Time to Kill the Bowl Games With a 24-Team Playoff?

Time to Kill the Bowl Games With a 24-Team Playoff?


  • Total voters
    16

Gamecock72

Joined Sep 24, 2019
Sep 24, 2019
675
548
93
With the CFP expanding to 24 teams, is it time to just kill the bowl games?

I’m honestly mixed on this. Part of me hates the idea of losing them. Bowls have been part of the fabric of college football for a long time. But the other part of me looks at how many players are opting out every year and wonders what the point is anymore.

Unless a CBA or that “Save College Sports” legislation actually forces players to play, a lot of these games are just going to keep getting watered down. Stars sit out to protect their draft stock, others transfer, and you’re left with half-strength rosters in games that don’t matter for the national title.

If the non-playoff bowls go away, the postseason gets a lot cleaner. Only 24 teams make it. That’s closer to the old bowl system in terms of how many teams actually get to keep playing. Making the playoff would mean something again instead of just being one of 40+ teams that get a participation trophy game in late December.

Curious what everyone else thinks. Keep the bowls for tradition, or just lean all the way into the playoffs and let the rest die?
 

Gamecock72

Joined Sep 24, 2019
Sep 24, 2019
675
548
93
CFP is just rebranding bowl games as CFP games.
Yes and no. Everything after the first two rounds is rebranded bowl games. But the first two rounds are not really that, since they have no affiliation with a bowl game name or location. They are home games for the higher seed team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: I4CtheFuture

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,770
18,467
113
Yes and no. Everything after the first two rounds is rebranded bowl games. But the first two rounds are not really that, since they have no affiliation with a bowl game name or location. They are home games for the higher seed team.
What I mean is, with expansion, teams who would have been playing in a mid-tier bowl before expansion are now playing in a CFP game.
 

Gamecock72

Joined Sep 24, 2019
Sep 24, 2019
675
548
93
What I mean is, with expansion, teams who would have been playing in a mid-tier bowl before expansion are now playing in a CFP game.
I agree, but currently, those bowl games that they would be playing in are still scheduled to be played with other teams.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,770
18,467
113
I agree, but currently, those bowl games that they would be playing in are still scheduled to be played with other teams.

Yeah, sure, if those bowls want to continue on, they'll just have to take lower caliber teams. My point is, the CFP is just taking over games/teams that would have been mid-tier bowl games/teams. If the pop tarts bowl wants to continue, it will not be a mid-tier bowl any longer because those teams are in the CFP. It will be a low tier bowl. All that will exist are low-tier bowls.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,610
6,160
113
I'm one of those that watches even the crappy bowls. I would like them to stay, just out of selfishness.

Christmas time and new years is always relaxing and finding what game is on that dday, even if i dont care what two teams are playing.

Imo, those bowls never "mattered". MTSU vs Texas State never mattered when we had the BCs, nor when we had 4 or 12 team playoffs. But it was still entertaining.

MTSU vs Texas State wont matter when we have a 24 team playoff either, but I would still watch it.

Now the portal? That might be cause for canceling only because, with all the transfers, some teams have issues even fielding a team. I think several backed out of bowls last year for that reason.
 

Harvard Gamecock

All-Conference
May 5, 2014
3,472
3,187
113
For clarification the NCAA only regulates Bowl Games, but doesn't operate the Bowl Games.
The operational standards are very minimal. Team eligibility, etc


Bowl Games are set up by local organizations (e.g. Chamber of Commerce) for the intent of promoting tourism to the community during the Holiday season.
As long as booster/tourists are still willing to spend a mini vacation to a select destination, Bowl Games will continue to exist.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,610
6,160
113
For clarification the NCAA only regulates Bowl Games, but doesn't operate the Bowl Games.
The operational standards are very minimal. Team eligibility, etc


Bowl Games are set up by local organizations (e.g. Chamber of Commerce) for the intent of promoting tourism to the community during the Holiday season.
As long as booster/tourists are still willing to spend a mini vacation to a select destination, Bowl Games will continue to exist.

I wonder how much money the local town gets vs the TV revenue.

Meaning, and it's just my impression, but the physical crowds for bowls have been diminishing a lot. But if the TV revenue still makes it worth it, we can play in front of 10 fans.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,770
18,467
113
I'm one of those that watches even the crappy bowls. I would like them to stay, just out of selfishness.

Christmas time and new years is always relaxing and finding what game is on that dday, even if i dont care what two teams are playing.

Imo, those bowls never "mattered". MTSU vs Texas State never mattered when we had the BCs, nor when we had 4 or 12 team playoffs. But it was still entertaining.

MTSU vs Texas State wont matter when we have a 24 team playoff either, but I would still watch it.

Now the portal? That might be cause for canceling only because, with all the transfers, some teams have issues even fielding a team. I think several backed out of bowls last year for that reason.
The opt outs are definitely a factor. We had a very real shot at only our 5th ever 10-win season a couple years ago but Rocket and that defensive player opted out. If they play, we win. 10-wins seasons are rarer than unicorns around here. When teams aren't even putting their best players out there, what's even the point?

I'm sorry to tell people, you will absolutely see opt outs in the 24-team CFP. If a guy is a shoe-in first round pick, does he really want to play potentially 5 more games? I always thought the opting out of a bowl game due to injury risk was a bogus excuse. But it gets a lot more legit when you're talking about 5 games. That's nearly an extra half season of play.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Harvard Gamecock

All-Conference
May 5, 2014
3,472
3,187
113
If the two teams who go to the bowls, their fans, ESPN, and the local bowl committee think it's worth their time and energy to put on, who am I to say they shouldn't?
Exactly.
The G6 schools have essentially been told there is only room for one of you. So if the schools and fans want to travel to El Paso (Sun), Myrtle Beach, Bahamas, etc, then by all means, go have a good time.
 

Harvard Gamecock

All-Conference
May 5, 2014
3,472
3,187
113
I'm one of those that watches even the crappy bowls. I would like them to stay, just out of selfishness.

Christmas time and new years is always relaxing and finding what game is on that dday, even if i dont care what two teams are playing.

Imo, those bowls never "mattered". MTSU vs Texas State never mattered when we had the BCs, nor when we had 4 or 12 team playoffs. But it was still entertaining.

MTSU vs Texas State wont matter when we have a 24 team playoff either, but I would still watch it.

Now the portal? That might be cause for canceling only because, with all the transfers, some teams have issues even fielding a team. I think several backed out of bowls last year for that reason.
For me, not caring who wins, adds an element to the game I usually don't get to experience. I can appreciate a good play on either side of the ball without the angst of wondering "why didn't my guys make the play instead of their guys".
 

Blues man

Joined Jul 1, 2009
Jan 22, 2022
1,977
1,947
113
I'm one of those that watches even the crappy bowls. I would like them to stay, just out of selfishness.

Christmas time and new years is always relaxing and finding what game is on that dday, even if i dont care what two teams are playing.

Imo, those bowls never "mattered". MTSU vs Texas State never mattered when we had the BCs, nor when we had 4 or 12 team playoffs. But it was still entertaining.

MTSU vs Texas State wont matter when we have a 24 team playoff either, but I would still watch it.

Now the portal? That might be cause for canceling only because, with all the transfers, some teams have issues even fielding a team. I think several backed out of bowls last year for that reason.
Same here. I couldn't begin to count the number of "never mattered" games I've watched over the holidays... not to mention actually looked forward to seeing them. I'd even call them part of the holidays, traditional. I'm thrilled we will play somewhere at this point. And whoever dresses out, good for them. I wont give the ones that don't a second thought.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,770
18,467
113
I'm one of those that watches even the crappy bowls. I would like them to stay, just out of selfishness.

Christmas time and new years is always relaxing and finding what game is on that dday, even if i dont care what two teams are playing.

Imo, those bowls never "mattered". MTSU vs Texas State never mattered when we had the BCs, nor when we had 4 or 12 team playoffs. But it was still entertaining.

MTSU vs Texas State wont matter when we have a 24 team playoff either, but I would still watch it.

Now the portal? That might be cause for canceling only because, with all the transfers, some teams have issues even fielding a team. I think several backed out of bowls last year for that reason.
I would like it if they brought back the New Year's Day bowls. I don't mind having a few scattered around elsewhere, but I miss crashing out on NYD, eating junk food and watching bowl games all day.
 

Jonesz2

Joined Aug 9, 2005
Aug 9, 2005
1,821
2,333
113
The only way to redeem bowl games that aren't part of the CFP is to arrange things so that all the healthy players play. Too much has been lost from the quality of the product otherwise. As things are, discontinue them.
Facts. The best players opt out or give half effort. It obviously means nothing to the players. The ones getting paid get their check regardless. I think NIL should be pro rated to games played
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,916
9,016
113
I would like it if they brought back the New Year's Day bowls. I don't mind having a few scattered around elsewhere, but I miss crashing out on NYD, eating junk food and watching bowl games all day.
Those are already absorbed in the Playoff system, though not necessarily all on Jan.1.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 18IsTheMan

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,916
9,016
113
I was just meaning bowls in general. Still feels like there should be a slate of bowl games on NYD.
I understand, but they don't need to be determined by who played, who didn't, how many sat our on one team versus the other and how good was a team's depth at those particular positions. Neither should break-even, and certainly not losing teams, participate. In those regards, we're well past the point where most bowls need to continue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRoo

atl-cock

All-Conference
Jan 18, 2022
3,730
1,855
113
I'm one of those that watches even the crappy bowls. I would like them to stay, just out of selfishness.

Christmas time and new years is always relaxing and finding what game is on that dday, even if i dont care what two teams are playing.

Imo, those bowls never "mattered". MTSU vs Texas State never mattered when we had the BCs, nor when we had 4 or 12 team playoffs. But it was still entertaining.

MTSU vs Texas State wont matter when we have a 24 team playoff either, but I would still watch it.

Now the portal? That might be cause for canceling only because, with all the transfers, some teams have issues even fielding a team. I think several backed out of bowls last year for that reason.
Whatever bowls survive the FBS playoff system let 'em. Free market capitalism and all that stuff.
 

ThinnyJ

Junior
Sep 16, 2023
412
339
63
I think once a couple teams realize revenue sharing takes money out of some of their pockets, there won't be conferences either. There's no need for them ... Then you'll see lesser schools get kicked to the curb.
 

Blues man

Joined Jul 1, 2009
Jan 22, 2022
1,977
1,947
113
Crowning a national champion is secondary when it comes to the life of the conferences IMO. I don't see conferences going anywhere because the NCAA is still spineless crap for the most part. Conferences (basically tiny unions) equals power and a voice. Without them the NCAA become more powerful. I just don't see the schools within the conferences yielding to them.
 

atl-cock

All-Conference
Jan 18, 2022
3,730
1,855
113
The opt outs are definitely a factor. We had a very real shot at only our 5th ever 10-win season a couple years ago but Rocket and that defensive player opted out. If they play, we win. 10-wins seasons are rarer than unicorns around here. When teams aren't even putting their best players out there, what's even the point?

I'm sorry to tell people, you will absolutely see opt outs in the 24-team CFP. If a guy is a shoe-in first round pick, does he really want to play potentially 5 more games? I always thought the opting out of a bowl game due to injury risk was a bogus excuse. But it gets a lot more legit when you're talking about 5 games. That's nearly an extra half season of play.
You have to make the NIL money contingent on playing in all playoff games.
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
766
323
63
I understand, but they don't need to be determined by who played, who didn't, how many sat our on one team versus the other and how good was a team's depth at those particular positions. Neither should break-even, and certainly not losing teams, participate. In those regards, we're well past the point where most bowls need to continue.
Agree. Unless NIL contracts include a clause that has players participating in bowl games what's the point at this point.
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,916
9,016
113
Crowning a national champion is secondary when it comes to the life of the conferences IMO. I don't see conferences going anywhere because the NCAA is still spineless crap for the most part. Conferences (basically tiny unions) equals power and a voice. Without them the NCAA become more powerful. I just don't see the schools within the conferences yielding to them.
I think conferences stay, for practical scheduling and partisan reasons if nothing else. Let's leave FCS schools out of it. They should be left out anyway since making the playoffs will automatically be easier so less need for cupcakes.

There are 138 teams in the NCAA Division I Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS) for the 2026 season. That many teams playing as independents, all trying to cobble together appealing (for their fans and TV) schedules, vying for good games that attract spectators and to which people could conceivably travel - yes, it's a consideration - would be utter chaos unless some central authority gets on the computers and schedules EVERYONE'S games.

No school would have anything to say about any team on their schedule. Many if not most will automatically not like schedules imposed upon them.

I can't see it.
 
Last edited:

atl-cock

All-Conference
Jan 18, 2022
3,730
1,855
113
I think conferences stay, for practical scheduling reasons if nothing else. Let's leave FCS schools out of it. They should be left out anyway since making the playoffs will automatically be easier.

There are 138 teams in the NCAA Division I Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS) for the 2026 season. That many teams playing as independents, all trying to cobble together appealing (for their fans and TV) schedules, vying for good games that attract spectators and to which people could conceivably travel - yes, it's a consideration - would be utter chaos unless some central authority gets on the computers and schedules EVERYONE'S games.

I can't see it.
For how long has FCS had playoffs?
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,770
18,467
113
A long time - with more teams than the FBS has had - and they have conferences.
Money is not a factor with the FCS teams though. Nobody's offering big money to an FCS school.

Major FBS schools are looking for any financial edge and a handful of them could get more money solo.
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,916
9,016
113
...Major FBS schools are looking for any financial edge and a handful of them could get more money solo.
Eliminating conferences will not achieve that for them. Those marquee conference games, especially those in the 3:30 and 7:30 windows, draw a lot of eyeballs that the networks pay for. Eliminate the competition for conference championships and you will diminish that appeal.
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
766
323
63
Eliminating conferences will not achieve that for them. Those marquee conference games, especially those in the 3:30 and 7:30 windows, draw a lot of eyeballs that the networks pay for. Eliminate the competition for conference championships and you will diminish that appeal.

I just don't understand the point of the SEC Championship once they eliminated the East / West Divisions?

I guess the schedule is a grab bag each year so it might make sense for #1 and #2 to play but it feels alot different.
 

USCrbCOCK

Joined Dec 7, 2006 • Garnet Trust Supporter
Dec 7, 2006
2,151
3,965
113
With the CFP expanding to 24 teams, is it time to just kill the bowl games?

I’m honestly mixed on this. Part of me hates the idea of losing them. Bowls have been part of the fabric of college football for a long time. But the other part of me looks at how many players are opting out every year and wonders what the point is anymore.

Unless a CBA or that “Save College Sports” legislation actually forces players to play, a lot of these games are just going to keep getting watered down. Stars sit out to protect their draft stock, others transfer, and you’re left with half-strength rosters in games that don’t matter for the national title.

If the non-playoff bowls go away, the postseason gets a lot cleaner. Only 24 teams make it. That’s closer to the old bowl system in terms of how many teams actually get to keep playing. Making the playoff would mean something again instead of just being one of 40+ teams that get a participation trophy game in late December.

Curious what everyone else thinks. Keep the bowls for tradition, or just lean all the way into the playoffs and let the rest die?
Maybe it will help insure all a teams stars play rather than sit out. I'm tired of paying a couple of thousand bucks for a few days in Fla to watch half a team (lose,).
 
Last edited:

Dabo's Weenie

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2024
1,290
1,389
113
The only way to redeem bowl games that aren't part of the CFP is to arrange things so that all the healthy players play. Too much has been lost from the quality of the product otherwise. As things are, discontinue them.
Johnny Depp Shock GIF by Ebenezer Movie


😄
 
  • Like
Reactions: USCrbCOCK

nlstanford

Joined Sep 9, 2002
Sep 9, 2002
331
868
73
Interesting thought.
European soccer does this with the Champions League and the Europa League tournaments. Anyone who follows the sport knows that the Champions League is the more prestigious of the two, but that doesn’t make Europa any less popular.

The added incentive is that the winner of the Europa League automatically qualifies for the Champions League the following season.
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,916
9,016
113
I just don't understand the point of the SEC Championship once they eliminated the East / West Divisions?

I guess the schedule is a grab bag each year so it might make sense for #1 and #2 to play but it feels alot different.
I think many younger folks don't remember life before championship games. I love championship games. But here's the deal, I believe that, most often, the team that played best all season long won them - most often.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRoo
GamecockCentral

Latest

  1. 01 GamecockCentral Football Insider Report: CFP rankings, Sellers, and preparing for offseason
  2. 02 GamecockCentral Football South Carolina remains in College Football Playoff rankings; What would that mean for the Gamecocks in future 24-team fields?
  3. 03 TheBigSpur Football South Carolina is No. 21 and that gives the Gamecocks a needed boost
  4. 04 GamecockCentral Football Three players to know from South Carolina's next opponent, the Georgia Bulldogs
  5. 05 GamecockCentral Basketball Three burning questions ahead of South Carolina's matchup with Elon