Would Self be pushed out as UK coach?

BIGBLUE402

Senior
Jan 1, 2011
6,931
737
0
Wasn't Mao Chalmers the PG for KU? Sorry if I am incorrect wasn't following the college basketball season too hard at the time.
 

KWilt43atbuzz

All-American
Nov 18, 2012
17,050
6,848
0
That's correct, I don't believe he's a good in game coach. Great recruiter and motivater but either doesn't know what to change or is too stubborn to make changes when needed in the tournament. We rarely run plays or make adjustments.

I hate KU and don't care for Self but I'm not gonna hate on him for basically the same thing Cal is doing. Cal just happens to win 1-2 more games in the tournament than Self. But both only have 1 of what matters, and Cal has had more talent than Self since he's been here.

At this point I don't know how any UK fan could make fun of any coach for "choking" or not winning a title.

What about making fun of a program that has the 2nd most wins in college basketball history but has only mustered 3 ships?
 

BoulderCat_rivals187983

All-Conference
May 22, 2002
7,871
3,227
0
I have to believe his seat would be getting pretty hot. I don't focus on Final 4's as much as some of you. It's national titles that count. Self has one, so does Cal. They both field teams practically every year that are capable of doing so. I think Self is an outstanding coach, and recruiter. They'll be right back next year as we will though I have to admit I never thought this year's UK team was capable of that.
 

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
52,132
73,725
113
IMO, Kansas hasn't choked. They NEVER are Really as good as their weak opponent record makes them out to be or as good as their inflated by the talking heads procrastinators think they are.
They can't really choke if they really aren't the real thing to begin with......they just meet the less than standard level of what they really are.
Now one can argue, that a better coach might have them being more successful and that is a potentially good argument. However though they don't have that coach...they have a nice guy, that can recruit a little.
Kansas was the better team out of the 2 on the court last night. They didn't use their advantages. I think they are as good as everyone thinks they are but they do crap like they did last night.
It just proves how tough it is to win and how few coaches there are out there that are truly top notch.
 

BIGBLUE402

Senior
Jan 1, 2011
6,931
737
0
That's correct, I don't believe he's a good in game coach. Great recruiter and motivater but either doesn't know what to change or is too stubborn to make changes when needed in the tournament. We rarely run plays or make adjustments.

I hate KU and don't care for Self but I'm not gonna hate on him for basically the same thing Cal is doing. Cal just happens to win 1-2 more games in the tournament than Self. But both only have 1 of what matters, and Cal has had more talent than Self since he's been here.

At this point I don't know how any UK fan could make fun of any coach for "choking" or not winning a title.

Since Cali has been here Bill self has had KU as a 1 or 2 seed every year and has only made the final four once and one time he overachieve for one.

As far as talent goes he has had the number one and two overall picks and lost early, he had the Morris Twins and a NPOY Thomas Robinson behind them he has had guys like X. Henry, cliff Alexander, josh Shelby this year Diablo and Bragg I'm sorry these are highly rated out of high school why can't they play a lick when they get to KU? Development? Evaluation by coaching staff?

And I know all you care about is titles but the final four is a damn good accomplishment as well and we have been to four in the last six years ad have beaten really good teams to get to a couple.
 

CatsnRoses

All-Conference
May 13, 2007
6,803
2,717
0
Would be interesting to see how much more scrutiny he'd be under if not for that legitimate miracle win in 2008. Guy is indebted to Mario Chalmers for life.
 

thebluestripes

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2014
2,145
2,621
0
Now that is something you don't see everyday[roll]
 
  • Like
Reactions: Calsthebomb

Kats23

All-American
Nov 21, 2007
8,683
5,914
63
You won't see any articles or analysts talking about how little Self has achieved with as many high class recruiting classes they bring in. They sure will chastise Cal in a New York minute but Self is certainly held to a different standard
 

ck-2

Heisman
Apr 7, 2007
11,306
19,154
113
I know this will make some on here mad. But after last year I find it hard to criticize another team or coach for choking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZaytovenCat

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
52,132
73,725
113
Me too. I think @ZaytovenCat doesn't think he's a great "floor coach", which, I'll tell ya, I;ve heard from hundreds of UK fans on the roads, at the games, in bars after the games, etc. This board is not like typical Uk fans that I seem to run into in life. But, I don't think he thinks he's a bad coach. I'll let him answer it.

If any UK fan doesn't want Cal to stay at UK until Jesus comes back, they are off.
I don't think zaytovencat is worthy of the respect he's getting in this thread. I just think he's a guy that can't control his anger after a loss.
 

jrpross_rivals

Heisman
Feb 21, 2008
17,688
36,477
113
Not one fan wants Cal gone. Not one.

Way to completely go full hyperbolic retard.
As ridiculous as it would seem, that's not entirely true. About 2 months ago one member on here said (& I'm paraphrasing; don't remember the exact words) after 4/7 subpar regular seasons, he'd rather part ways and give Shaka Smart a try.

No joke.
 

HexxenHammer

Sophomore
Nov 25, 2010
665
189
0
Without a doubt we would have run him off by now. Can't think of too many coaches who have routinely done less with more.

Heck, if Kendall Marshall doesn't get injured in 2012, KU wouldn't even make the final four that year.
 

catdance

All-Conference
Feb 21, 2016
1,355
1,693
0
I know this will make some on here mad. But after last year I find it hard to criticize another team or coach for choking.
We are not talking about 1 year,we're talking about a collection of years. In reference to Cal, the favorite team rarely wins the tournament.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HexxenHammer

gracetoyou

Heisman
Apr 19, 2009
20,740
30,278
113
That's correct, I don't believe he's a good in game coach. Great recruiter and motivater but either doesn't know what to change or is too stubborn to make changes when needed in the tournament. We rarely run plays or make adjustments.

I hate KU and don't care for Self but I'm not gonna hate on him for basically the same thing Cal is doing. Cal just happens to win 1-2 more games in the tournament than Self. But both only have 1 of what matters, and Cal has had more talent than Self since he's been here.

At this point I don't know how any UK fan could make fun of any coach for "choking" or not winning a title.


Whatever...lol

I'm sorry but putting your team in the best possible position to win a championship is very important. Therefore final 4's are very important!! Cal does that...Self can't get deep enough to attempt.

You will not win it every year even if you have the best team. Kansas has been the best team all year long, but they're home now. The best team rarely wins it. So it's not a knock on Cal for losing last year. Coach K's most talented team didn't win it. The UNLV team of the early 90's was probably one of the top 5 best in NCAA history....lost to a Duke team they were much better than. So, making 4 final four's in 7 seasons & the championship game in 2 of those Final fours is amazing!

And...Cal does it with an almost entirely new team every year.

Self has proved he CANNOT coach talent
 
Last edited:

catdance

All-Conference
Feb 21, 2016
1,355
1,693
0
That's correct, I don't believe he's a good in game coach. Great recruiter and motivater but either doesn't know what to change or is too stubborn to make changes when needed in the tournament. We rarely run plays or make adjustments.

I hate KU and don't care for Self but I'm not gonna hate on him for basically the same thing Cal is doing. Cal just happens to win 1-2 more games in the tournament than Self. But both only have 1 of what matters, and Cal has had more talent than Self since he's been here.

At this point I don't know how any UK fan could make fun of any coach for "choking" or not winning a title.
I just saw the stat, Self has lost more games as a 1 seed since 2004, than any other coach. Looking at Self's history, what chances would you give him to make the final four as an 8 seed?
 

FtWorthCat

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2001
6,721
4,532
0
^^^^this says it all. Tubby quit recruiting about 2 yrs before he left, he wasn't sniffing another final 4 anytime soon.

Well, Draymond Green was committed to UK when Tubby left, and we were most likely going to get Patrick Patterson either way. Plus Kenny Frease, who went on to have a nice career at Xavier, would likely have come to UK.
 

JC CATS

Heisman
Jun 18, 2009
23,517
12,221
0
^^^^this says it all. Tubby quit recruiting about 2 yrs before he left, he wasn't sniffing another final 4 anytime soon.
Tubby had Green from Michigan State and some other studs coming in, he may have had another FF. I realize that doesn't fit your agenda though so carry on...
 

12375CAT

All-Conference
Feb 15, 2012
87,767
1,283
113
Bill Self (just barely) lost out to Quinn Snyder to coach @ Missouri awhile back.
Tigers would have worshiped the ground he walked on instead of throwing him under the bus like Bird fans did @ the beginning of conference play.
 

Orange Soda King

All-Conference
Jan 3, 2014
6,018
2,474
0
Doesn't Self have 3 Final Fours? Or was not coach when they played Syracuse in the 2003 championship game? But still, I think fans would be at least a little disgruntled. Not sure about pushed out...
 
Feb 21, 2006
8,403
9,162
0
Jesus Christ gets pushed out if he doesn't make it to final fours here...

Self always does well on the recruiting trail, dominates conference and gets a favorable seed...he should probably have another title, maybe two...is a sweet 16 and elite 8 machine...but that wouldn't cut it here...

honestly i would say if he doesn't get another final four or title soon then his seat will get hot...but who the heck is going to be significantly better than self...anyone else that could be considered better or even lateral has a good gig...
 

BurpinTurpin_rivals209459

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2009
4,084
1,091
0
That's correct, I don't believe he's a good in game coach. Great recruiter and motivater but either doesn't know what to change or is too stubborn to make changes when needed in the tournament. We rarely run plays or make adjustments.

I hate KU and don't care for Self but I'm not gonna hate on him for basically the same thing Cal is doing. Cal just happens to win 1-2 more games in the tournament than Self. But both only have 1 of what matters, and Cal has had more talent than Self since he's been here.

At this point I don't know how any UK fan could make fun of any coach for "choking" or not winning a title.
Boy, you just really take the cake. What do you think about Coach K bowing out in the first weekend for all of those years? Bad in game coach, or not as much talent as Lehigh? Which is it?

What about John Wooden? 1966? 1974? What happened? Choked! Can't coach with all that talent, huh?

Dean Smith. He was cheatin' his little heart out, but I can acknowledge he was a good coach. Two Championships in all those years? Bad coach! Choke!

Izzo!

Pitino!

Adolph friggin' Rupp!

Bobby Knight!

Claire friggin" BEE!

Who is good enough for you?? Who?? Who?? Who???
 

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
just saying grace, the hardened critics, such as Zay, Cut-nets, 3rex etc.......have said time and time again, they would not replace Calipari.

I get the thread, but lets not pretend any UK fan wants Cal gone.
I think you're right about 3rex, suspect you're wrong on Zay, nearly certain that you're wrong on Cut-Nets.
 

.S&C.

All-American
Jul 8, 2014
45,292
6,422
0
I think you're right about 3rex, suspect you're wrong on Zay, nearly certain that you're wrong on Cut-Nets.

Naw man Zay said he wouldn't replace cal and Cut Nets has said the same.

Im not casting an opinion or backing anyone, just stating the fact that there really aren't any serious UK fans that would replace Cal. Its something tho board floats that isn't true.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZaytovenCat

dave5164

All-Conference
Apr 6, 2009
4,119
2,599
0
It is hard to fire a Head Coach that like Coach Cal continues to win 30+ games in the season and most of the time wins the Conference and Conference Tournaments. Also, most of the time they are either a #1 or #2 Seed in the Tourney and like Coach Cal has been to the Final Four 4 ut of 7 years and Won a Championship and a Runner-up. Self has a won a Champiosnhip and a Runner-up and been to 6 Elite 8 games and 8 sweet 16 games and 5 1st or2nd round games. He has been to the Tournament in every year for 13 years and has won 385 games and lost only 83. You just can't fire Head Coaches like Bill Self or Coah Cal just because they don't win the Chamionship each year. Look at what they have done at a Pressure School like Kentucky and Kansas in the years they have been there and they both have done outstanding jobs at both schools and the fans should appreciate to have them at UK and Kansas.
 

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
That's correct, I don't believe he's a good in game coach. Great recruiter and motivater but either doesn't know what to change or is too stubborn to make changes when needed in the tournament. We rarely run plays or make adjustments.

I hate KU and don't care for Self but I'm not gonna hate on him for basically the same thing Cal is doing. Cal just happens to win 1-2 more games in the tournament than Self. But both only have 1 of what matters, and Cal has had more talent than Self since he's been here.

At this point I don't know how any UK fan could make fun of any coach for "choking" or not winning a title.
Self's talent per roster is way way way way the hell closer to Cal's talent per roster than his results are close to Cal's results.

Nobody who was attempting objectivity would fail to realize this. Not even Kansas fans believe that Self does as well as Cal relative to talent.

That could be your new tag-line - "Zaytoven - less objective about Cal than a rival fan".
 

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
Naw man Zay said he wouldn't replace cal and Cut Nets has said the same.

Im not casting an opinion or backing anyone, just stating the fact that there really aren't any serious UK fans that would replace Cal. Its something tho board floats that isn't true.
Alright, well I have no reason to disbelieve you, but I'd love to see @ZaytovenCat and @CUT-NETS confirm

I do agree that it is an infinitesimally tiny chunk of fans who really want to faaaaaaaaar Cal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: .S&C.

stoneycat_20

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2003
24,212
4,344
0
I've said for a couple years that Self is not the great coach he's made out to be..He has a way to go to be on Cal's level...I do hope Cal tones the yelling down next year though...Some kids don't like that..He even said Alex didn't..I think that is one thing that happen to Skal..What he's done is awesome, but he makes mistakes too (his words)....You can hear him through the TV...Just stop the yelling like a wild man..Don't want you to stroke out
 

Neue Regel

All-Conference
Mar 12, 2003
12,346
2,061
0
Saw this on Kansas scout forum. Man talk about apathy:

DH2KUBCOSR

Re: Don't look now but Syracuse is making this a game
8:45 PM
We should hang an f'ing banner and this Syracuse game proves it.

We were the best team in college basketball for four months. In almost any other non-American instant gratification gambling-based society, they'd have awarded is the championship for proving it over the span of a season. We essentially have two of those already in the Helms trophy. Add 1997, 2010 and 2016 to those banners.

Now Syracuse in the span of two weeks and beating four teams, three of which were godawful, can claim that they had a better season than us and many Americans will buy into that argument.
 

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
Saw this on Kansas scout forum. Man talk about apathy:

DH2KUBCOSR

Re: Don't look now but Syracuse is making this a game
8:45 PM
We should hang an f'ing banner and this Syracuse game proves it.

We were the best team in college basketball for four months. In almost any other non-American instant gratification gambling-based society, they'd have awarded is the championship for proving it over the span of a season. We essentially have two of those already in the Helms trophy. Add 1997, 2010 and 2016 to those banners.

Now Syracuse in the span of two weeks and beating four teams, three of which were godawful, can claim that they had a better season than us and many Americans will buy into that argument.
I mean - he's right.

The single game elimination format is a magical ratings-generation machine - it has nothing to do with fairly selecting the best team.

Buuuuuut....

Over the long view (say, a few decades long coaching career), the breaks in that tournament should be at least somewhat subject to the law of averages and you should get a somewhat more accurate picture of a program or coach's status.

They have a monster recruiter and a good, not great coach. It is what it is.
 

TTTblue24

All-Conference
Feb 1, 2004
3,983
2,997
113
Tubby had Green from Michigan State and some other studs coming in, he may have had another FF. I realize that doesn't fit your agenda though so carry on...
So who were the other "stud" recruits?? I have no agenda, congrats on trying to play the "I'm smarter than you" card so I'll say you have an agenda. Not everyone who posts has an agenda pretty boy. Btw, everyone knows tubby was told to make staff changes & refused, so that's where the fallout started. Is that better mr agenda???
 

gojvc

All-American
Feb 5, 2005
28,744
7,273
0
So who were the other "stud" recruits?? I have no agenda, congrats on trying to play the "I'm smarter than you" card so I'll say you have an agenda. Not everyone who posts has an agenda pretty boy. Btw, everyone knows tubby was told to make staff changes & refused, so that's where the fallout started. Is that better mr agenda???
He might have gotten Patrick Patterson. We'll never know.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football CFB Cheat Sheet: Week 12
  2. 02 KSR Football Bio Blast: Missouri Tigers
  3. 03 KSR KSR GAMEDAY: Kentucky Plays for History at Missouri
  4. 04 KSR Podcasts 11 Personnel: Luckett's Play Sheet at Missouri
  5. 05 KSR Basketball KSR's top takeaways from Kentucky's double-digit loss at Indiana