LSU played Luis

Chesusdog

All-American
May 2, 2006
5,228
5,748
113
And here's why I'm not a lawyer, because I don't understand what stops the NCAA from saying "okay fine, you lose every game. You do not get to participate in post season games."
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,491
33,361
113
It’s their league. I feel like they can e decide how their league is run to an extent
Not if the courts say a player is eligible. Thats like saying it’s my company. I can hire & fire who I want. And to an extent you can. But the law & courts put limits on that. And you absolutely have to abide by those limits.
 

lazlow

Senior
Jul 9, 2009
1,420
737
113
But wouldn’t be surprising if the courts said yea, you have to reinstate ( because you went down that road to begin with) but we’re agnostic to what opponents you play, what conference your in ( if any conference at all) and wether or not the player sees the court/fielld. Dont think the higher courts let LUS have their cake and eat it too.
 

ll Martain ll

Junior
Oct 5, 2014
382
297
63
Didn't Alabama do this last year with absolutely no penalty until the courts eventually overturned the decision? Seems like until the SEC/NCAA decide to actually make and enforce rules, schools are going to push boundaries.

Reminds me of when my 4 year old does something I tell her not to do. If I ignore it, her not listening to me just gets worse.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Boosh

GOOD_DAWG

Freshman
Sep 1, 2012
141
79
28
Am I the only guy who legit doesn’t care about this? LSU is a bunch of scumbags. Haven’t we all known this since we were children growing up? It’s part of the reason we didn’t attend the university or root for the teams.

Over half the schools in the conference act like this regularly. Kick them out of the conference. We would all be better off. Until then, who cares?
 

Bulldog45

All-Conference
Oct 2, 2018
1,542
2,255
113
No wonder we struggle to be competitive.. everyone else is playing to a different set of rules meanwhile we follow all of them.
The SEC is basically travel ball on steroids. Here are the rules for those who want to play by the rules. If you don’t want to play by the rules, expect a really strong email to go out to everyone (rule followers and rule breakers) saying that if you don’t stop breaking the rules we may start enforcing the rules at some point.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,491
33,361
113
Nothing like risking your status with the league for a sport with no ROI
And for risking so much only to back down in football. LSU has made a lot of enemies at the SEC office for essentially zero benefit to them. They may not have a conference night game at Tiger Stadium for another 5 years. And if/when they ever do something the SEC can punish them for, I wouldn't expect any leniency like most schools get. Stupid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: skip dog and 8dog

theoriginalSALTYdog

All-Conference
Jul 10, 2021
2,026
2,653
113
And for risking so much only to back down in football. LSU has made a lot of enemies at the SEC office for essentially zero benefit to them. They may not have a conference night game at Tiger Stadium for another 5 years. And if/when they ever do something the SEC can punish them for, I wouldn't expect any leniency like most schools get. Stupid.
Yep and when you play with fire you'll eventually get burned. . . . .
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,311
5,867
113
Because you can’t just arbitrarily ignore a court order.
I wonder what would happen if they told schools if they don't want to play LSU, the league will treat it as a W on their schedule for conference standings purposes. Presumably the schools with home games against LSU would play them, but maybe not play at LSU. I'm sure the judge would go ballistic, but it'd be pretty easy to justify that they can't force schools to play against a school operating under different rules and they need to sue the individual schools if they want to force them to play.
 

Bulldog45

All-Conference
Oct 2, 2018
1,542
2,255
113
I wonder what would happen if they told schools if they don't want to play LSU, the league will treat it as a W on their schedule for conference standings purposes. Presumably the schools with home games against LSU would play them, but maybe not play at LSU. I'm sure the judge would go ballistic, but it'd be pretty easy to justify that they can't force schools to play against a school operating under different rules and they need to sue the individual schools if they want to force them to play.
That would be interesting. Not sure how many season ticket holders they have for basketball, but I assume they’d either have to offer refunds or face demands for refunds due to the canceled home games.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,491
33,361
113
I wonder what would happen if they told schools if they don't want to play LSU, the league will treat it as a W on their schedule for conference standings purposes. Presumably the schools with home games against LSU would play them, but maybe not play at LSU. I'm sure the judge would go ballistic, but it'd be pretty easy to justify that they can't force schools to play against a school operating under different rules and they need to sue the individual schools if they want to force them to play.
They'd be right back in court with a pi$$ed off judge. Believe me, if the SEC could do anything about this to punish LSU they would. And yeah, we probably have a power hungry judge overstepping his role. But this is still a country ruled by law. And the judges interpret the law. SEC can appeal to a higher court (which will take so long it will all be moot by then), but that's about it. What the SEC can't do is just go around ignoring court orders. But I suspect that, while they can't punish LSU directly for this, the indirect cost to LSU will be a lot more than this whole thing was worth.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,311
5,867
113
They'd be right back in court with a pi$$ed off judge. Believe me, if the SEC could do anything about this to punish LSU they would. And yeah, we probably have a power hungry judge overstepping his role. But this is still a country ruled by law. And the judges interpret the law.
We are generally a country ruled by law, but not in this instance. There is a judge elected by people in a few parishes in Louisiana purporting to rule over schools located across 12 states. He's not interpreting the law, he's making law.

SEC can appeal to a higher court (which will take so long it will all be moot by then), but that's about it. What the SEC can't do is just go around ignoring court orders. But I suspect that, while they can't punish LSU directly for this, the indirect cost to LSU will be a lot more than this whole thing was worth.
I don't see the actual order online, so it would depend on its wording, but I don't know that excusing the schools from playing LSU if they did not want to would violate the preliminary injunction. They're not prohibiting RJ Luis from being on the team or competing. They're just not forcing member schools to play against a school not abiding by the rules if they don't want to. I'm sure the judge would be pissed off and he's not worried about embarrassing himself, so he can come back after the fact and try to issue an injunction forcing the SEC to threaten schools if they are not willing to play against LSU, but it does not on its face violate the snippets that are published on line.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chesusdog

40 acres and a mule

All-Conference
Dec 9, 2018
993
1,001
93
They'd be right back in court with a pi$$ed off judge. Believe me, if the SEC could do anything about this to punish LSU they would. And yeah, we probably have a power hungry judge overstepping his role. But this is still a country ruled by law. And the judges interpret the law. SEC can appeal to a higher court (which will take so long it will all be moot by then), but that's about it. What the SEC can't do is just go around ignoring court orders. But I suspect that, while they can't punish LSU directly for this, the indirect cost to LSU will be a lot more than this whole thing was worth.
First, I am not a lawyer and don't know all the ins and outs of who sued who where and what the outcome was.

But, I thought that this was the entire reason the SEC filed the Federal lawsuit in the U.S. District court in Alabama was to get the issue out of the Louisiana State courts and into the Federal courts. The thing the SEC wants the District court to decide is: Do we as a freely associated organization have the right to enforce our own rules without interference from State courts or not?

This isn't over by a long shot. LSU has made a ton of enemies both in the SEC office and other SEC members. I don't think expulsion is entirely off the table, but nothing will happen before the District court rules.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,491
33,361
113
We are generally a country ruled by law, but not in this instance. There is a judge elected by people in a few parishes in Louisiana purporting to rule over schools located across 12 states. He's not interpreting the law, he's making law.


I don't see the actual order online, so it would depend on its wording, but I don't know that excusing the schools from playing LSU if they did not want to would violate the preliminary injunction. They're not prohibiting RJ Luis from being on the team or competing. They're just not forcing member schools to play against a school not abiding by the rules if they don't want to. I'm sure the judge would be pissed off and he's not worried about embarrassing himself, so he can come back after the fact and try to issue an injunction forcing the SEC to threaten schools if they are not willing to play against LSU, but it does not on its face violate the snippets that are published on line.
1. That's your opinion. And I don't necessarily disagree with you. But that's not your or my or the SEC's place to make that call. SEC has to follow the court processes and can appeal to a higher court if they think it's appropriate to.

2. No, you can't just do that. That's just a back end way to defy a court order and will get you in trouble. Again, if it were that simple, you can bet the SEC would do something about it. They can't and they know they can't. Which is why they've publicly stated they will comply with the court order. It's not like they have a choice.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,491
33,361
113
First, I am not a lawyer and don't know all the ins and outs of who sued who where and what the outcome was.

But, I thought that this was the entire reason the SEC filed the Federal lawsuit in the U.S. District court in Alabama was to get the issue out of the Louisiana State courts and into the Federal courts. The thing the SEC wants the District court to decide is: Do we as a freely associated organization have the right to enforce our own rules without interference from State courts or not?

This isn't over by a long shot. LSU has made a ton of enemies both in the SEC office and other SEC members. I don't think expulsion is entirely off the table.
I don't think it's over either. And if the SEC can get the Federal court in Birmingham to overrule that order, I suspect it will be like the player Alabama played for a couple of games last year until the court reversed its injunction. He's ineligible and no punishment for the games he played under a court order.
 

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,045
6,895
113
Yep and when you play with fire you'll eventually get burned. . . . .
Will they eventually get burned though? I am not justifying or defending the dumbass stuff the school has done, but it genuinely seems like there just isnt a penalty that will hurt them enough to change due to being burned.

- They kept Will Wade for 3 seasons after the FBI and NCAA investigations were ongoing(why do they take that long?!), despite the guy clearly being guilty.
- LSU enjoyed the benefits of successful regular seasons and making the NCAA tournament each year they kept him after the investigations were known.
- They eventually fired him once the allegations were issued 3 years later, and self imposed losing 1 scholarship for the next two seasons...so they effectively didnt pay any penalty.
- LSU then hired the guy back 4 years later because they had sucked since Wade left.


If anything, the above will show LSU how they should keep going with Wade, since they sucked after they basically had to let him go. LSU as a school benefitted from defying pretty much everyone's views and keeping Wade as coach after the investigations were issued.
They should do the same thing now- ignore people who reference what is 'right' or what is 'honest' and play who they can to make them good. If the season's games are thrown out in the future...ok, that doesnt really change anything since everyone knows the games did happen. It sucks, but that clearly isnt a strong enough penalty for schools to care in the moment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

Dawgzilla2

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2022
2,877
3,344
113
We are generally a country ruled by law, but not in this instance. There is a judge elected by people in a few parishes in Louisiana purporting to rule over schools located across 12 states. He's not interpreting the law, he's making law.


I don't see the actual order online, so it would depend on its wording, but I don't know that excusing the schools from playing LSU if they did not want to would violate the preliminary injunction. They're not prohibiting RJ Luis from being on the team or competing. They're just not forcing member schools to play against a school not abiding by the rules if they don't want to. I'm sure the judge would be pissed off and he's not worried about embarrassing himself, so he can come back after the fact and try to issue an injunction forcing the SEC to threaten schools if they are not willing to play against LSU, but it does not on its face violate the snippets that are published on line.
The orders are not available on line as far as I can tell, so we can only go with third party information. IIRC, though, the order prohibited the NCAA and SEC from taking any action detrimental to the athletes or any school signing them based on their eligibility. I think excusing teams from playing LSU could easily be deemed an action detrimental to the school based on Luis' eligibility.

The SEC could justifiably ignore the order as unlawful, and overstepping the court's authority. The LA state court would then hold Sankey and the SEC in contempt. I'm really not sure how the court would then enforce any sanctions against Sankey, as long as he stays out of LA. Maybe I'm missing something. I don't know if other SEC employees need to visit Baton Rouge from time to time, but they could try to avoid it.

But, I don't think we want an association of Higher Education Institutions flaunting court orders. It is literally uncivil, and sets a horrible example. The whole purpose of the Federal Case is to get a ruling that the LA court cannot prevent the SEC from taking action against LSU. The SEC should wait for a ruling in that case first, even if the case has to be transferred to a Federal Court in LA.

Anyway, LSU is clearly on notice that playing Luis is a risk.

As an aside, I think the LA judge also enjoined LSU from taking detrimental action against any of the plaintiff athletes based on their eligibility. This was to give LSU cover if they played them, but LSU was not even a party to the case. Maybe LA courts can enter equitable orders against non-parties.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,311
5,867
113
1. That's your opinion. And I don't necessarily disagree with you. But that's not your or my or the SEC's place to make that call. SEC has to follow the court processes and can appeal to a higher court if they think it's appropriate to.

2. No, you can't just do that. That's just a back end way to defy a court order and will get you in trouble. Again, if it were that simple, you can bet the SEC would do something about it. They can't and they know they can't. Which is why they've publicly stated they will comply with the court order. It's not like they have a choice.
I'm not suggesting they not comply with the order. I am suggesting an action that won't violate the terms of the order I've seen quoted. It will piss the judge off, and they likely won't do it because they are going to be risk averse. But the judge is already out over his skis. He likely can't hold them in contempt. He's already out over his skis and if he tries to punish the school for doing what he hasn't prohibited them from doing, at some point he will go far enough that he gets himself in trouble. He can simply modify his injunction and direct the SEC to punish schools if they choose not to play LSU, but that makes him look worse (which he apparently doesn't care much about, but there is some limit). Member institutions that are state schools can also ask their own courts for injunctions against the SEC preventing them for punishing them if they don't want to play LSU.

Again, none of that will likely happen, but based on the provisions of the preliminary injunction that I've seen quoted, they can do it.

ETA: They can't declare it a win for the team not playing like I originally suggested. IF they do that they'd have to give LSU a W or it'd arguably be a punishment. WOuld have to treat it as just a non-played game since and everybody that declines to play would just have one less conference game in their record.

ETA2: iN addition to being risk averse, they presumably wouldn't do it unless ESPN is on board, because it would 17 up the tv side.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,491
33,361
113
I'm not suggesting they not comply with the order. I am suggesting an action that won't violate the terms of the order I've seen quoted. It will piss the judge off, and they likely won't do it because they are going to be risk averse. But the judge is already out over his skis. He likely can't hold them in contempt. He's already out over his skis and if he tries to punish the school for doing what he hasn't prohibited them from doing, at some point he will go far enough that he gets himself in trouble. He can simply modify his injunction and direct the SEC to punish schools if they choose not to play LSU, but that makes him look worse (which he apparently doesn't care much about, but there is some limit). Member institutions that are state schools can also ask their own courts for injunctions against the SEC preventing them for punishing them if they don't want to play LSU.

Again, none of that will likely happen, but based on the provisions of the preliminary injunction that I've seen quoted, they can do it.

ETA: They can't declare it a win for the team not playing like I originally suggested. IF they do that they'd have to give LSU a W or it'd arguably be a punishment. WOuld have to treat it as just a non-played game since and everybody that declines to play would just have one less conference game in their record.

ETA2: iN addition to being risk averse, they presumably wouldn't do it unless ESPN is on board, because it would 17 up the tv side.
You really should email your advice to Sankey. Because I'm sure if he can find a way to punish LSU for this right now, he would absolutely love to do it and would get zero push back from the other 15 schools. I'm kind of surprised none of the SEC's lawyers have thought of this though. **
 

Dawgzilla2

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2022
2,877
3,344
113
I'm not suggesting they not comply with the order. I am suggesting an action that won't violate the terms of the order I've seen quoted. It will piss the judge off, and they likely won't do it because they are going to be risk averse. But the judge is already out over his skis. He likely can't hold them in contempt. He's already out over his skis and if he tries to punish the school for doing what he hasn't prohibited them from doing, at some point he will go far enough that he gets himself in trouble. He can simply modify his injunction and direct the SEC to punish schools if they choose not to play LSU, but that makes him look worse (which he apparently doesn't care much about, but there is some limit). Member institutions that are state schools can also ask their own courts for injunctions against the SEC preventing them for punishing them if they don't want to play LSU.

Again, none of that will likely happen, but based on the provisions of the preliminary injunction that I've seen quoted, they can do it.

ETA: They can't declare it a win for the team not playing like I originally suggested. IF they do that they'd have to give LSU a W or it'd arguably be a punishment. WOuld have to treat it as just a non-played game since and everybody that declines to play would just have one less conference game in their record.

ETA2: iN addition to being risk averse, they presumably wouldn't do it unless ESPN is on board, because it would 17 up the tv side.
The LA court clearly cannot force the individual SEC schools to do anything. What you are suggesting likely violates several contracts, and cause problems with ESPN. And even though the schools could argue that Luis being on the court also violates one or more agreements, who really wants to go down that road?

They will likely get some guidance from the Federal Court before SEC play, anyway.

And, maybe you were just typing too fast, but the LA judge will DEFINITELY hold the SEC and Sankey in contempt if they take any action, and so far the LA Appellate court has backed the judge. The question is whether that contempt order really means anything?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,311
5,867
113
You really should email your advice to Sankey. Because I'm sure if he can find a way to punish LSU for this right now, he would absolutely love to do it and would get zero push back from the other 15 schools. I'm kind of surprised none of the SEC's lawyers have thought of this though. **
I guarantee you they have thought of it and probably a half dozen better alternatives. Again, risk averse plus TV issues.
The LA court clearly cannot force the individual SEC schools to do anything. What you are suggesting likely violates several contracts, and cause problems with ESPN. And even though the schools could argue that Luis being on the court also violates one or more agreements, who really wants to go down that road?

They will likely get some guidance from the Federal Court before SEC play, anyway.

And, maybe you were just typing too fast, but the LA judge will DEFINITELY hold the SEC and Sankey in contempt if they take an action, and so far the LA Appeallate court has back the judge. The question is whether that contempt order really means anything?
I mean, he will probably try, he's clearly not worried about following the law. But generally you can't hold somebody in contempt because you think they violated the spirit of the order if they did not actually violate the order. If the SEC just says they won't punish schools for refusing to play, they haven't blocked Luis from joining LSU's team, practicing, or competing. They haven't penalized or find LSU for rostering or playing Luis. They haven't acted in concerted with anybody to do any of those things (although they'd have to actually not act in concert and not encourage schools to not play LSU; it would have to really be individual schools deciding). They have a good faith reason for doing it; the judge has created the situation where the schools are not playing under the same rules, and it's not unreasonable for the SEC to take a hands off position with its members as far as how they want to proceed when conference rules are not in place. Again, there may parts of the order not quoted that would be violated, but based on what's been quoted, the judge would have a conniption fit but would not have grounds to hold them in contempt because they would not be violating a clear and unambiguous term of the injunction.
 

hatfieldms

All-Conference
Feb 20, 2008
8,803
2,618
113
Not if the courts say a player is eligible. Thats like saying it’s my company. I can hire & fire who I want. And to an extent you can. But the law & courts put limits on that. And you absolutely have to abide by those limits.

then why have a league? Just turn it over to the government and let them **** it up like they do everything else
 

tired

All-Conference
Sep 16, 2013
3,780
1,583
113
That judges order will eventually be worth about as much as toilet paper & Sankey will wipe his *** with it. Stay out of LA, 17 LSU & that judge.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Who carries the load?
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Bulldogs prepare for mid-major test against Tulsa in Jackson
  3. 03 On3 Football Mississippi State RB Fluff Bothwell re-signs with Bulldogs for 2027
  4. 04 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout
  5. 05 Maroon and White Chris Jans proud of Mississippi State's "must-win" performance on the road at UCF