If Iowa goes 10-2, should Kirk announce his retirement?

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,692
5,371
113
Now hear me out, Iowa goes 10-2, Kirk says it's been a great year and he is calling it quits. CFP gives Iowa a bid due to this factor.
What??? Kirk might have a better team next year, I dont think he is retiring this year. He has almost all of his 2 deep lineup coming back, Monty gone, maybe an OTackle is gone, a couple more , Ostrenga I think, another Lbkr who is not a starter usually. But only about 5 or 6 players. We have Lbkrs to to replace those leaving and plenty of TEnds. I think Vonnahme is third year and could go pro but I really think he wants to show better one more year at Iowa.

KIrk is "young" and can take the sideline collisions like last Saturday so he is staying.

LJ is probably coming back maybe as he has taking a lot of hits, I bet Moulton goes pro as he has 4 years of pounding on him already. XWilliams comes back, BJackson comes back, Hank back I would think. A lot of the defense is back although I think one cornerback is 5th year. Oh yeah, we lose one DTackle to 5 years
 

HawkeyeGenius

Heisman
Iowa Swarm member
Nov 25, 2021
14,616
24,294
113
What??? Kirk might have a better team next year, I dont think he is retiring this year. He has almost all of his 2 deep lineup coming back, Monty gone, maybe an OTackle is gone, a couple more , Ostrenga I think, another Lbkr who is not a starter usually. But only about 5 or 6 players. We have Lbkrs to to replace those leaving and plenty of TEnds. I think Vonnahme is third year and could go pro but I really think he wants to show better one more year at Iowa.

KIrk is "young" and can take the sideline collisions like last Saturday so he is staying.

LJ is probably coming back maybe as he has taking a lot of hits, I bet Moulton goes pro as he has 4 years of pounding on him already. XWilliams comes back, BJackson comes back, Hank back I would think. A lot of the defense is back although I think one cornerback is 5th year. Oh yeah, we lose one DTackle to 5 years
Going to need some serious cash to get some of those guys back.
 

RuggieC

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2014
647
1,283
93
What??? Kirk might have a better team next year, I dont think he is retiring this year. He has almost all of his 2 deep lineup coming back, Monty gone, maybe an OTackle is gone, a couple more , Ostrenga I think, another Lbkr who is not a starter usually. But only about 5 or 6 players. We have Lbkrs to to replace those leaving and plenty of TEnds. I think Vonnahme is third year and could go pro but I really think he wants to show better one more year at Iowa.

KIrk is "young" and can take the sideline collisions like last Saturday so he is staying.

LJ is probably coming back maybe as he has taking a lot of hits, I bet Moulton goes pro as he has 4 years of pounding on him already. XWilliams comes back, BJackson comes back, Hank back I would think. A lot of the defense is back although I think one cornerback is 5th year. Oh yeah, we lose one DTackle to 5 years
This
 

3-D_chess

All-Conference
Jul 18, 2025
1,302
1,432
113
He should definitely retire if he makes the playoffs.

He's old and not designed for the modern college game, which (unfortunately) has turned into pro-football.

By his own admission he wasn't a good fit for the NFL because of the egos involved. Winning future college games will increasingly rely on young male egos.

Besides, I think he might have stumbled onto a good replacement in Lester. Someone is gonna give Tim another shot at the HC position, considering his age and understanding of the offense I think he would be a good fit here.
 

Bigg21

Redshirt
Sep 9, 2026
3
4
2
We've been told the Hawks are a year ahead of schedule, does that ever come to fruition? If it wasn't for the fake punt, wasn't the Orange Bowl win team vs GT a year ahead of schedule, or do I have my years mixed up?
 

Sett1997

All-Conference
Oct 23, 2025
981
3,001
93
Going to 24 teams boys. I think he wants a shot at that. We would have been in, many years. Cool thing about 24 teams is you aren't playing a Georgia or Miami first round.
 
Last edited:

85Bears

All-American
Aug 31, 2019
6,340
7,028
108
What??? Kirk might have a better team next year, I dont think he is retiring this year. He has almost all of his 2 deep lineup coming back, Monty gone, maybe an OTackle is gone, a couple more , Ostrenga I think, another Lbkr who is not a starter usually. But only about 5 or 6 players. We have Lbkrs to to replace those leaving and plenty of TEnds. I think Vonnahme is third year and could go pro but I really think he wants to show better one more year at Iowa.

KIrk is "young" and can take the sideline collisions like last Saturday so he is staying.

LJ is probably coming back maybe as he has taking a lot of hits, I bet Moulton goes pro as he has 4 years of pounding on him already. XWilliams comes back, BJackson comes back, Hank back I would think. A lot of the defense is back although I think one cornerback is 5th year. Oh yeah, we lose one DTackle to 5 years
Moulton isn’t going to be drafted. I don’t know where he’s going if he leaves.
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,692
5,371
113
So he’s leaving early to be an undrafted free agent ? That makes no sense
Running backs, short shelf life, he is mature, probably 22 years old, he improved a lot this year with his vision and has a lot of very good videotape highlights. In retrospect players like Lucas VanNess probably should have stayed another year but left after his third year at Iowa and didnt play much as a true freshman. He is showing up better now in the pros but it took him about 3 years
 

Outbackbowl2017

All-Conference
Dec 4, 2016
1,940
3,248
113
So he’s leaving early to be an undrafted free agent ? That makes no sense
Kinda like Tyler Goodson sitting out the bowl game to prep for the draft as an unrestricted free agent signing.

And Kirk ain’t going anywhere with the 24 team play offs next year. He’s gonna coach till he’s 80 based upon his energy/stamina. Besides, Mary won’t let him retire. Look at Tom Moore. The minute those guys quit coaching, they die and I have to assume KF is afraid of that hsppening if and when he retires. Moore too.
 

85Bears

All-American
Aug 31, 2019
6,340
7,028
108
Kinda like Tyler Goodson sitting out the bowl game to prep for the draft as an unrestricted free agent signing.

And Kirk ain’t going anywhere with the 24 team play offs next year. He’s gonna coach till he’s 80 based upon his energy/stamina. Besides, Mary won’t let him retire. Look at Tom Moore. The minute those guys quit coaching, they die and I have to assume KF is afraid of that hsppening if and when he retires. Moore too.
Moulton is too small and slow to be drafted, he wouldn’t even make a practice squad. He’s not giving up a nil paycheck to be unemployed. literally no one would advise him to leave Early.
 

85Bears

All-American
Aug 31, 2019
6,340
7,028
108
Running backs, short shelf life, he is mature, probably 22 years old, he improved a lot this year with his vision and has a lot of very good videotape highlights. In retrospect players like Lucas VanNess probably should have stayed another year but left after his third year at Iowa and didnt play much as a true freshman. He is showing up better now in the pros but it took him about 3 years
Small backs that run a 4.5 and are listed by draft sites as UDFA aren’t giving up a nil paycheck to be unemployed. he wouldn’t even make a practice squad. Unless someone’s on acid, nobody is advising Moulton to leave early.
 

The Big Z

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
2,345
4,538
113
He should definitely retire if he makes the playoffs.

He's old and not designed for the modern college game, which (unfortunately) has turned into pro-football.

By his own admission he wasn't a good fit for the NFL because of the egos involved. Winning future college games will increasingly rely on young male egos.

Besides, I think he might have stumbled onto a good replacement in Lester. Someone is gonna give Tim another shot at the HC position, considering his age and understanding of the offense I think he would be a good fit here.
This makes zero sense. Hes built an incredible culture here. And he’s embraced the portal for the right people. Look at who we got this year. Phillips, Diaz, Hawthorne, are not only cultural fits but kick *** players in the Hawkeye mold. 8-4 last year with a great chance to be 10-2 this year. 18-6 in his last 2 years does not show the game is passing him by.
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,692
5,371
113
Small backs that run a 4.5 and are listed by draft sites as UDFA aren’t giving up a nil paycheck to be unemployed. he wouldn’t even make a practice squad. Unless someone’s on acid, nobody is advising Moulton to leave early.
Man, you sound really growly like an old beat up bear. Maybe Moulton has graduated and he wants to try to get on a practice squad where he can be the opposing team running back in practice for awhile and if it doesnt work out he can try to find a job and get on with his life. or if he really wants to play football some more there is Canada and other leagues
 

85Bears

All-American
Aug 31, 2019
6,340
7,028
108
Man, you sound really growly like an old beat up bear. Maybe Moulton has graduated and he wants to try to get on a practice squad where he can be the opposing team running back in practice for awhile and if it doesnt work out he can try to find a job and get on with his life. or if he really wants to play football some more there is Canada and other leagues
What is your fixation with the illusion Moulton is leaving early ? It’s not happening bud
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,692
5,371
113
There are teams we could beat. If we got a good draw and continue to get better each week it could get really interesting. Next year this team returning should be in the top ten And a really good team.
Correct, when you have a great defense ala the '85 Bears then you can beat anybody
 

JerseyCityHawk

All-Conference
Jul 6, 2025
1,600
2,626
112
Moulton is too small and slow to be drafted, he wouldn’t even make a practice squad. He’s not giving up a nil paycheck to be unemployed. literally no one would advise him to leave Early.
Yes he doesn’t seem to have a second or 3rd gear ⚙️… he’s a good back don’t get me wrong but not an NFL style back… I do love his heart and dedication to Iowa football and is a standup guy
 
  • Like
Reactions: DuddyB and 85Bears

jwgohawks

Sophomore
Mar 5, 2003
85
194
33
Admittedly, I wanted a change from KF a couple times now over the years and he's bounced back every time. So it's going to be completely on KF when he retires and I don't see it for a few more years. I'm surprised KF has kept up with the times and is still successful when a lot of old school coaches have left the game. For what it's worth, I think he's the only reason they're doing more with less money in this NIL era. The world after KF world concerns me and I'm not in a hurry to get to it anymore because I think it will take a lot more money to stay competitive.
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,374
4,208
113
Yes he doesn’t seem to have a second or 3rd gear ⚙️… he’s a good back don’t get me wrong but not an NFL style back… I do love his heart and dedication to Iowa football and is a standup guy
We don’t a have a NFL back on the roster currently but we have several “good” college backs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JerseyCityHawk

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,692
5,371
113
Admittedly, I wanted a change from KF a couple times now over the years and he's bounced back every time. So it's going to be completely on KF when he retires and I don't see it for a few more years. I'm surprised KF has kept up with the times and is still successful when a lot of old school coaches have left the game. For what it's worth, I think he's the only reason they're doing more with less money in this NIL era. The world after KF world concerns me and I'm not in a hurry to get to it anymore because I think it will take a lot more money to stay competitive.
I was with you as far as KF needing to get more aggressive offensively or to move on a couple times in his nearly 3 decades at Iowa. The 2006-2007-early 2008 era was turmoil, athletes in trouble, bad offense, really bad in game management decisions. Late 2010 thru 2012 (James Vandenberg taking every snap and young Rudock not getting any snaps once the season was lost). These were times when KF seemed to have lost the ship.

But he always rallies, he got rid of a disruptive DLine coach, made an OC change that worked in 2013-16, some new coaches and very good recruiting, and 2017-20 with some very good results and offens.

But the Lester hire and reviving the passing game is coming along, the OLine seems to have had a rebirth after 2021-2023 down times.

As head coach and leader he has seem the ship list to the side but has made changes to turn things around.

Before Fry and Kirk the hawks were historically a less that 50% winning team iirc and now they have been around 66% the last 47 years. Damn good
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,692
5,371
113
Admittedly, I wanted a change from KF a couple times now over the years and he's bounced back every time. So it's going to be completely on KF when he retires and I don't see it for a few more years. I'm surprised KF has kept up with the times and is still successful when a lot of old school coaches have left the game. For what it's worth, I think he's the only reason they're doing more with less money in this NIL era. The world after KF world concerns me and I'm not in a hurry to get to it anymore because I think it will take a lot more money to stay competitive.
My low point with Conservative Kirk was in 2007. My son and his friend were going to Purdue and had an extra ticket. I went and it was fun with those two but the game was utter hell and disappointment. Purdue wasnt great but Jake the Snake and the offense were lousy, many passes in the dirt.

But the ultimate was right at the end of the first half. PU was up by 10 iirc, the hawks had the ball at about the 50 or just in PU territory, maybe 3 seconds on the clock, and Kirk punts instead of trying a hell mary pass. I was effing dumbfounded, perplexed and thought how can we win doing passive crap like that. I certainly wanted him to leave after that game.
 

83Hawk

All-Conference
Jan 1, 2023
1,927
4,293
113
We've been told the Hawks are a year ahead of schedule, does that ever come to fruition? If it wasn't for the fake punt, wasn't the Orange Bowl win team vs GT a year ahead of schedule, or do I have my years mixed up?
Sounds about right.

The Hawks seem to do better when the expectations are low.
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 On3 Football College Football Playoff Top 25: Third official 2026 CFP rankings revealed
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Football Kirk Ferentz updates injuries, talks Fighting Illini
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football Hank Brown prepares to face Fighting Illini defense
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting In-state athlete Paul Beswick receives opportunity from Iowa
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Football Iose Epenesa hopes to follow in brother's footsteps at Illinois