10-2 IOWA will make the CFP. Many "experts" are saying it. Are "the experts" right?

squeezebox_1

All-Conference
Mar 6, 2018
1,371
1,966
113
I don't think this happens for 2 reasons:

1. While not the same committee, there is a precedence for leaving out a team (FSU, who also happened to be undefeated) who's lost their QB for the year. I think for this reason, they leave out OSU.

2. We've got some very similar data points as Oregon. We will have beaten Illinois and Oregon lost to them. We beat NW on the road by a bigger margin than Oregon beat them at home. Oregon also lost to Okie St, who lost to ISU, who we beat. I don't see the committee leapfrogging Oregon over us.
Acting like we know what this committee will do is a misnomer. I agree that there should be no case for Ohio State or Oregon to jump Iowa, but Oregon holds wins over Ohio State, Boise, and possibly a still ranked USC team.

Ohio State, will hold a win over a CFP bound Indiana and Iowa (borderline if we win out).
 
  • Like
Reactions: LetsGoHawks83

BigOHawk1

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2001
671
1,225
93
Lots of games left to be played. I can just about guarantee that a Top 10 team or 2 will lose over the next couple of weeks.
Some good stuff here on last page, agree with the Oregon and OSU stuff, not worried about either of them assuming we win last two for the reasons above. I'm inclined to think even if a team above us struggles but doesn't lose they might fall -- hell they dropped Indiana 5 spots on a BYE week. Committee is just waiting to drop UCLA like a rock if they lose, similar to 2015 Iowa.
Just remember even IF Oregon jumps Iowa the favor will be returned next week after we beat Illinois, not sure if committee looks ahead but it really doesn't matter, we need to be rooting hard against Tennessee, BYU, Tx Tech, Wake etc. You talk about style points, what about defensive style points? Their darling Wake almost lost to Purdue, who put up 30+ on Wake and Iowa hold them to a season low points - double narrative.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LetsGoHawks83

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,666
15,901
113
Interesting. Fox sports puts this out, and it has both Oregon and Ohio State ahead of Iowa.

But I’ve been told in this thread, that neither a 3 loss Oregon nor a 3 loss OSU would get in ahead of 2 loss Iowa.
This is one guy, and no one who means anything is putting OSU ahead of Iowa this week. Someone could sneak Oregon in there. There isn't a lot of distance between Oregon and Iowa today.
 

TRHawkeye28

Senior
Jan 1, 2023
411
922
93
If Hawks had beaten Minny.... We would still be behind WF or TT right? Or basically swap us with BYU at #10 which would have been the best case scenario
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,377
4,219
113
If Hawks had beaten Minny.... We would still be behind WF or TT right? Or basically swap us with BYU at #10 which would have been the best case scenario
If they have beaten Minnesota, we would only be wondering who we would be hosting in the first round if we won out.

The reality is that loss put us in no position to complain too much. It was simply an inexcusable loss. Coaches and players will have to live with that if it ends up being what keeps them out.
 

Outbackbowl2017

All-Conference
Dec 4, 2016
1,940
3,248
113
I think the Iowa Oregon comparison comes down to how Iowa does at Illini this weekend. If Iowa wins, the door shuts on Oregon unless Iowa loses to them as well or Nebraska. Iowa’s chances hinge on teams ahead of them losing to get into the top 11. As we all know, 12 is reserved for G6 which is a stupid rule. Only should happen if ranked inside the top 12, just like all other schools not named Notre Dame which got an advantage over all teams with that rule of getting an invite if inside the top 12. Don’t like it ND? Join a conference. Stop placating to ND or G6 teams which haven’t faired well in the play offs.
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,666
15,901
113
If Hawks had beaten Minny.... We would still be behind WF or TT right? Or basically swap us with BYU at #10 which would have been the best case scenario
No. Iowa would likely be alongside UCLA and Indiana in the top 10, definitely in front of Tennessee, TT, WF, and BYU. If Iowa misses the CFP you can point directly to that loss as the primary reason why.
 

Fight4Iowa

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
459
649
93
If we beat Illinois, Nebraska beats OSU this weekend, and then we beat Nebraska. We'll be in. If Nebraska loses to Ohio State then we probably need to beat Nebraska by as much or possibly more than Ohio State did. Otherwise, Oregon or OSU might get the nod over us if they win out.

Never rule out Michigan beating Ohio State either. That game is in Columbus this year though.
 

LuciousBDragon

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2017
771
1,225
93
Simple as this

- Iowa wins out
- Tennessee loses to LSU
- TTU loses in Big 12 title game in convincing fashion
- Committee realizes Iowa brings about 20x television eyes than Wake Forest and actually has 100x fans all over the country ready to travel
- WF somehow drops a game to GA Tech or Duke and/or blown out by The U in ACC-CG.
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,832
45,793
113
Interesting. Fox sports puts this out, and it has both Oregon and Ohio State ahead of Iowa.

But I’ve been told in this thread, that neither a 3 loss Oregon nor a 3 loss OSU would get in ahead of 2 loss Iowa.
1 AP voter is not the CFP committee.

TV networks are in the business of getting views.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LetsGoHawks83

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,832
45,793
113
If they have beaten Minnesota, we would only be wondering who we would be hosting in the first round if we won out.

The reality is that loss put us in no position to complain too much. It was simply an inexcusable loss. Coaches and players will have to live with that if it ends up being what keeps them out.
Why doesn't Oregon have to live with losing to Illinois or Oklahoma State?
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,377
4,219
113
Why doesn't Oregon have to live with losing to Illinois or Oklahoma State?
They will if they’re not selected. My point is once we got to the 12 team format there’s usually a game or two that determine your fate that you should or could’ve won. If Iowa were somehow on the outside looking in at 11-1 their only loss to Ohio State, I would be irate.
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,666
15,901
113
Why doesn't Oregon have to live with losing to Illinois or Oklahoma State?
They do. They're not in the field yet any more than Iowa is. The committee would however have to consider today's version of Oregon better than the one that lost to those teams in order to insert them above Iowa.
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,832
45,793
113
They do. They're not in the field yet any more than Iowa is. The committee would however have to consider today's version of Oregon better than the one that lost to those teams in order to insert them above Iowa.
Then they should also have to consider Iowa better and Ohio State worse than they were when they played each other earlier.

They would have to be doing some mental gymnastics to create a case that Oregon should be ahead of Iowa if both win out.
 

The Big Z

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
2,345
4,542
113
We'll be 13 after tomorrow night. So we'll need 2 bump up 2 spots in the next 2 weeks. Some of you are way to worried about OSU. They struggled to beat NW at home. They'lll move up to maybe 16-17 this week. As others have stated, we need LSU to somehow pull out a big win over Tennessee. Also, do not sleep on KU against BYU at home this Saturday. KU has been in every game this year and finally put it together against W Virginia last week. If those 2 happen we are 11.
 

Fight4Iowa

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
459
649
93
I think if we win out, the odds of us being in the playoffs is like 90%. The odds of us winning out are much lower than making the playoffs if we do. Maybe a 45% chance we win out?
 

The Big Z

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
2,345
4,542
113
I think if we win out, the odds of us being in the playoffs is like 90%. The odds of us winning out are much lower than making the playoffs if we do. Maybe a 45% chance we win out?
We're favored by 6 1/2 over Illinois and will be favored by a minimum of 7 against Nebraska. Maybe more. Some people on here are giving Nebraska way more credit than they deserve. They stink.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TRHawkeye28

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,666
15,901
113
Then they should also have to consider Iowa better and Ohio State worse than they were when they played each other earlier.

They would have to be doing some mental gymnastics to create a case that Oregon should be ahead of Iowa if both win out.
It's really not that hard. Oregon has always been viewed as a much stronger team on paper. Their overall talent was the reason they were considered a top 2 or 3 team to start the season out. They severely underachieved over the first half of the year due to an offense that, despite tons talent, couldn't score points. The "experts" will point to the removal of the OC resulting in a much improved offense that is now playing to its talent level after that firing and an adjustment period for it's new starting QB. See how easy that was?
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,832
45,793
113
It's really not that hard. Oregon has always been viewed as a much stronger team on paper. Their overall talent was the reason they were considered a top 2 or 3 team to start the season out. They severely underachieved over the first half of the year due to an offense that, despite tons talent, couldn't score points. The "experts" will point to the removal of the OC resulting in a much improved offense that is now playing to its talent level after that firing and an adjustment period for it's new starting QB. See how easy that was?
Right but why do they get the benefit of the doubt but not Iowa?

That's what I'm asking.

If they can ignore a bunch of issues with Oregon, they should with Iowa.
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,377
4,219
113
We'll be 13 after tomorrow night. So we'll need 2 bump up 2 spots in the next 2 weeks. Some of you are way to worried about OSU. They struggled to beat NW at home. They'lll move up to maybe 16-17 this week. As others have stated, we need LSU to somehow pull out a big win over Tennessee. Also, do not sleep on KU against BYU at home this Saturday. KU has been in every game this year and finally put it together against W Virginia last week. If those 2 happen we are 11.
I am going to guess that Tennessee, Texas and Alabama all could survive another loss.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LetsGoHawks83

HawksRule73

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
985
2,406
93
Some good stuff here on last page, agree with the Oregon and OSU stuff, not worried about either of them assuming we win last two for the reasons above. I'm inclined to think even if a team above us struggles but doesn't lose they might fall -- hell they dropped Indiana 5 spots on a BYE week. Committee is just waiting to drop UCLA like a rock if they lose, similar to 2015 Iowa.
Just remember even IF Oregon jumps Iowa the favor will be returned next week after we beat Illinois, not sure if committee looks ahead but it really doesn't matter, we need to be rooting hard against Tennessee, BYU, Tx Tech, Wake etc. You talk about style points, what about defensive style points? Their darling Wake almost lost to Purdue, who put up 30+ on Wake and Iowa hold them to a season low points - double narrative.
Totally agree on the defensive style points. I'd even throw in special teams style points. We've got multiple kick/punt return TDs. We lead the nation in defensive ppg and redzone defense. There needs to be just as much weight given to defense as there is offense.
 

HawksRule73

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
985
2,406
93
Acting like we know what this committee will do is a misnomer. I agree that there should be no case for Ohio State or Oregon to jump Iowa, but Oregon holds wins over Ohio State, Boise, and possibly a still ranked USC team.

Ohio State, will hold a win over a CFP bound Indiana and Iowa (borderline if we win out).
I don't know.....that's why I said "I don't think". :cool:
 

squeezebox_1

All-Conference
Mar 6, 2018
1,371
1,966
113
I don't know.....that's why I said "I don't think". :cool:
Well there also isn't precedent set. FSU was a different scenario with that QB playing the entire season before the injury. Ravioli has come in and played well, especially last week. The head of the committee stated last week that they were impressed with the changes in Oregon's offense. Even if we beat Illinois, the committee could state that they beat Ohio State, which is a more impressive win. It would be really nice to see Ohio State drop another game, but I don't see that happening.
 

LakeO83

Redshirt
Jul 10, 2025
16
24
3
Acting like we know what this committee will do is a misnomer. I agree that there should be no case for Ohio State or Oregon to jump Iowa, but Oregon holds wins over Ohio State, Boise, and possibly a still ranked USC team.

Ohio State, will hold a win over a CFP bound Indiana and Iowa (borderline if we win out).
If OSU wins out you can take it to the bank that they will jump the Hawkeyes. That's just how this works.
 

BigOHawk1

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2001
671
1,225
93
If OSU wins out you can take it to the bank that they will jump the Hawkeyes. That's just how this works.
We may laugh at this but I think there is a REAL possibility of Nebraska giving OSU all they can handle on Big Noon this Saturday, they might gear up to try to save more coaches job and their QB and D are pretty decent. As much as it pains us to say it we want Big Red to win and in hopes of making our resume stronger while also giving OSU a knockout blow.
 

Fight4Iowa

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
459
649
93
If OSU wins out you can take it to the bank that they will jump the Hawkeyes. That's just how this works.
Iowa will have been on a 5 game winning streak if we win out. Ohio State just a 3-game winning streak. Ohio State will have lost 2 times since Oct. 31 whereas Iowa wouldn't have lost since Oct. 24. We beat Northwestern more soundly and by more @ Northwestern than Ohio State did at home. The next two similar data points will be against Nebraska and Michigan.

I think if we beat Nebraska by more than Ohio State does, that will be enough to seal the deal with us getting in over Ohio State, I think. They aren't the same team with the QB injury.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Big Z

HawksRule73

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
985
2,406
93
We may laugh at this but I think there is a REAL possibility of Nebraska giving OSU all they can handle on Big Noon this Saturday, they might gear up to try to save more coaches job and their QB and D are pretty decent. As much as it pains us to say it we want Big Red to win and in hopes of making our resume stronger while also giving OSU a knockout blow.
Agreed. This weekend, we all need to be fans of:

1. MSU
2. Neb
3. Kansas
4. Georgia Tech
5. Arkansas
6. LSU
7. Baylor
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,832
45,793
113
If OSU wins out you can take it to the bank that they will jump the Hawkeyes. That's just how this works.
So if OSU wins out and Iowa wins out, OSU should jump 7 spots in the final 3 weeks to be ahead of Iowa for beating the exact same teams Iowa has already beat?

Sounds logical.
 

tampahawkfan77

Freshman
Jan 8, 2005
34
81
18
We may laugh at this but I think there is a REAL possibility of Nebraska giving OSU all they can handle on Big Noon this Saturday, they might gear up to try to save more coaches job and their QB and D are pretty decent. As much as it pains us to say it we want Big Red to win and in hopes of making our resume stronger while also giving OSU a knockout blow.
I wouldn't be surprised at that, either. OSU didn't exactly blow out Northwestern this weekend, either.. So I could see Nebraska giving them a game.
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Basketball WATCH: Jan Jensen, Hawkeyes recap Vandy, preview Montana State
  2. 02 Rivals Basketball Recruiting Inside the recruitment of No. 12-ranked Grant Duggins: Where things stand with UNC, NC State, Kansas & more
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Basketball Recruiting Keller Daugherty officially signs with Iowa
  4. 04 On3 Football Kirk Ferentz: Iowa coaches bringing up style points in CFP race 'could be grounds for firing'
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Football PFF Deep Dive: Illinois Fighting Illini