Your argument is not good in that 12 teams excludes teams that are quite possibly contenders, but due to teams playing vastly different schedules, they are left out due to absolute record. Comparing simple W-L record of 135 teams playing VASTLY different schedules with almost no overlap is dumb and not statistically valid. The only answer is allowing the top teams from from P2 (6-8) / P4 Conference (12-16 teams) into the playoffs and the remaining top 8-12 teams from non-P4 teams and independents (which is on the order of a field of 75 teams). That is not too many teams for a Playoff. Beyond that, since the teams are seeded in the Playoff (with a top 8 seeds receiving a bye in first round), it's just dumb to claim that the #9 seed shouldn't beat the #24 seed AT HOME if they are truly the #9 seed (which is impossible to say just looking at records when the #9 and #24 seeds will generally have played a completely different schedule during the regular season). But again, it's dumb to claim that you can absolutely tell the difference between the lowest 16 seeds in a 24 team Playoff Format by simply comparing records when the #9 Seed could quite possibly have a much better overall record playing in the MWC or the MAC or the P12 or the AAC..... etc..... versus the #24 seed playing in the SEC or B1G. But again, if the #9 Seed can't beat that SEC or B1G team
@Home, then they really weren't the #9 team in the country in the first place - were they?????