I think we're way past the point where we can ever expect the NCAA to do a good job at pretty much anything they get involved with. At this point it feels like a corrupted organization that now just exists as a toll taker middle man between the fans and the schools (and the conferences they belong to). The NCAA doesn't enforce academic standards, they no longer enforce impermissible benefits rules now that NIL is a thing, and it's been abundantly clear that they have terrible lawyers considering how much the structure that used to be college sports has just imploded and they seem to lose anything they try to fight against. I'm honestly not sure what value they even bring to the table at this point....I guess they arrange national tournaments? The schools and conferences seem to do most of everything (deal with eligibility, schedule games, hire referees, provide facilities, etc.) and the courts seem to be the only enforcement mechanism now (a very wildly inconsistent one at that). I just think about the movie Office Space...I want to sit the head of the NCAA down and ask "what exactly do you do here?"
I'm not a conspiracy theory person at all, but I'm also not ignorant. When you place people from conferences and schools on selection committees where their teams are participating in that tournament... and let them make judgment calls, there is always going to be the problem of human bias. Not sure there is a perfect solution...if you try to derive a formula to take all judgment out of the equation, at some point there will be some scenario that seems unjust. For example, beating a team with their best player injured shouldn't count the same as beating them at full strength, but formulas probably wouldn't be able to take that into account. And one of the main inputs will likely be rankings, which are always subjective, filled with human judgment, and usually never get it right outside of maybe the top few teams. But with the amount of money and emotions involved in college sports, there is no way in hell there aren't decisions being made behind closed doors to benefit one school or the other depending on who is sitting on the selection committees. The process should at least be more transparent so you could see exactly who voted for what, but obviously that will never happen with how the NCAA does things.
The best thing will probably end up being to just let AI be the selection committee in the future and get rid of the flawed humans...the robots are coming for all of our jobs. Anyways, I'm just shouting at the clouds, nothing is going to change anything.