Beamer's hurdle as a head coach

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,761
18,457
113
He can recruit talent. Nobody really denies that. This roster has plenty of talent to compete. He's also capable of getting the players up for surprising wins in big games. His best wins are up there with the best of them. As Josh Pate said, if a casual fan watched one of our games when every player is clicking, they would wonder how we ever lose a game.

He's also finally assembled a solid all-around staff. Something that eluded him his first 5 years.

What he lacks...and he's desperately lacking...is consistency. He just hasn't found a way to put it all together. Win all the games we're supposed to win AND win a few of the others. If you went back and gave us wins in every game we SHOULD have won since Beamer was here, he would have a fantastic record.

I don't know what the trick is. He's had too many impressive wins to say he simply sucks as a coach. There's obviously something there in terms of coaching talent. But he's also had too many inexplicable performances where we seem thoroughly unprepared. I don't know how you bridge the gap in getting consistent performances. It doesn't seem he does either.

I hope he can figure it out.
 

Deathstar

Senior
Sep 6, 2026
761
580
93
I will just go on the record and say he sucks as a coach, he was only hired because our AD was a baseball coach with no business experience and his daddy was a famous coach. He is only still employed here because our former AD was a baseball coach with no business experience who gave a famous coaches kid a lifetime contract for one good season.
 

Dabo's Weenie

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2024
1,290
1,389
113
Lou Holtz said you have a different team every week.

Don't know if he was any good as a coach, so I'm not sure how much credence to give that statement.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kidrobinski

Forkcock

All-Conference
Feb 11, 2006
1,914
2,010
113
When Beamer gets a big win or two, he gets a coaching high and thinks he can get cute and outsmart everybody. That's when we get brought down to earth.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecox4982

Rob Hawk

Sophomore
Nov 15, 2019
143
111
43
Would be curious if the former players that supported hiring Shane were to give a true assessment of Shane now, would they still be onboard?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

atlanta cock#

Heisman
Jun 1, 1998
14,762
36,123
98
I will just go on the record and say he sucks as a coach, he was only hired because our AD was a baseball coach with no business experience and his daddy was a famous coach. He is only still employed here because our former AD was a baseball coach with no business experience who gave a famous coaches kid a lifetime contract for one good season.
He fancies himself as a maverick ala John McCain. In reality, he's a DA.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,780
3,396
113
I give Donati more credit for this year's staff. Briles is here because of Donati. Briles had the good judgment to bring OL coach Clements with him. The OL and the OC are the heart of the offense. Does Donati have a past working relationship with other quality OCs? I don't think he does. Once Briles leaves, which I fear is sooner than later, Beamer will be on his own in filling the OC job. How has that worked for us in the past?

And if Briles leaves, don't be shocked if he takes Clements with him.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,167
3,731
113
Lou Holtz said you have a different team every week.

Don't know if he was any good as a coach, so I'm not sure how much credence to give that statement.
That makes me wonder how good of an actual coach Lou really is. He is a great speaker, but his coaching leaves some questions. He was good at Arkansas and ND (ND in those days was pretty easy to be good at), but everywhere else, he was average at best.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: kidrobinski

Go Gamecocks

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2021
1,886
1,559
113
He can recruit talent. Nobody really denies that. This roster has plenty of talent to compete.
Avg when you start losing key starters to injuries & don't have elite depth. You become a Sunbelt team.

How about Miss St? They just lost to Auburn 41-9. Lost to Vandy the week before.

They've lost 6 in a row since Kamario Taylor got hurt. Read that again.....6 in a row. Fire Jeff Lebby....he sucks...fans hate him....he's just a cheerleader...he's on estrogen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kidrobinski

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,916
9,016
113
He can recruit talent. Nobody really denies that. This roster has plenty of talent to compete. He's also capable of getting the players up for surprising wins in big games. His best wins are up there with the best of them. As Josh Pate said, if a casual fan watched one of our games when every player is clicking, they would wonder how we ever lose a game.

He's also finally assembled a solid all-around staff. Something that eluded him his first 5 years.

What he lacks...and he's desperately lacking...is consistency. He just hasn't found a way to put it all together. Win all the games we're supposed to win AND win a few of the others. If you went back and gave us wins in every game we SHOULD have won since Beamer was here, he would have a fantastic record.

I don't know what the trick is. He's had too many impressive wins to say he simply sucks as a coach. There's obviously something there in terms of coaching talent. But he's also had too many inexplicable performances where we seem thoroughly unprepared. I don't know how you bridge the gap in getting consistent performances. It doesn't seem he does either.

I hope he can figure it out.
Without quibbling over some of your introductory premises, you've just described a fatal flaw.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Rhode Island Dork

All-Conference
Nov 10, 2024
1,451
1,203
113
He can recruit talent. Nobody really denies that. This roster has plenty of talent to compete. He's also capable of getting the players up for surprising wins in big games. His best wins are up there with the best of them. As Josh Pate said, if a casual fan watched one of our games when every player is clicking, they would wonder how we ever lose a game.

He's also finally assembled a solid all-around staff. Something that eluded him his first 5 years.

What he lacks...and he's desperately lacking...is consistency. He just hasn't found a way to put it all together. Win all the games we're supposed to win AND win a few of the others. If you went back and gave us wins in every game we SHOULD have won since Beamer was here, he would have a fantastic record.

I don't know what the trick is. He's had too many impressive wins to say he simply sucks as a coach. There's obviously something there in terms of coaching talent. But he's also had too many inexplicable performances where we seem thoroughly unprepared. I don't know how you bridge the gap in getting consistent performances. It doesn't seem he does either.

I hope he can figure it out.
He can't stay out of his own way. He has to "play head coach."
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,761
18,457
113
Without quibbling over some of your introductory premises, you've just described a fatal flaw.
I enjoy quibbling! Quibble away!

I agree inconsistency is generally a fatal flaw. Beamer's case is complicated, though, by the magnitude of the big wins.
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
765
322
63
Banging the Beamer drum is an act of futility.

You're stuck with him for at least another 2 years at this point.

Settle in and focus on the other chess pieces if you need to.

You better hope Sellers comes back because that could be instrumental to the Briles situation.

Otherwise, the house could be cleaned and they will build again around Shane Beamer.

I'm not saying that's the best idea --- it just seems by far the most likely.

He's a fundraiser and a mouthpiece. That's about it and they like him for that role.

It's too expensive to spin the coaching wheel again at this juncture.

I'm certain the AD looks around at all of the expensive coaching carosel situations in horror. (FSU, etc.)

The #1 priority should be finding a solid replacement for Sellers eventual departure at any cost.

This has been a good season.

No one with half a brain is putting the staff on the warm/hot seat for Saturday Night or this season in general.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kidrobinski

kidrobinski

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2004
1,783
1,547
113
I give Donati more credit for this year's staff. Briles is here because of Donati. Briles had the good judgment to bring OL coach Clements with him. The OL and the OC are the heart of the offense. Does Donati have a past working relationship with other quality OCs? I don't think he does. Once Briles leaves, which I fear is sooner than later, Beamer will be on his own in filling the OC job. How has that worked for us in the past?

And if Briles leaves, don't be shocked if he takes Clements with him.
Don’t understand why this is apparently considered a Beamer ding or a subplot. We needed an OC and an OL coach, Donati knows an OC guy, a guy who’s regarded as successful, this guy is comfortable working with that OL coach, and bazinga, bob’s your uncle. And if that OC leaves, OF COURSE he takes the OL coach with him. Geez.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRoo

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,609
6,157
113
Don’t understand why this is apparently considered a Beamer ding or a subplot. We needed an OC and an OL coach, Donati knows an OC guy, a guy who’s regarded as successful, this guy is comfortable working with that OL coach, and bazinga, bob’s your uncle. And if that OC leaves, OF COURSE he takes the OL coach with him. Geez.

Because of Beamer's previous OC hirings, and how it took an AD stepping in to help him hire a competent OC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecock stock

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,761
18,457
113
Don’t understand why this is apparently considered a Beamer ding or a subplot. We needed an OC and an OL coach, Donati knows an OC guy, a guy who’s regarded as successful, this guy is comfortable working with that OL coach, and bazinga, bob’s your uncle. And if that OC leaves, OF COURSE he takes the OL coach with him. Geez.

I also don't see this as a knock against Beamer. It's unlikely that Donati forced Briles on Beamer, though many on here have assumed it. Most likely the Donati connection played a factor, but I don't see that as a knock on Beamer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kidrobinski

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,609
6,157
113
I give Donati more credit for this year's staff. Briles is here because of Donati. Briles had the good judgment to bring OL coach Clements with him. The OL and the OC are the heart of the offense. Does Donati have a past working relationship with other quality OCs? I don't think he does. Once Briles leaves, which I fear is sooner than later, Beamer will be on his own in filling the OC job. How has that worked for us in the past?

And if Briles leaves, don't be shocked if he takes Clements with him.

Agreed.

I think of it this way, Shane has shown how good of a judge he is of OC's. If Donati really was the key to the Briles hire, then its incumbent on him to do it again. If he wants Shane to succeed.
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
765
322
63
Agreed.

I think of it this way, Shane has shown how good of a judge he is of OC's. If Donati really was the key to the Briles hire, then its incumbent on him to do it again. If he wants Shane to succeed.

What Donati won't do is get in a situation like Clemson has where one guy (Dabo) is playing King.

The hiring/firing of assistant coaches will likely be a collective decision by Beamer and the AD.

Beamer is fine with that because he gets his check and is not 100% on the hook in the eyes of the AD if things don't work out.

New era.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,761
18,457
113
Agreed.

I think of it this way, Shane has shown how good of a judge he is of OC's. If Donati really was the key to the Briles hire, then its incumbent on him to do it again. If he wants Shane to succeed.

Alternatively, everyone has weaknesses. Growth is coming to realize those weaknesses and how to address them and surround yourself with people who can offset them. Perhaps Beamer realized he wasn't hitting it right at OC hires and leaned on Donati's connection with Briles.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,609
6,157
113
Alternatively, everyone has weaknesses. Growth is coming to realize those weaknesses and how to address them and surround yourself with people who can offset them. Perhaps Beamer realized he wasn't hitting it right at OC hires and leaned on Donati's connection with Briles.

One can hope. If true, he realized he has to go after effective OC's, and maybe next time he will be able to pick one without it being handed to him by his boss.
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
765
322
63
One can hope. If true, he realized he has to go after effective OC's, and maybe next time he will be able to pick one without it being handed to him by his boss.

Maybe not and who cares.

A collective effort to assemble the staff and possibly roster too.

Beamer is the front guy and the fundraiser.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,780
3,396
113
Don’t understand why this is apparently considered a Beamer ding or a subplot. We needed an OC and an OL coach, Donati knows an OC guy, a guy who’s regarded as successful, this guy is comfortable working with that OL coach, and bazinga, bob’s your uncle. And if that OC leaves, OF COURSE he takes the OL coach with him. Geez.
Lurker answered it before I got to. And he answered it better than I would have.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,780
3,396
113
Alternatively, everyone has weaknesses. Growth is coming to realize those weaknesses and how to address them and surround yourself with people who can offset them. Perhaps Beamer realized he wasn't hitting it right at OC hires and leaned on Donati's connection with Briles.
We all hope that Beamer has grown when it comes to hiring Offensive Coordinators. If people cannot see how uninspiring his previous Offensive Coordinator hirings were prior to Briles, all I can say is "sheesh". That's not a "knock" or "ding" on Shane. It's a FACT. smh There is nothing wrong with leaning on Donati's connection. There is also nothing wrong with mentioning the obvious.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: SouthernBelly

kidrobinski

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2004
1,783
1,547
113
We all hope that Beamer has grown when it comes to hiring Offensive Coordinators. If people cannot see how uninspiring his previous Offensive Coordinator hirings were prior to Briles, all I can say is "sheesh". That's not a "knock" or "ding" on Shane. It's a FACT. smh There is nothing wrong with leaning on Donati's connection. There is also nothing wrong with mentioning the obvious.
No one said the previous OC was the cats meow my friend. Sometimes things work out, sometimes they don’t. That one didn’t obviously, but that wasn’t the point now was it. And “leaning on donati’s connection” is not what has been surmised.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,780
3,396
113
No one said the previous OC was the cats meow my friend. Sometimes things work out, sometimes they don’t. That one didn’t obviously, but that wasn’t the point now was it. And “leaning on donati’s connection” is not what has been surmised.
So, what was my point?

I wrote above that I give more credit to Donati for the staff, specifically Briles and Clements. If that's what you are referring to, I stand by that, good fellow 70s era SC grad buddy. That's not a knock or ding, imho.
 
Last edited:

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,916
9,016
113
I enjoy quibbling! Quibble away!

I agree inconsistency is generally a fatal flaw. Beamer's case is complicated, though, by the magnitude of the big wins.
They were wins he was able to garner without shortening games that needed to be shortened, lengthening games that needed to be lengthened, or making go/no-go decisions impeccably multiple times. In that last regard, he has been shaky. I would describe him as the antithesis of the best I have ever seen in those regards: Vince Dooley.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,780
3,396
113
antithesis of the best I have ever seen in those regards: Vince Dooley.
I really, really liked Vince Dooley, especially after hearing him speak at my high school football team's banquet in January 1968. I never saw teams come out of halftime as fired up and different than Dooley's Dawgs. Not before nor since.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,167
3,731
113
I really, really liked Vince Dooley, especially after hearing him speak at my high school football team's banquet in January 1968. I never saw teams come out of halftime as fired up and different than Dooley's Dawgs. Not before nor since.
Dooley was a brutal DI type head coach who put on a smooth act in interviews and on the sideline. His practices were so tough, players had a better chance of injury in practice than in games. One reason his teams were so good in the second half was because they were in top physical condition. When the opponent started slowing down in the second half, UGA never lost a step and that translated into a lot of late game wins. He was a master at halftime adjustments too.
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
765
322
63
Maybe deep down Donati wishes he could pull the switcharoo with Beamer and Briles at this point.

It's just logistically impossible.

The best chance you BOTs have is for Donati to take another OC job (like A&M) and then Beamer flops with his new staff and no Sellers.

Then he might be able to reel him back in.

With that said, there's absolutely no guarantee than Briles would be a good HC.

In fact, I think it would likely handicap his talents.

However, they all seem to want to try their hand so he'll probably do the same.

My understanding (and someone correctly me if I'm wrong) is that his entire family is still in Texas.

So I'll stick with the idea that we'll need Sellers in 2027 for Briles to stay put.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kidrobinski
GamecockCentral

Latest

  1. 01 TheBigSpur Football South Carolina is No. 21 and that gives the Gamecocks a needed boost
  2. 02 GamecockCentral Football CFP Chair Hunter Yurachek explains why South Carolina is still ranked after blowout loss
  3. 03 GamecockCentral Football Everything Georgia HC Kirby Smart said about South Carolina before Week 12 matchup
  4. 04 GamecockCentral Basketball Three burning questions ahead of South Carolina's matchup with Elon
  5. 05 GamecockCentral Football Recruiting South Carolina football's team recruiting ranking following ratings updates