Commonwealth University to close Mansfield campus in 2028 amid falling enrollment

psuro

Heisman
Aug 24, 2001
9,934
21,818
113
You can blame an older, poorer tax base with no interest in supporting education for generations that they won't benefit from.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Waaaaaaaany

MtNittany

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
4,186
5,793
113
You can blame an older, poorer tax base with no interest in supporting education for generations that they won't benefit from.
Most of the "tax base" has empty pockets, because they're part of the "tax base".

If kids wanted to go to Mansfield, and the price was right, they would. As it is, neither of those are true. Companies go out of business every day. Why can't schools?
 

MtNittany

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
4,186
5,793
113
As a “society” (😞), we’re dumb with education. Where will be without it? 🤔

😞
Even trade schools are going to be useless at some point. One can learn to weld or do plumbing on youtube and with AI.

As far as the intellectual side of the equation, there is a need for STEM obviously, but that's about where it stops to be honest.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobPSU92

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
543
274
63
You can blame an older, poorer tax base with no interest in supporting education for generations that they won't benefit from.


Spoken like a professor whose only interest is lining his own pockets. Educators do t understand simple demographics. Tioga County is losing population yet mansfield leadership thought it was a good idea to expand and build dorms.


Next up is cheyney, loch haven, Edinboro, california and clarion.
 
Last edited:

Nitt1300

Heisman
Nov 2, 2008
8,106
15,184
113
Even trade schools are going to be useless at some point. One can learn to weld or do plumbing on youtube and with AI.

As far as the intellectual side of the equation, there is a need for STEM obviously, but that's about where it stops to be honest.
I'm not so sure about that- there are welders and there are welders.
Same with plumbers.
But apprentice programs can teach either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobPSU92

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
543
274
63
The move to ‘consolidate’ six schools into two schools with six campuses was a dumba$$ move from the start. What little money was saved was probably spent on new letterhead and rebranding.


No it wasn't. That had nothing to do with the real problem. Consolidation didn't cause enrollment to drop 70%. Enrollment was already down. If they didn't consolidate, enrollment is still down.


The real stupidity was EXPANDING while enrollment was dropping.


What was your plan for 6 schools with declining enrollment? Do nothing??
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bison13

MtNittany

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
4,186
5,793
113
I'm not so sure about that- there are welders and there are welders.
Same with plumbers.
But apprentice programs can teach either.
If a good hardworking kid knows how to do the basics, any good small biz owner will take him on and get him certified in what's needed. No need for Penn College - except like PSU itself - just for the real heady stuff.

The kid's probably gonna make less then someone w/ a framed degree, but he's not gonna have those student loan bills and will be able to start to accumulate wealth instead.

Trade schools were great until people like PSU got involved with them. The idea of working part time and paying tuition and having a few bucks in your pocket is a distant memory.
 
Last edited:

Nittering Nabob

All-Conference
Sep 17, 2024
3,854
3,667
113
Just a small canary in the coal mine of collegiate education, especially in Pennsylvania.

Wife #5 and I toured Mansfield and Wellsboro a couple of years ago looking for real estate opportunities. Nice area, but mostly old people in town to see the PA Grand Canyon. Wellsboro is a really nice town, but it can’t sustain itself without Mansfield.

The current economics of higher education are going to be painful over the next five years. Penn State isn’t exempt.

I’m trying to think of an alternate use for Mansfield/Commonwealth U but nothing obvious comes to mind except for immigrant/low-income communal housing complete with on site athletic and dining facilities.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bison13

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
543
274
63
Eliminating parts of four administrations was essentially doing nothing. They should have made the hard decision back then to actually close campuses.

So you would have done exactly what they just did but sooner. Maybe next time you should enlighten everyone at the time and not wait til after the fact.
 

manatree

All-American
Oct 6, 2021
3,638
6,654
113
So you would have done exactly what they just did but sooner. Maybe next time you should enlighten everyone at the time and not wait til after the fact.

I did, along with several others on the previous board. Just as many of us have been saying that Penn State should have made a decision to close campuses years ago. The same goes with questioning Penn State’s continual expansion of UPark.
 
  • Like
Reactions: doctornick

doctornick

All-Conference
Sep 4, 2007
750
1,249
93
You can blame an older, poorer tax base with no interest in supporting education for generations that they won't benefit from.
Not sure I follow. Schools like this are closing because students aren’t enrolling. With the demographic cliff combined with fewer foreign students and just a general trend of fewer kids attending college, we are going to see a ton more school closures.

The reality is that there are far too many colleges open in this country. What should happen is that high schools should actually be improved and make it so that a high school diploma is a meaningful achievement that reflects actual specific skills attained. The problem is that due to softening of curricula and just passing kids along that a HS diploma is meaningless now. You can’t tell if a kid with one is a superstar or can’t do middle school math or write a coherent sentence. So far too many jobs “require a college degree” for simple crap that should be able to be done by anyone who graduated high school.

if we made high school what it’s supposed to be - and that people who aren’t learning actually repeating grades or failing out - then there wouldn’t be the push for underprepared kids to go to college where they really don’t belong.

Too many kids go to college because they want to goof off and drink and party not because they want to actually achieve intellectual growth.
 

doctornick

All-Conference
Sep 4, 2007
750
1,249
93
No it wasn't. That had nothing to do with the real problem. Consolidation didn't cause enrollment to drop 70%. Enrollment was already down. If they didn't consolidate, enrollment is still down.


The real stupidity was EXPANDING while enrollment was dropping.


What was your plan for 6 schools with declining enrollment? Do nothing??

the plan should have been to close them then. The multiple campus but one school idea was idiotic and just wasting money.
 

Wilbury

Senior
Oct 28, 2021
318
417
63
No it wasn't. That had nothing to do with the real problem. Consolidation didn't cause enrollment to drop 70%. Enrollment was already down. If they didn't consolidate, enrollment is still down.


The real stupidity was EXPANDING while enrollment was dropping.


What was your plan for 6 schools with declining enrollment? Do nothing??
except it hurt schools like Bloomsburg who were doing fine. Consolidation was just passing the buck. They should have closed the struggling schools on day 1 and reallocated the resources and money to the remainder.
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
543
274
63
except it hurt schools like Bloomsburg who were doing fine. Consolidation was just passing the buck. They should have closed the struggling schools on day 1 and reallocated the resources and money to the remainder.

Except you are wrong. Bloomsburg wasn't doing fine. Bloomsburg's enrollment was down 30% and they are losing twice as much money as mansfield. If you want to close the struggling schools then that is most of the psac schools. Might be everyone except wcu.


PSU will lose $125m this year. Psu should probably close about 15 branch campuses tomorrow and every sport other than football and basketball. You on board using your previous reasoning?
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,669
6,981
113
Most of the "tax base" has empty pockets, because they're part of the "tax base".

If kids wanted to go to Mansfield, and the price was right, they would. As it is, neither of those are true. Companies go out of business every day. Why can't schools?
there have been numerous colleges and universities closing. Academics are generally poor managers, keep spending and raising tuition and fees in an environment with falling numbers of available students.

It almost like a $700Million stadium renovation in a period of falling attendence.
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
543
274
63
there have been numerous colleges and universities closing. Academics are generally poor managers, keep spending and raising tuition and fees in an environment with falling numbers of available students.

It almost like a $700Million stadium renovation in a period of falling attendence.

Averaged 107k fans when renovation started. Happy now?


You on board with psu eliminating teams that lose money?
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,669
6,981
113
Not sure I follow. Schools like this are closing because students aren’t enrolling. With the demographic cliff combined with fewer foreign students and just a general trend of fewer kids attending college, we are going to see a ton more school closures.

The reality is that there are far too many colleges open in this country. What should happen is that high schools should actually be improved and make it so that a high school diploma is a meaningful achievement that reflects actual specific skills attained. The problem is that due to softening of curricula and just passing kids along that a HS diploma is meaningless now. You can’t tell if a kid with one is a superstar or can’t do middle school math or write a coherent sentence. So far too many jobs “require a college degree” for simple crap that should be able to be done by anyone who graduated high school.

if we made high school what it’s supposed to be - and that people who aren’t learning actually repeating grades or failing out - then there wouldn’t be the push for underprepared kids to go to college where they really don’t belong.

Too many kids go to college because they want to goof off and drink and party not because they want to actually achieve intellectual growth.
agreed, but another option...ask why college is 4 years...my granddaughter, for example, is taking 3 semesters of a language she'll never use, plus a multitude of humanities courses that mean nothing to her....etc. Make college 2 years for the major you chose. If a student wants to take all the "required" non major specific, fine...some people really are into that stuff...with all the information on line these days, if someone wants to study the works of DaVinci, you don't need to spend time in college to do it.
 

Bison13

All-American
May 26, 2013
3,907
6,540
113
Just a small canary in the coal mine of collegiate education, especially in Pennsylvania.

Wife #5 and I toured Mansfield and Wellsboro a couple of years ago looking for real estate opportunities. Nice area, but mostly old people in town to see the PA Grand Canyon. Wellsboro is a really nice town, but it can’t sustain itself without Mansfield.

The current economics of higher education are going to be painful over the next five years. Penn State isn’t exempt.

I’m trying to think of an alternate use for Mansfield/Commonwealth U but nothing obvious comes to mind except for immigrant/low-income communal housing complete with on site athletic and dining facilities.
I’ve never been to the campus, but I wonder if there’s anything there for some type of stem related fabrication to happen. Using any labs or other buildings for potential healthcare spots could be another option.
 

Parkland Fan

Junior
Jul 25, 2001
195
288
62
I've welded before in my contractor friend's shop. Also just recently had to braze a copper HVAC line.
MtNittany. You are a very good poster, but this one is pretty ridiculous. Power plants, including the nuclear ones, are full of high end welds. I hope your post was sarcasm.
 

Colt2169

All-Conference
Dec 13, 2021
1,431
1,958
113
Spoken like a professor whose only interest is lining his own pockets. Educators do t understand simple demographics. Tioga County is losing population yet mansfield leadership thought it was a good idea to expand and build dorms.


Next up is cheyney, loch haven, Edinboro, california and clarion.
Those dorms are almost brand new
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Basketball Penn State basketball passes unusual test in win over IU Indy
  2. 02 BWI Football Penn State pass rusher ruled out for Saturday; what is RB Carson Hansen's and Rutgers' QBs' status on Wednesday?
  3. 03 BWI Football Beaver Stadium renovation update: See how and when Penn State will complete construction on the new lower bowl
  4. 04 BWI Football Penn State vs. Rutgers Preview: Brahmer and Ebel Return, NFL Decisions and Predictions
  5. 05 BWI Football Penn State's Audavion Collins on his final season: 'Don't second-guess yourself'