Good read on Beamer's communication issues

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,761
18,457
113
For the record, I'm still in Beamer's corner, but there are some areas where I would like to see some growth. One is in his communication. I would like to see him develop a more even keeled demeanor. He's goofily happy after wins and bristly after losses. This is a pretty good read on his shortcomings in this area. Kind of lengthy.


A notable excerpt that highlights a recurring theme:

"The loss to Arkansas wasn't a fluke or some mysterious football anomaly that can be dismissed with a reminder that the team had a bad night. South Carolina turned the football over four times, went 1-for-5 in red-zone scoring, and committed 12 penalties for 91 yards. The Gamecocks had opportunities to make the game competitive and repeatedly shot themselves in the cleats. Beamer acknowledged the mistakes. Cool. He acknowledged the disappointment. Great. He acknowledged that the team wasn't good enough. Awesome.
But acknowledging a problem and correcting it are two very different responsibilities, and this is where the juggernaut of frustration with Shane Beamer becomes more difficult to dismiss.
The South Carolina Gamecocks have experienced enough recurring problems that the conversation should have moved beyond identifying what went wrong. Preparation, execution, discipline, offensive consistency, in-game adjustments, and communication have all become part of a larger conversation about the direction of the program. At some point, a program can't keep treating every disastrous performance as an isolated setback. Because eventually, the setbacks become the story."
 
  • Like
Reactions: sclawman77

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,780
3,396
113
For the record, I'm still in Beamer's corner, but there are some areas where I would like to see some growth. One is in his communication. I would like to see him develop a more even keeled demeanor. He's goofily happy after wins and bristly after losses. This is a pretty good read on his shortcomings in this area. Kind of lengthy.


A notable excerpt that highlights a recurring theme:

"The loss to Arkansas wasn't a fluke or some mysterious football anomaly that can be dismissed with a reminder that the team had a bad night. South Carolina turned the football over four times, went 1-for-5 in red-zone scoring, and committed 12 penalties for 91 yards. The Gamecocks had opportunities to make the game competitive and repeatedly shot themselves in the cleats. Beamer acknowledged the mistakes. Cool. He acknowledged the disappointment. Great. He acknowledged that the team wasn't good enough. Awesome.
But acknowledging a problem and correcting it are two very different responsibilities, and this is where the juggernaut of frustration with Shane Beamer becomes more difficult to dismiss.
The South Carolina Gamecocks have experienced enough recurring problems that the conversation should have moved beyond identifying what went wrong. Preparation, execution, discipline, offensive consistency, in-game adjustments, and communication have all become part of a larger conversation about the direction of the program. At some point, a program can't keep treating every disastrous performance as an isolated setback. Because eventually, the setbacks become the story."
Yes, I don't like his lack of control on his emotions. Enthusiasm is fine. But him being goofy and bristly is different. He is nearly 50. I grew up watching Cowboys legend Tom Landry. I lean to preferring more towards that conservative demeanor.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rhode Island Dork

kidrobinski

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2004
1,783
1,547
113
Yes, I don't like his lack of control on his emotions. Enthusiasm is fine. But him being goofy and bristly is different. He is nearly 50. I grew up watching Cowboys legend Tom Landry. I lean to preferring more towards that conservative demeanor.
I grew up watching Vince Lombardi. Mike Ditka. Jimmy Jones. Etc. Conservative demeanor they weren’t.

Maybe you guys can lobby your guy Donati to get Beams to take a Dale Carnegie course.
 

sclawman77

All-Conference
Jun 27, 2011
1,928
1,748
113
You can tell when Beamer starts getting very defensive about something because he stares at the floor and starts talking out of the side of his mouth.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Rhode Island Dork

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,780
3,396
113
I grew up watching Vince Lombardi. Mike Ditka. Jimmy Jones. Etc. Conservative demeanor they weren’t.

Maybe you guys can lobby your guy Donati to get Beams to take a Dale Carnegie course.
kidrobinski, you are no dummy. You know everybody has a different personality. So, it stands to reason that everybody has a preference. When Beamer was hired, he said that his Dad advised him to "be himself". I had no idea what that meant at the time. I do now. That's not my style. Spurrier, Morrison, Carlen were nothing like that. As they say, to each his own.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,761
18,457
113
I dont think that, I just think he desperately wants everyone to tell him how smart he thinks he is.
For me, it's just that he's hyper aware of outside criticism and reactionary in his pressers. Even though he says he doesn't pay attention to outside noise.

Even just the way he responds to wins. After the UT win, he unprovoked went on a rant about the conspiracy theories surrounding our big win against them a few years ago. Then after the OU win, he again unprovoked went on about he we didn't catch the SEC flu.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,609
6,157
113
For me, it's just that he's hyper aware of outside criticism and reactionary in his pressers. Even though he says he doesn't pay attention to outside noise.

Even just the way he responds to wins. After the UT win, he unprovoked went on a rant about the conspiracy theories surrounding our big win against them a few years ago. Then after the OU win, he again unprovoked went on about he we didn't catch the SEC flu.

I sgree. I just attribute that to something akin to imposter syndrome. He was brought in to be a cheerleader, from day one. He very desperately wants to be know as a smart coach with gotcha trick plays that sway the game. Almost like he's living in some kind of shadow...
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,167
3,731
113
I sgree. I just attribute that to something akin to imposter syndrome. He was brought in to be a cheerleader, from day one. He very desperately wants to be know as a smart coach with gotcha trick plays that sway the game. Almost like he's living in some kind of shadow...
Maybe he has fully bought into the silliness of "Beamer Ball" the announcers are always yapping about. Trick plays are fun and great when you run them against Kent State or Towson. They usually get blown up when you run them against SEC teams.
 
GamecockCentral

Latest

  1. 01 TheBigSpur Football South Carolina is No. 21 and that gives the Gamecocks a needed boost
  2. 02 GamecockCentral Football CFP Chair Hunter Yurachek explains why South Carolina is still ranked after blowout loss
  3. 03 GamecockCentral Football Everything Georgia HC Kirby Smart said about South Carolina before Week 12 matchup
  4. 04 GamecockCentral Basketball Three burning questions ahead of South Carolina's matchup with Elon
  5. 05 GamecockCentral Football Recruiting South Carolina football's team recruiting ranking following ratings updates