Unpopular Opinion: The Portal is Not the Way to Build a Program

615dawg

All-American
Jun 4, 2007
7,501
5,334
113
The top seven teams in the SEC have something in common - they are building their programs with recruits they sign out of high school. The only SEC teams ranked in this week's CFP Top 25 that has more snaps played by portal signees than high school signees is No. 25 Ole Miss and an upstart Kentucky.

High School Lebby believes the opposite. He believes that we can raid the portal to build a team. While you can get some pieces, you cannot build a competitive team using the portal only.

 

hatfieldms

All-Conference
Feb 20, 2008
8,799
2,611
113
The better teams are able to hold on to their higher rated recruits. We get then to come in, have a great season and then they bolt.

sure you have your acceptions but for the most part you are fighting to keep anyone who is somewhat successful

it has to be a good belt of recruiting and portal
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,473
33,336
113
The better teams are able to hold on to their higher rated recruits. We get then to come in, have a great season and then they bolt.

sure you have your acceptions but for the most part you are fighting to keep anyone who is somewhat successful

it has to be a good belt of recruiting and portal
We're not losing many of our players that way. Very few. A couple of WRs, who we really didn't want to keep anyway and replaced with as good or better receivers, and a very mediocre QB (although what I wouldn't give for a very mediocre QB now). The problem is we're just not recruiting many good players to begin with.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,473
33,336
113
You have to have some of both. Use the portal as a supplement, not to bring in 40 new transfers every year. You can't just bring in an all-star team in June and expect them to gel by September. Or even December/January.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Captain Ron

8dog

All-American
Feb 23, 2008
15,326
7,754
113
The top seven teams in the SEC have something in common - they are building their programs with recruits they sign out of high school. The only SEC teams ranked in this week's CFP Top 25 that has more snaps played by portal signees than high school signees is No. 25 Ole Miss and an upstart Kentucky.

High School Lebby believes the opposite. He believes that we can raid the portal to build a team. While you can get some pieces, you cannot build a competitive team using the portal only.

Well in fairness to coaches the portal has everyone thinking there are no rebuilds anymore so it puts pressure on new coaches to have immediate impact. Look where all the new coaches are on that chart.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hatfieldms

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,678
13,494
113
Dude our fans think the same way, this isn't some new concept - all our fans and talking heads and anyone else can talk about it who we gonna muh buy out of the portal

We have no concept of how to develop and retain, if you can't play immediately we run you off, which is rich coming from a program with our history

It is truly hilarious watching all of our fans come around to the points I was trying to make 3 years ago, when all anybody could think about was the portal and running off Leach's young players because he muh tanked the program

And by the way, there's no plan that works across the board, Clemson used only high school kids and they suck, Ole Miss has been heavy portal for years and had the most success in their history
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,303
5,857
113
The top seven teams in the SEC have something in common - they are building their programs with recruits they sign out of high school. The only SEC teams ranked in this week's CFP Top 25 that has more snaps played by portal signees than high school signees is No. 25 Ole Miss and an upstart Kentucky.

High School Lebby believes the opposite. He believes that we can raid the portal to build a team. While you can get some pieces, you cannot build a competitive team using the portal only.

I don't disagree with the general point, but we don't suck because we relied too much on the portal. We would definitely be in better shape if we had some more good freshmen and sophomores that had been recruited here out of high school. But the biggest problem we have talent wise is that we don't have a serviceable backup QB. I can understand that being hard to get when you have a generational talent that's a sophomore that's clearly going to be the starter. The second biggest problem is we are short one OT. To my knowledge we have never had the luxury of having a good OT in every class, and they are obviously a hot commodity in the transfer portal. We need one more good DL, and that is probably the most damning for Lebby. We should be able to have a decent DL at this point.

But mostly the problem is just that Lebby sucks. It's not the balance between portal and high school recruiting. If we had a young OT we signed out of high school that would be good in another year or two, that would be great, but it wouldn't fix this years team. And I don't think the way the team has fallen apart without KT is just missing KT. We have a culture problem and lack of coaching in general that KT helped hide, but we have a problem with this team that is beyond talent.
 

lazlow

Senior
Jul 9, 2009
1,417
734
113
The top seven teams in the SEC have something in common - they are building their programs with recruits they sign out of high school. The only SEC teams ranked in this week's CFP Top 25 that has more snaps played by portal signees than high school signees is No. 25 Ole Miss and an upstart Kentucky.

High School Lebby believes the opposite. He believes that we can raid the portal to build a team. While you can get some pieces, you cannot build a competitive team using the portal only.

Lol, lurking variables. I think the question isn’t why do shark attacks trend with ice cream sales, but what do the two have in common?

and what do uk and um have in common?
 
  • Like
Reactions: POTUS
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout
  2. 02 Maroon and White Chris Jans proud of Mississippi State's "must-win" performance on the road at UCF
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Injury Update: QB AJ Swann and S Isaac Smith to miss Senior Day game
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Tennessee Tech Players to Know
  5. 05 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 86-83 UCF: Bulldogs earn road win in fight from start to finish with Golden Knights