Prognostication on when the NCAA will lay down the hammer....

HICATFAN

All-American
Aug 15, 2001
9,189
8,488
113
.....on UNCheats and/or ULosers?.......

.....and do you think the hammer will be a velvet hammer for either or both?......

AlohaCat
 
Dec 12, 2007
68,157
14,860
0
 
Nov 27, 2009
21,246
21,450
0
Best case scenario.....
They both get hammered hard (Loss of banners/games/scholarships) and used as examples to the other member institutions about the dangers of institutionalized academic fraud (UNCheat) and not having a freaking clue what minors are doing on your campus while they make recruiting visits (L1C4nication).

Worst case scenario....
Nothing happens to UNCheat because the NCAA allows them to use the carefully crafted excuse that "non-athletes" were allowed into those fake classes. Therefore.....nothing they did falls under NCAA guidelines. A public warning is made by Emmert that..."The NCAA by-laws have now been changed so the next time this happens anywhere (besides UNCheat and Duke)...watch out!"
UofL's self imposed sanctions are deemed appropriate and Slick Rick celebrates with a Party in Minardi.
 

TBCat

Heisman
Mar 30, 2007
14,317
10,332
0
I think UL is actually in big trouble. Bigger than they would ever guess. UL will get the book thrown at them. They might even have to vacate a title. Even if not they will still get at least one more year of post season ban and probably lose some scholarships over the next couple years.

UNC on the other hand will get almost nothing. The problem here is that there is no strategic way to punish them. If the NCAA finds that there has been decades worth of academic fraud then even a 2 year ban would seem like a joke. If the NCAA formally finds that UNC spent decades playing with players who knowingly committed academic fraud with the assistance of the school itself the NCAA would lose all credibility if they do not vacate wins and titles. This would disrupt the legacy of Dean Smith which the NCAA would never allow. I really don't see how even a 2 year ban would be enough. What UNC did is every bit as corrupt as SMU football back in the 80's. Keep in mind this isn't just playing academically ineligible or having tutors write papers for some athletes. This is the university itself creating an infrastructure to commit academic fraud. You can't even blame this on a single coach the way UK football did with Bassett. This went on for decades and with 3 different coaching staffs.
 

Lumpy 2

All-Conference
Jan 16, 2011
1,944
1,106
0
If they do anything at all, it will be after the fall semester starts at UNC when it will be too late for players to transfer.
 

Real Deal 2

Heisman
Jan 25, 2007
11,483
14,076
113
I think they both get hit hard. I think UL gets hit harder due to perception not severity. In my mind UNC is the worst case in the history of the NCAA, fake classes, instructors, coaches are all complicit in the cover up. At least 4 different coaches, 3 NC teams. I think games and NC's should be taken away.

UNC is the worst but UL will get hit harder, President is going to be gone, RP is going to be gone
You don't self impose a ban unless there is serious shish. I have heard they have corroborated all book and have found a lot of other that knew. I think RP will vehemently deny he had knowledge and he may not have known exact deal but NCAA is going to punish him for not knowing. They are waiting for him to lie and call his hand.

It is easier to punish someone because of morality such as hookers because most public opinion is obvious that this is wrong. Coaches paying etc.. Very bad but not near as bad as UNC being blatant cheaters for 25 years.
IMO
 
  • Like
Reactions: dynastydreamuk

TBCat

Heisman
Mar 30, 2007
14,317
10,332
0
I doubt the NCAA will get into the weeds of sorting out which games to vacate, etc. I doubt they vacate wins or take down banners. But there is a simple, efficient way to punish them: Just say there was no institutional control in the entire athletic department that allowed the fraud to continue, and put the entire department on probation with a 2-3 year post-season ban. That's what I expect to happen.
I don't see how they can justify that. This isn't lack of institutional control. Lack of institutional control is a failure of the university to have proper controls in place. What UNC did goes way beyond that. The school actually set up a program to cheat. It's not a lack of monitoring such as what UK football did with Bassett. This is similar to SMU in football where the school president actually sat in on meetings to pay players. I have no doubt the NCAA would like to give UNC a slap on the wrist but it won't be easy to dumb down the violation to meet the punishment you would like to give them. I believe it's far more likely that the NCAA will find a way to cop out. Several UNC defenders have already floated the line the NCAA has standards for passing entrance exams but don't have standards on degree programs at various schools. In other words UNC didn't cheat they just have a crappy degree. I have a feeling the NCAA will try to settle on something like that which would leave UNC with no punishment.
 

Real Deal 2

Heisman
Jan 25, 2007
11,483
14,076
113
Both schools will asked to cut ties from past which means victories and banners or punishment going forward will be severe. This is why most feel like RP is an almost sure bet of being gone. RP stays than those seasons and titles are revoked. UNC will be somewhat like this, they will have to punish someone. Difference is the UL was all on RP's watch and I think there are major validation in coaches being complicit in paying the hookers and organizing these events.
IMO
 

sluggercatfan

Heisman
Aug 17, 2004
35,953
29,631
0
.....on UNCheats and/or ULosers?.......

.....and do you think the hammer will be a velvet hammer for either or both?......

AlohaCat
Both will be very light with Otis coming out on the short end of the stick, but with nothing drastic...as for uncheat they will skate free..you cannot mess with one of the chosen ones.
 

uky8unc5

Heisman
May 22, 2002
17,436
12,953
113
The media will praise the ncaa when uncheat skates..espn darling!!
You may be correct, but the days leading up to Final Four, big boys like Sports Illustrated and the NY Times were firing bullets. And CBS didn't seem to shy from the subject.

I hope I am correct (and I know, so do you).
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: sluggercatfan

akaukswoosh

Hall of Famer
Jan 14, 2006
82,898
127,546
93
Honest Roy Williams is telling anybody who will listen that there will be no MBB sanctions. Apparently Ferguson believes him


Paul BiancardiVerified account ‏@PaulBiancardi Apr 8
Recruiting update: Terrance Ferguson tells Espn that
#UNC HC Roy Williams has offered him a scholarship & he plans to visit next week.
 

mebeblue2

Heisman
Dec 20, 2009
98,152
10,574
0
i think they both get hammered
they both deserve to get hammered
i don't think the NCAA is going to have a choice
let Emmert try to explain to congress why both got a slap on the wrist
the NCAA has to prove they are more than just a money making machine
 

CatEye2010

All-American
Jan 5, 2010
6,225
6,820
73
You are falling into the trap UNC-Cheats wants everyone to fall into -- you are confusing pathetically EASY classes with FAKE classes. But Wainstein and the NCAA findings were both clear on that. The classes weren't just easy, they were fraudulent. McCants of course is exhibit one. Taking fake classes is not permissible, however shoddy your university and its controls. It amounts to keeping athletes eligible improperly.

Additionally, there's the findings of SACS, the accrediting body, that found fraudulent/fake courses over years at unc** that led to them placing unc** on probation (the second worst punishment they can give, short of removing accreditation entirely, a death blow to a school). If the NCAA chooses, they can cite that significant punishment as proof of fake classes/ineligible MBB players and use that to drop the hammer.

There's an atmosphere of embarrassment among the academics/faculty that their school has been placed on probation by SACS.
 

sluggercatfan

Heisman
Aug 17, 2004
35,953
29,631
0
If they dont vacate hundreds of UNC wins....

Not only is the NCAA useless in enforcement...

It gives every other school a blueprint how to duplicate how UNC cheated and get away with it.

If that is how its going to be
The problem with this statement is that uncheat, Puke, and touchdown Jesus are untouchable and by whatever means necessary the crooks at the top will coverup for them.
 

TBCat

Heisman
Mar 30, 2007
14,317
10,332
0
You are falling into the trap UNC-Cheats wants everyone to fall into -- you are confusing pathetically EASY classes with FAKE classes. But Wainstein and the NCAA findings were both clear on that. The classes weren't just easy, they were fraudulent. McCants of course is exhibit one. Taking fake classes is not permissible, however shoddy your university and its controls. It amounts to keeping athletes eligible improperly.
Oh I'm not falling for it. I just believe the UNC will try to get the NCAA to go with that. What UNC did is in my opinion at least as severe as SMU. Far worse than UK basketball under Sutton or football under Mumme. Both of which the NCAA claimed to have considered the death penalty for.
 

JimmyJimmy

All-Conference
Apr 26, 2005
2,110
1,038
0
I think they both get hit hard. I think UL gets hit harder due to perception not severity. In my mind UNC is the worst case in the history of the NCAA, fake classes, instructors, coaches are all complicit in the cover up. At least 4 different coaches, 3 NC teams. I think games and NC's should be taken away.

UNC is the worst but UL will get hit harder, President is going to be gone, RP is going to be gone
You don't self impose a ban unless there is serious shish. I have heard they have corroborated all book and have found a lot of other that knew. I think RP will vehemently deny he had knowledge and he may not have known exact deal but NCAA is going to punish him for not knowing. They are waiting for him to lie and call his hand.

It is easier to punish someone because of morality such as hookers because most public opinion is obvious that this is wrong. Coaches paying etc.. Very bad but not near as bad as UNC being blatant cheaters for 25 years.
IMO
Plus there is still the possibility of criminal charges against people associated with Looserville over the allegations.
 

tarheelguy124

Redshirt
Jan 3, 2007
126
24
0
Well it definitely doesn't hurt UK that that your coach had 2 final 4s taken away, so that is encouraging. The recruits line up to play here. He is better than krat.
 

TNCatfanforever

Heisman
Apr 3, 2003
22,083
13,961
62
Well it definitely doesn't hurt UK that that your coach had 2 final 4s taken away, so that is encouraging. The recruits line up to play here. He is better than krat.
I shouldn't respond.....our coach has never been accused or found guilty of one single violation....I am surprised you can even write given the fact you never went to school.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Guess Who

tarheelguy124

Redshirt
Jan 3, 2007
126
24
0
College sports is insane, most athletes have 2/3s the SAT score of the regular students and the regular students flunk out all the time. Plus athletes play almost a professional schedule. None of them ever flunk out. Alabama's football roster is like an NFL team, grades are never a problem, injuries are all they worry about. and they stay 3 or 4 years. At least a lot of UK's basketball players just stay 1 year. What does Duke and Stanford do to keep their athletes eligible It is all beyond belief.
 

MdWIldcat55

Heisman
Dec 9, 2007
21,731
87,967
113
College sports is insane, most athletes have 2/3s the SAT score of the regular students and the regular students flunk out all the time. Plus athletes play almost a professional schedule. None of them ever flunk out. Alabama's football roster is like an NFL team, grades are never a problem, injuries are all they worry about. and they stay 3 or 4 years. At least a lot of UK's basketball players just stay 1 year. What does Duke and Stanford do to keep their athletes eligible
Your deflection is transparent and nonsensical. NO OTHER UNIVERSITY set up an entire fake department and gave players fake grades for decades. UNC is the worst cheaters in the history of collegiate sports. It's a disgrace to have the entire university put on probation by the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools Commission because of the activities of the athletic department. At the point that happened, any honorable university would have self-punished severely.
 

Lumpy 2

All-Conference
Jan 16, 2011
1,944
1,106
0
College sports is insane, most athletes have 2/3s the SAT score of the regular students and the regular students flunk out all the time. Plus athletes play almost a professional schedule. None of them ever flunk out. Alabama's football roster is like an NFL team, grades are never a problem, injuries are all they worry about. and they stay 3 or 4 years. At least a lot of UK's basketball players just stay 1 year. What does Duke and Stanford do to keep their athletes eligible It is all beyond belief.
Maybe they send their players to Durham to get diagnosed with learning disabilities.
 

tarheelguy124

Redshirt
Jan 3, 2007
126
24
0
Only a fool
Your deflection is transparent and nonsensical. NO OTHER UNIVERSITY set up an entire fake department and gave players fake grades for decades. UNC is the worst cheaters in the history of collegiate sports. It's a disgrace to have the entire university put on probation by the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools Commission because of the activities of the athletic department. At the point that happened, any honorable university would have self-punished severely.
I love college sports, I just think the NCAA needs to be more honest about what is going on. It would take a person with a perfect SAT score to do what college athletes have to try to do.
 

uky8unc5

Heisman
May 22, 2002
17,436
12,953
113
College sports is insane, most athletes have 2/3s the SAT score of the regular students and the regular students flunk out all the time. Plus athletes play almost a professional schedule. None of them ever flunk out. Alabama's football roster is like an NFL team, grades are never a problem, injuries are all they worry about. and they stay 3 or 4 years. At least a lot of UK's basketball players just stay 1 year. What does Duke and Stanford do to keep their athletes eligible It is all beyond belief.
Take care of your own house. Off the top of my head:
Didn't Kansas go on 3 years probation after Roy left? As I recall, boosters were giving "gifts" to players after they graduated...and Ole Roy was fully aware of that. That wasn't the only thing going on, but don't try to tell me Roy is squeaky clean.
 
Last edited:

mebeblue2

Heisman
Dec 20, 2009
98,152
10,574
0
Only a fool

I love college sports, I just think the NCAA needs to be more honest about what is going on. It would take a person with a perfect SAT score to do what college athletes have to try to do.

since you love CBB, then we are to assume that you believe that UNC should get absolutely hammered by the NCAA for systematic academic fraud that went on for two decades
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lumpy 2

tarheelguy124

Redshirt
Jan 3, 2007
126
24
0
OK i'll bite,
Everything you say is a variation on "everybody does it." That's just living in denial, which seems to be the common attitude of the UNC-Cheats fanbase. The fact is NO ONE else ever set up the systematic cheating scheme and sustained it for nearly two decades to keep players eligible. You are all alone.
Don't you think athletes in every college look for easy classes? Hell I know regular students do. No one has ever said the coaching staff directed anyone to take certain classes. Does UK not have some easy classes in some departments? Does coach Cal check out all the courses before he allows athletes to take them?
 

tarheelguy124

Redshirt
Jan 3, 2007
126
24
0
OK i'll bite,

Don't you think athletes in every college look for easy classes? Hell I know regular students do. No one has ever said the coaching staff directed anyone to take certain classes. Does UK not have some easy classes in some departments? Does coach Cal check out all the courses before he allows athletes to take them?
I appreciate you guys not kicking me. you are better than a lot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: awf

mebeblue2

Heisman
Dec 20, 2009
98,152
10,574
0
OK i'll bite,

Don't you think athletes in every college look for easy classes? Hell I know regular students do. No one has ever said the coaching staff directed anyone to take certain classes. Does UK not have some easy classes in some departments? Does coach Cal check out all the courses before he allows athletes to take them?

there is a huge difference in "EASY" and "FAKE"
UNC had fake classes
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Underdogs have owned Kentucky vs. Missouri series
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Kentucky Fouled Five Indiana 3-Point Shooters
  3. 03 KSR Football Will Stein's Message to Kentucky Ahead of Missouri Road Trip
  4. 04 KSR Football CFB Cheat Sheet: Week 12
  5. 05 KSR Football Bio Blast: Missouri Tigers