Rip the bandaid off....

BigOHawk1

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2001
676
1,233
93
I know I shouldn't be mad but I am, bias is running rampant with the bluebloods and getting the $$$ teams into the playoff. 3 loss teams leaping over 2 loss teams with similar wins yet OSU at home by less than us and Oregon wow you beat a lifeless Mich team....Hawks should come out swinging Saturday. I hope nobody in the Top 12 loses the next few weeks and OSU and Oregon left hanging by a thread.
 

Fight4Iowa

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
460
651
93
I know I shouldn't be mad but I am, bias is running rampant with the bluebloods and getting the $$$ teams into the playoff. 3 loss teams leaping over 2 loss teams with similar wins yet OSU at home by less than us and Oregon wow you beat a lifeless Mich team....Hawks should come out swinging Saturday. I hope nobody in the Top 12 loses the next few weeks and OSU and Oregon left hanging by a thread.
Committee is going to get a good look at Iowa vs. Nebraska and Ohio state vs. Nebraska over the next two weeks.
 

85Bears

All-American
Aug 31, 2019
6,346
7,045
108
I mean they just had that with Northwestern. If anything OSU squeaking out a last second 1 point win while Iowa wins by 21 will just reinforce their decision to drop Iowa in the final ranking below a 4 loss team.
what is hilarious if anyone watches Ohio State every week, they were probably the best team on the country when Sayin was starting, and now without him they are absolute dogshit , not even a top 20 team.
 
Feb 25, 2008
33,183
32,559
113
what is hilarious if anyone watches Ohio State every week, they were probably the best team on the country when Sayin was starting, and now without him they are absolute dogshit , not even a top 20 team.
They've recovered enough in the committees eyes that they will co** block Iowa.

Remember, this is an SEC/ESPN slanted piece of sh** committee.
 

HawkBall23

Heisman
Oct 6, 2001
6,217
11,992
113
what is hilarious if anyone watches Ohio State every week, they were probably the best team on the country when Sayin was starting, and now without him they are absolute dogshit , not even a top 20 team.
What's even funnier is FSU was left out in the cold, even at 13-0, a few years ago due to their stud QB being out for a good chunk of the season.

But OSU is ranked #14, while dealing with that same issue, based solely on their name brand & Jeremiah Smith, and poised to get into the CFP if they win out.

With these rankings, the committee is literally saying record and standings don't mean shid. Its how they interpret the teams based on the "look and feel" in their eyes.

Crooked as all f*k.
 

10001110101

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2003
1,332
1,779
113
No one asked about Arizona moving up 6 spots after a loss? I don’t care if it was the #2 team in the country.

One team moves down 5 spots after a bye
Another team moves up 6 spots after a loss

How is that even possible?
Unicorn Magic GIF by Ghood Girl ® Magic
 

Grayhair1981

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2006
1,273
2,398
113
What's even funnier is FSU was left out in the cold, even at 13-0, a few years ago due to their stud QB being out for a good chunk of the season.

But OSU is ranked #14, while dealing with that same issue, based solely on their name brand & Jeremiah Smith, and poised to get into the CFP if they win out.

With these rankings, the committee is literally saying record and standings don't mean shid. Its how they interpret the teams based on the "look and feel" in their eyes.

Crooked as all f*k.
The bigger issue with OSU has been their defense. It has been non-existent the past few weeks.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,087
8,637
113
you can’t lose to a mediocre Minny team, you just can’t

our non conference was also a joke
Once again, go back and look at some of the SEC teams non cons. People make this argument every year. They play a LOT of crap teams as well, but they bolster their wins AND their losses by keeping even their crap teams in the polls all year just so they can say they have so many "ranked wins".

And I'm sorry the "can't lose to Minny" argument is crap as well. There are plenty of SEC teams (a couple of ranked ones by the way) that are no better than Minnesota,...
 

toddhawk

Junior
Sep 11, 2002
94
202
33
you can’t lose to a mediocre Minny team, you just can’t

our non conference was also a joke
As much fun as it would be to see Iowa in the CFP, the reality is that we barely beat a mediocre ISMoo squad at home, needed a near miracle to beat just as mediocre Michigan, got depantsed at home by tosu and lost to a pathetic goof team. Once that all happened, we just didn't have the competition left to recover. But 10-2 is still on the table which most teams would give anything to have. GO HAWKS!
 

Smigamorski

Sophomore
Mar 4, 2019
119
160
43
Maybe they didn't move up Iowa because they think they are going to lose. They would look kind of stupid moving Iowa up 2 -3 spots just for them to lose against Illinois. Fair or unfair Osu and Oregon pass the "eye test" over Iowa which is why they are ranked higher. Iowa just needs to take care of business. They may not get in the playoff but I don't see a 3 loss Osu or Oregon getting in over them.
 

Palmerhawk

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,639
5,165
113
Maybe they didn't move up Iowa because they think they are going to lose. They would look kind of stupid moving Iowa up 2 -3 spots just for them to lose against Illinois. Fair or unfair Osu and Oregon pass the "eye test" over Iowa which is why they are ranked higher. Iowa just needs to take care of business. They may not get in the playoff but I don't see a 3 loss Osu or Oregon getting in over them.
Wtf?
Alabama might lose to mighty Chattanooga or auburn so the committee should drop them to 23 to avoid being embarrassed,right?

OSU getting throttled by USC and oregon the last 3 weeks " passes the eye test"?
OSU without sayin is 1-2 the last 3 weeks.
OSU without sayin is very average
Iowa vs OSU right now...Iowa wins.
Oregon lost to unranked ok st and Illinois and ost at home to UCLA....that passes the eye test?

All we can do is play well and root for many upsets in front of us but it feels like the fix is in...OSU and oregon to cockblock Iowa outta the mix to allow 4-6 sec teams in


Go Nebraska!
 

OnlyTheObscure

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
3,759
5,352
113
Iowa likely will finish the year not beating a team ranked in final poll.

need to drop the guaranteed games to one. Playing Minnesota Nebraska and Wisconsin every year cuts down on the chances of playing better big ten teams.

no signature wins and the big ten perceived as being down this year don’t help.
 

MeetTheFerentzes

All-American
Sep 6, 2022
3,311
6,676
113
Iowa likely will finish the year not beating a team ranked in final poll.

need to drop the guaranteed games to one. Playing Minnesota Nebraska and Wisconsin every year cuts down on the chances of playing better big ten teams.

no signature wins and the big ten perceived as being down this year don’t help.
I don't know how the committee can explain Oregon and Ohio St jumping Iowa in their rankings after this week's games (Iowa solidly covers the spread over their opponent, while Oregon and Ohio St both beat teams at home that Iowa already beat on the road), but truth be told, Iowa had a chance to "remove all doubt" (Notre Dame's motto this season) but were not able to with a bad loss, to go along with no marquee victories. ONE opponent this season currently in the top 25, and like you said, it will likely end that way. Big Ten is down and inconsistent.

As far as the schedule goes, yeah, I don't like having 3 protected opponents, all mediocre programs overall. However, no one will be complaining about a weak B1G schedule next season. For non-conf schedule, having a Big 12, Mountain West and MO Valley team as our opponents isn't terrible; all three of those teams just happened to be lousy this season.

If Iowa is left out of the CFP, playing LSU or Ole Miss in a bowl game isn't a terrible consolation prize. Then, they'll have to come back next season with a chip on their shoulder.
 

Palmerhawk

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,639
5,165
113
How can anybody be surprised? It was over when we lost @ Minnesota. We don't have a strong enough schedule or big wins to counter that.
Minny would be just another mediocre win and committee gives no credit for that.
We has to go 12-0 to have a chance to finish ahead of 9-3 sec teams.
We lost our shot when the preseason rankings came out with 11 sec teams in top 25.
They are only slowly phasing out preseason factors( recruiting rankings,returning production ect) in current rankings...per ESPN.
Our recruiting rankings and the loss of many starters last year had a bigger impact on our current ranking than a single loss to minny.

Games are a factor but have to look better on paper for Iowa to gain ground
 

OnlyTheObscure

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
3,759
5,352
113
I don't know how the committee can explain Oregon and Ohio St jumping Iowa in their rankings after this week's games (Iowa solidly covers the spread over their opponent, while Oregon and Ohio St both beat teams at home that Iowa already beat on the road), but truth be told, Iowa had a chance to "remove all doubt" (Notre Dame's motto this season) but were not able to with a bad loss, to go along with no marquee victories. ONE opponent this season currently in the top 25, and like you said, it will likely end that way. Big Ten is down and inconsistent.

As far as the schedule goes, yeah, I don't like having 3 protected opponents, all mediocre programs overall. However, no one will be complaining about a weak B1G schedule next season. For non-conf schedule, having a Big 12, Mountain West and MO Valley team as our opponents isn't terrible; all three of those teams just happened to be lousy this season.

If Iowa is left out of the CFP, playing LSU or Ole Miss in a bowl game isn't a terrible consolation prize. Then, they'll have to come back next season with a chip on their shoulder.
Yes. This is the last year to worry about it.

any power four team that can’t make a 24 team field needs to just STFU.
 

HawkBall23

Heisman
Oct 6, 2001
6,217
11,992
113
Everyone keeps bringing up the @ Minnesota loss as the reason the Hawks aren't in the Top 12. Going by the committee's morally corrupt worldview, that makes sense.

But using that same corrupt worldview, Georgia and Utah have the same amount of wins against ranked opponents, but #1 Georgia lost at home to a 4-4/6-4 Auburn while #2 Utah is undefeated.

Why is Georgia being rewarded for losing a home game vs an unranked opponent??
 

Smigamorski

Sophomore
Mar 4, 2019
119
160
43
Wtf?
Alabama might lose to mighty Chattanooga or auburn so the committee should drop them to 23 to avoid being embarrassed,right?

OSU getting throttled by USC and oregon the last 3 weeks " passes the eye test"?
OSU without sayin is 1-2 the last 3 weeks.
OSU without sayin is very average
Iowa vs OSU right now...Iowa wins.
Oregon lost to unranked ok st and Illinois and ost at home to UCLA....that passes the eye test?

All we can do is play well and root for many upsets in front of us but it feels like the fix is in...OSU and oregon to cockblock Iowa outta the mix to allow 4-6 sec teams in


Go Nebraska!
Yes they pass the eye test over Iowa... You are actually trying to debate this?
 

Palmerhawk

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,639
5,165
113
Yes they pass the eye test over Iowa... You are actually trying to debate this?
Eye test is totally subjective,right?
But no debate is allowed?
Whose eyes?
Is eye test listed as a factual criteria by committee?
You are saying that OSU pass the eye test at 1-2 in last 3 weeks while Iowa wins 82-17 over the same period? No debate? BS.
 
Feb 25, 2008
33,183
32,559
113
Let's see how close I was:

1. Georgia 9-1
2. Utah 10-0
3. Alabama 8-2
4. UCLA 10-0
5. Notre Dame 9-1 (down 1)
6. Texas 8-2 (up 1)
7. Miami 9-1
8. Tennessee 8-2 (down 1)
9. Indiana 9-1 (up 1)
10. Wake Forest 9-1 (down 1)
11. BYU 8-2 (up 1)
12. Texas Tech 9-1
13. Oregon 7-3
14. Ohio State 7-3
15. Iowa 8-2
16. Boise State 9-1 (down 1)
17. Kentucky 7-3 (up 1)
18. Houston 7-3 (down 2)
19. USC 7-3 (up 1)
20. Arizona 7-3 (up 1)
21. Oklahoma 6-4 (down 1)
22. Louisville 7-3 (down 1)
23. South Carolina 6-4 (up 2)
24. Florida 6-4
25. Liberty 9-1 (not ranked)

Outside looking in: Mississippi (6-4), LSU 6-4, Duke 7-3), North Dakota State (8-2), Wyoming (7-3), UTSA (8-2), Memphis (8-2), Missouri 6-4, Auburn 6-4, Louisiana Tech (8-2)
 

Smigamorski

Sophomore
Mar 4, 2019
119
160
43
Eye test is totally subjective,right?
But no debate is allowed?
Whose eyes?
Is eye test listed as a factual criteria by committee?
You are saying that OSU pass the eye test at 1-2 in last 3 weeks while Iowa wins 82-17 over the same period? No debate? BS.
Bigger brands, better athletes, proven success against top flight teams. Not too mention a majority of America would rather watch a game with either of those 2 teams over Iowa. Right or wrong there is still a not great national perception of Iowa.
 

Fight4Iowa

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
460
651
93
Well if osu loses to nebby this week and Iowas still has to keep winning then no doubt we jump them
Gotta worry about Oregon too. If Ohio State loses to Nebraska, and we win our final two games by 7 or more, I think we can still jump Oregon even if Oregon wins out. We'll need Oregon to win each game in tight games though.

#1 - Oregon's win over Ohio State will look less and less impressive
#2 - We will have beaten Illinois by 7 or more @ Illinois whereas Oregon would have lost @ Illinois by 11 points
#3 - We will have beaten Washington by 17 points @ Washigton whereas Oregon would have beaten Washington at home by 7 or less.
 

Old_wrestling_fan2

All-Conference
Mar 2, 2009
718
3,236
93
What's even funnier is FSU was left out in the cold, even at 13-0, a few years ago due to their stud QB being out for a good chunk of the season.

But OSU is ranked #14, while dealing with that same issue, based solely on their name brand & Jeremiah Smith, and poised to get into the CFP if they win out.

With these rankings, the committee is literally saying record and standings don't mean shid. Its how they interpret the teams based on the "look and feel" in their eyes.

Crooked as all f*k.
Also, "body of work" is used to justify any oddities in the process.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HawkBall23

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,699
5,374
113
Gotta worry about Oregon too. If Ohio State loses to Nebraska, and we win our final two games by 7 or more, I think we can still jump Oregon even if Oregon wins out. We'll need Oregon to win each game in tight games though.

#1 - Oregon's win over Ohio State will look less and less impressive
#2 - We will have beaten Illinois by 7 or more @ Illinois whereas Oregon would have lost @ Illinois by 11 points
#3 - We will have beaten Washington by 17 points @ Washigton whereas Oregon would have beaten Washington at home by 7 or less.
We need to jump more than Oregon and OSU as we have to get to at least the 11th spot because 12 is reserved of Boise, a G6 team. So there are 4 teams between the hawks and #11 spot
 

10001110101

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2003
1,332
1,779
113
Maybe they didn't move up Iowa because they think they are going to lose. They would look kind of stupid moving Iowa up 2 -3 spots just for them to lose against Illinois. Fair or unfair Osu and Oregon pass the "eye test" over Iowa which is why they are ranked higher. Iowa just needs to take care of business. They may not get in the playoff but I don't see a 3 loss Osu or Oregon getting in over them.
I wish some of you would make a sincere attempt to get your mind more aligned with reality.

Some of the off the wall rationalizing I've read on here has been fascinating.

Reality is: They boldly and shamelessly favor bluebloods, the sec, and of course their very very mostest favoritist: sec bluebloods.
 

RuggieC

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2014
655
1,291
93
Let's see how close I was:

1. Georgia 9-1
2. Utah 10-0
3. Alabama 8-2
4. UCLA 10-0
5. Notre Dame 9-1 (down 1)
6. Texas 8-2 (up 1)
7. Miami 9-1
8. Tennessee 8-2 (down 1)
9. Indiana 9-1 (up 1)
10. Wake Forest 9-1 (down 1)
11. BYU 8-2 (up 1)
12. Texas Tech 9-1
13. Oregon 7-3
14. Ohio State 7-3
15. Iowa 8-2
16. Boise State 9-1 (down 1)
17. Kentucky 7-3 (up 1)
18. Houston 7-3 (down 2)
19. USC 7-3 (up 1)
20. Arizona 7-3 (up 1)
21. Oklahoma 6-4 (down 1)
22. Louisville 7-3 (down 1)
23. South Carolina 6-4 (up 2)
24. Florida 6-4
25. Liberty 9-1 (not ranked)

Outside looking in: Mississippi (6-4), LSU 6-4, Duke 7-3), North Dakota State (8-2), Wyoming (7-3), UTSA (8-2), Memphis (8-2), Missouri 6-4, Auburn 6-4, Louisiana Tech (8-2

Bigger brands, better athletes, proven success against top flight teams. Not too mention a majority of America would rather watch a game with either of those 2 teams over Iowa. Right or wrong there is still a not great national perception of Iowa.
Yeah I wish we had the National Brand of Wake Forest, BYU and Texas Tech. :(
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football Hawkeye Report Podcast
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Football Hawkeye Report Podcast with Trevor Lauck
  3. 03 Rivals Football Recruiting Four-star Iowa QB commit Chase Grove talks latest experience inside Kinnick Stadium
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Football Kelvin Bell talks Iowa defensive line development
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Basketball WATCH: Jan Jensen, Hawkeyes recap Vandy, preview Montana State