Notre Dame recap

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,251
182,335
113
Tournament type feel game today where both teams were trading blows and unfortunately the better team ended up winning.

Defense performance aside for now, there is nothing I can fault RU for in this game. They encountered a shooting clinic by the Irish in the first half who made 15 straight fg attempts and yet RU found a way to hang in there to be down just 5 at halftime. Incredibly RU would get a brief lead here and the Irish always seem to have just a little more. Unbelievably RU fought through another 12 straight made fg by ND late in the game and through sheer grit incredulously fought back from a sure regulation loss down 95-88 by finally honing on defense, turning the Irish over 2x and then holding them on the D the last possession while raining buckets. RU forced overtime and then completed a 9-0 run by taking command 97-95 before going cold while the Irish once again through flames into the bucket eventually pulling away 110-100 which was hardly indictive of how close RU came to winning this game.

Every Rutgers fan should be heartened by this effort. While RU stayed close to Houston, they never threatened and never had the contributions needed to win that game. Today, you could see the blueprint. Lino was Lino 7-14 fg/7-8 ft. RU was getting to the line. Gurdak was once again providing buckets in the paint. Finally T Francis showed up in a big way with 25 points on 9-18 fg shooting. J Mike in a complete reversal of his stink egg vs Houston was incredible...a monster dunk and 3-3 3pt fg 14 points. Granted the offense will never shoot 60% like they did in regulation but Rutgers had guys contributing where you could see how they could pick off some decent teams. Even Smith got untracked a bit offensively and yes the defense is a problem but for me baby steps in getting him going. The revelation of Miteo playing at a level 2x his years was beautiful. 11 minutes, 9 points/3 boards on 4-7 shooting. This is the kind of exponential growth in game 5 in a big time game you only dream of. Obviously he got a bit gassed late.

Some debate Knights rotation in the overtime, putting Gurdack Buchanan, Smith, Lino, Francis rather than going with that late lineup but I am okay with it. You sort of have to go with your experience there. Buchanan really gave little this game and thats an issue because if just contributed something, it could have put RU into the win column. I think Knight has a very very very very tough job as I said in trying to fit the jigsaw puzzle pieces together. Today was a step in the right direction in that only 10 played. He is in a tough spot because the first 3 OOC against trash opponents really did not test the team or work toward figuring out a rotation. Still a case of trying to blend the old guys with the new. For this Vegas tourney, Knight isnt playing for the future, he wants to win these games. Cutting the rotation was needed, perhaps vs UNLV and with some tired legs you will see more guys but maybe not. I like Garvaglias upside and its tellling he is getting a good run. Jones I like too but todays wasnt his day and only limited to 10 minutes and when you J Mike playing 29 and being a stud out there that is what you roll with.

And give major credit to Notre Dame. I actually find it astounding RU was even in this game given how fluid and efficient the Irish offense was. This is a very good Irish team. Played Florida tough and beat Nova in a far away place. They will win their share in the ACC and be a NCAA tourney team. I said Rutgers wasnt going to be able to win a track meet and outscore ND. At some point they would have to make some stops and defensive plays and you know what we saw a little bit of that Pikiell magic int the last minute of regulation. Rutgers just does not have the experience to be able to pull out a close game like this but they came awfully close despite a very weak defense. And yeah did the Irish play bad D...well I think the RU shots were way more degree of difficulty than ND and RU did a phenomonal job at the free throw line while the Irish left the door open by struggling there until late in the game.

If you are thinking this team has NCAA potential, I am going to throw some water over that. Rutgers is a team with some great parts right now but its just not a complete team. Knight would be a coach of the year if he pushed this team into the NCAA tourney. There is a lot of progress that needs to happen. I would not say never but its just a small chance. Advice for the season is to just enjoy the vast improvement over last year at this time and now we have some better horses. Yet in some ways there were some major expectations put on guys like Smith and Syndor to produce right away and that has not happened at all yet. Amazingly usually I am the negatoid but I am calling for some patience on the development of these guys and Coach Knight figuring out the roles for them as we go forward in December. Team has more depth sure, the jury is out on quality depth. The team has offensive ability but can they shoot and play defense at the same time. Right now not sure they can at the moment

This is a team I think that has already shown it does not quit and will be a fun watch to see how they development. There will certainly be frustrating moments but likely some really nice times at the RAC. Its not NCAA but from 3 really disappointing seasons including last years 14-20 where they couldnt beat anyone better than them its not that bad to have a goal of say 17-18 wins in a season where the program will be given a pass due to Coach Pikiells health issues. I have gone from being bitter about the past 3 years to at least being able to be interested enough to write some recaps again.

Let us see what they got for another likely matchup with UNLV. Its one you really want them to get and based on their play in the first 2 games, they SHOULD get it.
 
Last edited:

RUChet

All-Conference
Apr 8, 2023
3,468
4,224
113
Offense was very good except once again only 15 assists on 37 FGs is not good.

yes we scored a lot but we’d score even more with better offense

But the defense was atrocious .we have terrible post defense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dark_check

yesrutgers01

Heisman
Nov 9, 2008
122,959
38,860
113
My take on moral victories are not a game you played well enough to win but came up short but the game you played like crap and still find a way to win.

Anyway- i actually was excited with the team to see it go to OT after trailing at the half. but a 10 pt OT loss sucks- the good thing, there is some obvious talent.
 

jordkap

All-Conference
Jul 11, 2016
2,887
4,604
77
Lot of words to say this was a moral victory, which I disagree with. Coming away from this tournament a 3rd time with nothing really to show for it sucks
 

dark_check

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2022
2,833
3,377
113
Tournament type feel game today where both teams were trading blows and unfortunately the better team ended up winning.

Defense performance aside for now, there is nothing I can fault RU for in this game. They encountered a shooting clinic by the Irish in the first half who made 15 straight fg attempts and yet RU found a way to hang in there to be down just 5 at halftime. Incredibly RU would get a brief lead here and the Irish always seem to have just a little more. Unbelievably RU fought through another 12 straight made fg by ND late in the game and through sheer grit incredulously fought back from a sure regulation loss down 95-88 by finally honing on defense, turning the Irish over 2x and then holding them on the D the last possession while raining buckets. RU forced overtime and then completed a 9-0 run by taking command 97-95 before going cold while the Irish once again through flames into the bucket eventually pulling away 110-100 which was hardly indictive of how close RU came to winning this game.

Every Rutgers fan should be heartened by this effort. While RU stayed close to Houston, they never threatened and never had the contributions needed to win that game. Today, you could see the blueprint. Lino was Lino 7-14 fg/7-8 ft. RU was getting to the line. Gurdak was once again providing buckets in the paint. Finally T Francis showed up in a big way with 25 points on 9-18 fg shooting. J Mike in a complete reversal of his stink egg vs Houston was incredible...a monster dunk and 3-3 3pt fg 14 points. Granted the offense will never shoot 60% like they did in regulation but Rutgers had guys contributing where you could see how they could pick off some decent teams. Even Smith got untracked a bit offensively and yes the defense is a problem but for me baby steps in getting him going. The revelation of Miteo playing at a level 2x his years was beautiful. 11 minutes, 9 points/3 boards on 4-7 shooting. This is the kind of exponential growth in game 5 in a big time game you only dream of. Obviously he got a bit gassed late.

Some debate Knights rotation in the overtime, putting Gurdack Buchanan, Smith, Lino, Francis rather than going with that late lineup but I am okay with it. You sort of have to go with your experience there. Buchanan really gave little this game and thats an issue because if just contributed something, it could have put RU into the win column. I think Knight has a very very very very tough job as I said in trying to fit the jigsaw puzzle pieces together. Today was a step in the right direction in that only 10 played. He is in a tough spot because the first 3 OOC against trash opponents really did not test the team or work toward figuring out a rotation. Still a case of trying to blend the old guys with the new. For this Vegas tourney, Knight isnt playing for the future, he wants to win these games. Cutting the rotation was needed, perhaps vs UNLV and with some tired legs you will see more guys but maybe not. I like Garvaglias upside and its tellling he is getting a good run. Jones I like too but todays wasnt his day and only limited to 10 minutes and when you J Mike playing 29 and being a stud out there that is what you roll with.

And give major credit to Notre Dame. I actually find it astounding RU was even in this game given how fluid and efficient the Irish offense was. This is a very good Irish team. Played Florida tough and beat Nova in a far away place. They will win their share in the ACC and be a NCAA tourney team. I said Rutgers wasnt going to be able to win a track meet and outscore ND. At some point they would have to make some stops and defensive plays and you know what we saw a little bit of that Pikiell magic int the last minute of regulation. Rutgers just does not have the experience to be able to pull out a close game like this but they came awfully close despite a very weak defense. And yeah did the Irish play bad D...well I think the RU shots were way more degree of difficulty than ND and RU did a phenomonal job at the free throw line while the Irish left the door open by struggling there until late in the game.

If you are thinking this team has NCAA potential, I am going to throw some water over that. Rutgers is a team with some great parts right now but its just not a complete team. Knight would be a coach of the year if he pushed this team into the NCAA tourney. There is a lot of progress that needs to happen. I would not say never but its just a small chance. Advice for the season is to just enjoy the vast improvement over last year at this time and now we have some better horses. Yet in some ways there were some major expectations put on guys like Smith and Syndor to produce right away and that has not happened at all yet. Amazingly usually I am the negatoid but I am calling for some patience on the development of these guys and Coach Knight figuring out the roles for them as we go forward in December. Team has more depth sure, the jury is out on quality depth. The team has offensive ability but can they shoot and play defense at the same time. Right now not sure they can at the moment

This is a team I think that has already shown it does not quit and will be a fun watch to see how they development. There will certainly be frustrating moments but likely some really nice times at the RAC. Its not NCAA but from 3 really disappointing seasons including last years 14-20 where they couldnt beat anyone better than them its not that bad to have a goal of say 17-18 wins in a season where the program will be given a pass due to Coach Pikiells health issues. I have gone from being bitter about the past 3 years to at least being able to be interested enough to write some recaps again.

Let us see what they got for another likely matchup with UNLV. Its one you really want them to get and based on their play in the first 2 games, they SHOULD get it.
I hear you and love your takes but it’s really just a blown opportunity. It’s been years of excuses, silver linings etc. we heard all about the GM, the talent and depth. There was enough to get a 50/50 game but awful d and some key missed ls FTs did us in. Wasn’t ND roughly a similar RPI? If you want to signal a change in things it was getting this win. The big ten is a gauntlet and I’m not sure there’s a winning record out there for RU, but a lot of close losses won’t make me feel good about the programs direction.
 

Rutgers25

All-American
Jul 29, 2001
7,970
6,625
83
Lot of words to say this was a moral victory, which I disagree with. Coming away from this tournament a 3rd time with nothing really to show for it sucks

agree, no participation trophies here. The Dylan and Ace team went toe to toe with Bama in Vegas and it didn’t really mean anything. Have to win, no participation trophies. UNLV is essentially a must win. Lose and things can spiral with IU and Michigan on the horizon. Our interior defense is really bad and on ball D is not much better on the perimeter.

I do agree that ND offensively is finely tuned but this is the neighborhood we live in. Everybody we play has players. This isn’t the A-10.

sure, we have some pieces for the future but sadly in this day and age everybody is a 1-yr rental. For example, if Miteo continues to progress, will be able to afford to keep both him and Gurdak?
 
  • Like
Reactions: dark_check

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,251
182,335
113
Lot of words to say this was a moral victory, which I disagree with. Coming away from this tournament a 3rd time with nothing really to show for it sucks
never said it as a moral victory but not sure what you expect with the program coming off of 3 straight subpar seasons. Notre Dame is a better team than RU and does have more talent across the board and are well coached
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wagram97 and Scangg

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,251
182,335
113
agree, no participation trophies here. The Dylan and Ace team went toe to toe with Bama in Vegas and it didn’t really mean anything. Have to win, no participation trophies. UNLV is essentially a must win. Lose and things can spiral with IU and Michigan on the horizon. Our interior defense is really bad and on ball D is not much better on the perimeter.

I do agree that ND offensively is finely tuned but this is the neighborhood we live in. Everybody we play has players. This isn’t the A-10.

sure, we have some pieces for the future but sadly in this day and age everybody is a 1-yr rental. For example, if Miteo continues to progress, will be able to afford to keep both him and Gurdak?
are your goals the ncaa tourney?
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,251
182,335
113
unfortunately the program has been really bad the past 3 years, I wasnt a fan of returning Pikiell because lets face it, I dont think he was cut in the new world of nil, some of it his fault, some of it the previous AD. Not sure why you were expecting RU to go from bad team to bubble. More players doesnt mean better team and we are also dealing with basically a first year coach with our coach with cancer and that makes the whole evaluation of this season moot.
 

cRURah

All-Conference
Nov 13, 2004
5,030
4,111
62
Bac - Glad you’re bac to the recaps.

Correction though -Gurdak only played briefly in the OT, maybe the last minute or so when the game was essentially out of reach. It was an odd lineup to start OT especially since the big guy from ND, who had been tossing him around all game, had fouled out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: goru7

T2Kplus20

Heisman
May 1, 2007
32,891
20,971
113
Tournament type feel game today where both teams were trading blows and unfortunately the better team ended up winning.

Defense performance aside for now, there is nothing I can fault RU for in this game. They encountered a shooting clinic by the Irish in the first half who made 15 straight fg attempts and yet RU found a way to hang in there to be down just 5 at halftime. Incredibly RU would get a brief lead here and the Irish always seem to have just a little more. Unbelievably RU fought through another 12 straight made fg by ND late in the game and through sheer grit incredulously fought back from a sure regulation loss down 95-88 by finally honing on defense, turning the Irish over 2x and then holding them on the D the last possession while raining buckets. RU forced overtime and then completed a 9-0 run by taking command 97-95 before going cold while the Irish once again through flames into the bucket eventually pulling away 110-100 which was hardly indictive of how close RU came to winning this game.

Every Rutgers fan should be heartened by this effort. While RU stayed close to Houston, they never threatened and never had the contributions needed to win that game. Today, you could see the blueprint. Lino was Lino 7-14 fg/7-8 ft. RU was getting to the line. Gurdak was once again providing buckets in the paint. Finally T Francis showed up in a big way with 25 points on 9-18 fg shooting. J Mike in a complete reversal of his stink egg vs Houston was incredible...a monster dunk and 3-3 3pt fg 14 points. Granted the offense will never shoot 60% like they did in regulation but Rutgers had guys contributing where you could see how they could pick off some decent teams. Even Smith got untracked a bit offensively and yes the defense is a problem but for me baby steps in getting him going. The revelation of Miteo playing at a level 2x his years was beautiful. 11 minutes, 9 points/3 boards on 4-7 shooting. This is the kind of exponential growth in game 5 in a big time game you only dream of. Obviously he got a bit gassed late.

Some debate Knights rotation in the overtime, putting Gurdack Buchanan, Smith, Lino, Francis rather than going with that late lineup but I am okay with it. You sort of have to go with your experience there. Buchanan really gave little this game and thats an issue because if just contributed something, it could have put RU into the win column. I think Knight has a very very very very tough job as I said in trying to fit the jigsaw puzzle pieces together. Today was a step in the right direction in that only 10 played. He is in a tough spot because the first 3 OOC against trash opponents really did not test the team or work toward figuring out a rotation. Still a case of trying to blend the old guys with the new. For this Vegas tourney, Knight isnt playing for the future, he wants to win these games. Cutting the rotation was needed, perhaps vs UNLV and with some tired legs you will see more guys but maybe not. I like Garvaglias upside and its tellling he is getting a good run. Jones I like too but todays wasnt his day and only limited to 10 minutes and when you J Mike playing 29 and being a stud out there that is what you roll with.

And give major credit to Notre Dame. I actually find it astounding RU was even in this game given how fluid and efficient the Irish offense was. This is a very good Irish team. Played Florida tough and beat Nova in a far away place. They will win their share in the ACC and be a NCAA tourney team. I said Rutgers wasnt going to be able to win a track meet and outscore ND. At some point they would have to make some stops and defensive plays and you know what we saw a little bit of that Pikiell magic int the last minute of regulation. Rutgers just does not have the experience to be able to pull out a close game like this but they came awfully close despite a very weak defense. And yeah did the Irish play bad D...well I think the RU shots were way more degree of difficulty than ND and RU did a phenomonal job at the free throw line while the Irish left the door open by struggling there until late in the game.

If you are thinking this team has NCAA potential, I am going to throw some water over that. Rutgers is a team with some great parts right now but its just not a complete team. Knight would be a coach of the year if he pushed this team into the NCAA tourney. There is a lot of progress that needs to happen. I would not say never but its just a small chance. Advice for the season is to just enjoy the vast improvement over last year at this time and now we have some better horses. Yet in some ways there were some major expectations put on guys like Smith and Syndor to produce right away and that has not happened at all yet. Amazingly usually I am the negatoid but I am calling for some patience on the development of these guys and Coach Knight figuring out the roles for them as we go forward in December. Team has more depth sure, the jury is out on quality depth. The team has offensive ability but can they shoot and play defense at the same time. Right now not sure they can at the moment

This is a team I think that has already shown it does not quit and will be a fun watch to see how they development. There will certainly be frustrating moments but likely some really nice times at the RAC. Its not NCAA but from 3 really disappointing seasons including last years 14-20 where they couldnt beat anyone better than them its not that bad to have a goal of say 17-18 wins in a season where the program will be given a pass due to Coach Pikiells health issues. I have gone from being bitter about the past 3 years to at least being able to be interested enough to write some recaps again.

Let us see what they got for another likely matchup with UNLV. Its one you really want them to get and based on their play in the first 2 games, they SHOULD get it.
Against glorified high school teams = 3-0
Against real D1 teams = 0-2

Seems like a typical RU team so far.
 

fatsam98

Heisman
Mar 23, 2005
44,250
40,243
113
My recording cutoff with a minute left in the 2nd 🙄

Just win tomorrow. I expect a big effort against what will probably be UNLV again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wagram97

RUDiddy777

Heisman
Feb 26, 2015
34,083
38,608
113
agree, no participation trophies here. The Dylan and Ace team went toe to toe with Bama in Vegas and it didn’t really mean anything. Have to win, no participation trophies. UNLV is essentially a must win. Lose and things can spiral with IU and Michigan on the horizon. Our interior defense is really bad and on ball D is not much better on the perimeter.

I do agree that ND offensively is finely tuned but this is the neighborhood we live in. Everybody we play has players. This isn’t the A-10.

sure, we have some pieces for the future but sadly in this day and age everybody is a 1-yr rental. For example, if Miteo continues to progress, will be able to afford to keep both him and Gurdak?

In fairness, Dylan and Ace went toe to toe with Bama. Not sure the team did.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wagram97

Scangg

Heisman
Mar 19, 2016
25,508
49,538
113
The season isnt going to be defined on not pulling off the upset for an OT win in November against a NCAA tournament team

The main takeaway so far from this tournament is that we can play with good teams... which is a step in the right direction and means we should see a watchable competitive product all season. A team that we can have a realistic hope for a couples upset on our home court

If things break our way maybe we are a bubble team. Not sure if people were thinking we were going to be competing for this tournament or the B1G or something, but the team looks solid so far and we should be happy about it

Next season big recruiting class and we hopefully build off an improvement this season where the tournament is the expectation
 
  • Like
Reactions: Simce91

Wagram97

Senior
Mar 27, 2023
601
794
93
My son and I were at the game. We just liked how they never stopped fighting back. I thought the game was over like a minute left. Then watched them tie it up. Maybe this was at the RAC it’s a win.

Now we’re enjoying some drinks in Vegas before heading home tomorrow night. With a late flight tomorrow so may go to the 3rd game. Team is just so much more fun to watch this year. With the disaster of football that’s enough for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: goru7

goru7

All-American
Dec 12, 2005
6,497
7,838
113
BAC , nice to have you back with your recaps.

Thought it was unbelievable that we played absolutely no defense in the first half and were still in the game. This game tested Brandon and he did some nice things and some not so nice things. He never had his guards pressure ND guards to disrupt their rhythm and sets. Gurdak was over hedging causing open guys and then allowing layups. It was brutal to watch.


Then he did a really good thing as he subbed Miteo and let him go for 10 minutes and he was rewarded by the freshman with offense , a blocked shot and steady play and better defense.

Then he made a huge mistake in OT. He got a 2 point lead , had the ball , and the ND center fouled out and he didn’t put Gurdack or Miteo in the game and run a play for them. Going up 4 there might have or likely would have been enough to get the victory. Instead , Tarik misses a left side 3 and then we take 4 bad shots and game over as we had guards having to guard their lefty forward with bad switches. Definitely a missed opportunity.

We missed 3 foul shots in the last minute of regulation , Gurdack missed 2 and Lino 1 that might have been enough to win in regulation. But otherwise shot foul shots real well.

Lots of good things tonight despite the atrocious defense. Like having Tarik with 25 points and JMike with 14 points having excellent bounce back games with JMike playing some defense but Tarik’s defense is still terrible. Lino despite 2-3 bad turnovers and one wild shot played another very good game with 22 points . Gurdack and Miteo especially Miteo gave us over 20 points from the center position. Smith scored some instead of his zero the last 2 games.

The bad is the defense and the rebounding that Brandon has to get fixed. That was totally unacceptable defensive effort with multiple players playing none . Defense is about effort and toughness and that was sorely missing. To allow their point guard score 26 and the lefty wing 27 was a total failure. Doubt either will score that much again all year.

Overall , despite a lot of positives a total lost opportunity because I do not believe Notre Dame has a better team
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's Notre Dame Postgame Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to Notre Dame in wild Players Era 8 OT showdown
  4. 04 The Knight Report The Knight Report - Ask The Experts Chat: November 18th Edition
  5. 05 The Knight Report Wrestling Rutgers Wrestlers in the latest InterMat Rankings - Week Three