BLUF: Mississippi State needs to abandon its traditional pass-heavy approach for the final two games and install a simplified, run-first offense built around protecting the backup quarterback and hiding the offensive line's weaknesses.
My game plan:
Against Ole Miss: Use misdirection, screens, ball control and selective play-action. Don't get into a passing shootout.
My philosophy: Stop trying to make the backup quarterback play like Kamario Taylor. Build an offense around what the current personnel can actually execute. I'd rather win ugly than lose pretty.
Long Version
I agree with your assessment of the problem. If I were coaching Mississippi State for the final two games, I would change the offensive philosophy pretty substantially.
My objective would not be to turn the backup quarterback into the starting quarterback. It would be to build an offense that doesn't require the backup quarterback or the offensive line to do things they aren't particularly good at.
That means fewer traditional dropbacks, fewer long-developing routes, less exposure to pass rushers, and making the defense defend the entire width of the field.
I would essentially install a two-game survival offense: run-oriented, multiple formations, quick decisions, misdirection, and controlled aggression.
The most important development was the loss of Kamario Taylor.
Taylor was having an outstanding season before the injury:
Mississippi State+1
The subsequent quarterback situation has been a revolving door involving AJ Swann, Parker Puckett and Brodie McWhorter.
Here are the numbers that concern me most:
Seven sacks and four lost fumbles are devastating. Auburn converted the four first-half fumbles into 24 points.
Even more concerning, Puckett was sacked four times, and Swann was sacked twice before leaving with an injury.
Mississippi State+2
My conclusion: This isn't simply a quarterback problem. It's a protection problem, a ball-security problem and a lack of offensive identity without Taylor.
I would use five primary concepts.
mgoblog.com
I'd put the quarterback in the pistol with a running back directly behind him.
Why?
7220sports.com
I would quit asking this offensive line to consistently move defensive tackles off the ball.
Instead:
Use Anthony Evans III and the other receivers as ball carriers when appropriate.
auburnobserver.com
This is where I would really change things.
Get the ball out in approximately 1.5–2 seconds.
My passing menu would consist of:
No sitting in the pocket waiting for a receiver to uncover 20 yards downfield.
thekeyplay.com
I would use more 12 personnel (two tight ends).
Have one tight end help the offensive tackle on the defensive end. The other can release into the flat or run a short route.
I'd also keep a running back in protection on obvious passing downs.
I would rather have five yards and a completed pass than risk another strip-sack.
Use:
And I would not expose an inexperienced or injured quarterback to unnecessary hits.
My game plan:
- Run 60% of the time. Use inside zone, outside runs, counters and jet sweeps.
- Get the ball out quickly. Screens, slants, quick outs and swing passes. No long-developing routes.
- Use more two-tight-end formations. Keep extra blockers in to help the offensive line.
- Move the quarterback. Bootlegs, rollouts and occasional designed runs rather than stationary pocket passing.
- Simplify the quarterback's reads. One primary receiver and one safety valve. No complicated progressions.
- Protect the football. No unnecessary risks, especially sacks and strip-sacks.
- Control the clock. Shorten the game, win field position and keep the defense rested.
Against Ole Miss: Use misdirection, screens, ball control and selective play-action. Don't get into a passing shootout.
My philosophy: Stop trying to make the backup quarterback play like Kamario Taylor. Build an offense around what the current personnel can actually execute. I'd rather win ugly than lose pretty.
Long Version
I agree with your assessment of the problem. If I were coaching Mississippi State for the final two games, I would change the offensive philosophy pretty substantially.
My objective would not be to turn the backup quarterback into the starting quarterback. It would be to build an offense that doesn't require the backup quarterback or the offensive line to do things they aren't particularly good at.
That means fewer traditional dropbacks, fewer long-developing routes, less exposure to pass rushers, and making the defense defend the entire width of the field.
I would essentially install a two-game survival offense: run-oriented, multiple formations, quick decisions, misdirection, and controlled aggression.
1. What the results tell me
The season really divides into two parts.| Period | Record | Points scored |
|---|---|---|
| First four games | 4-0 | 172 |
| Following six games | 0-6 | 63 |
Taylor was having an outstanding season before the injury:
- 1,460 passing yards
- 17 passing touchdowns
- 4 interceptions
- 65.4% completion percentage
Mississippi State+1
The subsequent quarterback situation has been a revolving door involving AJ Swann, Parker Puckett and Brodie McWhorter.
The Auburn game is particularly revealing
41-9 lossHere are the numbers that concern me most:
| Category | Mississippi State |
|---|---|
| Total offensive yards | 262 |
| Rushing yards (net) | 46 |
| Yards per rushing attempt | 1.0 |
| Sacks allowed | 7 |
| Lost fumbles | 4 |
| Third-down conversions | 3 of 17 |
| Offensive plays | 74 |
Even more concerning, Puckett was sacked four times, and Swann was sacked twice before leaving with an injury.
Mississippi State+2
My conclusion: This isn't simply a quarterback problem. It's a protection problem, a ball-security problem and a lack of offensive identity without Taylor.
2. The offensive system I would install
I would keep some of Jeff Lebby's offensive principles but substantially simplify the execution.My proposed offensive identity
60% run / 40% pass, with the passing game built around quick decisions.I would use five primary concepts.
A. Pistol formation and misdirection
Upon Further Review 2024: Offense vs Fresno State | mgoblogmgoblog.com
I'd put the quarterback in the pistol with a running back directly behind him.
Why?
- Gives the quarterback a simpler read.
- Allows inside zone, outside zone and counter.
- Makes play-action more convincing.
- Doesn't require the quarterback to take deep drops.
B. Outside runs and jet sweeps
Why Has Wyoming's Offense Struggled So Mightily This Fall?7220sports.com
I would quit asking this offensive line to consistently move defensive tackles off the ball.
Instead:
- Jet sweeps.
- Outside zone.
- Toss plays.
- Running back counters.
- Wide receiver reverses.
Use Anthony Evans III and the other receivers as ball carriers when appropriate.
C. Quick passing game
Film Room: How Auburn aired it out without showing too much in Week 2auburnobserver.com
This is where I would really change things.
Get the ball out in approximately 1.5–2 seconds.
My passing menu would consist of:
- Bubble screens.
- Wide receiver screens.
- Slants.
- Quick outs.
- Hitch routes.
- Running back swing passes.
- Tight end stick routes.
No sitting in the pocket waiting for a receiver to uncover 20 yards downfield.
D. Use the tight ends as extra blockers
Hokies Likely to Use Heavier Looks to Create Mismatch Opportunities | The Key Playthekeyplay.com
I would use more 12 personnel (two tight ends).
Have one tight end help the offensive tackle on the defensive end. The other can release into the flat or run a short route.
I'd also keep a running back in protection on obvious passing downs.
I would rather have five yards and a completed pass than risk another strip-sack.
E. Limited quarterback movement
I wouldn't eliminate designed quarterback runs, but I'd be selective.Use:
- Read-option looks.
- Bootlegs.
- Sprint-outs.
- Occasional quarterback draws.
And I would not expose an inexperienced or injured quarterback to unnecessary hits.