FB Recruiting Take it down: The case for cleansing the rafters

Cawood86_rivals

Heisman
Feb 20, 2005
36,711
64,715
0
First and foremost, let it be known that I support Kentucky and whatever benefits it regardless.

While Kentucky was certainly great before he got here, its future at that time was VERY uncertain. MAJOR probation was looming, our winningest program of all time fell and we were even ineligible for the NCAAT his first 3 years. Put it this way, you're enjoying the success of the Kentucky brand today in large part because of Rick Pitino. To think otherwise is just asinine.

Wrong. We all enjoy what Rupp built not Pitino. The only reason UK even cares about basketball is because of Rupp. Joe Hall had the unenviable task of following Rupp. He was never able to satisfy the fanbase completely because he wasn't Rupp. Sutton comes along and fails miserably. Pitino came in with a win-win situation. If he succeeds, then he is forever loved, if he fails it's because the sanctions were too much.

The UK brand was here long before Pitino. He never took it where Cal has it now. Never. Pitino never acknowledged previous coaches like Cal has or players. You know why. It was all about him. You keep hanging onto him if you want. He benefitted as much from UK's success as UK did. More IMO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RacerX.ksr

RacerX.ksr

Hall of Famer
Sep 17, 2004
132,592
114,515
0
Wrong. We all enjoy what Rupp built not Pitino. The only reason UK even cares about basketball is because of Rupp. Joe Hall had the unenviable task of following Rupp. He was never able to satisfy the fanbase completely because he wasn't Rupp. Sutton comes along and fails miserably. Pitino came in with a win-win situation. If he succeeds, then he is forever loved, if he fails it's because the sanctions were too much.

The UK brand was here long before Pitino. He never took it where Cal has it now. Never. Pitino never acknowledged previous coaches like Cal has or players. You know why. It was all about him. You keep hanging onto him if you want. He benefitted as much from UK's success as UK did. More IMO.

Hell yes.
 

PayMeNoMind

Redshirt
Jan 1, 2012
5,271
2
38
Rick did alot for UK, or rather for Rick if you would like with UK benefiting. His years are listed on the banner so I would think that is fair. However, I don't think UK in fairness to UK should have to endure general insults from some one who has his banner up. If Rick can be careful to not offset his success while UK with current day insults then the banner should stay at UK's discretion. Although Farmer has had issues after UK he has not verbally degraded UK nor would he. If you believe Farmer was justified in getting a banner in the first place then it too should stay. The problem I see is that the unforgettables were very forgettable in talent.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RacerX.ksr

Bkocats

Heisman
Jan 2, 2011
80,908
70,033
67
I'm truly on the fence about it - my heart says take that thing down and burn it. It's not because Pitino left us, and, really, not because he went to UofL. It's not as if that really caused UK any problems. My issue has been his attitude towards UK and UK fans since then; his snide remarks, his dismissal of a fanbase who loved and supported him. What he does in his own bedroom (ok, restaurant) is his own business - that embarrassment was on him, and I didn't really give a flying fig how it made UofL look - beyond a few chuckles. This 2nd scandal is worse - but it really doesn't affect UK. All the problems at UofL right now are on them. But Pitino has gone out of his way to disrespect Kentucky and the BBN.
My head says that he earned his accolades at UK - and what he has done since he left does not change what he did while here.

I can tell you I never "liked" the man - and I like him even less now. I don't hate him - he's too pathetic. So anyway- I'm somewhat neutral on the argument.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RacerX.ksr

Hoskins91_rivals

All-Conference
Jun 12, 2011
6,755
1,623
50
Demonstrates how UK fans values are skewed because of basketball . Using what he did here as an excuse to overlook his massive failures to be a decent person . It doesn't matter if his ordeals happened elsewhere , you are honoring more than a record or atleast we should be . If you deem his behavior irrelevant , then you simultaneously condone all of it .
You're awfully quick to claim the moral high ground aren't you? He's had an affair, which in my opinion is no one else's business, and something that could get the school punished happened under his watch. We've had a few coaches like that. I don't concern myself with the lives of other people, and it's not my place to determine the repercussions of someone's actions.
 

BigBlueCatNation

All-Conference
Jan 31, 2006
77,495
4,426
113
Wrong. We all enjoy what Rupp built not Pitino. The only reason UK even cares about basketball is because of Rupp. Joe Hall had the unenviable task of following Rupp. He was never able to satisfy the fanbase completely because he wasn't Rupp. Sutton comes along and fails miserably. Pitino came in with a win-win situation. If he succeeds, then he is forever loved, if he fails it's because the sanctions were too much.

The UK brand was here long before Pitino. He never took it where Cal has it now. Never. Pitino never acknowledged previous coaches like Cal has or players. You know why. It was all about him. You keep hanging onto him if you want. He benefitted as much from UK's success as UK did. More IMO.

Just stop it. You probably want Tubby up there, too.
 

rockhound24_rivals

Sophomore
Dec 13, 2004
1,228
178
0
This topic is like arguing religion or politics on here. 1 millions words spoken and no opinions changed. I am on the side of leaving the banner up. I do agree that if Pitino does something that is illegal etc, then the banner should come down. Other than that, I still appreciate what he did for UK during his tenure and the banner is deserved. What he did for our program in his tenure was nothing short of remarkable. I remember Pitino as the guy that changed basketball during that era. He was the first to really embrace the 3 point shot, while pushing the tempo relentlessly most games.

I try not to compare our coaches. I try to judge each on the situation that they were put in. Rupp the father of a program. Coach Hall in a no-win situation. Sutton is over his head. Not in X's and O's but as a leader of a top program. Pitino rebuilt the program. We went from SI over for Shame to SI cover for Fame!! Tubby was awesome in 1998, but we slowly slipped into a mediocre team. Billy... What were we thinking?? Cal- Has done exactly what Pitino did plus some. He has rebuilt our program to unprecedented heights.

Of course I don't like the fact that Pitino talks down to our fans. That didn't start when he left. He NEVER gives an honest answer. It's always coach-speak. His personal business is just that in my eyes. If it's illegal, that's a whole different issue. I hated to see him take the UL job. It was easy to see where this was going to end. If he wins the games against. us, we hate him for leaving us and beating us. If we win the games, we ride him, and his own ego was going to get the best of him. The guy is a great coach and the situation with his brother-in-law was enough to make anyone bitter.

And before I get called names or asked to leave my fandom behind, I'd like to say... Been a fan for over 50 years and I have a son attending UK right now and was at the game. I'm sure that's not enough for some!

Let's just take the high road and smile, because we've dominated the series with RIck.
 
Last edited:
May 20, 2013
1,558
78
0
Imo this thread has gotten out of control. It's retarded to take down banners that represents a great time in Kentucky history and tradition. Pitino helped Kentucky and vice versa. Enjoy them as they are our don't look at them.
I formally request this topic to be closed
 

Xception

Heisman
Apr 17, 2007
26,407
22,344
0
You're awfully quick to claim the moral high ground aren't you? He's had an affair, which in my opinion is no one else's business, and something that could get the school punished happened under his watch. We've had a few coaches like that. I don't concern myself with the lives of other people, and it's not my place to determine the repercussions of someone's actions.
He is an employee of the state and represents the school , his actions as a public figure come with different standards . Larry Eustachy got fired in part for drinking at a frat party I think , a lot less than what Pitino has done . He is coach under one of the most morally bankrupt scandals involving hookers for players . At what point is it not ok to be a void of character , how many acts does it take to wipe away basketball wins . I want more than wins , I want someone who is not an embarrassment hanging in the rafters or being the coach . For the millions they make you would think that's ok to expect .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bkocats and Ugoff

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
Yep. Rick never took UK to the NIT. Never.
Excuse my snooping, but just a quick perusal through your post history, and I can see that putting Rick on a pedestal is pretty high on your priority list. And fair enough - he's one of the best coaches in the game.

But at the end of the day, you're trying to compare him favorably to the guy that he's 8-1 against now that they're both at big boy schools. Rick has only coached elite of the elite cbb programs for the past 25 years. Cal has only just begun enjoying the riches of a national blue chip program.

Cal has a 5% higher career winning percentage (a massive gap - that's the same as the all time percentage difference between Louisville and the University of Akron), the winning overall record, they went 3-3 when both were in the NBA, and he's beaten Rick with a massive talent disadvantage before, far greater than any of Rick's talent gaps.

In '95-'96, he had two players on the roster with high major offers, and Rick had one of the most talented teams of all time, featuring 9 future NBA guys. In the two games they played that year, Cal actually had a +3 point differential.

In modern terms, that would be like if Brad Stevens took his '10 Butler team, got two neutral site shots at the '15 Wildcats, split the series, and came out with a positive point differential.

Would you ever claim with a straight face that Stevens wasn't on Cal's level then? Of course not.

So yes, Rick is a great coach, and he's gotten a few on Cal, particularly when Cal was trying to build a Memphis program that didn't have nearly the cache of Louisville (during which time Cal did way better against Rick than Rick does against Cal now). But when they both have good talent, Cal wins just as much or more. Rick can't beat Cal with inferior talent, but Cal can beat Rick with inferior talent.
 
Last edited:

RacerX.ksr

Hall of Famer
Sep 17, 2004
132,592
114,515
0
If this was an actual debate there is no way the banner would stay up. The only argument from that side is that Rick did something good for us one time and that should give him carte blanche to do or say anything with regard to UK in the future.

Rick is the one who turned his back on us. He doesn't have a tattoo of his 96 championship on his back, does he? Did he respect us when he said that after a loss we would just go outside and stand around in the snow? He didn't just flip off a fan, he flipped off the reality of his relationship with UK. He said FU to all of us and the school. Why continue to exalt someone that feels that way?

Let the 96 banner stay up as it should, but take down the one that puts him on a pedestal by himself. He no longer deserves that honor.
 

John Henry

Hall of Famer
Aug 18, 2007
35,574
172,795
113
I can't stand the guy. At all. Hope he never wins another game. I hope the *****, Sypher, abortion scandals follow him forever. Small minded? Ok. And I don't give a crap.

But the banner has to stay up. He earned it. Taking it down would only fuel his pompous ego and make UK look small.

And put one up for Tubby while we're at it.

Tubby? Now we are really scraping the bottom. Tubby? Let Minnesota or Texas Tech put his banner up.
 

Bluemantoo

All-Conference
Dec 29, 2005
1,690
1,179
103
Haven't read all the posts, so someone may have already made the point I'm going to make. If so, my apologies for repetition.

I'm of the belief that Pitino, with all his arrogance, probably didn't think that taking the UL job would be a controversial decision. Instead, I think he believed that because he had 'resurrected' the UK program, he would likewise be lauded for returning to the bluegrass, hailed as a prodigal son, and turn the state red by resurrecting Louisville. I really don't think he ever even considered that taking the UL job would result in such disdain for him and the UL program among the BBN. I think this may explain why he now takes every opportunity to troll BBN, disparage Cal, and otherwise malign the fanbase and program --- his 'Grand Vision' didn't pan out, and as a result, he has become a bitter man playing second fiddle to Cal (who Pitino loathes). I'm convinced that Pitino truly believed that his decision to take the UL job would cause many UK fans to jump-ship and support UL, or at the very least, that he would be able to sway BBN's opinion to the point where UK fans would be supportive and mutually respectful of/to both programs.

Speaking of banners, I chuckled a bit when the TV cameras panned to Keightley's banner hanging beside Pitino's in the rafters... life-long UL hater Bill Keightley is probably rolling in his grave, LOL! I propose that if Pitino's banner is not removed, that we could at least start a movement to get Keightly's banner relocated in the rafters far away from Pitino's out of respect for the Keightley family and his legacy :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: John Henry

UpstateNYCat

All-Conference
Jul 4, 2012
2,931
2,482
0
Nope. He also never took them to four FF's either. I also remember that '96 team losing to some team from Massachusetts that year. Some up and coming coach beat UK pretty easily actually.

As I said before, Cal did a helluva job at UMass. And don't believe for a second I'm not happy with what all he has done at UK. I'm not trying to denigrate Cal at, I just prefer Rick's time at UK over Cal's. I find his teams were much more enjoyable to watch than what Cal has put out.
 

UpstateNYCat

All-Conference
Jul 4, 2012
2,931
2,482
0
Excuse my snooping, but just a quick perusal through your post history, and I can see that putting Rick on a pedestal is pretty high on your priority list. And fair enough - he's one of the best coaches in the game.

It's not about putting Rick on a pedestal, it's all about preference. I don't root for him or his UL teams. I'd love nothing more than to see them crash and burn. This is all about his time at UK. Otherwise, your post was solid.
 

UK90

Heisman
Dec 30, 2007
31,460
27,816
0
Then can we take the four silly "unforgettables" banners down too? After all, those being raised also was largely Pitino's doing, and was also a dumb mistake.

As long as we're up there cleansing might as well do a thorough job.
 

Cawood86_rivals

Heisman
Feb 20, 2005
36,711
64,715
0
As I said before, Cal did a helluva job at UMass. And don't believe for a second I'm not happy with what all he has done at UK. I'm not trying to denigrate Cal at, I just prefer Rick's time at UK over Cal's. I find his teams were much more enjoyable to watch than what Cal has put out.
Welp. Dumb just ain't a derogatory enough word for your post. You are clearly a fan of Pitino and not UK. Nobody since Rupp has had the success that Cal has had at UK. Four FF's in five years. Historic run last year. Multiple #1 recruiting classes. The cool school for recruits. Highly talented NBA players hanging out in the summer at UK. AD, Cousins, John Wall, MKG, KAT, etc loving Cal.

Yet you prefer Pitino's time here. [roll]
 

3rex

Senior
Nov 3, 2002
10,278
804
0
Ignorance is bliss.

I'm just curious & mean this as an honest question...but would you be so deeply offended if someone said they enjoyed Rupps tenure more, or Joe B's? Or it it just RP's tenure that bothers you?
More factors than wins likely determine what period they enjoyed more. It does for me.

I've lived through the end of Rupps tenure until now. I've loved UK hoops throughout, but my favorite period is also RPs. I was in my 20's, single, money to burn, had season tickets in the lower arena, travelled to Big Fours in Indy, Kuppenheimer Classics in Atlanta; to Sec tournaments in Atlanta & Memphis; and to NCAA games in Charlotte, Nashville, Indy, Detroit & more.
And none of my reasons are in any way meant as a knock to Cal, who is in the middle of great run all his own.
But now I have more responsibility, other commitments, etc.

I'm sure some recall their favorite periods as Rupps time, for similar, nostalgic type reasons...same for Joe B's etc.

Not everything is meant as a slight to Cal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UpstateNYCat

jameslee32

Heisman
Mar 26, 2009
33,666
22,359
83
Then can we take the four silly "unforgettables" banners down too? After all, those being raised also was largely Pitino's doing, and was also a dumb mistake.

As long as we're up there cleansing might as well do a thorough job.
The Unforgettables banners should also stay imo but to be honest, I always expect to see Derrick Miller and Reggie Hanson when I look up there for the very same reasons as those four.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bkocats and UK90

UpstateNYCat

All-Conference
Jul 4, 2012
2,931
2,482
0
IMO, there should be a single banner for The Unforgettables with their names and years in play. No real reason for each to have their own. Also, have no problem with Tubby being up there. When did UK start doing the banners in Rupp? I moved away in '78 and don't remember the banners back then, for the Title/FF teams anyway.
 

Rod Crandler

Junior
Mar 30, 2007
875
321
0
Ricks banner is not coming down, period, so it's not even worth discussing. What is worth discussing is adding Tubbys. He won us a championship and he deserves to be there.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Underdogs have owned Kentucky vs. Missouri series
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Kentucky Fouled Five Indiana 3-Point Shooters
  3. 03 KSR Football Will Stein's Message to Kentucky Ahead of Missouri Road Trip
  4. 04 KSR Football CFB Cheat Sheet: Week 12
  5. 05 KSR Football Bio Blast: Missouri Tigers