky, Booker averaged 10 ppg and shot 41% from 3 and 47% from the field. Solid college production. He is now gone and never played another game at Kentucky.

Last year Graham averaged 11.1 ppg and shot 44% from three and 46% from the field and will continue to improve and play for KU.

Booker is clearly more talented, but Kentucky never got to reap the rewards of it. KU will reap the rewards of Graham's talent.

You mean rewards like Final Fours? UK went to one of those with Booker. Meanwhile, your program is batting 1 for 7 in actually getting to Final Fours since UK hired Cal.
 

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
You mean rewards like Final Fours? UK went to one of those with Booker. Meanwhile, your program is batting 1 for 7 in actually getting to Final Fours since UK hired Cal.

Wait, I thought Booker was a bench player? And why do you cite the beginning of Kentucky basketball accomplishments with the date Cal became Kentucky's head coach? Kentucky has a storied and accomplished history pre-Cal. I would think the coach is not above the program is it?

This argument is dumb. Newman is going to be a very solid college player and I'm sure Self is not done recruiting for the 2017 class. Young, Sexton, Brown or others would be nice additions to replace Svi, Jackson and Mason on the perimeter. Newman will have to compete, but something tells me a redshirt sophomore is going to have a step up on an incoming recruit, regardless of high school rating.
 

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
Because at closing time, all the women look good, even the whores.

Continuing the analogy, Self is basically taking the midnight ***** knowing that she's carrying various STDs.

I stand guilty, having wanted Newman at that point. I'm not sure what to expect from him now in terms of his actual ability. What is a known variable, however, is the fact that he expects to dominate the ball. I'm not sure you Jayhawk fans are understanding fully what back-to-back years of Jackson's mom and Newman's dad is potentially going to do to your program.

KU isn't some mid-major where a kid's parents can impact a program. And where is it that Jackson or Newman's parents are overbearing? Because Jackson was not interested in playing for Kentucky? Newman will have to run the offense or sit on the bench, same as if he were playing for Cal.

You have an irrational hatred for KU and Self. Why is that?
 

Bungalow Bill

All-Conference
Apr 8, 2007
2,066
3,944
113
Didn't he commit before Cal went after Murray? Also, it was a down year, but in retrospect, I wouldn't call it terrible. Most of the top 30 had pretty good freshman seasons. Was it a down year in respect to one and done talent? Maybe. I think the number of kids now a days who think they are one and done is inflated anyways in every year.
If you want to see what a down year it was just look at the 16 draft and all of the head scratching 1st round picks. The freshmen just weren't nearly as good as they will be this coming season or seasons before.
 

CarolinaCatsFan

All-Conference
Sep 14, 2015
1,290
2,086
0
Wait, I thought Booker was a bench player? And why do you cite the beginning of Kentucky basketball accomplishments with the date Cal became Kentucky's head coach? Kentucky has a storied and accomplished history pre-Cal. I would think the coach is not above the program is it?

This argument is dumb. Newman is going to be a very solid college player and I'm sure Self is not done recruiting for the 2017 class. Young, Sexton, Brown or others would be nice additions to replace Svi, Jackson and Mason on the perimeter. Newman will have to compete, but something tells me a redshirt sophomore is going to have a step up on an incoming recruit, regardless of high school rating.

You know Newman may never play a minute for you guys, right?
 

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
If you want to see what a down year it was just look at the 16 draft and all of the head scratching 1st round picks. The freshmen just weren't nearly as good as they will be this coming season or seasons before.

Isn't the guard position one of the hardest to make a one and done jump? Weren't D'angelo Russell, Jones, Mudiay (who didn't play in college), Vaughn and Booker the only one and done's in the first round in 2015?
You know Newman may never play a minute for you guys, right?

Yeah, he likely will. Explain how he's going to improve his draft stock without playing in games and if he does jump, he will have helped this year's team in practice. Like I said, Self is not done recruiting the 2017 class.
 

KneeBurns

Senior
Mar 18, 2006
2,052
516
0
Because at closing time, all the women look good, even the whores.

Continuing the analogy, Self is basically taking the midnight ***** knowing that she's carrying various STDs.

http://www.kuathletics.com/news/201...-single-year-apr-scores-to-tie-ku-record.aspx


I stand guilty, having wanted Newman at that point. I'm not sure what to expect from him now in terms of his actual ability. What is a known variable, however, is the fact that he expects to dominate the ball. I'm not sure you Jayhawk fans are understanding fully what back-to-back years of Jackson's mom and Newman's dad is potentially going to do to your program.

#8 recruit, offers from everyone, transferring to Kansas. Sounds like a crappy basketball player.
 

KneeBurns

Senior
Mar 18, 2006
2,052
516
0
You mean rewards like Final Fours? UK went to one of those with Booker. Meanwhile, your program is batting 1 for 7 in actually getting to Final Fours since UK hired Cal.

That was sneaky! Conveniently cut-off the time frame so as not to include KU's 2008 Natty. Impressive. You almost fooled everyone here.
 

.S&C.

All-American
Jul 8, 2014
45,292
6,422
0
In his one year at Kentucky, Booker averaged 10 ppg and shot 41% from 3 and 47% from the field. Solid college production. He is now gone and never played another game at Kentucky.

Last year Graham averaged 11.1 ppg and shot 44% from three and 46% from the field and will continue to improve and play for KU.

Booker is clearly more talented, but Kentucky never got to reap the rewards of it. KU will reap the rewards of Graham's talent.




Devin Booker helped lead UK to a final four and championship game, 1 loss season, but you get to reap the rewards of those 4 year Kansas players that haven't advanced past the elite eight in (going on) 5 years.

We obviously view the phrase "reaping rewards" differently.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

cardsfan53

Junior
Apr 15, 2005
5,659
225
0
Isn't the guard position one of the hardest to make a one and done jump? Weren't D'angelo Russell, Jones, Mudiay (who didn't play in college), Vaughn and Booker the only one and done's in the first round in 2015?


Each of those guys were 1st round picks and 3 of them were on the all rookie team. 8 of the 10 players were 1 and done, the other 2 were overseas players. The 14 class was light years ahead of this past class.
 

DwayneMeighan

Heisman
Oct 15, 2012
5,102
12,654
0
Booker is clearly more talented, but Kentucky never got to reap the rewards of it. KU will reap the rewards of Graham's talent.
So another early exit flame out is considered "reaping the rewards" for KU, but a historical 38-1 season, with a trip to their fourth Final 4 in five years isn't considered "reaping the rewards" for UK?

Not to mention, Booker was a 4 star SG who didn't even start, played barely 20 minutes/game, sacrificed his game for his coach and teammates, yet still was drafted in the lottery, and proved this season that he was more than prepared for the NBA by his time at UK despite all of that .

Also, not sure if you realize this or not, but Booker is the poster child for what Cal preaches on the recruiting trail, and he just gives Cal one more bullet to add to his gun in future recruitments. UK reaped plenty from Booker, and will continue to do so in the future.
 

cardsfan53

Junior
Apr 15, 2005
5,659
225
0
Graham will have a chance to win a national title at Kansas. who would trade millions of dollars for a college championship?
 

gracetoyou

Heisman
Apr 19, 2009
20,713
30,240
113
Those saying Malik wasn't a top 10 prospect & asking why Cal was ever interested are hilariously strange.

Newman was unreal for Team USA his junior year. A slight decline began his Sr. season but he was definitely a top 10 prospect in that weak class.

Going to MSU was one of the dumbest decisions ever. Howland is washed up & terrible!
 
  • Like
Reactions: WP60

4UK

All-Conference
Sep 26, 2005
30,388
4,433
0
Agree to disagree. Other than Booker, Ulis and Allen, I think the classes are similar. I don't care about NBA potential, I care about college potential.

This makes sense. It's the type of argument a fan makes when they've been forced to convince themselves that conference championships are somehow better than NCAA tournament success.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

catdance

All-Conference
Feb 21, 2016
1,355
1,693
0
Well, Kansas is ranked 115th in US News and Kentucky is ranked 129th so I doubt "physics scholarships" are available at either of these schools.
Kansas fans, all wrapped up in rankings until reality smacks them in the face in March.
 

Son_Of_Saul

Hall of Famer
Dec 7, 2007
46,007
102,440
113
KU isn't some mid-major where a kid's parents can impact a program. And where is it that Jackson or Newman's parents are overbearing? Because Jackson was not interested in playing for Kentucky? Newman will have to run the offense or sit on the bench, same as if he were playing for Cal.

You have an irrational hatred for KU and Self. Why is that?

I hate Kansas because your assistant coaches continue to try to trash Kentucky on the recruiting trail. Self doesn't directly engage in the activities, but he allows his assistants to do so. It's call plausible deniability, and Self is the king at having others do his dirty work for him while he continues his "ah shucks" Bible salesman routine.

I want your program to fail. Me being dishonestly nice about your program won't make you hate UK any less than you already do. It's what fans do. It's tribalism at its absolute freaking best. I want your program to bleed to death, and I'm not going to hide it.
 

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
I hate Kansas because your assistant coaches continue to try to trash Kentucky on the recruiting trail. Self doesn't directly engage in the activities, but he allows his assistants to do so. It's call plausible deniability, and Self is the king at having others do his dirty work for him while he continues his "ah shucks" Bible salesman routine.

I want your program to fail. Me being dishonestly nice about your program won't make you hate UK any less than you already do. It's what fans do. It's tribalism at its absolute freaking best. I want your program to bleed to death, and I'm not going to hide it.

I don't hate Kentucky.
 

Son_Of_Saul

Hall of Famer
Dec 7, 2007
46,007
102,440
113
I don't hate Kentucky.

No?

So you weren't jumping for joy like this with your Kansas fans when UK fell to Wisconsin in '15?

Doubt it.

 

JayCatz44

Heisman
May 14, 2003
20,699
15,896
113
Wait, I thought Booker was a bench player? And why do you cite the beginning of Kentucky basketball accomplishments with the date Cal became Kentucky's head coach? Kentucky has a storied and accomplished history pre-Cal. I would think the coach is not above the program is it?

This argument is dumb. Newman is going to be a very solid college player and I'm sure Self is not done recruiting for the 2017 class. Young, Sexton, Brown or others would be nice additions to replace Svi, Jackson and Mason on the perimeter. Newman will have to compete, but something tells me a redshirt sophomore is going to have a step up on an incoming recruit, regardless of high school rating.
Bench player or not, Booker helped UK get back to another Final Four. Until Graham does that for Kansas, then it's Booker>Graham.
 
Dec 12, 2007
68,157
14,860
0
Devin Booker helped lead UK to a final four and championship game, 1 loss season, but you get to reap the rewards of those 4 year Kansas players that haven't advanced past the elite eight in (going on) 5 years.

We obviously view the phrase "reaping rewards" differently.

It's because KU fans have deluded themselves into thinking their reward is winning the most overrated conference in the history of sports year after year. They are working on a way to parlay 10 conference banners into a Helmsian title banner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: .S&C. and brianpoe

UKCAT5FAN

All-Conference
May 9, 2010
5,285
3,822
113
Wait, I thought Booker was a bench player? And why do you cite the beginning of Kentucky basketball accomplishments with the date Cal became Kentucky's head coach? Kentucky has a storied and accomplished history pre-Cal. I would think the coach is not above the program is it?

This argument is dumb. Newman is going to be a very solid college player and I'm sure Self is not done recruiting for the 2017 class. Young, Sexton, Brown or others would be nice additions to replace Svi, Jackson and Mason on the perimeter. Newman will have to compete, but something tells me a redshirt sophomore is going to have a step up on an incoming recruit, regardless of high school rating.


I actually have to agree with you here. I think it's a solid pick up for KU. Newman is very talented and a year off to get better could really help him. Something was off with him and MSU last year, I think that's obvious but I think KU is a good choice for Newman. I personally wish he would've went to WKU just so KU didn't get him but I think it's good for Malik. He needs some structure and I'd expect Self to be good for him. Like I said, he is very talented and could be a very special player for them in 2017.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KnowsAllTellsAll

UKCAT5FAN

All-Conference
May 9, 2010
5,285
3,822
113
Newman was the best available guard in the class. Cal wanted him because there was no one else. He also wanted him as a wing scorer, not a PG. Newman wanted to be the PG. We had Ulis and Briscoe as better options at PG. Newman did not want to accept being a wing scorer, so he went to MSU, where Howland promised him a shot at the PG spot.

Then we lucked out and Murray became available and was willing to accept the role as wing scorer for us. Newman is now a transfer sitting out next season. Murray is a lottery pick that is going to make a few million this next season while Newman enjoys the college life.

Just another episode of Cal knows best.



We were recruiting Newman for a long time. I don't think it was because he was the only one left. Wasnt he one of the first to receive an offer in that class? Could be mistaken but I thought he was one of the first. I believe that the Newman recruitment came down to 1 thing and 1 thing only, he wanted to be the man and take 50 shots a game. That obviously wasn't going to happen here and he just wanted the spot light on himself. Either he did or his dad did. I think that was the main factor in his recruitment.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Braydon Hawthorne's offensive game is only beginning to reveal itself
  2. 02 KSR Football Kentucky vs. Missouri is Officially the "Who Wants It More?" Bowl
  3. 03 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  4. 04 KSR Basketball It's not all bad: Five things Kentucky has done well this season
  5. 05 KSR Basketball Recruiting 5-star C Cherif Millogo signs with Kentucky