CFP proving it's about politics and name brand

BlIIlken2

All-Conference
Dec 4, 2021
1,872
4,911
112
Sarcastic Yeah Right GIF by Ryn Dean
 

bansheexyz

Junior
Sep 24, 2017
155
380
63
If Iowa wins at Illinois by double digits, we have to pass Oregon who lost by double digits to them. "Signature wins" cannot be a thing, this isn't basketball where every team plays 32 games and thus every team has opportunities to pick up signature wins. Football is very different, there are only 12 games and teams don't control the opportunities given. The metric thus has to be based on stats and margins of victory against similar competition. OSU also is a shadow of who they were when they beat Iowa, so Oregon's result isn't equivalent.
 

Fight4Iowa

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
471
672
93
I think if Iowa wins out and covers the spreads, they'll be in the playoffs barring Oregon winning in the B1G championship game.

Illinois hung around with UCLA @ UCLA. If Iowa covers @ Illinois, the committee will reward them by jumping them over Oregon if Oregon doesn't cover spread by more than a TD.

Ohio State beating Nebraska at Nebraska is more what we should be worried about. Ohio State is a bigger threat to our playoffs than Oregon, I think. Because they own the head ro head, yes, different team, with Sayin, but they won the game handily.
 

Hawk-A-Doodle-Doo

All-Conference
Oct 1, 2001
1,038
2,932
93
I think if Iowa wins out and covers the spreads, they'll be in the playoffs barring Oregon winning in the B1G championship game.

Illinois hung around with UCLA @ UCLA. If Iowa covers @ Illinois, the committee will reward them by jumping them over Oregon if Oregon doesn't cover spread by more than a TD.

Ohio State beating Nebraska at Nebraska is more what we should be worried about. Ohio State is a bigger threat to our playoffs than Oregon, I think. Because they own the head ro head, yes, different team, with Sayin, but they won the game handily.
Its Over GIF
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,468
4,349
113
I think if Iowa wins out and covers the spreads, they'll be in the playoffs barring Oregon winning in the B1G championship game.

Illinois hung around with UCLA @ UCLA. If Iowa covers @ Illinois, the committee will reward them by jumping them over Oregon if Oregon doesn't cover spread by more than a TD.

Ohio State beating Nebraska at Nebraska is more what we should be worried about. Ohio State is a bigger threat to our playoffs than Oregon, I think. Because they own the head ro head, yes, different team, with Sayin, but they won the game handily.
Nbc Thats Adorable GIF by Superstore
 
Feb 25, 2008
33,256
32,635
113
They keep us at 15 instead of dropping us?
I honestly expect them to drop us next week even if we win (because a few other teams behind us that they "value" more won their games).


But also because ole Kirk will treat this game against Illinois just like every other road game where we have to play as minimalist and afraid to make mistakes as possible..........
 
  • Like
Reactions: DukeSlater

carrier9

Freshman
Oct 21, 2014
45
64
18
I think if Iowa wins out and covers the spreads, they'll be in the playoffs barring Oregon winning in the B1G championship game.

Illinois hung around with UCLA @ UCLA. If Iowa covers @ Illinois, the committee will reward them by jumping them over Oregon if Oregon doesn't cover spread by more than a TD.

Ohio State beating Nebraska at Nebraska is more what we should be worried about. Ohio State is a bigger threat to our playoffs than Oregon, I think. Because they own the head ro head, yes, different team, with Sayin, but they won the game handily.
Don't discount the Jeremiah Smith factor. A lot of eyeballs will be watching while he finishes up his College career
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fight4Iowa

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,784
16,140
113
Its cute that you think computer rankings such as these can't be fed and taught bias.

No matter what, unpopular teams (like Iowa) are always gonna get screwed.
I know that computer rankings begin the year with recent history and recruiting rankings factoring in heavily. That's what drives most of the bias in those and why they tend to be extremely slow moving with regards to actual results. Oregon is a good case in point. As bad as they were throughout the middle of the season, they never dropped out of the top 10 in rankings like Sagarin. Same with Ohio St and LSU who have 3 and 4 losses respectively.
 

DukeSlater

All-American
Jul 2, 2023
2,549
5,590
113
Selection committee making their case to be replaced with computers.
Except if you input biased info, you'll get biased results with computers too. Since the machines were invented, this has been true: GIGO--garbage in, garbage out. So with the committee, they've simply eliminated the computers while still giving college football garbage results with NO transparency, NO established criteria, and NO accountability, just like the MAGA dictatorship.
 

DukeSlater

All-American
Jul 2, 2023
2,549
5,590
113
Sagarin and Massey both have Iowa 13 with OSU and Oregon ahead of them. Sagarin has UCLA 15. Computers spit out what they get fed. Iowa and UCLA's SoS kills them.
So it would have been better for Iowa to lose to Georgia or Wake Forest or any SEC team than to beat ISU, just one more reason the ISU game should be scrapped. It NEVER helps Iowa in any way, any shape, or any form, but it often hurts them, win or lose.
 

DukeSlater

All-American
Jul 2, 2023
2,549
5,590
113
Don't discount the Jeremiah Smith factor. A lot of eyeballs will be watching while he finishes up his College career
Smith is good, sure, but he's also overrated as hell. And it's ALL about him. Just ask him. Or just watch him. He has no business in the Heisman conversation, IMHO.
 

DukeSlater

All-American
Jul 2, 2023
2,549
5,590
113
ESPN talking about how nobody wants to play Oregon right now:ROFLMAO:. GTFO. Won at Ohio St, who had pull one out of the fire at home against NW last week and a Michigan team who doesnt want to be there. Id love to see Iowa go after Raiola again and make him look like the punk he actually is
Iowa would LOVE to play Oregon right now. Hell, KF should demand Iowa play Oregon at a neutral site next Tuesday just to warm up for the Nebraska game.
 

WeBeHerkin

All-American
Aug 5, 2016
5,824
6,573
113
I think if Iowa wins out and covers the spreads, they'll be in the playoffs barring Oregon winning in the B1G championship game.

Illinois hung around with UCLA @ UCLA. If Iowa covers @ Illinois, the committee will reward them by jumping them over Oregon if Oregon doesn't cover spread by more than a TD.

Ohio State beating Nebraska at Nebraska is more what we should be worried about. Ohio State is a bigger threat to our playoffs than Oregon, I think. Because they own the head ro head, yes, different team, with Sayin, but they won the game handily.
If by a miracle we get in the BTCG against UCLA we will beat their asses, no doubt
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Basketball Iowa Women's Basketball Tip Time Preview: Utah Utes
  2. 02 On3 Football College Football Rankings: AP Poll Top 25 after Week 12 released
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football FILM BREAKDOWN: Every Hank Brown pass attempt from the game against Illinois
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Football PFF Grades - Iowa defense vs Illinois
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Football PFF Grades - Iowa offense vs Illinois