MC @ LW-East - The Rematch!

Jul 9, 2025
447
522
93
Luckily the transfer portal was "wide open" so the QB that had given three years to the LWE program and Coach Z (and had older siblings that went through the program) was able to find a home at Marist.

BINGO OnVikings! you nailed it. Not too many people know about the above little nugget ^^^^^^^^^ do they! I first heard about it from a Coach at LWC and later confirmed it with a Coach at LWW. Zvonar had no problem screwing over a legacy who had given his all to the program in favor of Jonas. I'd heard for years from many area sources that he was another sellout chasing wins. He did do a nice job getting LWE football off the ground I'll give him that, but I always knew it wasn't about the kids with him. His cheapshots at the Catholic schools will go down as part of his legacy just like they did with Dan D over at Morris and Otto Z at R-B.
 
Last edited:

OnVikings!

Senior
Nov 15, 2024
364
562
87
Understood OnVikings on the R family and again the toughest game Loyola had was based on his performance while at Marist. Very happy he found a home. The path for the 3 transfers I am sure were from exposure/training camps that were commonly attended and with situations that existed with coaching at prior schools choices were made. Sounds like you are familiar with travel sports and the like. Common ground and exposure is appreciated communicating with you. What I don’t understand is your critique of a head coach who is speaking about a topic all HS public coaches discuss routinely. The IHSA will make the call eventually. Personally I don’t think the IHSA has a clue.
You may be correct about the exposure/training camps. I know a lot of these kids play 7-on-7 together as well. Anyone familiar with good HS football programs knows that your kids are your best recruiters. My critique of Z and his comments is that he is being critical of a practice that he has benefited from for years. It's hypocritical. And some might argue that it happening at a boundried school like LWE is not within the rules.
Again, he is a great coach, and by all accounts is a great person. I was always impressed with him when I'd see him out recruiting at youth games. However, I think he should have bit his tongue on those parting words. It definitely tarnishes his legacy. At least from my perspective.
 

OnVikings!

Senior
Nov 15, 2024
364
562
87
I seem to remember someone posting about him back in July and saying how he wasn't being recruited to sit on the bench and that he'd be the starter. Many MC folks ridiculed me and told me there were two "legacy" QBs in front of him and that his numbers at PE weren't good and that he'd never start and it made no sense why he'd transfer.

One of these days you people will listen to me.
I didn't see that coming at all. I don't think a lot of people "in the know" did either.
 

OnVikings!

Senior
Nov 15, 2024
364
562
87
Luckily the transfer portal was "wide open" so the QB that had given three years to the LWE program and Coach Z (and had older siblings that went through the program) was able to find a home at Marist.

BINGO OnVikings! you nailed it. Not too many people know about the above little nugget ^^^^^^^^^ do they! I first heard about it from a Coach at LWC and later confirmed it with a Coach at LWW. Zvonar had no problem screwing over a legacy who had given his all to the program in favor of Jonas. I'd heard for years from many area sources that he was another sellout chasing wins. He did do a nice job getting LWE football off the ground I'll give him that, but I always knew it wasn't about the kids with him. His cheapshots at the Catholic schools will go down as part of his legacy just like they did with Dan D over at Morris and Otto Z at R-B.
Dad is an StL alum too. Would've loved to see all those kids be Vikings.
 

WIU@78

All-Conference
Dec 27, 2006
8,256
1,087
66
Luckily the transfer portal was "wide open" so the QB that had given three years to the LWE program and Coach Z (and had older siblings that went through the program) was able to find a home at Marist.

BINGO OnVikings! you nailed it. Not too many people know about the above little nugget ^^^^^^^^^ do they! I first heard about it from a Coach at LWC and later confirmed it with a Coach at LWW. Zvonar had no problem screwing over a legacy who had given his all to the program in favor of Jonas. I'd heard for years from many area sources that he was another sellout chasing wins. He did do a nice job getting LWE football off the ground I'll give him that, but I always knew it wasn't about the kids with him. His cheapshots at the Catholic schools will go down as part of his legacy just like they did with Dan D over at Morris and Otto Z at ?
 

McCaravan

All-American
Feb 1, 2016
5,592
8,724
113
I seem to remember someone posting about him back in July and saying how he wasn't being recruited to sit on the bench and that he'd be the starter. Many MC folks ridiculed me and told me there were two "legacy" QBs in front of him and that his numbers at PE weren't good and that he'd never start and it made no sense why he'd transfer.

One of these days you people will listen to me.
I have no problem saying it was me. He came into MC to compete for a starting role. That role was given to Ryder Startz to start the season. He broke his collarbone in two places against ESL that required surgery and Cloherty was inserted full time and had done very well. With the receivers and TE MC had I'm confident Startz would have had similar success and more rushing yards as his running ability won him the spot out of camp. We will never know. From what I've seen out of Elliott in mop up duty he will be very similar to his brother the next 2 seasons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WIU@78 and Jenny27

WIU@78

All-Conference
Dec 27, 2006
8,256
1,087
66
Carmine you are delusional and should apply for a job with the Sun Times. Do you even know where LWW and LWC are located? Did you contact Provi also? If you had that assumption of chasing wins over athletes development as men would be muted. You do know the QB to Marist family currently has an athlete at LWE? Community counts.
 
Last edited:

sporthog_9er

All-Conference
Jun 9, 2001
1,381
1,237
113
I personally believe he did not communicate his quotes and comments here really well. There is a difference. There is a difference where one school requires families to move into a set boundary to attend, and the other can go outside of a normal boundary to get kids. I think that is what is being lost in Z's comments. Nobody is denying that LWE benefitted from getting some kids to move to LWE district. I believe what he was frustrated about is catholic schools getting the ability to go up to that 30 mile radius to get athletes, something a public cannot do- unless that family decides to move. Privates have to recruit to maintain operating- they have to do it! They need to do it. But bottom line it is a different set of rules that the two schools have to abide by. I think that is where his frustration was, and it was communicated poorly (and definitely communicated to the wrong reporter, again).
 
  • Like
Reactions: WIU@78

LWN_Pheonix

Senior
Oct 30, 2023
1,125
924
113
I personally believe he did not communicate his quotes and comments here really well. There is a difference. There is a difference where one school requires families to move into a set boundary to attend, and the other can go outside of a normal boundary to get kids. I think that is what is being lost in Z's comments. Nobody is denying that LWE benefitted from getting some kids to move to LWE district. I believe what he was frustrated about is catholic schools getting the ability to go up to that 30 mile radius to get athletes, something a public cannot do- unless that family decides to move. Privates have to recruit to maintain operating- they have to do it! They need to do it. But bottom line it is a different set of rules that the two schools have to abide by. I think that is where his frustration was, and it was communicated poorly (and definitely communicated to the wrong reporter, again).
What if a player on the offense lives in ten city of Chicago with his mom… and uses his aunts address in Frankfort

would you that is an acceptable way to attend a public school

hypothetical question….
 

johnndoe

Senior
Oct 19, 2019
1,281
918
113
Question: Could the MC/LWE match-up be considered comparable to an elite travel baseball team playing a squad with the best record from a top tier in-house league?
 

AlBundy33

Redshirt
Oct 9, 2025
12
17
3
I personally believe he did not communicate his quotes and comments here really well. There is a difference. There is a difference where one school requires families to move into a set boundary to attend, and the other can go outside of a normal boundary to get kids. I think that is what is being lost in Z's comments. Nobody is denying that LWE benefitted from getting some kids to move to LWE district. I believe what he was frustrated about is catholic schools getting the ability to go up to that 30 mile radius to get athletes, something a public cannot do- unless that family decides to move. Privates have to recruit to maintain operating- they have to do it! They need to do it. But bottom line it is a different set of rules that the two schools have to abide by. I think that is where his frustration was, and it was communicated poorly (and definitely communicated to the wrong reporter, again).
I agree with that. I do think he got caught up in the moment.

I just want to add a few points....It's not always about recruitment. For example, LW-East is a huge high school and many kids who would start at almost any other program never end up seeing the field at a school like East. Kids choose to go private for more opportunity. Kids often have the opportunity to play the position they have been playing in youth football and can even play both ways in some cases. Also, they can play at the Varsity level much sooner as well. At East it doesn't work that way. There are so many kids and often a stud LB maybe forced to become a defensive linemen or a QB now becomes a receiver. Mom and Dad feel little Johnny will have more opportunity so they choose to go private. Sometimes I think some public schools would benefit from having tryouts and reducing numbers. It may sway the kid who is considering going private to stay public. Just a thought.
 

mwesley78

Redshirt
Oct 14, 2021
1
0
0
I agree with that. I do think he got caught up in the moment.

I just want to add a few points....It's not always about recruitment. For example, LW-East is a huge high school and many kids who would start at almost any other program never end up seeing the field at a school like East. Kids choose to go private for more opportunity. Kids often have the opportunity to play the position they have been playing in youth football and can even play both ways in some cases. Also, they can play at the Varsity level much sooner as well. At East it doesn't work that way. There are so many kids and often a stud LB maybe forced to become a defensive linemen or a QB now becomes a receiver. Mom and Dad feel little Johnny will have more opportunity so they choose to go private. Sometimes I think some public schools would benefit from having tryouts and reducing numbers. It may sway the kid who is considering going private to stay public. Just a thought.
Reducing numbers is a great way to kill the game.
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,715
4,446
113
I personally believe he did not communicate his quotes and comments here really well. There is a difference. There is a difference where one school requires families to move into a set boundary to attend, and the other can go outside of a normal boundary to get kids. I think that is what is being lost in Z's comments. Nobody is denying that LWE benefitted from getting some kids to move to LWE district. I believe what he was frustrated about is catholic schools getting the ability to go up to that 30 mile radius to get athletes, something a public cannot do- unless that family decides to move. Privates have to recruit to maintain operating- they have to do it! They need to do it. But bottom line it is a different set of rules that the two schools have to abide by. I think that is where his frustration was, and it was communicated poorly (and definitely communicated to the wrong reporter, again).
He is a grown man, that is on him and deserves the criticism, this is not a 17 year old.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Dave Brody

WIU@78

All-Conference
Dec 27, 2006
8,256
1,087
66
So…this years fall guy on the private / public debate is the LWE retiring head coach. If you have been around long enough this topic is nothing new. Being Catholic myself I have lived and seen both sides for what…40 years. The difference lately has been the atrocious nature of Chicago public schools for student development. The rebuke is look at basketball…yep you only need 3 studs to make an impact in hoops which is way more manageable compared to football. If you really want an education for your student Benet Academy and Iggy are your choices. It really is not much different from travel sports anymore where camps and friends are made and plans are hatched. Coaching styles and focus may not match Johnnie’s skills so we move on. I would love to see the conversations at BR when QB developer made his pitch. If anyone thinks the IHSA has any control of the nature of recruiting you are dreaming.
 
  • Like
Reactions: USD24

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,715
4,446
113
So…this years fall guy on the private / public debate is the LWE retiring head coach. If you have been around long enough this topic is nothing new. Being Catholic myself I have lived and seen both sides for what…40 years. The difference lately has been the atrocious nature of Chicago public schools for student development. The rebuke is look at basketball…yep you only need 3 studs to make an impact in hoops which is way more manageable compared to football. If you really want an education for your student Benet Academy and Iggy are your choices. It really is not much different from travel sports anymore where camps and friends are made and plans are hatched. Coaching styles and focus may not match Johnnie’s skills so we move on. I would love to see the conversations at BR when QB developer made his pitch. If anyone thinks the IHSA has any control of the nature of recruiting you are dreaming.
Fall guy? He opened his mouth.
You pointing out only Benet and Saint Ignatius as the only two private schools you can really get an education is pure silliness and not even a point in any of this conversation.
It is like travel sports across all schools, agree.
No one is saying the IHSA has control of the situation. That has been conveyed over and over on this board. The IHSA doesn't care to police it.
 

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
205
189
31
So…this years fall guy on the private / public debate is the LWE retiring head coach. If you have been around long enough this topic is nothing new. Being Catholic myself I have lived and seen both sides for what…40 years. The difference lately has been the atrocious nature of Chicago public schools for student development. The rebuke is look at basketball…yep you only need 3 studs to make an impact in hoops which is way more manageable compared to football. If you really want an education for your student Benet Academy and Iggy are your choices. It really is not much different from travel sports anymore where camps and friends are made and plans are hatched. Coaching styles and focus may not match Johnnie’s skills so we move on. I would love to see the conversations at BR when QB developer made his pitch. If anyone thinks the IHSA has any control of the nature of recruiting you are dreaming.

So I’m assuming you’re talking about Greg Holcomb. What pitch do you think was made
 
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football 8A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football 7A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football 6A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  4. 04 Edgy Tim 5A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  5. 05 Edgy Tim Football 4A: Semifinalist Player of the Year