Would you at least give Mullen a call?

Do you give Mullen a call

  • Yes

    Votes: 124 62.0%
  • No

    Votes: 76 38.0%

  • Total voters
    200

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,310
5,866
113
For the life of me, i do not understand the people saying no to this
It's because they are essentially jilted lovers.

Mullen has some serious flaws as an employee (e..g, letting his desire for the next job negatively impact his performance), and there are legitimate questions as to his drive at this stage in life (I think the fact that he's at UNLV indicates he's still got something left in the tank, but it's fair to wonder whether he will lose some fire after a year or two). But those are things you feel out in the hiring process and take into account when structuring compensation. You say no immediately when you're upset that your former highly compensated employee viewed (and views) you as a paycheck, and not a lifelong commitment.
 
Oct 13, 2012
307
329
63
why would we call someone that did not & does not want to be here
no one wants to be here.
Mad Men Money GIF by GIFnosis
 

Anon1664462994

Redshirt
Sep 29, 2022
10
3
3
It's because they are essentially jilted lovers.

Mullen has some serious flaws as an employee (e..g, letting his desire for the next job negatively impact his performance), and there are legitimate questions as to his drive at this stage in life (I think the fact that he's at UNLV indicates he's still got something left in the tank, but it's fair to wonder whether he will lose some fire after a year or two). But those are things you feel out in the hiring process and take into account when structuring compensation. You say no immediately when you're upset that your former highly compensated employee viewed (and views) you as a paycheck, and not a lifelong commitment.
It would be like twisting the guy's arm...not a good start nor a good end
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,310
5,866
113
It would be like twisting the guy's arm...not a good start nor a good end
If he's not interested, then he's not interested. But you don't decline to reach out because you're worried he may not be interested. We're not looking for a date. We're looking for an employee. And I'm not saying I want him as my first choice. It's just that any competent coaching search is at least going to kick the tires with Mullen unless something crazy happens like we reach out to a candidate like Jake Dickert and get strong enough interest that we never have to even engage alternatives.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,310
5,866
113
Semi-OT - This could be a good year to hire a coach.

You've got FSU, Baylor, and Maryland open now and I'm not sure there are going to be any high profile programs adding to that list. A&M is an obvious one. Maybe Wisconsin? Other possibilities are USCe, TCU, Colorado, Ga Tech, Boston College, Kansas, and Cincinnati. I guess Memphis when Huff gets hired. I'm sure there are other ones I'm forgetting, but depending on who declines to pull the trigger, we could legitimately be the second most desirable job opening in the Southeast after FSU. Outside of FSU and A&M, I'm not sure any job is going to be obviously a bigger draw.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darryl Steight

MississippiTexan

Sophomore
Jun 11, 2014
149
135
43
Semi-OT - This could be a good year to hire a coach.

You've got FSU, Baylor, and Maryland open now and I'm not sure there are going to be any high profile programs adding to that list. A&M is an obvious one. Maybe Wisconsin? Other possibilities are USCe, TCU, Colorado, Ga Tech, Boston College, Kansas, and Cincinnati. I guess Memphis when Huff gets hired. I'm sure there are other ones I'm forgetting, but depending on who declines to pull the trigger, we could legitimately be the second most desirable job opening in the Southeast after FSU. Outside of FSU and A&M, I'm not sure any job is going to be obviously a bigger draw.
I agree. Not to mention we have KT which means a coach has a much better chance at success year one. If you wait to fire Lebby, you probably go up against some bigger schools and you have no KT. I'm not sure we will be much more desirable on the coaching market than we will be this off-season.
 

Wesson Bulldog

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2015
2,052
2,426
113
Mullen is interesting because of 2 reasons. Firstly, Saban is not at Alabama. They are not the scary juggernaut by appearance that they were under Nick Saban. Mullen sees this as an opportunity to win some games against them. Secondly, the SEC no long has divisions and is wide open. The pressure is off. The championship game is no more, and the playoff expands to 24 next year. He could see this as a great opportunity to win 9 games every year, make the playoff and be endeared by the fans.
I would make him our FIRST call without hesitation.
 

skip dog

All-Conference
Nov 15, 2005
1,616
1,522
93
...... I would call to get his thoughts on other candidates.
^^^^THIS^^^^^

He was 69-46 here, with a 33-39 conference record, w/ 2014 being his only year to have a winning conference record.

I just do not see him as the answer 10 years down the road from when he was last here

just my opinion
 

Anon1664462994

Redshirt
Sep 29, 2022
10
3
3
If he's not interested, then he's not interested. But you don't decline to reach out because you're worried he may not be interested. We're not looking for a date. We're looking for an employee. And I'm not saying I want him as my first choice. It's just that any competent coaching search is at least going to kick the tires with Mullen unless something crazy happens like we reach out to a candidate like Jake Dickert and get strong enough interest that we never have to even engage alternatives.
Good point
 

Darryl Steight

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
5,005
8,328
113
Semi-OT - This could be a good year to hire a coach.

You've got FSU, Baylor, and Maryland open now and I'm not sure there are going to be any high profile programs adding to that list. A&M is an obvious one. Maybe Wisconsin? Other possibilities are USCe, TCU, Colorado, Ga Tech, Boston College, Kansas, and Cincinnati. I guess Memphis when Huff gets hired. I'm sure there are other ones I'm forgetting, but depending on who declines to pull the trigger, we could legitimately be the second most desirable job opening in the Southeast after FSU. Outside of FSU and A&M, I'm not sure any job is going to be obviously a bigger draw.
Shirley even A&M has to apply the brakes at some point, don't they? They are still paying Jimbo $7M/year through 2031, I can't imagine they want to add whatever ungodly amount they'd have to buy out Elko for, plus hire a new guy... shirley.
 

BulldawgFan

Senior
Oct 7, 2013
369
766
93
For the life of me, i do not understand the people saying no to this
Stubborn pride based on the fact that Mullen took a once in a lifetime promotion to his dream school.

To some State fans, once you coach here the only way out is to get fired (doesn’t matter that that means they sucked). They’d rather a coach suck and be fired than a coach to succeed and move up in the world just to avoid the perceived embarrassment.

Would cut their nose off to spite their face.
 

BulldawgFan

Senior
Oct 7, 2013
369
766
93
^^^^THIS^^^^^

He was 69-46 here, with a 33-39 conference record, w/ 2014 being his only year to have a winning conference record.

I just do not see him as the answer 10 years down the road from when he was last here

just my opinion
Ok now list all the State coaches that have done better than that. There are none. Mullen achieved that at the school with the least resources during the SEC’s peak.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,310
5,866
113
^^^^THIS^^^^^

He was 69-46 here, with a 33-39 conference record, w/ 2014 being his only year to have a winning conference record.

I just do not see him as the answer 10 years down the road from when he was last here

just my opinion
He was 33-39 in a very different SEC. Bama with Saban, LSU with Miles, Arkansas with Petrino and Ryan Mallette, Auburn with Cam and then some good years with Malzahn. UM had some top ten teams. He just didn't get a break in the West and I think he played UGA a disproportionate amount of times also if I remember. I think the SEC shuffled up the schedule and we got a bad rotation.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,310
5,866
113
Shirley even A&M has to apply the brakes at some point, don't they? They are still paying Jimbo $7M/year through 2031, I can't imagine they want to add whatever ungodly amount they'd have to buy out Elko for, plus hire a new guy... shirley.
I think if they have a new coach they're excited about, they will be willing to spend the money. Not sure who that would be at this point. I don't think they were particularly excited about Elko, although I guess they got on board when they thought the alternative was Stoops.

Elko does have a duty to mitigate and his buyout supposedly doesn't have a big lump sum, so if he wants to coach, they will likely get a decent offset after a year or two.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darryl Steight

Howiefeltersnstch

All-Conference
Dec 28, 2019
3,224
3,949
98
I would make that two timing cheating b*tch come begging crawling on his knees. Then I would say " the fact is you done run and that cant be undone. Here's a quarter, call someone who cares"
 

BulldawgFan

Senior
Oct 7, 2013
369
766
93
I would make that two timing cheating b*tch come begging crawling on his knees. Then I would say " the fact is you done run and that cant be undone. Here's a quarter, call someone who cares"
😂😂 this is what I’m talking about.

Someone above referred to state fans, regarding Mullen, as jilted lovers. This is a perfect example!!

Would cut off your nose to spite your face.
 

skip dog

All-Conference
Nov 15, 2005
1,616
1,522
93
Ok now list all the State coaches that have done better than that. There are none. Mullen achieved that at the school with the least resources during the SEC’s peak.
I'm not talking about other State coaches.....I/we are talking about Mullen, and the idea that we should call him back in to coach STATE. I think we can do better than re-treading Uncle Eddie
 

BulldawgFan

Senior
Oct 7, 2013
369
766
93
I'm not talking about other State coaches.....I/we are talking about Mullen, and the idea that we should call him back in to coach STATE. I think we can do better than re-treading Uncle Eddie
Who’s better? Name a coach that we can realistically get and that has a better track record than Mullen.
 

skip dog

All-Conference
Nov 15, 2005
1,616
1,522
93
He was 33-39 in a very different SEC. Bama with Saban, LSU with Miles, Arkansas with Petrino and Ryan Mallette, Auburn with Cam and then some good years with Malzahn. UM had some top ten teams. He just didn't get a break in the West and I think he played UGA a disproportionate amount of times also if I remember. I think the SEC shuffled up the schedule and we got a bad rotation.
spot on that the SEC was tough in those 9 years he was at STATE, but makes me ask the question, if you take the 2014 season out of the discussion......and look at his others 8 years, what is the game that he won in the SEC that he was not supposed to win?

I'm not calling him a bad coach, but I am calling it a bad idea to entertain bringing him back
 

GiantInternetAsshole

All-Conference
Sep 22, 2026
1,249
1,143
113
I think you guys are forgetting that the man won 9 games with Chris Relf as quarterback.

We beat out some FCS teams for his recruitment.

Somebody on here nailed it last week. The MSU fanbase treats coaches like a marriage. Im not saying that we need to treat coaches like one night stands, but sometimes even if the sex is good, you can tell its not going to work long term and you need to move on.
We are in “the ex has changed her ways” territory with Lebby coming back for year 4. After year 5, we’ll look back and realize how stupid we were for letting Selmon and Co get away with keeping him a 4th year
 

GiantInternetAsshole

All-Conference
Sep 22, 2026
1,249
1,143
113
One thing I think a lot of people gloss over with Mullen is the landscape of college football has changed so much since 2017, I don’t think the grass looks as green on the other side of the fence as it once did. The list of jobs more attractive than MSU 15 years ago has dwindled down significantly due to conference realignment, the portal, etc. and of the ones that are still objectively better (top half of SEC, Miami, ND, and 4-5 Big Ten jobs), I’d be willing to bet none of them are looking to Mullen in his mid 50s to resurrect their program. Unless he makes a lateral move, I couldn’t imagine him shopping around every offseason.
 

M R DAWGS

All-Conference
Apr 13, 2018
2,330
2,275
113
He’s the surest bet to winning quickly that I know of. Not only would I call him, he’d be one of the first calls I make.

We’ve stomached enough iffy hires. Time to go with a known, sure thing at least for a while. Take a chance on the next one if Mullen fizzles.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,310
5,866
113
spot on that the SEC was tough in those 9 years he was at STATE, but makes me ask the question, if you take the 2014 season out of the discussion......and look at his others 8 years, what is the game that he won in the SEC that he was not supposed to win?

I'm not calling him a bad coach, but I am calling it a bad idea to entertain bringing him back
Every game we played against an SEC team not named Ole Miss, Vandy, Arkansas, or Kentucky. Those are the only programs without material advangtages over us. Every time we were supposed to be any other team, it was because Mullen had us punching above our weight (or at least at our weight while some programs temporarily underachieved).

He's a good coach. There is certainly no guarantee he will be good if we bring him back. As terrible as Freeze is, I did not expect him to fall on his face at Auburn after doing reasonably well at Liberty. Spurrier was never quire the same when he came back to college. I'm sure there are plenty of other good examples. But he will have a much higher likelihood of success than the next coach we likely will hire. We may get lucky. But that's what it will be. Luck. Not lottery ticket luck by any means. It's possible UK, Auburn, and UF have made good hires this year. But Mullen is still a solid option.
 
  • Like
Reactions: skip dog

triton28

Junior
Dec 18, 2009
1,506
284
78
It's because they are essentially jilted lovers.

Mullen has some serious flaws as an employee (e..g, letting his desire for the next job negatively impact his performance), and there are legitimate questions as to his drive at this stage in life (I think the fact that he's at UNLV indicates he's still got something left in the tank, but it's fair to wonder whether he will lose some fire after a year or two). But those are things you feel out in the hiring process and take into account when structuring compensation. You say no immediately when you're upset that your former highly compensated employee viewed (and views) you as a paycheck, and not a lifelong commitment.

^^^^THIS^^^^^

He was 69-46 here, with a 33-39 conference record, w/ 2014 being his only year to have a winning conference record.

I just do not see him as the answer 10 years down the road from when he was last here

just my opinion
Do you think he’s learned to take the dam points yet
 
  • Haha
Reactions: skip dog

triton28

Junior
Dec 18, 2009
1,506
284
78
Ok now list all the State coaches that have done better than that. There are none. Mullen achieved that at the school with the least resources during the SEC’s peak.
Mullen was a good hire by Byrne. And your post is correct. But this is the future not the past. Our qb is making 7-9 mil. We have more resources now and can do better than that. If we keep Lebby for ‘27 however, Mullen will be a slam dunk by ‘29.
 

Bulldawg77

All-American
Dec 1, 2019
4,905
9,602
108
I think the list of people that would consider our job at this juncture is pretty humbling and Mullen would be one of the best on that list….if he would consider it.
I couldn’t disagree more. Shite Mike this attitude from our fans is what holds us back. It’s utter Shite
 

8dog

All-American
Feb 23, 2008
15,330
7,759
113
I couldn’t disagree more. Shite Mike this attitude from our fans is what holds us back. It’s utter Shite
Meh. It’s a message board. I’m just discussing realities. It has zero impact on our success. If I were the AD id call everyone. But I’m not so I’m gonna think is reality on a message board. Huff, Mullen, Neal Brown. Who are some head coaches that would consider our job that get people excited?
 

Bulldawg77

All-American
Dec 1, 2019
4,905
9,602
108
Meh. It’s a message board. I’m just discussing realities. It has zero impact on our success. If I were the AD id call everyone. But I’m not so I’m gonna think is reality on a message board. Huff, Mullen, Neal Brown. Who are some head coaches that would consider our job that get people excited?
To get excited about would be coaches who have won even those at the G6 That beaten teams in P4
Jason Candle @UCONN
Charles Huff @ Memphis
Lance Taylor @ WMU
Jamey Chadwell @ Liberty
GJ Kinne @ Tx State
Jamarcus Shepard @ Oregon state
Neal Brown @ UNT
Two wild cards I’ll throw out Kane Womack DC at Bama. Was HC at South Alabama with a 22-16 record. The other is Clay Helton.
 

8dog

All-American
Feb 23, 2008
15,330
7,759
113
Yeah all those guys look about the same same to me.
To get excited about would be coaches who have won even those at the G6 That beaten teams in P4
Jason Candle @UCONN
Charles Huff @ Memphis
Lance Taylor @ WMU
Jamey Chadwell @ Liberty
GJ Kinne @ Tx State
Jamarcus Shepard @ Oregon state
Neal Brown @ UNT
Two wild cards I’ll throw out Kane Womack DC at Bama. Was HC at South Alabama with a 22-16 record. The other is Clay Helton.
Id look at Sheperd hard but the sample size is small. And Kinne. Tx state was terrible before he got there. He is probably the most realistic candidate I like. Dont think Chadwell is leaving Liberty for our job. The others all seem about the same to me on paper. I just want a guy who is organized, has some attitude and is passionate about gathering talent. We have not had that in a long time. Run whatever scheme you want.
 

Bulldawg77

All-American
Dec 1, 2019
4,905
9,602
108
Yeah all those guys look about the same same to me.

Id look at Sheperd hard but the sample size is small. And Kinne. Tx state was terrible before he got there. He is probably the most realistic candidate I like. Dont think Chadwell is leaving Liberty for our job. The others all seem about the same to me on paper. Our current coach checks none of those boxes. I just want a guy who is organized, has some attitude and is passionate about gathering talent. We have not had that in a long time. Run whatever scheme you want.
Chadwell would definitely take our job. Had we had our NIL shite together in 23 we very well could have hired him. He spent some time at DSU so he is familiar with the state
Candle won at Toledo before leaving for UCONN this year and would love an opportunity to coach SEC.
 

8dog

All-American
Feb 23, 2008
15,330
7,759
113
Chadwell would definitely take our job. Had we had our NIL shite together in 23 we very well could have hired him. He spent some time at DSU so he is familiar with the state
Candle won at Toledo before leaving for UCONN this year and would love an opportunity to coach SEC.
Candle may be great but Toledo won at a decent rate before him. And I’m sure there are factors I don’t know bc I don’t keep up with UConn but he gonna lose more games this year than the two previous years. May be great. Just nothing to get excited about. That’s why Kinne intrigues me. That program was garbage.
 

Bulldawg77

All-American
Dec 1, 2019
4,905
9,602
108
Candle may be great but Toledo won at a decent rate before him. And I’m sure there are factors I don’t know bc I don’t keep up with UConn but he gonna lose more games this year than the two previous years. May be great. Just nothing to get excited about. That’s why Kinne intrigues me. That program was garbage.
Matt Campbell at Penn Stste now formerly at Iowa state was at Toledo before Candle took over. Candle far exceeded anything Campbell did. This is His first year at UCONN after Mora went to Colorado State. Kinne would be good but needs a good DC. Do you keep ZA for one year and see how it plays out? Maybe.. I would be fine with either. Kinne also found and coached Cam Ward
 

Dawgzilla2

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2022
2,877
3,344
113
Stubborn pride based on the fact that Mullen took a once in a lifetime promotion to his dream school.

To some State fans, once you coach here the only way out is to get fired (doesn’t matter that that means they sucked). They’d rather a coach suck and be fired than a coach to succeed and move up in the world just to avoid the perceived embarrassment.

Would cut their nose off to spite their face.
Let's cut the "dream job" BS. He was headed to Tennessee until Stricklin got desperate and intercepted him. He wanted to make more money at a school with more financial resources.

I had no problem with Mullen leaving. I thought we were over paying him at the time, and I was surprised schools were willing to pay him more. Of course, it turned out he wasn't worth it.

I don't really want him back, but it has nothing to do with him leaving us 10 years ago.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Captain Ron

Zarbok

Sophomore
Dec 2, 2022
135
131
43
Not no, but 17777777777 no. We are absolutely NOT desperate, like at all. We would be the most promising job on the market. Fornthe next 1 to THREE years we would have the leading Heisman contender at QB, all sec was, all sec rbs, and a dexent enough secondary. Well have to actually pay real coaching money, so likely 6+ mil, but State looks really really good from a coaching perspective if you can recruit lineman.

Stop looking at your ex who left you.
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,689
13,511
113
Let's cut the "dream job" BS. He was headed to Tennessee until Stricklin got desperate and intercepted him. He wanted to make more money at a school with more financial resources.
Correct.

I had no problem with Mullen leaving. I thought we were over paying him at the time, and I was surprised schools were willing to pay him more. Of course, it turned out he wasn't worth it.
You're either lying or crazy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BulldawgFan

Captain Ron

Junior
Aug 22, 2012
749
387
63
Looks like to me Don has had the best winning percentage of any coach at MSU in the modern era that was also around for at least 5 years. And since he left, how have things looked? Before he got here, how did they look? Looks like to me based on history we got dang good value for our money.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Who carries the load?
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Bulldogs prepare for mid-major test against Tulsa in Jackson
  3. 03 On3 Football Mississippi State RB Fluff Bothwell re-signs with Bulldogs for 2027
  4. 04 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout
  5. 05 Maroon and White Chris Jans proud of Mississippi State's "must-win" performance on the road at UCF