So what does the Dem win really mean?

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,059
5,720
113
Republican haven't offered a plan for this, for the same reason I don't wear Badger gear,... We don't like the program,... Good luck with your attempted repairs.

To be fair, they haven't offered a plan to improve healthcare....ever?
 

dpic73

Heisman
Jul 27, 2005
37,297
35,085
113
Republicans haven't offered a plan for this, for the same reason I don't wear Badger gear,... We don't like the program,... Good luck with your attempted repairs.
Same ole Republican plan for everything - cut taxes and blow shi.t up, literally and figuratively and then blame Democrats for the fallout.
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,059
5,720
113
The topic under discussion was enhanced ACA subsidies, initiated during covid and terminated in 2025 by Democrats...

Fine, I'll concede that to you because I'm tired of the point. Everyone thinks healthcare is too expensive. Republicans don't want to do the ACA, fine. What's a decent plan they actually have? I've yet to hear one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dpic73

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,570
24,204
113
Fine, I'll concede that to you because I'm tired of the point. Everyone thinks healthcare is too expensive. Republicans don't want to do the ACA, fine. What's a decent plan they actually have? I've yet to hear one.

They don’t have a plan. It’s literally the issue that had me basically drop from being “pro-Republican” to “keep the democrats from doing dumb shlt” in 2017. Years and years of “repeal and replace.” Then zero plan for replacement. That was the light bulb moment for me that they were totally worthless.
 

Rifler

All-American
Jan 26, 2011
6,710
7,569
113
Fine, I'll concede that to you because I'm tired of the point. Everyone thinks healthcare is too expensive. Republicans don't want to do the ACA, fine. What's a decent plan they actually have? I've yet to hear one.

Here's my approach..
Single payer government safety net program for "basic" care, everyone is covered,.. On top of this is where private insurance carriers would function by offering supplemental plans, either through employers or on the open market, to individuals that wanted and could afford to pay for a higher level of coverage,... This single payer "basic" system would need to be audited on an annual basis to confirm the financial state of the program. When necessary adjustments would be made to the defined list of basic services covered so as to ensure that the system remains financially viable, and the level of services covered acceptable,.. With this approach everybody has at least "basic" coverage, which I think is the primary goal.
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,059
5,720
113
Here's my approach..
Single payer government safety net program for "basic" care, everyone is covered,.. On top of this is where private insurance carriers would function by offering supplemental plans, either through employers or on the open market, to individuals that wanted and could afford to pay for a higher level of coverage,... This single payer "basic" system would need to be audited on an annual basis to confirm the financial state of the program. When necessary adjustments would be made to the defined list of basic services covered so as to ensure that the system remains financially viable, and the level of services covered acceptable,.. With this approach everybody has at least "basic" coverage, which I think is the primary goal.

I wish your party supported something like that but it sounds a lot like SoCiAlIsM to me.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,674
6,984
113
But doesn't Trump have the CONCEPTS of a Healthcare Plan? Asking for a friend...
does he need one..we have the ACA.....wasn't that going to solve the healthcare issue, insure all 41 million Americans without coverage, lower costs, save every family $2500... seems there are short memories among us...

yea I know, trump's fault
 
  • Haha
Reactions: hopefultiger13

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,674
6,984
113
Fine, I'll concede that to you because I'm tired of the point. Everyone thinks healthcare is too expensive. Republicans don't want to do the ACA, fine. What's a decent plan they actually have? I've yet to hear one.
you might have missed this..the governor of colorado, which just declared that current Medicaid costs are unsustainable...multiple reasons. Might provide some good information on possible results for a Medicare for all system...not saying you are for a Medicare or single payer system
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,674
6,984
113
I wish your party supported something like that but it sounds a lot like SoCiAlIsM to me.
aren't Medicaid and Medicare like that? we could have catastrophic programs, but current federal law has so many caveats

I'm going to withhold judgement until I see what a Democrat controlled Congress proposes on healthcare. There's a part of me that feels that their answer will be more money....and that might be an answer..but not the only answer
 

hopefultiger13

Heisman
Aug 20, 2008
11,435
18,414
113
does he need one..we have the ACA.....wasn't that going to solve the healthcare issue, insure all 41 million Americans without coverage, lower costs, save every family $2500... seems there are short memories among us...

yea I know, trump's fault
LMAO... Indeed there are some short memories. I've never called the ACA perfect in any way. But Dude, Trump and the Republicans have done everything they can to dismantle the ACA with no plan at all to back it up. They eliminated the mandate, Trump slashed money funding it several times.

Again, the ACA was never perfect, not even close. BUT it was a way to help folks with healthcare. The USA is the richest country in the world. And we have a healthcare system that sucks donkey balls and yet we somehow pay more than any other country for it. The Republicans have NO PLAN, they never did, despite Trump telling us all multiple times that it was coming soon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dpic73

Rifler

All-American
Jan 26, 2011
6,710
7,569
113
I wish your party supported something like that but it sounds a lot like SoCiAlIsM to me.

This wouldn't be socialism, and it would have to pay for itself,... Main problem would lie with the public's acceptance of what the basic plan covered.
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,059
5,720
113
This wouldn't be socialism, and it would have to pay for itself,... Main problem would lie with the public's acceptance of what the basic plan covered.

I know full well that it's not socialism, I'm just pointing out that it's the sort of thing that the GOP has historically falsely declared as socialism.
 

Moogy

All-American
Jul 28, 2017
8,130
5,817
113
Here's my approach..
Single payer government safety net program for "basic" care, everyone is covered,.. On top of this is where private insurance carriers would function by offering supplemental plans, either through employers or on the open market, to individuals that wanted and could afford to pay for a higher level of coverage,... This single payer "basic" system would need to be audited on an annual basis to confirm the financial state of the program. When necessary adjustments would be made to the defined list of basic services covered so as to ensure that the system remains financially viable, and the level of services covered acceptable,.. With this approach everybody has at least "basic" coverage, which I think is the primary goal.

Which sort of things are "basic services"? And which are "extra" so that only those who can afford to pay for private healthcare get them covered?

So, like, if you're a poor, you get an annual physical covered, but if that annual physical shows you might have a brain tumor, you can't pay for the MRI/Catscan? So, a poor just has to wait and see if they die, and then they'll know they had one? Or is an MRI/Catscan a basic service, and you can get that covered, only to find out you have a brain tumor, but then any treatment (chemo/surgery), is on your dime? So a poor can know that they have an operable/treatable brain tumor, but just have to wait to die because they can't afford the coverage to get it treated?

The thing is, the "basic stuff" is the stuff that's most affordable, and most likely for a poor to be able to afford coverage for ... so the government covering that is sort of a kick in the nuts, rather than a true help.
 

Rifler

All-American
Jan 26, 2011
6,710
7,569
113
Which sort of things are "basic services"? And which are "extra" so that only those who can afford to pay for private healthcare get them covered?

So, like, if you're a poor, you get an annual physical covered, but if that annual physical shows you might have a brain tumor, you can't pay for the MRI/Catscan? So, a poor just has to wait and see if they die, and then they'll know they had one? Or is an MRI/Catscan a basic service, and you can get that covered, only to find out you have a brain tumor, but then any treatment (chemo/surgery), is on your dime? So a poor can know that they have an operable/treatable brain tumor, but just have to wait to die because they can't afford the coverage to get it treated?

The thing is, the "basic stuff" is the stuff that's most affordable, and most likely for a poor to be able to afford coverage for ... so the government covering that is sort of a kick in the nuts, rather than a true help.

My approach would be to start with the dollars that the tax base could handle and then draw the line roughly where money runs out,... Going in I think you would have to cover all the normal services such as pre-natal care, deliveries, immunizations, pediatric visits. emergency room services, annual physicals, doctor visits, general lab work and so forth,... We can afford basic care for everyone,.. What we can't afford is unlimited care for everyone.
 

Moogy

All-American
Jul 28, 2017
8,130
5,817
113
My approach would be to start with the dollars that the tax base could handle and then draw the line roughly where money runs out,... Going in I think you would have to cover all the normal services such as pre-natal care, deliveries, immunizations, pediatric visits. emergency room services, annual physicals, doctor visits, general lab work and so forth,... We can afford basic care for everyone,.. What we can't afford is unlimited care for everyone.
Right, so basically, if you're relatively healthy, we got you. If you're really sick, or you think you might be really sick, you're on your own, to cover the stuff you can't afford to cover.
 

Rifler

All-American
Jan 26, 2011
6,710
7,569
113
Right, so basically, if you're relatively healthy, we got you. If you're really sick, or you think you might be really sick, you're on your own, to cover the stuff you can't afford to cover.

I think it reaches well beyond relatively healthy, but yes, at some point uncovered medical issues could be encountered if all you had was the basic coverage... But as I said, we cannot afford unlimited care for everyone, so even thinking that should be the goal is a total pipe dream.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,674
6,984
113
LMAO... Indeed there are some short memories. I've never called the ACA perfect in any way. But Dude, Trump and the Republicans have done everything they can to dismantle the ACA with no plan at all to back it up. They eliminated the mandate, Trump slashed money funding it several times.

Again, the ACA was never perfect, not even close. BUT it was a way to help folks with healthcare. The USA is the richest country in the world. And we have a healthcare system that sucks donkey balls and yet we somehow pay more than any other country for it. The Republicans have NO PLAN, they never did, despite Trump telling us all multiple times that it was coming soon.
forget just for a minute that republicans have no plans....they do, it's called the ACA....yes, they should not have eliminated the mandate..but lets be fair, democrats did NOT offer any bills during Biden admin to restore the mandate. Instead they concentrated on more financial benefits to users.

Also being fair, quite a few of the "problems" with ACA were identified both by republicans, healthcare experts and economists over the provisions of the ACA...most were ignored. At the same time, republicans should have participated in developing the plan. They decided to let domocrats go it alone...which was a mistake, IMO.

The ACA was doomed well before trump...Obama eliminated other funding sources like the Cadillac tax and the tax on medical equipment. Once these went away the funding didn't add up.

All that aside..The ACA has some good points and we should do what we can to correct the flaws. We've had it now for 15 years, we should have the experience to correct the bad and or add to the good. Some are enamored with Medicare for all, and while it really sounds good...free healthcare paid for by the rich...those same people are being "eyed" for taxes to fund social security, national free daycare, expanded Medicaid etc. Before long we're going to run out of rich people
 
  • Like
Reactions: hopefultiger13

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,674
6,984
113
My approach would be to start with the dollars that the tax base could handle and then draw the line roughly where money runs out,... Going in I think you would have to cover all the normal services such as pre-natal care, deliveries, immunizations, pediatric visits. emergency room services, annual physicals, doctor visits, general lab work and so forth,... We can afford basic care for everyone,.. What we can't afford is unlimited care for everyone.
governments don't think like that...In business every year I was given performance targets (always higher) and operating budgets (always lower). The task was to manage to budget and meet goals.

The government, seemingly at all levels, starts with "what do we want to do and what does it cost", and then determines how much do we need to raise taxes to pay for it. (MY HOA seems to operate the same way)
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,674
6,984
113
I think it reaches well beyond relatively healthy, but yes, at some point uncovered medical issues could be encountered if all you had was the basic coverage... But as I said, we cannot afford unlimited care for everyone, so even thinking that should be the goal is a total pipe dream.
we should add back catastrophic insurance. There are so many caveats that not many can qualify, but that would eliminate the extreme medical bills.
 

Rifler

All-American
Jan 26, 2011
6,710
7,569
113
we should add back catastrophic insurance. There are so many caveats that not many can qualify, but that would eliminate the extreme medical bills.

With my approach catastrophic coverage could be picked up with a supplemental policy,... I believe that the basic coverage has to come with a defined limit,.. We can't afford to fund unlimited health care for everyone, when everyone isn't funding the program.
 

hopefultiger13

Heisman
Aug 20, 2008
11,435
18,414
113
forget just for a minute that republicans have no plans....they do, it's called the ACA....yes, they should not have eliminated the mandate..but lets be fair, democrats did NOT offer any bills during Biden admin to restore the mandate. Instead they concentrated on more financial benefits to users.

Also being fair, quite a few of the "problems" with ACA were identified both by republicans, healthcare experts and economists over the provisions of the ACA...most were ignored. At the same time, republicans should have participated in developing the plan. They decided to let domocrats go it alone...which was a mistake, IMO.

The ACA was doomed well before trump...Obama eliminated other funding sources like the Cadillac tax and the tax on medical equipment. Once these went away the funding didn't add up.

All that aside..The ACA has some good points and we should do what we can to correct the flaws. We've had it now for 15 years, we should have the experience to correct the bad and or add to the good. Some are enamored with Medicare for all, and while it really sounds good...free healthcare paid for by the rich...those same people are being "eyed" for taxes to fund social security, national free daycare, expanded Medicaid etc. Before long we're going to run out of rich people
Nice response, I think you are being VERY kind to Republican here on the Health Care, but at least your response doesn't saying how high your T score is while talking about sucking cock... so that's something. I actually do think that Medicare for all is a good idea and that involves a two pronged approach: taxes do indeed cover it. Perhaps increased taxes across the board. But the majority of the price gets paid by negotiating with Healthcare for prices. A one payer system removes a TON of overhead from the medical establishment by reducting filing to a bunch of insurance companies that all ask for different things and cover different things. As I said above. We have one of the worst healthcare systems in the 1st World while still paying the most (and it's not close) of any other country. Fixing that would be a HUGE step toward fixing healthcare.
 

TigerGrowls

Heisman
Dec 21, 2001
50,482
39,371
113


The people who told you to vote Democrat because of artificially inflated gas prices before the midterms are traitors to America who fell for Russian and Chinese propaganda in support of the Iranian regime.

I hate to say it, but the average person in our country isn’t too smart.

We are kind of a dumb society.

I wish we could just openly talk about how stupid the average person in our country is. x.com/andrewkolvet/s…
 
  • Haha
Reactions: dpic73

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,674
6,984
113
Nice response, I think you are being VERY kind to Republican here on the Health Care, but at least your response doesn't saying how high your T score is while talking about sucking cock... so that's something. I actually do think that Medicare for all is a good idea and that involves a two pronged approach: taxes do indeed cover it. Perhaps increased taxes across the board. But the majority of the price gets paid by negotiating with Healthcare for prices. A one payer system removes a TON of overhead from the medical establishment by reducting filing to a bunch of insurance companies that all ask for different things and cover different things. As I said above. We have one of the worst healthcare systems in the 1st World while still paying the most (and it's not close) of any other country. Fixing that would be a HUGE step toward fixing healthcare.
see, I disagree...I think you overestimate the number of bureaucrats which will be replaced, and I don't think you'll eliminate all the coding. If someone, be it government or industry is going to manage the program, they have to know the type of treatments, number of times..etc, all the things you need to know.

We might have a semantic issue...I'm on Medicare, and I go through some of the same problems you go through with a private healthcare provider...not everything is covered, some things are limited in usage, same requirements for approvals, it's means tested, and it only covers 80%. It's hard to get a human being who actually knows the programs when you call..same kinds of problems...

If you didn't have these controls, fraud would be off the charts.

Medicare has set rates, higher than Medicaid but lower than private health insurance. In fact the higher private rates offset the lower government rates. Some hospitals with predominant Medicaid/Medicare patients have closed, they don't get enough money to pay the staff and keep the lights on.

Now, if you wanted to go with some really, really basic plan with add ONS for the services a person would really need, that might be an option. But, I revert to the premise that we complain about efficiency of the FAA, The FDC, DoD, transportation etc, why would we thing the "department of Medicare" would be any different.

Personally, I'm in the camp of fix the ACA, the system is set up and it would be a heck of a lot cheaper than a Medicare for all program. IMO
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,059
5,720
113
see, I disagree...I think you overestimate the number of bureaucrats which will be replaced, and I don't think you'll eliminate all the coding. If someone, be it government or industry is going to manage the program, they have to know the type of treatments, number of times..etc, all the things you need to know.

We might have a semantic issue...I'm on Medicare, and I go through some of the same problems you go through with a private healthcare provider...not everything is covered, some things are limited in usage, same requirements for approvals, it's means tested, and it only covers 80%. It's hard to get a human being who actually knows the programs when you call..same kinds of problems...

If you didn't have these controls, fraud would be off the charts.

Medicare has set rates, higher than Medicaid but lower than private health insurance. In fact the higher private rates offset the lower government rates. Some hospitals with predominant Medicaid/Medicare patients have closed, they don't get enough money to pay the staff and keep the lights on.

Now, if you wanted to go with some really, really basic plan with add ONS for the services a person would really need, that might be an option. But, I revert to the premise that we complain about efficiency of the FAA, The FDC, DoD, transportation etc, why would we thing the "department of Medicare" would be any different.

Personally, I'm in the camp of fix the ACA, the system is set up and it would be a heck of a lot cheaper than a Medicare for all program. IMO

I think it's worth keeping in mind that, as far as I can recall, you have been on government healthcare your entire life and your perspective might be narrow and or skewed.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,674
6,984
113
I think it's worth keeping in mind that, as far as I can recall, you have been on government healthcare your entire life and your perspective might be narrow and or skewed.
not accurate, I was on company healthcare during my years in industry...But I don't know what that has to do with my experiences with Medicare...
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,059
5,720
113
not accurate, I was on company healthcare during my years in industry...But I don't know what that has to do with my experiences with Medicare...

You didn't have tricare the whole time? I thought that was almost always better than any private insurance.
 

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,570
24,204
113
With my approach catastrophic coverage could be picked up with a supplemental policy,... I believe that the basic coverage has to come with a defined limit,.. We can't afford to fund unlimited health care for everyone, when everyone isn't funding the program.

I also think the individual has to hold up their end of the bargain by doing what they can to maintain their health. I think it’s absurd to expect others to pay for their chronic disease caused by years of poor diet, lack of exercise and obesity, for example. That’s on the individual and we the taxpayers shouldn’t have to pay for their mistakes.
 
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football Graham Neff: 'What drives winning is different now'
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football Wednesday Evening Clemson Football Insider
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Football Additional intel on why evaluation and valuation are major points of scrutiny under Dabo Swinney
  4. 04 Tiger Illustrated Football The uncomfortable truth for Dabo Swinney and Clemson
  5. 05 Tiger Illustrated Football Recruiting Tuesday Clemson Football Recruiting Nuggets