Courtside views

hdhntr1

All-Conference
Sep 5, 2006
38,908
1,552
113
It might get ugly, but I'm hoping CCC goes ahead and just throws him in the deep end this year and take his lumps so that he will be ready next year.

One thing that Collins said in the last post-game presser is that he didn't play Ghai because the other team went "small ball". Not sure I fully understand or agree with that strategy. In the past, I don't remember Big Ten opponents not playing their big men just because we went out there with a "small ball" lineup - on the contrary, they would use that as an opportunity to punish us by abusing our lack of height with their big men. So why can't we do the same on the rare occasion when we have a size advantage? It would seem to be especially good to get Ghai some minutes/experience/confidence when he is the tallest man on the court. Anybody have an explanation on this for me?
Well he got in
 

rogerkim

Junior
Jan 22, 2020
1,042
233
63
I wonder if Ghai goes up against Federiko during practice, and that gives CC enough data he needs to assess if Symon can handle a small ball 5 at this point. Also, I'm intuiting that Ghai's pivot game is still emerging, and that he's not dominant there enough to compensate for the fact that he'd get outrun on defense by a small ball 5. Or put it this way, if he already was a finished product offensively, he'd be at another program.
Good point and you are probably right. Now that I got an extended look at Ghai in the Columbia game, I better understand why CCC isn't playing him much. He is too raw to know how to exploit his height advantage over a smaller 5. I think CCC saying that he "used a smaller lineup because the other team did" is actually his nice way of not throwing Ghai under the bus by saying he's not ready.

The problem is, with McEldon on indefinite leave and Soulis now out due to get foot surgery (per CCC's post game presser), we are basically down to Frederiko and Ghai as our bigs. And based on how both played against Columbia, I am worried that this is going to be a very long season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macarthur31

macarthur31

Senior
Nov 9, 2006
1,773
403
83
Good point and you are probably right. Now that I got an extended look at Ghai in the Columbia game, I better understand why CCC isn't playing him much. He is too raw to know how to exploit his height advantage over a smaller 5. I think CCC saying that he "used a smaller lineup because the other team did" is actually his nice way of not throwing Ghai under the bus by saying he's not ready.

The problem is, with McEldon on indefinite leave and Soulis now out due to get foot surgery (per CCC's post game presser), we are basically down to Frederiko and Ghai as our bigs. And based on how both played against Columbia, I am worried that this is going to be a very long season.
Our guy is 2 years away from being 2 years away. And, if it was the world pre-portal, then he's got the makin's of being a Matt Nicholson type story: learn the ropes and get stronger as an underclassman, and then thrive as a junior/senior.

Throughout Collins long tenure, his best pivots have been Alex Olah (who he inherited, but classic back to the bucket pivot), Dererk Pardon (who was a true rebounding machine, but really was a PF who played C), and Matt Nicholson (defensive anchor). I might consider Ryan Young, but he left - and perhaps that spoke to his pecking order in the offensive system. He even flirted with Pete Nance at the five for "Positionless Basketball." I'm wondering if the longterm pattern of not being able to discern/develop frontcourt players consistently is showing out in this portal era.
 

loyolacat

Junior
Oct 21, 2006
2,876
201
63
Our guy is 2 years away from being 2 years away. And, if it was the world pre-portal, then he's got the makin's of being a Matt Nicholson type story: learn the ropes and get stronger as an underclassman, and then thrive as a junior/senior.

Throughout Collins long tenure, his best pivots have been Alex Olah (who he inherited, but classic back to the bucket pivot), Dererk Pardon (who was a true rebounding machine, but really was a PF who played C), and Matt Nicholson (defensive anchor). I might consider Ryan Young, but he left - and perhaps that spoke to his pecking order in the offensive system. He even flirted with Pete Nance at the five for "Positionless Basketball." I'm wondering if the longterm pattern of not being able to discern/develop frontcourt players consistently is showing out in this portal era.
Yep tough to run the Collins offense w/o a strong 5....calls for going to a small lineup with lots of movement...but we are not that quick either....this group is a problem for AI...might short circuit
 
  • Like
Reactions: macarthur31

macarthur31

Senior
Nov 9, 2006
1,773
403
83
Yep tough to run the Collins offense w/o a strong 5....calls for going to a small lineup with lots of movement...but we are not that quick either....this group is a problem for AI...might short circuit
I'd actually offer it's actually tough to run the Collins offense without a "dirty work" 5. Matt Nicholson was probably the most fully formed post player developed during Collins tenure, and that's mainly because he was deployed to screen, fight for boards, and perhaps most importantly - not complain when Boo, Nick and Brooks were taking the majority of the shots.

Page showed he could be an offensive gamechanger at points, but was just not consistent enough defensively to earn Collins trust; it appeared this season, Collins was going back to a familiar formula - Jake West as floor general (BMac/Boo), LA Pratt being a li'l bit Audige and a li'l bit Ty Berry, and get floor spacing from Karasinski, Smith and Kostic and McEldon/Soulis would be Temu Nicholson/Verhoeven. I'd argue that hypothesis would be best-case scenario 10th/11th in B1G and flirt with the postseason. However, with no 5 at all? Hoo boy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hdhntr1
Wildcat Report

Latest

  1. 01 Wildcat Report Behind Enemy Lines: Minnesota
  2. 02 Wildcat Report Northwestern at Ohio State PFF Grades Analysis
  3. 03 Wildcat Report Northwestern working to support, improve QB Nicco Marchiol ahead of Minnesota
  4. 04 Wildcat Report Northwestern embarrassed by Columbia, 75-53
  5. 05 Wildcat Report Notebook: Braun looks to snap three-game losing streak at Minnesota