Would Self be pushed out as UK coach?

familydivided

Redshirt
Mar 24, 2010
13
19
0
I'm a KU fan first (KU alumnus), but I also cheer for Kentucky since my sister is a UK alumnus. Roy was at KU for 15 years and never won a national championship. Self won a championship in year 5 at KU. I'm beginning to think KU just has bad luck in the tourney. Self has gotten us to the championship game 2 times in the last 8 years, having the unfortunate luck of having to play a great Kentucky team with the best young player in college basketball... who is now the best young player in professional basketball.

Cal gets more recruits than Self and appears to do a better job of getting the OAD's to jell as a team more quickly than Self. I appreciate both coaches although I will admit that I didn't like Cal very well until a few years ago. Perhaps it is because I love KU more than UK and didn't like it when UK fans bad mouthed Self and his NCAA losses. I began to like Cal when I followed Kentucky basketball more closely these past few years. Cal is brilliant at keeping UK in the spot light. He has what it takes to coach at Kentucky, great coach, high energy and media savvy. He understands the OAD's better than any coach, although Coach K hasn't done too bad.

Calipari owns Self as far as wins when playing against each other, and Self owns Roy as far as wins when playing against each other. I think Cal, Self, and Roy are great coaches, however, Self and Roy don't appear to make team/game adjustments as well as Calipari. That said, it doesn't make them bad coaches, it just means they are less likely to do as well as Cal in out of conference games.

I doubt Self is in the hot seat this year but it may be getting warm. We lost to a very good team this year by 5 pts. We didn't flame out the first week of the conference like we did the last few years and we didn't get blown out by a lower seed.... which makes Saturday's loss a little easier than the last 2 years.
 

McThick

Redshirt
Mar 20, 2014
81
38
0
This thread is funny. Ever since Cal has been here, he has owned Self in recruiting and it hasn't even been close. And most on here talk about it a lot. Our guys are head and shoulders above their guys. With the exception of a few players we smoke them in talent every year. As far as I know, Self has never had a #1 recruiting class, how many have we had? Now, trying to say he sucks because of "all" that talent. Who does he have in the NBA that comes close to our guys? There's a couple, but nothing like our guys. It's funny to me to be bagging on another coach saying he should be better, when every other fan base says with the talent we get every year we should have more titles. The only coach that comes close to Cal in terms of talent, is K, and how many titles has he won since Cal has been here?
 

gracetoyou

Heisman
Apr 19, 2009
20,740
30,278
113
This thread is funny. Ever since Cal has been here, he has owned Self in recruiting and it hasn't even been close. And most on here talk about it a lot. Our guys are head and shoulders above their guys. With the exception of a few players we smoke them in talent every year. As far as I know, Self has never had a #1 recruiting class, how many have we had? Now, trying to say he sucks because of "all" that talent. Who does he have in the NBA that comes close to our guys? There's a couple, but nothing like our guys. It's funny to me to be bagging on another coach saying he should be better, when every other fan base says with the talent we get every year we should have more titles. The only coach that comes close to Cal in terms of talent, is K, and how many titles has he won since Cal has been here?


Self has had a lot of talent & he beat Cal out with Alexander, Ellis, Oubre, Diallo, & Bragg just in the last few years. So don't say Self hasn't had talent. UK, Duke, & Kansas have had the most talent the last several years.

Self does not do well with elite talent...kind of like Tubby Smith. He does better with 3-4 star players that will hang around fir a few years...hence why he had such a good year this year...

SO let's not be stupid & act like he hasn't had much talent...lol

Signed
-Xavier Henry (#2)
-Josh Selby (#1)
-Andrew Wiggins (#1)
-Kelly Oubre (#6)
-Joel Embiid (#2)

Just to name a few off the top of my head from the last few years. There's more...I'm just shooting from the hip from recently.

BTW...Coach K's 2010 title was not a talented team & was an unexpected fluke. They seriously played no one. K has had much better talent since then but has not done well in the tourney until last year with the talent.

Your totally basketball ignorant if you think Cal cannot coach. Absolutely no one...no one...in college basketball takes essentially an entirely new team every year & succeeds. He doesn't get nearly the credit he deserves in getting elite talent to buy into a team concept & also to actually play defense.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Big_Blue79

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
This thread is funny. Ever since Cal has been here, he has owned Self in recruiting and it hasn't even been close. And most on here talk about it a lot. Our guys are head and shoulders above their guys. With the exception of a few players we smoke them in talent every year. As far as I know, Self has never had a #1 recruiting class, how many have we had? Now, trying to say he sucks because of "all" that talent. Who does he have in the NBA that comes close to our guys? There's a couple, but nothing like our guys. It's funny to me to be bagging on another coach saying he should be better, when every other fan base says with the talent we get every year we should have more titles. The only coach that comes close to Cal in terms of talent, is K, and how many titles has he won since Cal has been here?
Cal averages 6 five stars per roster. Self averages around five.


Ooh poor self, how is he supposed to compete?

Why is it Cal's fault that you're too mcthick to understand that having the #1 class only accounts for part of the roster? It's not Cal's fault that you don't notice some of Self's five stars because either they're in an older recruiting class but stuck around...

Or because while Cal gets roasted for having one Skal-level flop, Self has 4 in just the last 2 years (Oubre, Alexander, Diallo, and their other five star big who also averages like 2 and 2 this year), and it's not nearly the same story as anything occurring at UK.


We should start a charity.. "Help Bill Self get better burger boys".

Children in Africa, women in the slave trade in Thailand, and Bill Self. All the most noble charity causes. HE ONLY HAS FIVE STUDS PER YEAR AND A BUNCH OF FOUR STARS AND IF THEY FLOP IT'S NOT HIS FAULT AND HOW IS HE SUPPOSED TO KEEP UP WITH BIG BAD CAL LIKE THAT POOR GUY
 

RC_Texas

Junior
Jul 12, 2015
1,105
300
83
If the measurement of success is NCAA Championships then no. The only active coaches with more Championships than Self (tied with others including Calipari) are Roy and K. While I am not a big fan of K, his success is hard to argue. No wonder Duke wants Coach K to keep coaching into his 90’s. When K retires Dukes goes back to being Wake Forrest. Roy is interesting. He is the same X's and O's Coach that he was at Kansas but has two Championships to show for it at UNC. The question that the NCAA is investigating now will be interesting to see what he is doing different at UNC.

Am I disappointed in the way the Kansas season ended. Yes. I hate losing more than I love winning. Was the season a failure? No. Many bright moments. Do I want Self fired? Absolutely not.

Interesting topic on Rupp...I don't post much on PHOG. I am much more active on another Kansas board. But I read PHOG. I don't see the level of enthusiasm for other team’s failures on either board that I see on Rupp. I count at double digits threads on Rupp regarding Kansas’s loss in the tournament. The longest thread on Rupp isn’t about Kentucky, it’s about Louisville.
 
Jan 29, 2003
18,120
12,185
0
From the USAToday piece on KU underachieving:

► In the last eight years, the Jayhawks have been a No. 1, No. 2, No. 2, No. 1, No. 2, No. 1, No. 1 and No. 3 seed in the NCAA tournament. And they turned those great regular season résumés into only one Final Four run.

► Kansas' loss to Villanova was Bill Self's ninth NCAA tournament loss as the better seed, tied with Mike Krzyzewski for the most since 2004, Self's first season at Kansas.

that first stat is particularly indicting....
 
Jan 29, 2003
18,120
12,185
0
I think Cal, Self, and Roy are great coaches, however, Self and Roy don't appear to make team/game adjustments as well as Calipari.
note the words here of the Kansas fan....

I don't know why you guys engage with the likes of Zaytoven, he's an imbecile as are the others who trot out meaningless platitudes and generalizations about Cal's supposed 'inferrior' bench coaching. He's a fabulous bench coach - there are 350 D1 coaches in the country, and I'd wager a good bit that he's in the top, I don't know, 5% of them. It's like idiots who, because they don't want to credit Kansas or Louisville, try to argue that they aren't great programs. If there are 350 programs, and Louisville is say number 8 or whatever, that means you have, oh I don't know, 342 that are worse. Speaks for itself. You get fixated on the top 1 or 2, point out how far Louisville is below that, ignoring that they are above 340+ schools. Myopia. Same with Cal. I'd like one of our resident idiots to start the list of coaches better at in game adjustments....

And here's a thought: if you really think we "rarely run plays" then you don't know enough about basic basketball to be commenting.
 
Last edited:

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
If the measurement of success is NCAA Championships then no. The only active coaches with more Championships than Self (tied with others including Calipari) are Roy and K. While I am not a big fan of K, his success is hard to argue. No wonder Duke wants Coach K to keep coaching into his 90’s. When K retires Dukes goes back to being Wake Forrest. Roy is interesting. He is the same X's and O's Coach that he was at Kansas but has two Championships to show for it at UNC. The question that the NCAA is investigating now will be interesting to see what he is doing different at UNC.

Am I disappointed in the way the Kansas season ended. Yes. I hate losing more than I love winning. Was the season a failure? No. Many bright moments. Do I want Self fired? Absolutely not.

Interesting topic on Rupp...I don't post much on PHOG. I am much more active on another Kansas board. But I read PHOG. I don't see the level of enthusiasm for other team’s failures on either board that I see on Rupp. I count at double digits threads on Rupp regarding Kansas’s loss in the tournament. The longest thread on Rupp isn’t about Kentucky, it’s about Louisville.
Yeah, you're normally an okay poster, but your red white and blue shades are giving you a bad look in that last paragraph.

Dropping Cal's name on Kansas's scout forum will net you the same results as wearing a swastika shirt at a black lives matter rally.

You guys might've had your busiest day of posting last season when our team lost to Wisconsin.

Go get a hold of some objectivity and then come back.
 

RC_Texas

Junior
Jul 12, 2015
1,105
300
83
Like I said the Kansas Board that I am active on isn't a Kentucky- or Cal-bashing board. Granted, I am not sure that anyone would say a nice thing about MethZoo but that is on a completely different level. We talk more Kansas sports. KUsports.net is now discussing the Kansas assistant coaches, who is staying and who is going, the 'Nova game plan or lack of, Josh Jackson, Big12 Rosters for next season, etc. The only thread that is focused on any other school is a thread titled 'At this point, anybody but UNC'. Don't get me wrong, the majority of Kentucky fans that I interact with are very respectful and positive, like all fan bases, there is a percentage that gives BBN a black eye. And that final group seems to start a lot of Threads that are not focused on Kentucky Basketball.
 

McThick

Redshirt
Mar 20, 2014
81
38
0
Self has had a lot of talent & he beat Cal out with Alexander, Ellis, Oubre, Diallo, & Bragg just in the last few years. So don't say Self hasn't had talent. UK, Duke, & Kansas have had the most talent the last several years.

Self does not do well with elite talent...kind of like Tubby Smith. He does better with 3-4 star players that will hang around fir a few years...hence why he had such a good year this year...

SO let's not be stupid & act like he hasn't had much talent...lol

Signed
-Xavier Henry (#2)
-Josh Selby (#1)
-Andrew Wiggins (#1)
-Kelly Oubre (#6)
-Joel Embiid (#2)

Just to name a few off the top of my head from the last few years. There's more...I'm just shooting from the hip from recently.

BTW...Coach K's 2010 title was not a talented team & was an unexpected fluke. They seriously played no one. K has had much better talent since then but has not done well in the tourney until last year with the talent.

Your totally basketball ignorant if you think Cal cannot coach. Absolutely no one...no one...in college basketball takes essentially an entirely new team every year & succeeds. He doesn't get nearly the credit he deserves in getting elite talent to buy into a team concept & also to actually play defense.

You name 5 guys over a period of 6 years...and Embid was not the
Self has had a lot of talent & he beat Cal out with Alexander, Ellis, Oubre, Diallo, & Bragg just in the last few years. So don't say Self hasn't had talent. UK, Duke, & Kansas have had the most talent the last several years.

Self does not do well with elite talent...kind of like Tubby Smith. He does better with 3-4 star players that will hang around fir a few years...hence why he had such a good year this year...

SO let's not be stupid & act like he hasn't had much talent...lol

Signed
-Xavier Henry (#2)
-Josh Selby (#1)
-Andrew Wiggins (#1)
-Kelly Oubre (#6)
-Joel Embiid (#2)

Just to name a few off the top of my head from the last few years. There's more...I'm just shooting from the hip from recently.

BTW...Coach K's 2010 title was not a talented team & was an unexpected fluke. They seriously played no one. K has had much better talent since then but has not done well in the tourney until last year with the talent.

Your totally basketball ignorant if you think Cal cannot coach. Absolutely no one...no one...in college basketball takes essentially an entirely new team every year & succeeds. He doesn't get nearly the credit he deserves in getting elite talent to buy into a team concept & also to actually play defense.

Are you serious? Since Cal has been here he has recruited 31 burger boys to 12 of Kansas. Embid wasn't #2, he was #25. So let's not be stupid. And Cal smokes Self in top 5 and top 10 recruits, it's not even close. Let's also not be ignorant and say I said Cal couldn't coach. You won't find that anywhere in my post.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZaytovenCat

ZaytovenCat

All-American
Apr 25, 2013
24,121
8,953
97
Alright, well I have no reason to disbelieve you, but I'd love to see @ZaytovenCat and @CUT-NETS confirm

I do agree that it is an infinitesimally tiny chunk of fans who really want to faaaaaaaaar Cal.
@Jkwo ive stated repeatedly I don't want Cal gone. He's our best option. I just want him to change a few things and improve on a few things. He makes the right decisions on 90% of the things he does. It's that 10%, that usually comes at the worst time in the NCAA tournament, that hurts us.
 

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
Cal averages 6 five stars per roster. Self averages around five.


Ooh poor self, how is he supposed to compete?

Why is it Cal's fault that you're too mcthick to understand that having the #1 class only accounts for part of the roster? It's not Cal's fault that you don't notice some of Self's five stars because either they're in an older recruiting class but stuck around...

Or because while Cal gets roasted for having one Skal-level flop, Self has 4 in just the last 2 years (Oubre, Alexander, Diallo, and their other five star big who also averages like 2 and 2 this year), and it's not nearly the same story as anything occurring at UK.


We should start a charity.. "Help Bill Self get better burger boys".

Children in Africa, women in the slave trade in Thailand, and Bill Self. All the most noble charity causes. HE ONLY HAS FIVE STUDS PER YEAR AND A BUNCH OF FOUR STARS AND IF THEY FLOP IT'S NOT HIS FAULT AND HOW IS HE SUPPOSED TO KEEP UP WITH BIG BAD CAL LIKE THAT POOR GUY
Notice how McThick talks about absolute numbers of top level recruits over the years, attempting to circumvent the infinitely more rational star average per roster numbers that I talked about above, and also acts like grace's abbreviated list encompasses all of Self's studs. What an embarrassment - it's not even like he's making a bad attempt at refuting an argument - he's presenting arguments that have already been crushed earlier in the thread. What a joke.

Keep talking about absolute number of recruits as if that more accurately reflects talent than how much talent is actually on given roster from all four classes. It's the same convenient BS tendentious argument when an IU fan states that anything outside titles does not matter, therefore IU > KU historically.

Not accurate in the least, but mighty convenient.

Embarrassing.

You want to know the reality, buddy?

Cal is 1a/1b with K over the past 7 years in both recruiting and results in the entire country. Makes sense, right? Best recruiting, best results.

Self is easily easily easily 3rd after them, and much closer to their level than to whoever is fourth, and he's somewhere 6-10 in results depending on how you look at it.
 

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
@Jkwo ive stated repeatedly I don't want Cal gone. He's our best option. I just want him to change a few things and improve on a few things. He makes the right decisions on 90% of the things he does. It's that 10%, that usually comes at the worst time in the NCAA tournament, that hurts us.
Fair enough. S&C was right. Now I await Cut.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZaytovenCat

ZaytovenCat

All-American
Apr 25, 2013
24,121
8,953
97
Boy, you just really take the cake. What do you think about Coach K bowing out in the first weekend for all of those years? Bad in game coach, or not as much talent as Lehigh? Which is it?

What about John Wooden? 1966? 1974? What happened? Choked! Can't coach with all that talent, huh?

Dean Smith. He was cheatin' his little heart out, but I can acknowledge he was a good coach. Two Championships in all those years? Bad coach! Choke!

Izzo!

Pitino!

Adolph friggin' Rupp!

Bobby Knight!

Claire friggin" BEE!

Who is good enough for you?? Who?? Who?? Who???
Lmao calm down child.

I don't have a problem at all with K losing to Lehigh or other flameouts because he has MULTIPLE titles. Seriously? Wooden? He has 10 titles so no problem there either. Now I would have a problem with Dean if he spent all those years at UK and just won 2 rings but at least he did get a 2nd title.

All it would have took to get me to stop complaining was winning the title last year. Or 2014. Realistically we should have 3 titles with a good possibility of 4 in Cal's 7 years but we have ONE. That's just too hard and too much for me to overlook. Now if we were playing with the same talent everyone else has then I might be just as happy with only making 4 Final Fours like so many here are. But we consistently have more talent than every team we play. In '10, '11, '14 and '15 we had more talent and were better than the team that ended our season. The only constant in those losses is Cal. He gets out coached in the biggest games each tournament. Even the title year the stall ball allowed KU to climb back in it for a bit. We only got that title due to an NBA lockout and having the best player in UK history. If that's what it takes to get 9 then how in the hell am I supposed to be optimistic and happy about what's going on here?
 

ZaytovenCat

All-American
Apr 25, 2013
24,121
8,953
97
And here's a thought: if you really think we "rarely run plays" then you don't know enough about basic basketball to be commenting.

Name something. The closest thing to a play we have ran since Cal has been here was the give and go that Jorts and Knight ran. We have zero inbounds plays, just put a tall guy in a corner and throw it high to him. We also leave the middle open more than we should when defending an inbounds under the opponents goal.

2010 was all Wall creating for everyone.
2011 Knight and Jorts give and go.
2012 throw lobs or the "weave."
2013 haha uhh yeah.
2014 throw it to Julius and pray he could score on 3 guys.
2015 our most diverse offense in which everyone could score but still no set plays.
2016 Ulis creating for everyone.

Also one thing we have a problem of doing every year is everyone stands around on offense. Murray had a 10 game stretch where he learned to move without the ball and that's when he got hot. He went back to standing around a lot against Indiana. We make ourselves so much easier to guard simply from not moving without the ball. This problem tripled whenever Briscoe would run point and initiate the offense. Andrew would also stand up top pounding the ball into the ground as well. The majority of our offense comes from just being more athletic than our opponent.

I really don't know how some can't see this. It's clear as day.
 

Clive Gollings

All-Conference
Nov 10, 2014
6,004
4,725
0
I do have to laugh at "only 4 Final Fours". That's about as pessimistic as one can get.

7 seasons. 4 Final Fours (57%), 2 National title games (28%), and Title (14%).
 
Last edited:
Jan 29, 2003
18,120
12,185
0
I do have to laugh at "only 4 Final Fours". That's about as pessimistic as one can get.

7 seasons. 4 Final Fours (57%), 2 National title games (28%), and Title (14%).
Beoheim has been coaching at Syracuse - supposedly a 'brand' school - for 40 years. He is now in his 5th final four, with one title. Twenty-four hours ago he had the same number of final fours and titles in 40 years as Cal does in 7 years at UK.

Anyone who finds Cal lacking isn't a person to be taken seriously.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GFANBB

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
Beoheim has been coaching at Syracuse - supposedly a 'brand' school - for 40 years. He is now in his 5th final four, with one title. Twenty-four hours ago he had the same number of final fours and titles in 40 years as Cal does in 7 years at UK.

Anyone who finds Cal lacking isn't a person to be taken seriously.
You know what they're gonna say Mojo.. "Cal has aaawwwll the talent! ANYBODY would win that muuuch with aaaaawl the talent!"

Well, he was at a much worse school and had way, way, way less talent at UMASS than Syracuse usually has and he was still winning at a better rate than Boeheim when he was coaching there.

But some people don't like talking about that.
 

Clive Gollings

All-Conference
Nov 10, 2014
6,004
4,725
0
You know what they're gonna say Mojo.. "Cal has aaawwwll the talent! ANYBODY would win that muuuch with aaaaawl the talent!"

Those same people probably discredit recruiting rankings. Meaning, they're only great players when they can be used against Calipari, but not great players when used for the players potential, production and legacy.

"They were great players and Calipari couldn't win with them" Vs. "They weren't great players because they didn't win the title and lost against such and such school and were known for many flaws".
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jkwo_rivals113955

bcox13

Senior
Apr 23, 2009
4,488
944
71
I would be disappointed in the way the year ended if I were a Kansas fan just as I am about our early exit. Without question, Kansas had a deeper team than UK, but UK also had a 1st team AA, and a 2nd team AA. Hard to except a 2nd round exit regardless of who we had to play as a #5 seed.

For me, these questions that are asked about other coaches after not winning it all or making final four just show how truly hard the NCAA tourny format is. UK has had the overall #1 seed 3x I believe since Cal arrived and only one of those teams made it to the final game.

Coach K is a great coach and he has five titles in 35 years. Self is a great coach and recruiter and has one title. Cal, as good as he has been has 1 title. The year Kansas beat Memphis just shows again how hard it is. Memphis did everything right for 36 minutes of regulation in that game, and somehow lost it at the ft line. Is that the coaches fault?

As bad as losing sucks, early or late in the tourny, as Ive gotten older it becomes easier to get over and move on to the next season. I've seen some pretty big upsets over the years.

There is nobody I would rather have than Cal, and if I was a Kansas fan I would say the same about Self.
 

McThick

Redshirt
Mar 20, 2014
81
38
0
Cal averages 6 five stars per roster. Self averages around five.


Ooh poor self, how is he supposed to compete?

Why is it Cal's fault that you're too mcthick to understand that having the #1 class only accounts for part of the roster? It's not Cal's fault that you don't notice some of Self's five stars because either they're in an older recruiting class but stuck around...

Or because while Cal gets roasted for having one Skal-level flop, Self has 4 in just the last 2 years (Oubre, Alexander, Diallo, and their other five star big who also averages like 2 and 2 this year), and it's not nearly the same story as anything occurring at UK.


We should start a charity.. "Help Bill Self get better burger boys".

Children in Africa, women in the slave trade in Thailand, and Bill Self. All the most noble charity causes. HE ONLY HAS FIVE STUDS PER YEAR AND A BUNCH OF FOUR STARS AND IF THEY FLOP IT'S NOT HIS FAULT AND HOW IS HE SUPPOSED TO KEEP UP WITH BIG BAD CAL LIKE THAT POOR GUY
Notice how McThick talks about absolute numbers of top level recruits over the years, attempting to circumvent the infinitely more rational star average per roster numbers that I talked about above, and also acts like grace's abbreviated list encompasses all of Self's studs. What an embarrassment - it's not even like he's making a bad attempt at refuting an argument - he's presenting arguments that have already been crushed earlier in the thread. What a joke.

Keep talking about absolute number of recruits as if that more accurately reflects talent than how much talent is actually on given roster from all four classes. It's the same convenient BS tendentious argument when an IU fan states that anything outside titles does not matter, therefore IU > KU historically.

Not accurate in the least, but mighty convenient.

Embarrassing.

You want to know the reality, buddy?

Cal is 1a/1b with K over the past 7 years in both recruiting and results in the entire country. Makes sense, right? Best recruiting, best results.

Self is easily easily easily 3rd after them, and much closer to their level than to whoever is fourth, and he's somewhere 6-10 in results depending on how you look at it.

I made up my mind I wasn't going to reply to you're post because you're just wrong. Self has had 5 players that are one and done. That leaves 7 over a 7 year period that has stayed more than one year. And I don't know their players well enough to know how long they stayed. But I do know there are two years where KU got zero burger boys and one year they got one....Perry Ellis at 24. And if Cal had got him that's another year they get shut out. You said Kansas is averaging 5 burger boys a year, just under Cal. 12/7=1.71 burger boys per year. Now, I've presented it my way. Let's see you put your way to numbers like I did, instead of just declaring it so. Also, everyone here also knows there is a difference in quality from the top ten 5 stars vs the bottom ten 5stars. Let's take this coming year. We will have a minimum of five 5 stars on the roster with the 5th, 6th, 7th, 17th, and 26th top recruits coming in. Kansas loses Ellis, Seldom, and Diablo, and possibly Bragg. Even if Bragg stays, they have one 5 star coming in, Udoka somebody at 27. That makes 2 5 stars. Tell me how that even comes close to the talent we have coming in.
 

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
I made up my mind I wasn't going to reply to you're post because you're just wrong. Self has had 5 players that are one and done. That leaves 7 over a 7 year period that has stayed more than one year. And I don't know their players well enough to know how long they stayed. But I do know there are two years where KU got zero burger boys and one year they got one....Perry Ellis at 24. And if Cal had got him that's another year they get shut out. You said Kansas is averaging 5 burger boys a year, just under Cal. 12/7=1.71 burger boys per year. Now, I've presented it my way. Let's see you put your way to numbers like I did, instead of just declaring it so. Also, everyone here also knows there is a difference in quality from the top ten 5 stars vs the bottom ten 5stars. Let's take this coming year. We will have a minimum of five 5 stars on the roster with the 5th, 6th, 7th, 17th, and 26th top recruits coming in. Kansas loses Ellis, Seldom, and Diablo, and possibly Bragg. Even if Bragg stays, they have one 5 star coming in, Udoka somebody at 27. That makes 2 5 stars. Tell me how that even comes close to the talent we have coming in.
Lmao - you act like you understand the argument, and then you end once again with "Talent coming in" , which again, offers a helplessly incomplete picture of the talent on two rosters.

I applaud you for at least attempting to look at it the reasonable way, but you couldn't help but screw all of it up with all of your thickness. 12/7 is how you calculate per year? Once again, that's about recruiting, and not total roster talent, buddy. Those numbers account only for what comes in - not what goes out. And furthermore, the numerator fails to take into account retained older talent from before the period in question.

When I talk about Cal's average 6 five stars per roster, I'm talking about a player who was considered 5 star by anybody in the final rankings, including the various ratings in the RSCI. I exclude Kanter because he didn't play for us. I include Patterson (as I include Collins) because though Cal didn't recruit him, he was on the roster.

I think that method pretty closely mirrors the high numbers that rival fans choose to throw in our faces when talking about Cal's wild abundance of talent.

By this definition, Kansas played 16 different five stars in that span, not 12 as you suggest (again, the flaw in your method rears its head).

Additionally, I realize I painted myself into a little bit of a corner, because I said "five stars", but in fact Kansas gets a favorable look in this arbitrary "five star" cutoff. Reason being that they played a good number of kids who were top 30 but not five star, while we did not, but instead had a number who were at the bottom of the five star range and so weren't appreciably better recruits. Sorry, but Doron Lamb is not a bigger time prospect than Marcus Morris in any universe. Additionally, every single KU roster was busting out the seams with four stars after the fives - often their 11th man was a four star, so the Bill Self pity tour really hits some bumps in the road there.

Here we go - starting from the Wall year up until this latest season.

Sherron Collins
Henry
Johnson
Robinson
Marc Morris (top 30)
Aldrich (top 30)
Withey (top 30)


Selby
Johnson
Robinson
Withey (top 30)

Johnson
Robinson
Mclemore
Withey (top 30)

Ellis
Johnson
Mclemore
Withey (top 30)


Ellis
Wiggins
Selden
Embiid
Brannen Greene (top 30)

Svi
Alexander
Oubre
Selden
Ellis
Brannen Greene (top 30)

Bragg
Diallo
Svi
Ellis
Brannen Greene (top 30)

And again, Self's starting lineup is always older and more experienced than Cal's, and usually by a healthy margin. I weep for the guy. I really do.

Going strictly by 5 stars, your Jayhawks have got just under 4 per roster, where we have just under 6.
Going by top 30 players, (due to the aforementioned favorable coincidence), you have exactly 5, and, again, we have 6.

As for the top half versus bottom half five star distinction - that is the first decent point that you make. Unlike the 25 vs 30th ranked player, I do think there's a difference between 5 and 15. It's a fair point so long as we're comparing apples to apples (freshman vs freshman, etc). But there is a significant mitigating factor there - which is that the lower half five stars or guys who are in that top 30 (some classes top 40) range tend to be the types who will get a shot at the league at some point, but who stick around. So for example, the best freshman point guard we (or maybe anyone) have ever had was John Wall. But he was soon bested by a lower half five star in his second year. The fact that some are more apt to stick around is not trivial - it is hugely significant.

That is why the gap between the programs' talent is not nearly as wide as the ridiculous way that you attempted to portray it - looking at just the absolute number of five stars recruited gives the impression that UK has 2-3 times more, which is an argument only accepted by trolls or simpletons or people who don't actually watch college basketball.

So there are the numbers laid out. I've told you my criteria and there is no mysterious black box to my calculations. One small note, though - most of this trash talk doesn't revolve around the head to head record, because that's not really what you KU fans are so insecure about. Your boy has acquitted himself fairly well in that regard against UK. It's really the coaches versus the tournament, isn't it?

And in that vein, I think it's worth looking at this talent argument in light of their respective knockout losses. Cal took 6 top 30 players per roster and has only lost to good teams in the tournament, often the champion.

Why are Self's 5 top 30 players per roster not enough to insulate him from those rascally mid majors and other assorted elite 8 flameouts? Hmm?

And for God's sake, stop saying "we". You're not fooling anybody by intentionally misspelling all of their players' names in a massive display of overcompensation. That combined with the fact that your incredibly sporadic post history mostly revolves around
a. bitching at UK fans for bitching about refs (reasonable, but if it's the only thing you ever do...) and
b. defending Billy Toupee, who even Kansas fans (other than you) acknowledge isn't as good a coach as Cal.

Makes it pretty clear where your loyalties lie. And that's okay. Doesn't make you evil. Just a little confused.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: michaeluk26

d2atTech

All-Conference
Apr 15, 2009
3,477
2,578
0
No real UK fan wants Cal's head.

I'd say Self would be feeling a lot of heat at UK. UK has higher standards than KU. KU is kinda like UL to me...minus the rivalry in state for UK. KU is pretty irrelevant with their 3 titles and standing pat there.

real uk fans want cal to bring home number 12
 

McThick

Redshirt
Mar 20, 2014
81
38
0
Lmao - you act like you understand the argument, and then you end once again with "Talent coming in" , which again, offers a helplessly incomplete picture of the talent on two rosters.

I applaud you for at least attempting to look at it the reasonable way, but you couldn't help but screw all of it up with all of your thickness. 12/7 is how you calculate per year? Once again, that's about recruiting, and not total roster talent, buddy. Those numbers account only for what comes in - not what goes out. And furthermore, the numerator fails to take into account retained older talent from before the period in question.

When I talk about Cal's average 6 five stars per roster, I'm talking about a player who was considered 5 star by anybody in the final rankings, including the various ratings in the RSCI. I exclude Kanter because he didn't play for us. I include Patterson (as I include Collins) because though Cal didn't recruit him, he was on the roster.

I think that method pretty closely mirrors the high numbers that rival fans choose to throw in our faces when talking about Cal's wild abundance of talent.

By this definition, Kansas played 16 different five stars in that span, not 12 as you suggest (again, the flaw in your method rears its head).

Additionally, I realize I painted myself into a little bit of a corner, because I said "five stars", but in fact Kansas gets a favorable look in this arbitrary "five star" cutoff. Reason being that they played a good number of kids who were top 30 but not five star, while we did not, but instead had a number who were at the bottom of the five star range and so weren't appreciably better recruits. Sorry, but Doron Lamb is not a bigger time prospect than Marcus Morris in any universe. Additionally, every single KU roster was busting out the seams with four stars after the fives - often their 11th man was a four star, so the Bill Self pity tour really hits some bumps in the road there.

Here we go - starting from the Wall year up until this latest season.

Sherron Collins
Henry
Johnson
Robinson
Marc Morris (top 30)
Aldrich (top 30)
Withey (top 30)


Selby
Johnson
Robinson
Withey (top 30)

Johnson
Robinson
Mclemore
Withey (top 30)

Ellis
Johnson
Mclemore
Withey (top 30)


Ellis
Wiggins
Selden
Embiid
Brannen Greene (top 30)

Svi
Alexander
Oubre
Selden
Ellis
Brannen Greene (top 30)

Bragg
Diallo
Svi
Ellis
Brannen Greene (top 30)

And again, Self's starting lineup is always older and more experienced than Cal's, and usually by a healthy margin. I weep for the guy. I really do.

Going strictly by 5 stars, your Jayhawks have got just under 4 per roster, where we have just under 6.
Going by top 30 players, (due to the aforementioned favorable coincidence), you have exactly 5, and, again, we have 6.

As for the top half versus bottom half five star distinction - that is the first decent point that you make. Unlike the 25 vs 30th ranked player, I do think there's a difference between 5 and 15. It's a fair point so long as we're comparing apples to apples (freshman vs freshman, etc). But there is a significant mitigating factor there - which is that the lower half five stars or guys who are in that top 30 (some classes top 40) range tend to be the types who will get a shot at the league at some point, but who stick around. So for example, the best freshman point guard we (or maybe anyone) have ever had was John Wall. But he was soon bested by a lower half five star in his second year. The fact that some are more apt to stick around is not trivial - it is hugely significant.

That is why the gap between the programs' talent is not nearly as wide as the ridiculous way that you attempted to portray it - looking at just the absolute number of five stars recruited gives the impression that UK has 2-3 times more, which is an argument only accepted by trolls or simpletons or people who don't actually watch college basketball.

So there are the numbers laid out. I've told you my criteria and there is no mysterious black box to my calculations. One small note, though - most of this trash talk doesn't revolve around the head to head record, because that's not really what you KU fans are so insecure about. Your boy has acquitted himself fairly well in that regard against UK. It's really the coaches versus the tournament, isn't it?

And in that vein, I think it's worth looking at this talent argument in light of their respective knockout losses. Cal took 6 top 30 players per roster and has only lost to good teams in the tournament, often the champion.

Why are Self's 5 top 30 players per roster not enough to insulate him from those rascally mid majors and other assorted elite 8 flameouts? Hmm?

And for God's sake, stop saying "we". You're not fooling anybody by intentionally misspelling all of their players' names in a massive display of overcompensation. That combined with the fact that your incredibly sporadic post history mostly revolves around
a. bitching at UK fans for bitching about refs (reasonable, but if it's the only thing you ever do...) and
b. defending Billy Toupee, who even Kansas fans (other than you) acknowledge isn't as good a coach as Cal.

Makes it pretty clear where your loyalties lie. And that's okay. Doesn't make you evil. Just a little confused.

Lol...sure Change the rules after you said 5 STARS. Withey, mclemore, Robinson were not top 30, top 40, but not top 30. You are making this way harder than it is. I used Rivals rankings, because that is the one by far that everyone respects and most people use. Cal by far brings in more talent than Self. Who cares what 4 star scrubs return to Kansas because they aren't good enough to go anywhere. Most of them couldn't sit on our bench. With the exception of a couple of years, Kansas isn't close to our level of talent, I don't know why you can't see that. The funny thing is , I'm not knocking Cal. He does a tremendous job. How many times has Cal landed 3 of the top five recruits? For or five of the top ten? Now, how about Self? In each of those years you listed, post our 5stars and returning 4 stars beside it. Not even close. Cal smokes Self every year.
 

26MichaelUK

All-American
Feb 14, 2013
36,689
5,377
93
Lol...sure Change the rules after you said 5 STARS. Withey, mclemore, Robinson were not top 30, top 40, but not top 30. You are making this way harder than it is. I used Rivals rankings, because that is the one by far that everyone respects and most people use. Cal by far brings in more talent than Self. Who cares what 4 star scrubs return to Kansas because they aren't good enough to go anywhere. Most of them couldn't sit on our bench. With the exception of a couple of years, Kansas isn't close to our level of talent, I don't know why you can't see that. The funny thing is , I'm not knocking Cal. He does a tremendous job. How many times has Cal landed 3 of the top five recruits? For or five of the top ten? Now, how about Self? In each of those years you listed, post our 5stars and returning 4 stars beside it. Not even close. Cal smokes Self every year.
Jesus Christ, how do you not see what he is saying is accurate? Also, its blatantly obvious you're not a UK fan.
 

BurpinTurpin_rivals209459

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2009
4,084
1,091
0
Lmao calm down child.

I don't have a problem at all with K losing to Lehigh or other flameouts because he has MULTIPLE titles. Seriously? Wooden? He has 10 titles so no problem there either. Now I would have a problem with Dean if he spent all those years at UK and just won 2 rings but at least he did get a 2nd title.

All it would have took to get me to stop complaining was winning the title last year. Or 2014. Realistically we should have 3 titles with a good possibility of 4 in Cal's 7 years but we have ONE. That's just too hard and too much for me to overlook. Now if we were playing with the same talent everyone else has then I might be just as happy with only making 4 Final Fours like so many here are. But we consistently have more talent than every team we play. In '10, '11, '14 and '15 we had more talent and were better than the team that ended our season. The only constant in those losses is Cal. He gets out coached in the biggest games each tournament. Even the title year the stall ball allowed KU to climb back in it for a bit. We only got that title due to an NBA lockout and having the best player in UK history. If that's what it takes to get 9 then how in the hell am I supposed to be optimistic and happy about what's going on here?
Lol yeah I was kind of kidding.

But my point is that even the greatest coaches of all time, with very high levels of talent, lose in the Tournament. I get being disappointed- I am too- but Cal has only been at a major blue-blood program for 7 years. K has been at Duke for 30. Self has been at Kansas for twice as long as Cal. Pitino has been at UK/Louisville for twice as long as Cal. Ol' Lyin' Roy has been at Kansas/UNC for 25 years. What Cal has done in only 7 years is extraordinary. Give him time.

Btw, honest question, how long have you been a UK fan? Have you lived through the many years in which a Final Four, not to mention a championship, wasn't even a remote option for us? I've been watching since 1978, and the only era of success I can compare to Cal's over these past 38 years is the five year period in the late 90's.
 

BurpinTurpin_rivals209459

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2009
4,084
1,091
0
I also think people are forgetting what everybody said back in 09-10: You Can't Win With Freshmen-Dominated Teams. Cal did it and everyone changed the narrative. Everyone focused on the "Talent" after that, forgetting they are Freshmen.
 

ZaytovenCat

All-American
Apr 25, 2013
24,121
8,953
97
Been a fan since I was about 7-8 which was '95-'96. From TN with family being UT fans I have no idea what gravitated me towards UK. My earliest memory is getting a Mercer jersey and watching the Syracuse game.

I understand your point. I honestly wouldn't be upset about not winning the title if Tubby or BCG was the coach but when you're as close as we have been and fail to get it then it makes it worse than not even sniffing a title IMO. Especially when it's happened over and over.

While I was thoroughly pissed losing to Indiana, I think I'd rather it happen that way then to lose again in the Final Four. Much easier to get over.
 

.S&C.

All-American
Jul 8, 2014
45,292
6,422
0
As ridiculous as it would seem, that's not entirely true. About 2 months ago one member on here said (& I'm paraphrasing; don't remember the exact words) after 4/7 subpar regular seasons, he'd rather part ways and give Shaka Smart a try.

No joke.


Our fanbase has probably 5 million people in it. I would say of those maybe 100 or less actually want cal gone. It's probably the best approval rating in any sport, yet the op comes up with this is nonsense.

And when cal leaves, we better not go anywhere near Smart.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rbky53

jrpross_rivals

Heisman
Feb 21, 2008
17,688
36,477
113
Our fanbase has probably 5 million people in it. I would say of those maybe 100 or less actually want cal gone. It's probably the best approval rating in any sport, yet the op comes up with this is nonsense.

And when cal leaves, we better not go anywhere near Smart.
Not right now anyway. He seems to be a solid coach but he has very little experience recruiting on the national scale. I wouldn't mind seeing how he does at Texas but I agree, right now, Smart would be Stupid.
 

bcox13

Senior
Apr 23, 2009
4,488
944
71
Been a fan since I was about 7-8 which was '95-'96. From TN with family being UT fans I have no idea what gravitated me towards UK. My earliest memory is getting a Mercer jersey and watching the Syracuse game.

I understand your point. I honestly wouldn't be upset about not winning the title if Tubby or BCG was the coach but when you're as close as we have been and fail to get it then it makes it worse than not even sniffing a title IMO. Especially when it's happened over and over.

While I was thoroughly pissed losing to Indiana, I think I'd rather it happen that way then to lose again in the Final Four. Much easier to get over.
So you think that not competing for titles is better than being close on an almost annual basis and winning one every 6-7 years? You would understand if we had a coach that couldn't get us in the position, but get pissed at the coach that does?

I'm sorry man, but that is a horrible take. It certainly explains some of your posts, but I just can't wrap my head around that concept.
 
  • Like
Reactions: michaeluk26

McThick

Redshirt
Mar 20, 2014
81
38
0
Jesus Christ, how do you not see what he is saying is accurate? Also, its blatantly obvious you're not a UK fan.

Whatever Mike. Sure he is right about some of that, but so am I . And I've probably been a fan longer than you've been alive, when Kentucky basketball wasn't about draft picks. Give me some 3 or 4 year guys, so you can really find out what a kid is all about. Tyler would go down as an all time great Wildcat if he would stay all four years. And just because someone doesn't see the way you do or doesn't see everything through blue tinted glasses, doesn't make them any less of a fan , so piss off!
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZaytovenCat

26MichaelUK

All-American
Feb 14, 2013
36,689
5,377
93
Lmao calm down child.

I don't have a problem at all with K losing to Lehigh or other flameouts because he has MULTIPLE titles. Seriously? Wooden? He has 10 titles so no problem there either. Now I would have a problem with Dean if he spent all those years at UK and just won 2 rings but at least he did get a 2nd title.

All it would have took to get me to stop complaining was winning the title last year. Or 2014. Realistically we should have 3 titles with a good possibility of 4 in Cal's 7 years but we have ONE. That's just too hard and too much for me to overlook. Now if we were playing with the same talent everyone else has then I might be just as happy with only making 4 Final Fours like so many here are. But we consistently have more talent than every team we play. In '10, '11, '14 and '15 we had more talent and were better than the team that ended our season. The only constant in those losses is Cal. He gets out coached in the biggest games each tournament. Even the title year the stall ball allowed KU to climb back in it for a bit. We only got that title due to an NBA lockout and having the best player in UK history. If that's what it takes to get 9 then how in the hell am I supposed to be optimistic and happy about what's going on here?
Oh, is that "all" it would take. I know, and you know, damn well that if Cal had 2 titles you would be here bitching about him not having 3. You have been on a yearlong meltdown and just keep getting worse. We lose a game to Tennessee and you make a thread saying Cal is not even a "good" coach. You called Murray another Archie Goodwin for Gods sake. You seriously need to rethink how you enjoy UK basketball because you havethe emotional stability of a teenager.

Once again you, like rival fans act like we have 25 year old NBA talent playing against college kids. Its ********. Our talent is young, raw, and straight outta high school. We are at a significant disadvantage in terms of playing other teams with talent and experience. Yet you think talent should automatically equal titles when there is NO specific formula to winning titles. Talent is just one of numerous variables. You know it took K four final fours to win a title. Keep in mind he averages 1 title every 7years. Cal is right on pace. Only one team out of 68 win the title which makes it by far the hardest championship to win in sports.

You're next point is the one that pisses me off the most. You're basically saying Cal won a title because of a generational player and thus he can't win another one without someone like that. The stupidity of that assertion lies is the fact that he has played in 2 other championship games, one at Memphis that took a historic meltdown and a miracle shot to lose. In the other we lost to UConn by 6, again losing by the slimmest of margins. He almost won a title at UMass for Christ's sake, and would have if the best team in college basketball history was not in their path. They beat us early in the year with one NBA player against 9 and damn near did it again in the final four. We lost in the final four to UConn by one freaking point that was basically the title game. Last year we lost on ******** calls. If you can consistently play deep into the tournament in final fours you will win titles and make no freaking mistake he will win another one. Your sense of entitlement is unfreaking real. All you can ask for is to be in the hunt most years and Cal has done that and way more.

Look, it took the worst shooting night in our history, coupled with the worst 3 point shooting team in the tournament scoring every basket in the first half from 3 to lose in 2010, to a team who should've been a 1 seed. In 2011 in the final four it took our best 3 point shooting team in our history, coupled with an extremely bad matchup with a team that beat us by 17 earlier in the year, and our best player to have a horrific game to lose by a single point but just getting there, taking out the overwhelming favorite OSU and the best 2UNC, was an amazing coaching job by Cal. In 2014 we had to play four straight games that were high pressure down to the wire classic games, losing ourbest defender, and having to beat 3 straight teams that were in the previous final four just to get to the final four! Then we had to beat a damn good Wisconsin team. Some guy crunched the numbers to find out we had the hardest path to a championship game in tournament history. We simply ran into our worst matchup in UConn, where losing our best defender in the sweet 16 caught up with us. We ran out of gas. Again, that was what Mike DeCourcey of sporting news called the greatest coaching in the game since coach K in the early 90s. Last year was the most heartbreaking loss I've ever experienced in my life. However, unlike you I got over it and appreciated a still historic season. You must also realize everyone on that Wisconsin team came back to specifically to beat UK. They hadno problem tellng everyone fromthe summer on. Dekker's twitter photo was of him in despair, with the UK players celebrating our victory over them. It was also thebest offensive team in men pom history by far. Did Cal make some blunders in these games. Absolutely. But simply accomplishing what he has at UK is incredible. Do I want more titles? Hell yes, but I appreciate the inredible runs we've went on with cal and having lasting memories of some incredible UK moments in the tournament. The teams that have put us out were damn good too.

Cal has the second best NCAA tournament win % in history and plays to his seed or better the best in NCAA history. Get over yourself.
 

KingOfBBN

Heisman
Sep 14, 2013
39,077
38,403
0
Only one of our coaches has multiple titles. All we could ever ask for is to be in contention and out of Cal's 7-years, we have been in contention for the title in five of them and got to the last weekend of the season in four of them.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football CFB Cheat Sheet: Week 12
  2. 02 KSR Football Bio Blast: Missouri Tigers
  3. 03 KSR KSR GAMEDAY: Kentucky Plays for History at Missouri
  4. 04 KSR Podcasts 11 Personnel: Luckett's Play Sheet at Missouri
  5. 05 KSR Basketball KSR's top takeaways from Kentucky's double-digit loss at Indiana