Hoping for a miracle 16-3 shots NW.
Respectfully, this makes zero sense and is an insane take.I need help analyzing this team - when we got the 5th years back, I thought for sure (casual observer) that we’d be one the best 2-3 teams in the country easily. And we really have never seem to have turned the corner. We may get lucky and win this one, but it truly looks like the #1 team in the country playing a #8 or worse.
This is way too much of a hot take, but Erin sometimes seems more into living an Instagram life and motivational sloganeering and we seem to be doing less with more this year. She of course has been very successful for a young coach after inheriting a wagon, so I know it’s premature to write her off.
the good news is that we didn’t give away any tendencies on that shootout cause it was awfullol Announcers don’t even have their stats correct.
We were just in a shootout last week.
Sad but truethe good news is that we didn’t give away any tendencies on that shootout cause it was awful
I knew it was sacrilegious to bring this up on this board, but I appreciate the response. You referenced injuries, but other than this vague comment you still didn’t really answer my question - was there something specific that caused this team to drop off from a run of 7 out of 8 FF?Respectfully, this makes zero sense and is an insane take.
As you said you’re a casual observer, if you’ve been watching the games, you’d know this is a wild take.
All our losses have been very close and on the margins. Only 3 losses since the players regained eligibility, and 2 of those losses included extremely shady officiating. Others who have watched each game will back me up on this. We’re not even fully healthy in this game right now either.
I’ve watched and/or attended each game this year, so I feel pretty confident with my statement.
Also, the fact that this game is going to OT is good evidence to show we are one of the top 2-3 teams in the country.
It’s pretty simple. Northwestern is the best team in the country by far. They haven’t lost at full strength all year.I knew it was sacrilegious to bring this up on this board, but I appreciate the response. You referenced injuries, but other than this vague comment you still didn’t really answer my question - was there something specific that caused this team to drop off from a run of 7 out of 8 FF?
You reference close games, 3 losses since the super seniors arrived (now 4, but how is that proving your point), and shady officiating. But that feels like surface level analysis.
Do you really think a team that gets totally dominated like that (run of play, corners, possession, 21-6 shots, 13-1 SOG) is one of the top 2-3 teams in the country?! Even the Miami game was a slog.
We’re spoiled, there will be down years, the program is fine, I was just curious about the drop off. And it would have been significant if we didn’t get the super senior reprieve.
Saw Kirsch at the F4 game last year, he was into it to say the leastSteve Kirschner's daughter on NW...talk about an interesting dynamic. Add in the Sessa dynamic and storylines abound even before you talk about the dominance of the two programs.
Appreciate this (and the edits) - well said and thought out. I’m not trying to start a fight and I get the perspective - I’m protective of my UNC baseball fandom every year after investing in every game and having people pop up for the first time with dumb questions/takes every postseason like I did here.It’s pretty simple. Northwestern is the best team in the country by far. They haven’t lost at full strength all year.
We had a hole to dig out early in the year, which obviously impacted our resume and seed. If we had our full team all year, we wouldn’t have been playing a team like NW in round 2 on the road and likely would have made the FF.
And yes, despite today’s stats, I do think we are one of the best 2-3 teams in the country. Offense is only one part of the game. Our defensive performance today was elite. That matters as much as the offensive stats. NW is obviously much better than us this year, and it’s not uncommon for the best team in college field hockey to dominate another team in the final four or title game. That doesn’t mean the other team isn’t a top 2-3 team. Due to our seeding, we unfortunately just had to play NW in an earlier round than otherwise. This isn’t new either. Karen Sheldon lost to NW in the first round of the 2021 NCAA tourney with Erin Matson.
The margins in college field hockey are very weird and chemistry is key. Chemistry was never able to get to 100% with injuries and players in and out of the lineup. We were still down a starter today.
It’s pretty hard to give detailed analysis over the 3 losses in one text, but if you go through the past few pages, it might shed some light on some of the losses and the complexities within them. The Syracuse loss was in a shout out and we had actually scored the winning goal but the refs accidentally called an early whistle to take the goal off the board. The Wake game included a late BS upgraded penalty, which allowed them to take the lead late.
The Liberty loss was unacceptable, but even that was a 2-1 on the road against a team that has weirdly had our number.
Nobody is saying this was a standard year. It was obviously a down year, but keep in mind there were other players from last year’s team that didn’t return and both our top international recruits didn’t end up suiting up. One for eligibility reasons. One for injury reasons. Dani Mendez, one do the 2025 All-Americans, also didn’t look like herself this year.
Erin has 9 top 10 players committed for the next 3 classes, including America’s next international FH star. The next school with the most only has 4. She is doing a great job, and the “social media” take is honestly very lazy and unsupported. We’ve heard this take several times, and it’s just crazy. She works very hard, and I know that for a fact through connections I have with the program.
So did I. Brutal.I wasn't able to watch the game closely, but man I celebrated after Northwestern shot in the 5th round. I thought they had missed that shot for sure.
Not trying to fight either but where do you get the idea that college field hockey is predictable?Appreciate this (and the edits) - well said and thought out. I’m not trying to start a fight and I get the perspective - I’m protective of my UNC baseball fandom every year after investing in every game and having people pop up for the first time with dumb questions/takes every postseason like I did here.
I respectfully disagree that we played like a top 2-3 team (4-4 since the grad additions against top 20 etc) but hopefully the program can turn the page and get back to spoiling us again.
Field hockey seems like fairly predictable sport in terms of teams being good/bad when you think they’ll be. I just couldn’t quite figure this squad out (was our midfield a weak link, key injuries, etc) - you addressed it as well as possible. Probably just a combo of chemistry, bad breaks, and disruption from the legal process leaving the team in limbo.
That’s also a good point. And we were expecting to have two additional ones on top of who we already have.Field hockey championships are won by teams which have 3-4+ foreign starters. This is what was missing from the 2026 Heels. I believe NW had at least 4 import starters.
We lost to Liberty 2-1; traditionally their roster has around 10 imports.
I am not complaining; that’s simply the nature of the sport at the NCAA level.
These are all great points as well. Thank you for helping enhance my points.I will add just a couple of thoughts to an already good conversation:
- stars matter a lot in FH. We were dominant (usually) when we had Matson: the best US player in the sport. While Heck is easily top 2-3 players her career, The best was Sessa. She puts NW over the top. She transferred away from UNC when her coach retired. the next star should be D’Ariano. She is ours but will likely take next year off for the Olympics training cycle.
- This sport is about as predictable as soccer. You can dominate a game, but one goal wins and that can, at time, come from the team with much fewer chances and shots. But if you have Matson, who averaged over 3 points per game in her career, you can build margins that bad fortune can’t overcome.
- It is very rare for young players to star in this sport. US youth filed hockey is universally unserious as sport compared to BB, FB, baseballs, softball, soccer, even volleyball. Even if you have star potential, the teams you play on and against do not provide a level of competitiveness to hone that skill. So you don’t actually play real field hockey until you get to college. Meaning, that is when your learning curve starts. This team was very young until our 5th years became eligible. We will still be young next year.
- This is because we did have a small lull in recruiting during the coaching transition, plus as stated above we lost our best player to the portal. That lull ended with Matson’s title, but recruits commit as HS Juniors so we are still waiting for most of that talent to arrive and then magure
- Next year could look more like the beginning of this year (not our best) because of the above. Unless we get multiple key international players and transfers. That part of recruiting is faster impact and still TBD.
Riley or Ryleigh?Come on Riley. Save us.
!!!Impressed with the defensive effort.
Offensive? Not at all. No shots from Ryliegh. 1 save made all game by their GK and 0 goals by us. Horrific.
Need to augment/alter the staff. If we can, bring in a GM who is a long time coach from the PA club scene.
Help one of the assistants get a head coaching job and bring in an assistant from say, the Netherlands, who has plenty of experience.
Our coaches are light on experience and it showed throughout the year.
You are correct that I didn’t watch or closely follow all of the college field hockey games this year (I don’t think that should disqualify me from stating an opinion that I’ll try to support more with evidence here). I see scores and have a general understanding of the teams, programs and trends and I’m not totally uneducated about the landscape. I’ll maintain that the sport is “predictable” in the sense that upsets are rare, and the consensus preseason favorites generally have the seasons the polls suggest they will.Not trying to fight either but where do you get the idea that college field hockey is predictable?
I’m not saying this to be smart, but am I correct to say you may have kept up with scores throughout the year and but weren’t watching all the games/closely following.
Agree on your game summary but as far as the staff, we actually have the largest staff in the county.Impressed with the defensive effort.
Offensive? Not at all. No shots from Ryliegh. 1 save made all game by their GK and 0 goals by us. Horrific.
Need to augment/alter the staff. If we can, bring in a GM who is a long time coach from the PA club scene.
Help one of the assistants get a head coaching job and bring in an assistant from say, the Netherlands, who has plenty of experience.
Our coaches are light on experience and it showed throughout the year.
Rivals Football Recruiting
North Carolina makes its pitch to 4-star QB Blake Roskopf after hosting official visit
Inside Carolina Football
UNC Safety Greg Smith Suspended For First Half at Virginia
Inside Carolina Football
Margin For Error Narrowing as UNC Enters Final Two Games of 2026
Inside Carolina Football Recruiting
Connail Jackson Commitment Q&A: 'I Loved It and Just Decided to Commit'
Inside Carolina Football
Film Room: Handling the Free Pass Rusher