Team like IC simply have much higher ceilings than the 3A publics; not to mention the rural private schools. I mean, I suppose it’s theoretically possible that some farm town of 4000 people is gonna produce a half dozen D1 football players that are all the same age, but it’s not exactly likely. If they did, there would probably be some kind of secret government laboratory nearby.
Anyway, every so often, the private school will put together a roster that approaches the ceiling, and that’s when even the top tier small town schools start receiving drubbings, and then things get testy. Althoff a couple years ago is a good example of this. They put together a squad of some dudes that were gonna play next level, including at least one who will probably be in the NFL soon. They proceeded to lap the field and then rubbed Lena’s nose in it over and over in the title game. So it certainly does happen to teams outside the CCL as far as “outrage”, to go back to a previous question.
With all that said, IC is perfectly fine playing in 3A because that’s where the rules say they belong. Maybe some schools will want to change the rules again… tbd. I have noticed more and more poster that identity as CCL fans remark that maybe some of their teams shouldn’t be in the smaller classes though.