10-2 IOWA will make the CFP. Many "experts" are saying it. Are "the experts" right?

Randon

All-Conference
Feb 5, 2003
817
1,814
93
Iowa Stays ahead of Oregon and OSU in the AP this week.
This doesn't mean squat in the CFB ranking. The committee will slobber over Ohio State and Oregon like they always do and select them with three losses before they take an Iowa team with two losses. Very unfair but you can see it coming.
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,834
45,795
113
This doesn't mean squat in the CFB ranking. The committee will slobber over Ohio State and Oregon like they always do and select them with three losses before they take an Iowa team with two losses. Very unfair but you can see it coming.
Its a solid indicator when 2 major polls still value Iowa more.

OSU didn't beat NW as bad as Iowa did.

Oregon's win over Michigan was no more impressive than Iowa's win over Purdue.

I think people can "see it coming" because they're trying not to get their hopes up so they won't be hurt.

If the CFP wanted to put Oregon or OSU ahead of Iowa they could have 2 weeks in a row but they didn't. Neither have done anything to warrant jumping Iowa. They've essentially signaled this is Iowa's spot to lose.
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,378
4,219
113
Part of their equation is wins over teams with a winning record. It increases the odds. It isn't the sole reason.
Not that it matters what people want to wish cast matters but if you really want to see Iowa will make the playoff we should root for everybody that’s on our schedule that’s not playing us at this point
 
  • Like
Reactions: uihawk82

BringBackBradBanks

All-Conference
Jul 19, 2022
979
2,182
93
Would a three loss Tennessee (with losses to Texas, LSU and South Carolina) stay ahead of a 10 and 2 Iowa in the final CFP rankings?!? My guess is they might. 🤦‍♂️ Not outraged if they do, but would be pissed if a three loss Oregon somehow jumps Iowa.
 

The Big Z

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
2,345
4,543
113
I am going to guess that Tennessee, Texas and Alabama all could survive another loss.
Tennessee will probably stay at 8 this week. Now if they go out and lose 24-23 to LSU you could be right that they might not drop below us. If LSU would blow them out there's a really good chance they're done. There's no way you could keep them above us.
 

BigOHawk1

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2001
671
1,227
93
Would a three loss Tennessee (with losses to Texas, LSU and South Carolina) stay ahead of a 10 and 2 Iowa in the final CFP rankings?!? My guess is they might. 🤦‍♂️ Not outraged if they do, but would be pissed if a three loss Oregon somehow jumps Iowa.
Nope, this late in season don't care what conf. you are from a 3rd loss should auto boot you from the Top 12.
 

HawksRule73

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
985
2,407
93
I am going to guess that Tennessee, Texas and Alabama all could survive another loss.
I think Texas and Alabama probably could just because of brand. Tennessee, I'm not so sure. Maybe if they lost by a walkoff FG against LSU they'd stay above us. But they're at home and LSU is a 4 loss team, so I think any loss drops them just behind us.
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,693
5,372
113
Not that it matters what people want to wish cast matters but if you really want to see Iowa will make the playoff we should root for everybody that’s on our schedule that’s not playing us at this point
Yeah, Iowa St should finish 7-5 or 6-6

Wisky, Minny, jNW, actually all of our Big 10 opponents except for Purdue have winning records except Minny at 5-5. Some of them play each other yet but the hawks have played pretty good teams this year, even Michigan at 5-5 hahahahah
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,693
5,372
113
Tennessee will probably stay at 8 this week. Now if they go out and lose 24-23 to LSU you could be right that they might not drop below us. If LSU would blow them out there's a really good chance they're done. There's no way you could keep them above us.
Correct since LSU is not a great team this year
 
Aug 27, 2003
888
595
93
Hawks fan in New Jersey here. Unlike Dirt Bag Oregon Iowa is not into style points, running up the score. Just looking
to win the game. Kirk might want to get the extra TD against Illinois , even thought its against his nature. BYU has the Notre Dame
and Arizona wins. Hugh, would not complain about BYU getting in. As terrible as it sounds need Iowa St. to finish strong.
Makes the Hawks win more impressive. Boys how about a 27-0 shutout .
 

Destin Hawk

All-Conference
Mar 19, 2022
498
1,409
93
The head of the bowl selection committee is the Arkansas AD, before than he worked at Alabama (not as AD). SEC bias, and yes a 3 loss Tennessee team will be in before Iowa at 10-2. We've gotta home for a mess with the Big 12 teams and the 2 AC teams
 

yrunvs

Senior
Feb 18, 2012
331
552
93
The steal is on. Get used to it. That's where we're at. Robbery right in front of you and there isn't a thing that can be done.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 83Hawk

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,378
4,219
113
Nope, this late in season don't care what conf. you are from a 3rd loss should auto boot you from the Top 12.
I’ll repeat, there is no way that SEC will allow the committee to only take three teams. Kentucky or Tennessee will get the nod with three losses.
Look

It’s going to come down to the big 12 gets three teams and the ACC gets two teams. I think ultimately it will come down to needing 2 out of 3 losing between TT, BYU and WF.
 
Oct 12, 2025
245
360
63
B1G should and will get three teams in somehow. I think we can be the third.

The way I see it all of the spots are pretty much locked in except for the 11seed. That will go to BYU, TT or Iowa.

B1G should get that spot every time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Big Z

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,223
29,240
113
Interesting. Fox sports puts this out, and it has both Oregon and Ohio State ahead of Iowa.

But I’ve been told in this thread, that neither a 3 loss Oregon nor a 3 loss OSU would get in ahead of 2 loss Iowa.

If the committee puts Oregon, IOWA and Ohio State together, then they look at head to head.

HOWEVER, apparently 7-2 Alabama (#3) is SO MUCH BETTER than 7-2 Tennessee (#8); that is why their head to head does not matter.

This committee makes up its "rules" and its "logic" as it goes.

Tennessee destroying Alabama DOES NOT MATTER. Make it make sense.

 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,223
29,240
113
Great conversation.

Iowa is legit….Their passing game is so much better than it’s ever been. Tony Diaz has been a huge addition to this team. They have an offensive line with 2 potential first round NFL draft picks. LJ Phillips is playing lights out. Got an elite tight end.

I think Iowa will win out and be sitting there at 10-2.

I think they’ll be a team you don’t want to play in the playoff.

This Phil Parker defense….they only had 3 returning starters. They lost 4 defensive lineman coming into this year that combined for 77 starts….their D Line is playing great….They’ve given up 3 touchdowns in the last 4 games….The closer you get to the red zone, good luck….


Watch the full discussion:

 
  • Like
Reactions: oldxbbc

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,223
29,240
113
The discussion should be about Illinois and the fighting Berts. There is no CFP discussion without beating Illinois and then Nebraska these are not gimme games. All this talk about the CFP is putting the cart before the horses.

That's the job of the coaches and players.

The fans can dream big. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Big Z

WeBeHerkin

All-American
Aug 5, 2016
5,749
6,517
113
This doesn't mean squat in the CFB ranking. The committee will slobber over Ohio State and Oregon like they always do and select them with three losses before they take an Iowa team with two losses. Very unfair but you can see it coming.
lol lol lol. They ain’t passing us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Big Z

83Hawk

All-Conference
Jan 1, 2023
1,930
4,298
113
The steal is on. Get used to it. That's where we're at. Robbery right in front of you and there isn't a thing that can be done.
Yep. Should Iowa be fortunate enough to finish 10-2, there are going to be a lot of angry Hawkeye fans when the playoff teams are announced.

And there will be some debate among the national media talking heads about whether a 3 loss SEC team, or a 3rd Big 12 team should have got in over Iowa, but it won’t last long.

Such is the life of Hawkeye fans. I’ll be happy with 10-2, playoffs or not.
 
  • Sad
  • Like
Reactions: yrunvs and Iron Doc

Hawkmanic23

All-Conference
Mar 11, 2026
3,171
2,557
113
Yes, we should be 13th but we need to be at least 11th come time they add Boise.

If the CFP pickers give the hawks 14-17 pts because of their defense, which they are worth holding a high scoring PU team to 7, then the hawks get in at 10-2

Still afraid the Big 12 might get 3 and SEC 4 which doesnt leave much room if ACC gets 2 and Big has 2 ahead of Iowa. Just cant imagine the weak Big 12 getting three teams in
The Big 12 doesn’t deserve 3 teams in CFP, simply because of their poor defenses.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Big Z

Outbackbowl2017

All-Conference
Dec 4, 2016
1,940
3,248
113
Right now, it looks like 3 teams from the SEC, 3 from B12 (top three didn’t all play each other, which is bs, need flex schedules late in season), 2 from B1G, 2 from ACC, ND (which should count as an ACC member) and G5 Boise.

The only variable is TN losing to LSU then Iowa jumps into that spot or Oregon or tOSU. Personally, I think Iowa is going to get the shaft if 10-2. Win out and see what happens. Don’t want to hear rival fans talk if that happens.
 

Old_wrestling_fan2

All-Conference
Mar 2, 2009
715
3,234
93
The discussion should be about Illinois and the fighting Berts. There is no CFP discussion without beating Illinois and then Nebraska these are not gimme games. All this talk about the CFP is putting the cart before the horses.
I agree. Remember Minnesota. As a Haek fan, I would love to see them get in the CFP. But if they don't, and I don't think they will, they have only themselves to blame IMO. Scoring just 10 points v. Minny seriously weakens any case that they could make that they are one of the 12 best teams in CFP.
 

HawksRule73

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
985
2,407
93
I am never being a fan of Nebby for any reason. Don't lose to ******* Minnesota and none of this is even a discussion
No offense, but that's just a dumb take. First of all, we lost to Minnesota, so nothing we can do about that now. But what we can hope for are teams ahead of us to lose so we can get into the Top 11. And if that means rooting for Nebraska, so be it. My fandom for Iowa is greater than my hatred for Nebraska. If that's not the case for you, you might want to reconsider things.
 

HawksRule73

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
985
2,407
93
I agree. Remember Minnesota. As a Haek fan, I would love to see them get in the CFP. But if they don't, and I don't think they will, they have only themselves to blame IMO. Scoring just 10 points v. Minny seriously weakens any case that they could make that they are one of the 12 best teams in CFP.
Does Georgia losing AT HOME to a ****** Auburn team weaken their case? Or is that just reserved for our team?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Unclesammy

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,834
45,795
113
Does Georgia losing AT HOME to a ****** Auburn team weaken their case? Or is that just reserved for our team?
To be fair they have wins over the AP #7, #23, #25, and two wins over teams recieving votes.

Even with their 1 L, they are beating teams 42-15

It was a bad L, but Auburn is still receiving votes and Georgia is crushing people this season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Old_wrestling_fan2

iahawkeyes17

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2014
963
2,402
83
Tennessee will probably stay at 8 this week. Now if they go out and lose 24-23 to LSU you could be right that they might not drop below us. If LSU would blow them out there's a really good chance they're done. There's no way you could keep them above us.
Tenn win vs Kentucky could seem less impressive with UK playing at mizzou and against L’ville to end the year. S Carolina loss looks worse after losing to a bad Arkansas team last week. I agree if they lose the score of the game vs LSU could really play into how far they drop.

If Tenn lost I’d argue that Ohio st and Oregon have better 3 losses resume with wins and who they lost to compared to Tenn. regardless don’t think any of those 3 with 3 losses should be ahead of Iowa, WF, byu or TT.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Big Z

squeezebox_1

All-Conference
Mar 6, 2018
1,372
1,967
113
Tenn win vs Kentucky could seem less impressive with UK playing at mizzou and against L’ville to end the year. S Carolina loss looks worse after losing to a bad Arkansas team last week. I agree if they lose the score of the game vs LSU could really play into how far they drop.

If Tenn lost I’d argue that Ohio st and Oregon have better 3 losses resume with wins and who they lost to compared to Tenn. regardless don’t think any of those 3 with 3 losses should be ahead of Iowa, WF, byu or TT.
That win against Bama will probably keep them above OSU and Oregon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Big Z

RuggieC

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2014
648
1,286
93
This doesn't mean squat in the CFB ranking. The committee will slobber over Ohio State and Oregon like they always do and select them with three losses before they take an Iowa team with two losses. Very unfair but you can see it coming.
With Oregon it would not shock me......piss me off but not shock me. Ohio State on the other hand, I do not believe they will get in. No Sayin.....no OSU in the playoffs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Big Z

Old_wrestling_fan2

All-Conference
Mar 2, 2009
715
3,234
93
Does Georgia losing AT HOME to a ****** Auburn team weaken their case? Or is that just reserved for our team?
Actually, yes, it does. BUT...since that is their only loss they are still sitting pretty. It also doesn't hurt that they are the current #1 ranked team...Iowa is not. We are a fringe candidate to be selected, not a lock. If we had only lost once, even if it was to Minny, we could be much more confident.

Hopefully we get in, but if we don't, then we really cannot complain too much...IMO.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Iron Doc
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football Kelvin Bell talks Iowa defensive line development
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Basketball WATCH: Jan Jensen, Hawkeyes recap Vandy, preview Montana State
  3. 03 Rivals Basketball Recruiting Inside the recruitment of No. 12-ranked Grant Duggins: Where things stand with UNC, NC State, Kansas & more
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Basketball Recruiting Keller Daugherty officially signs with Iowa
  5. 05 On3 Football Kirk Ferentz: Iowa coaches bringing up style points in CFP race 'could be grounds for firing'